My co-worker and I lost the server lottery at lunch today. We were promptly greeted by a host and sat at a little two top in the bar area, but the prompt service ended there. We waited for over five minutes just for someone to come by and offer us water. For that to finally happen, it took other servers noticing and coming over to cover for our waitress. One came to us while the other went to find her. But hey, at least since it took ten minutes for her to show we already knew what we wanted to eat. We put in our orders and began the next longest wait ever. At this point the surrounding two tops were still empty. Every second of twenty minutes passed before I noticed that a guy sitting behind us, who hadn't even been there when we ordered, had already ordered and been served his food. By now it was 12:40 (we got there around noon or so), so I had to go make the bartender aware of the situation. Told him we had jobs to get to (writing this in the car ride back - six minutes late for our 1 p.m. meeting) and he immediately got our food and notified the manager (implying that it had been sitting there waiting under a heat lamp). The manager came over and apologized, and looked like she might offer us something on the house, but didn't. Maybe we weren't rude enough? Then she went on her way. All told our server filled our waters once and brought us a check. She came back and offered us dessert, said it would be on the house. However we didn't have time for dessert so we passed. You'd think after that you'd get a discount, a comp or something, but no, nothing at all. Horrible experience. Tipped 10% when I probably should've stiffed. Guess I'm not the asshole I used to be. Chalk it up to old age.
Had delicious French onion soup, a hummus appetizer and turkey club sandwich. I'd recommend all three of those, especially the hummus app.
(5)
Jamie C.
I used to love the Rusty Bucket and considered it one of the restaurants you can always count on for good food and good service. I'm really disappointed to say the past two visits have not met my expectations. The food had some issues; a hard branch of kale in a salad and a hair in my dip. This past time my family and I sat at the bar and waited 15 minutes with empty glasses before we had to ask for refills ourselves. We've always had great service until now so that was disappointing. I just wanted to write in so that Rusty Bucket has a chance to get back to the level of service I've come to know from them. Would really like to go back one day...
(2)
Ben C.
Good overall, I usually get a burger and its always comes out the way it should. The buffalo chicken sandwich is a good choice add well. Service is usually prompt but once we had a rarely seen server.
(4)
Marsha F.
The Rusty Bucket on Lane Avenue is hands-down the best overall restaurant in the City of Columbus. The food is consistently superb. The waitstaff is friendly. Once in a blue moon, the kitchen is slow, but the vibe of TV sports makes the wait no big deal.
(5)
Amanda D.
The food is average, but definitely will not disappoint. If you want to watch a sports game and eat a good burger with fries I'd say go here.
(3)
Christiana C.
My sister and I were jonesing for wings on a game day, but didn't want to wait or be FORCED to watch the game. In came Rusty Bucket! We got seated right away and while there's an OPPORTUNITY for watching the game (on multiple TVs and a huge projector screen with multiple events shown at once), you can also have an experience where you are not bombarded with the game (should it not be your team or should you dread the words "the game" in any capacity). Our waitress was great and made it a point to allow us to try multiple brews on tap to make sure we got the one we wanted (maybe I am cheaply bought, but this behavior just makes me love a waitress more). And the food! We got wings in Classic Joe sauce (recommended by said waitress) and I loved them. I wish they had boneless wings but when I'm jonesing and not ready to wait somewhere else, Rusty Bucket is totally my new go-to.
(4)
Christina C.
I am tempted to make some sort of witty pun on the name "Rusty Bucket" - but I got nothin'. And it would be completely irrelevant. For restaurant amenities and overall ambiance: 4 stars For unique drink selection: 4 stars For food quality: 2 stars Average: 3 First of all this is your run of the mill sports-bar-like tavern with tv's for games and beverages for consuming; however, the menu classes the place up a bit with a plethora of impressive-sounding options making it a perfect suburbanite destination. On this said visit, I tried the buffalo chicken sandwich with the cucumber and tomato salad as my side. Pretty standard actually - nothing too over the top - the bun was underwhelming and the breading was overwhelming. I guess they didn't get the memo I'm watching my carb intake. Alas, my hope was in the cucumber and tomato salad since it had feta cheese (my favorite) - but that too was underwhelming and actually quite chewy. Yes, chewy veggies. Now let's talk highlights! The Bucket scores major points for a fire pit outside on the patio, daily blue plate specials, daily drink specials (including a Finlandia vodka and pineapple diddy!) and TV's in the bathrooms.Yes, TV's in the bathrooms.
(3)
Amanda K.
i really enjoy this place. I'm not one for chain restaurants, but I can't deny how delicious the slider appetizer is, and the buffalo chicken sandwich is scrumptious! they have a nice patio, and service is typically great.
(4)
Rusty G.
Great atmosphere, friendly staff, great neighborhood bar and grill. The food is very good for bar style menu.
(5)
Tina F.
Awesome Martinis & Veggie Burgers! This is much better than your typical chain restaurant. The veggie burger is not from a box, but home made. It has lots of beans and some rice in it and it comes topped with a delicious roasted red pepper relish - so it is very juicy and flavorful. It comes with fries but for a little extra you can get the Double Nickel Salad - which is like the old 55 salad - very good - make sure to ask for no bacon if you're vegetarian! The Martinis are delicious - I love the Key Lime. It is sweet but not overly so, but I would still choose it for dessert! It is usually crowded, so you either have to wait for a table or sit outside. I usually sit outside on the big covered patio.
(4)
Amanda B.
I headed here with a group of 12 friends on a Wednesday night. It's a pretty "normal" sports bar type of place, but the menu seems designed to be a bit classier than your average pub grub so I was interested in checking it out. Unfortunately, I was disappointed. The food was atrocious. I got the taco salad, which oddly looked more like cole slaw and was so bad that I took two bites and gave up (and I hate wasting food). My friend got fish that was so greasy that she also couldn't eat it. Some other folks at our table got the small pizzas, which were OK but also pretty greasy and nothing to write home about. The only thing that seemed to go over well at our table was the mac 'n cheese. Otherwise, everything seemed too bland, too greasy, too low-quality. I think they really missed the mark on aiming for classy pub food. This wasn't even decent pub food. The waitress and waiter at our table were friendly, and you could tell they were trying. But it was obvious they weren't prepared to handle a large table of people in addition to the rest of the crowd- I think they may have been understaffed. It took about 20-25 minutes for them to even take our orders. The food came out quickly once it was ordered though. The only plus I can see is the place looked comfortable and the staff was friendly. There was a big bar with plenty of seating and what looked like a pretty relaxed, friendly crowd. The patio looks like it would be nice in warm weather. Unfortunately, the cover and the heaters they used in an attempt to make it into cold weather seating weren't really enough and I was half freezing while I was waiting for my food. Overall, a pretty disappointing experience with a menu that at face-value looked like it had promise.
(2)
Amanda H.
Star Clarification: 3 if you sit on the patio. 2 if you're forced to endure the arctic blast of the A/C, volume decibels rivaling an airport runway and (and this is strictly my opinion) a sad, sports zombie crowd inside. If you're not the sports bar type (and/or don't have a downy undercoat or three-inch layer of subcutaneous fat), don't bother with the Bucket indoors. The patio, however, is another world, and with the warm weather approaching, I'll finally be able to get back to this place. Don't expect anything spectacular form the menu - they do pub grub well, and even the "healthier" salmon and chicken dishes are nice, but overall it's what I'd call average. The service here has always been stellar, though, so I have no complaints there. A very friendly staff from management to hostess. They also handle kids well, with numerous kid menu choices and a family friendly atmosphere. For me, Rusty Bucket's niche is found in summer evenings on the patio having a drink and a bite to eat with the family. No fortune blown, but a satisfying experience.
(3)
Ryan M.
Wanted to try a new restaurant out while I was down in Columbus shopping, thought this would be a fun place to try. -Service was pretty good, nothing to complain about -Lots of beer choices, prices seemed fair -Ordered the Mac N Cheese dinner platter, very disappointed on quantity, this could be sold as a side platter. it was good though -Reminds me of a TGIF, but with less of a deal. I probably would not eat there again, wasn't all impressed, but it wasn't horrible
(3)
Jordan M.
Friendly service and consistent, quality food.
(4)
Zack R.
Let's talk wings. They're a little pricy at around $9 per pound. They're a little small. In fact, I don't think you actually get a full pound in the "pound". All that said, they are some of the tastiest wings I've ever had ever. Period. I can't say anything bad about any of the flavors I tried: chipotle, sweet chili, Joe's original, and sriracha. All of them were excellent, and prepared perfectly. Not breading like Roosters does it either! Also our server, Lauren, was super friendly. Upon her recommendation, we also finished the night with the bread pudding cinnamon role thingy. Oh holy night, was that thing good. A soaked cinnamon roll with fresh whipped cream and vanilla ice cream. So simple, yet so damn good. And to no fault of hers, the place was slow. Like reeeaaaaly slow. They definitely lose a star for that. But I will say, when the wing crave comes calling, I will be back!
(3)
Chrissy B.
Consistently good food with a gluten free menu. The staff is delightful and competent. They have Angry Orchard on tap. All things I look for in a restaurant. Safe eating with good service.
(4)
Karen W.
Been here many times and never had a bad meal or experience here. The food is very good and they offer a variety of foods too. The atmosphere is perfect and if you can get a seat out on the patio, do it!! They keep the drinks coming so that you can enjoy your time at the restaurant!
(4)
Marissa C.
We enjoy the ambiance and food at the Rusty Bucket. The patio is great - very relaxing and a nice place to enjoy a casual meal and drinks. The inside has the feel of a sports bar, with lots of TVs, making it a great place to catch a game. I've visited this location at a couple of different times and days, and there is a distinct difference in experience. While the service I have received is always friendly and attentive, and the food good, the biggest issue I notice is the amount of time it takes for the food to arrive after ordering. I won't go during a lunch hour any more, as it consistently has taken much too long for the food to arrive. That said, the one time when a group of us literally had to request the food to be boxed the moment it appeared on the table, the manager personally came over and apologized and gave us all of our meals free. That was much appreciated. On the other hand, we've had very good experiences with reasonable timing going in at different times, whether in a large group or just my husband and I. Now, as to the food specifically - my husband particularly enjoys the burgers and the buffalo chicken sandwich, and the generous portion of fries that comes with these dishes. I've sampled several items off of the gluten-free menu, all of which have been tasty, but my favorite is the Grilled BBQ Chicken plate. It comes with a large juicy piece of chicken slathered in a very tasty version of BBQ sauce, some creamy and completely sinful cheddar mashed potatoes, and skillet beans. Now, the first time I ordered this, I was not sure what to expect with "skillet beans." I LOVE them. They are crisp tender green beans with slivers of onion and red pepper and piece of bacon. Amazing - talk about comfort food! My mouth is watering just describing the dish. I also love that I can get a Woodchuck here.
(4)
Tim S.
Not much that stands out here. I have not had terrible experiences, but certainly forgettable ones. Food is average to below average and service is about the same. I think they are confused on what type if restaurant they want to be as well...seems like a combination of a couple concepts. Drinks are nothing great, and weak.
(2)
Lynnette S.
Great location, good food and impressed they had a gluten free menu. Our server was the major downer. We had to wait over five minutes for my daughter's meal to come. The server then asked how everything was so far--ummm...we have been waiting to start, don't know. Also, he flirted with the table next to us (two college ladies)--hovering, joking, talking, talking, talking...it was unprofessional and annoying. Food was good though, see pics here: dinnerswithourdaughter.b… .
(2)
Megan M.
This place gets three stars for its deep-fried pickles, standard pub fare, extensive beer selection, etc. What I'd like to really talk about is the problem of the children. This restaurant is overrun with children. Running, screaming, bumping-into-you children. I had to move from the patio because two toddlers were running around at top speed, screaming so loud I couldn't hear my friend. So we moved to the bar, where I sat next to half of a soccer team of little girls. Maybe I'm just sounding grumpy here, but it's hard to enjoy my seasonal Oktoberfest brew while elbow-to-elbow with an eight-year-old in pigtails. So, if you'd like a peaceful, kid-free happy hour, I suggest you go somewhere else. If you are looking for a place to toss back a few drinks while your kids run amok, this restaurant is for you!
(3)
Molly B.
During the day of the first OSU game, I was desperate to find a place to watch the game. I didn't want to go on campus but I didn't want to drive too far away from my house either. Rusty Bucket is within walking distance to my house, but I had never been there. I decided to call them to see if we could get a table. Not only could we get a table that day, but it wasn't crowded at all. Rusty Bucket saved the game for me. We sat on the patio and had a big TV to ourselves. The beer list is huge and the food is decent. I'd give it 4 stars if it weren't a chain.
(3)
Brian B.
The Rusty Bucket is just your average chain restaurant. It's got decent atmosphere and tvs everywhere (including the bathroom) but for some reason it all feels manufactured. The food is decent but I just can't help thinking of all the other unique and local restaurants in Columbus that one could eat. Not bad, but not great.
(3)
Mindy W.
This review is strictly for Whopper Jr....you know who you are. I love the finlandia cosmo, although yesterday I stuck with iced tea. I enjoy the Rusty Bucket, although it's not my favorite "tavern" on earth. The service is almost always good, the ambience is fun and the food is decent although nothing too exciting. I used to come here much more frequently when I lived over on Olde Henderson, but my trips are few and far between now that I don't live as close. Go for the burger, the cheesesteak, the fried pickles...hard to go wrong with those choices. It's definitely a good place for a group of people when nobody knows what they want!
(3)
Hannah M.
Order the mac 'n cheese. Even if you're lactose intolerant, trust me. You won't regret it...really. The lemon chicken was pretty good as well and my boyfriend enjoyed his fish and chips, but I definitely snacked on my friend's mac 'n cheese throughout the meal (she told me to- I swear!). The server was nice and attentive, but I do wish they had a better selection of ciders. This place is supposed to have a solid beer selection and I get that ciders are a little alternative, but still. Woodchuck is good but it's not the only good cider around! Give me some options, please.
(4)
Bill C.
So Yelp has compelled me to write this review, as I am "The Duke" of Rusty Bucket on Lane Ave. Okey dokey....here I go. I really really like the Rusty Bucket. I go there at least once a week. The atmosphere is comfy and warm, its usually busy and vibrant and has a very convenient location. let's start with the "meh" and finish strong: 1) Food. well, the food at the Bucket is pretty weak. I eat there every Tuesday for the spaghetti special (which is awesome) but otherwise, you'll find traditional tavern fare done just OK. The chili is good as are most sandwiches, but if it's an entree you're looking for....well just don't 2) Drinks. Great rectangular bar usually filled with interesting and friendly regulars. Good draught beer selection and very interesting signature cocktails. Fresh-squeezed juices and fresh fruit ingredients/garni make the cocktail menu verrry appealing. If I'm not eating spaghetti on Tues, I'm one of those regulars. 3) Staff/Service. Just awesome. From Management to hostii, the front of the house staff here is incredible. Always friendly, upbeat, efficient and product-knowledgeable, I don't know of a better ensemble of service folks (and trust me, I should) So, I'll continue my weekly+ Dukedom and encourage those who like a great environment with great staff to visit the Bucket ASAP. I'll be the devastatingly handsome fat guy drinking a Stella at the bar...say hi. :)
(4)
L b.
I've eaten here three times which means this place has exhausted it's second chances. The most recent offender: the buffalo chicken sandwich. "Panko breaded chicken" = gross... although it sounded good. A grilled chicken breast would have been a lot better. A lot of buffalo sauce, and I'm not sure I actually spotted any blue cheese on it as advertised. When I let myself eat bar food, I want it to be delicious and worth the calories. I always find myself leavning this place wishing I'd had a salad.
(2)
Ka T.
Considering this is right up the street from me, Ive chosen this resturant over other bar type food in the area. The staff is very friendly and the food has always been good.
(5)
Andrew F.
I will not be going back to this location. Sadly, from now one we are making the extra long trip to the Bucket in Dublin where I have been many times and always been happy. My GF and I went here tonight and I was compelled to sign up with yelp just to tell how awful our entrees were. First of all, our waitress was very nice and she was trying hard to keep up. Still our service was very slow which was not her fault, but she barely checked on us after we got our food bc she was so overworked, not bc she didn't care. We had the fried pickles which were amazing as always, then it was all downhill from there. Our food was so over cooked that it ruined everything. I had the Saturday special BBQ ribs with fries and slaw and my GF had the taco salad. My ribs weren't burnt, but they were so dried out and flavorless I almost sent them back, but I always fear doing that. The fries tasted good, but were covered in BBQ sauce and squished bc they set the ribs on top of them. Then the slaw was sweet which I like, but was so watered down I took 2 bites and pushed it away. My GF's taco salad looked gross despite her pumping it up so much before she got her food. To me it looked like a big pile of watery shredded lettuce with a spoon of salsa on top. Apparently the beef was hidden under the salad, but I didn't see much beef. The tortilla shell on the bottom was so hard that she could hardly cut it and she was so disappointed. She said it was the worst taco salad she has ever had despite loving it every time at other Buckets. Then there were little kids everywhere and the whole restaurant was so loud I could hardly hear half of what my GF said throughout the meal. Again, I would have sent both of our meals back, but I always fear retaliation when it comes to that stuff. Dublin here we come baby!
(1)
Randy S.
I've been drawn to the Rusty Bucket since I heard from a friend that it is similar to Old Bag of Nails -- a restaurant I dig a good bit. Somehow, I've waited a few years to try the Rusty Bucket. I finally visited the Lane Avenue location today. Just like that other C-bus chain, the Bucket specializes in pub grub. They've got deep-fried pickles, fish and chips, burgers and the like. However, they fall short of Old Bag of Nails' standard. I prefer Old Bag's slightly "pubbier" atmosphere. It's darker, has a better draft beer selection and just seems more local somehow. Food-wise, I prefer the Old Bag there too. Rusty Bucket does a good job with burgers (juicy and flavorful even when well cooked), but I miss the sliders at the Old Bag. I had the Elvis burger (lots of sauteed onions and Velveeta cheese), which was tasty but absurdly messy. The bun just couldn't hold up to the toppings. The fries were flavorful but a little overcooked. Above all, the experience felt a bit too much like a good day at a Max & Erma's.
(3)
Emily D.
It's not my FAVORITE Irish pub, but they do have a pretty good fish sandwich. This location has a lot of TVs so it's good for watching a game. The servers are always nice and fast with your order, which is great because normally I'm just here to grab a bite between errands.
(3)
Travis Z.
This is a fun establishment that has great bar food. It has nice decor inside and a nice patio.
(4)
F Z.
I finally got the chance to see what the Rusty Bucket Corner Tavern is really all about. The reason? VetDoc needed a couple of beers. I've always driven by the place since it's in the same mall complex as New York and Company, one of my favorite stores, but have never actually felt the need to step inside since it's known for its comfort food. Apparently Rusty Bucket is known for its deep fried pickles with ranch dipping sauce. I love pickles... on my burgers. Not trans-fat loaded and, well, more trans-fat loaded assuming we take into account the ranch sauce. I was feeling somewhat healthful when I looked at the menu which probably explained my ordering the lemon chicken. VetDoc went straight for one of the manly dishes offered, the Turkey Club Sandwich. I took one look at his mayo-ladened sandwich and opted not to try it. (I silently vowed to run an extra 20 minutes on the treadmill at the gym for VetDoc later that day.) My lemon chicken looked and tasted healthy, despite the menu's claim that the sauce all over my plate was garlic sauce. The mashed potatoes, however, were far too lemony/sour and clashed with my palate and just how mashed potatoes should taste in general. I think Rusty Bucket tried a little too hard to make their menu sound somewhat ethnic infused. I mean, hummus as an appetizer option? Pan-seared salmon entree? I think they should just stick to the whole concept of being the place for comfort food -- and comfort food done right, for that matter. Rusty Bucket is exactly what it is: a tavern. So don't expect a fancy schmancy restaurant.
(2)
Pete C.
The Rusty Bucket is an awesome little bar with loads more character than you'd expect from a place in a shiny new "Gateway" style plaza that was built with the hopes of pushing the ghetto just a few more blocks closer to the city. After all, this is Bexley; what would you expect? Anyways, this area is rather deprived of a bar scene, which makes the Rusty Bucket that much more valuable for actually being a decent place to drink and hang out. The drinks aren't as cheap as I'd like, but for a destination for just an hour or two of drinking and catching up with friends that have relocated to different sides of the cty after graduation, I couldn't ask for anything more. The tap selection is bountiful and has a few much-appreciated curveballs, the scenery is lowkey and surprisingly un-suburban, the porch is beautiful, and the bartenders tend to be the friendly lot that you can converse with before your friends arrive. Perhaps the proximity to Capital University lends to a younger feel at times, but either way I'm appreciative of the lack of Bexley snobbery that could potential ruin an otherwise decent bar.
(4)
Walt S.
Setting the stage. The Buckeyes had just gotten kicked to the curb by the Badgers in hoops. I had just finished 4.5 hours of interior labor and was heading home and was hungry. The PGA TOUR at Riviera CC/L.A. had 2 hours to go and I love golf. So The Rusty Bucket Corner Tavern on Lane Avenue captured me. And it was A-OK! I was greeted by not one but two hostesses, both perky and kind. I chose the bar - they went back to chit-chatting. The place was about half full due to the Buckeye loss. I sat at the bar and was greeted by Courtney who works part-time, one day being Sunday; she was full of spirit and smiles. Nice! I had diet soda and ordered the Spinach Queso dip and the Ahi Tuna Wrap as an entree. The queso was surprisingly delicious even though in my brain I was expecting to see a more white queso than the more cheesier melt with spinach. Spicey! The dip had nice heat to it both from the oven and with spices. I sat, read the Dispatch and dipped quietly. Then came the Ahi Tuna Wrap with a side of cucumber tomato salad (that had goat cheese, I believe). This was a good meal; the wrap was bigger than planned so half went home with me. I enjoyed watching the PGA TOUR on TV (several options to watch; some too high up causing me to crane my neck - yes, nitpicking). Maybe it's me but to have a tuna wrap, dip and a diet soda.... for $22,... pricing isn't modest at this Rusty Bucket. The menu is diverse and I will return to try another entree' - I want to try their wings.
(3)
Bobbi K.
Great experience! Went there with a daughter that has tons of allergies, Chef Jason and out awesome waitress Mary made a special meal for her that was in her words "amazing!!"! We will come here again. Only down side, it's a bit spendy. Price aside, this place is wonderful!
(4)
Alaina C.
Consistently good food every time I eat here. I've never had a bad meal. Favorites include the bucket of shrimp, buffalo chicken sandwich, and the beef stroganoff (Wednesday special). Meatloaf is also good.
(4)
Doug O.
There are a lot of wonderful independent bars in this city, and generally I would head to any one of them before going to a chain like this. That being said, I had a surprisingly good experience at The Rusty Bucket. My wife and I went with a few friends on a Wednesday night for the $5 whiskey special. There were plenty of seats at the bar, as they have built a nice, large wraparound bar. The bartenders were friendly and attentive. There was a surprisingly good beer list, and top shelf bourbons were on sale for $5, which is an offer I can't refuse. The bar had a warm and friendly atmosphere. The room was large and accommodating, and there were lots of nice TVs, so this might actually be a solid place to watch a game. It was too cold for the patio, but that looked pretty nice too. A lot better than I would have expected from a corporatey, chainy place. Don't sell it short just because it isn't terribly unique or original. It's actually a pretty solid place.
(3)
Zach M.
I like Rusty Bucket, I really do. Good location. Good atmosphere, feels neighborhoody. Clean. Great drinks. But everytime I come here I always leave with the feeling it's not as good as I think it is. It's basically a TGI Friday with a better bar. The recent remodel came me that feeling more than ever. It's not bad, I'm sure I'll stop in again, but I always leave kind of unsatisfied. It's good for a quick bite though.
(3)
L A.
I have received two follow ups from the manager, regarding our experience. When I spoke with Jen today, she was very through in explaining the evening, and situation, kind, and accommodating. Perhaps that night was a bad night for everyone. She assured things will be improved upon in the future regarding service. Will of course give it another shot.
(3)
Karen M.
I went with a group of ladies...sixteen of us. The service was great for a group of that size. They had rogue beer on tap. And my burger was perfectly cooked. I would recommend this place and will go back! Um... Oops my fries were cold. The pizza looks delish as well!
(4)
Doug W.
A nice ambience and good food will bring me back to the Rusty Bucket. I had a delicious reuben and sampled some of the pizza which was pretty good. It was very crowded on a Friday night, but so was every other place within a few miles. Worth the wait.
(4)
Albert H.
My wife and I celebrated our 44th Anniversary at Rusty Bucket on Lane ave, we sat at the bar and had great service from the bar tender Ryan and Britney, I had the chicken parmesan which Ryan recommended and was excellent and my wife had the meatloaf which was good, we definitely will go back and highly recommend this restaurant!
(4)
Steve D.
Not a bad place. Drinks and food are decent. Staff is cute and friendly enough. Issues though: Prices are a little high, congestion always at the door, parking is almost always full, the music and voices very loud, and there are buggin' TVs EVERYWHERE. You can't even take a leak without hearing people on TV cheering you on. I go back when friends are there, but that's about it.
(2)
Stephen P.
Rusty Bucket has a great staff and beer selection. The food is mostly average, except for the buffalo chicken sandwich. I routinely stop by alone on lunch breaks solely for the buffalo chicken sandwich- I have never found one as good as the one at Rusty Bucket. Outside of that, I never really had anything that I disliked or could rave about like the buffalo chicken. Definitely a good place for a quick lunch, or to have a few drinks. The patio is great for relaxing and drinking on. Sidenote, they use these awesome devices attached to the check presenter that allows you to swipe your credit card at the table. The device then turns green so the server can pick it up and print your receipts. I had never seen anything like it, and thought it was pretty awesome.
(3)
Erin S.
We recently moved from Worthington to UA area. We love the RB by Worthington Hills and decided to place a take out order at RB on Lane. My husband ordered fish and chips, my son had the kids mac n cheese, I had the asian tuna wrap with sweet potato fries, and we ordered two sticky bun bread puddings for dessert. We were so disappointed. We have ordered all of these items before (in house and take out) and it seems like the serving size for everything was cut in half. All of us ordered fries and each received less than a handful. My husband's fish was below average and ate only half of it and the tuna in my sandwich was tough. The only thing that was edible was the mac n cheese, small serving size of fries, and the ice cream that came with the bread pudding. Oh, the bread pudding was the biggest disappointment. Salt. We couldn't taste anything, but salt. We love this bread pudding and hoped that it would make up for everything else with our order. So sad. Unfortunately, we won't be going back any time soon.
(2)
Russ R.
I have given the Bucket a couple tries but time to kick the bucket to the curb. Ok service at best and a horrible Rueben on its best day but made worse by it being ice cold. Good thing I have the option not to go back and I am gonna take it.
(2)
Whitney S.
Rusty Bucket is always a great place for some good food! There aren't many places to get peel-n-eat shrimp in Columbus, but this is one!! They're smothered in old bay (of course) and come with cocktail sauce and their creamy Texas sauce... YUM. Wednesday's are Whiskey Wednesdays.. Any bourbon or whiskey (all the way to tip top shelf) are $6! They also have a patio to enjoy the increasingly nice weather!
Takes Reservations : Yes Delivery : No Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Dinner Parking : Private Lot Bike Parking : Yes Wheelchair Accessible : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Ambience : Casual Noise Level : Average Alcohol : Full Bar Outdoor Seating : Yes Wi-Fi : No Has TV : Yes Waiter Service : Yes
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
Luke T.
My co-worker and I lost the server lottery at lunch today. We were promptly greeted by a host and sat at a little two top in the bar area, but the prompt service ended there. We waited for over five minutes just for someone to come by and offer us water. For that to finally happen, it took other servers noticing and coming over to cover for our waitress. One came to us while the other went to find her. But hey, at least since it took ten minutes for her to show we already knew what we wanted to eat. We put in our orders and began the next longest wait ever. At this point the surrounding two tops were still empty. Every second of twenty minutes passed before I noticed that a guy sitting behind us, who hadn't even been there when we ordered, had already ordered and been served his food. By now it was 12:40 (we got there around noon or so), so I had to go make the bartender aware of the situation. Told him we had jobs to get to (writing this in the car ride back - six minutes late for our 1 p.m. meeting) and he immediately got our food and notified the manager (implying that it had been sitting there waiting under a heat lamp). The manager came over and apologized, and looked like she might offer us something on the house, but didn't. Maybe we weren't rude enough? Then she went on her way. All told our server filled our waters once and brought us a check. She came back and offered us dessert, said it would be on the house. However we didn't have time for dessert so we passed. You'd think after that you'd get a discount, a comp or something, but no, nothing at all. Horrible experience. Tipped 10% when I probably should've stiffed. Guess I'm not the asshole I used to be. Chalk it up to old age.
(1)Anne Z.
Slow service. Mediocre food. Chain food, so don't expect anything special. Nice patio.
(2)Tyler S.
Had delicious French onion soup, a hummus appetizer and turkey club sandwich. I'd recommend all three of those, especially the hummus app.
(5)Jamie C.
I used to love the Rusty Bucket and considered it one of the restaurants you can always count on for good food and good service. I'm really disappointed to say the past two visits have not met my expectations. The food had some issues; a hard branch of kale in a salad and a hair in my dip. This past time my family and I sat at the bar and waited 15 minutes with empty glasses before we had to ask for refills ourselves. We've always had great service until now so that was disappointing. I just wanted to write in so that Rusty Bucket has a chance to get back to the level of service I've come to know from them. Would really like to go back one day...
(2)Ben C.
Good overall, I usually get a burger and its always comes out the way it should. The buffalo chicken sandwich is a good choice add well. Service is usually prompt but once we had a rarely seen server.
(4)Marsha F.
The Rusty Bucket on Lane Avenue is hands-down the best overall restaurant in the City of Columbus. The food is consistently superb. The waitstaff is friendly. Once in a blue moon, the kitchen is slow, but the vibe of TV sports makes the wait no big deal.
(5)Amanda D.
The food is average, but definitely will not disappoint. If you want to watch a sports game and eat a good burger with fries I'd say go here.
(3)Christiana C.
My sister and I were jonesing for wings on a game day, but didn't want to wait or be FORCED to watch the game. In came Rusty Bucket! We got seated right away and while there's an OPPORTUNITY for watching the game (on multiple TVs and a huge projector screen with multiple events shown at once), you can also have an experience where you are not bombarded with the game (should it not be your team or should you dread the words "the game" in any capacity). Our waitress was great and made it a point to allow us to try multiple brews on tap to make sure we got the one we wanted (maybe I am cheaply bought, but this behavior just makes me love a waitress more). And the food! We got wings in Classic Joe sauce (recommended by said waitress) and I loved them. I wish they had boneless wings but when I'm jonesing and not ready to wait somewhere else, Rusty Bucket is totally my new go-to.
(4)Christina C.
I am tempted to make some sort of witty pun on the name "Rusty Bucket" - but I got nothin'. And it would be completely irrelevant. For restaurant amenities and overall ambiance: 4 stars For unique drink selection: 4 stars For food quality: 2 stars Average: 3 First of all this is your run of the mill sports-bar-like tavern with tv's for games and beverages for consuming; however, the menu classes the place up a bit with a plethora of impressive-sounding options making it a perfect suburbanite destination. On this said visit, I tried the buffalo chicken sandwich with the cucumber and tomato salad as my side. Pretty standard actually - nothing too over the top - the bun was underwhelming and the breading was overwhelming. I guess they didn't get the memo I'm watching my carb intake. Alas, my hope was in the cucumber and tomato salad since it had feta cheese (my favorite) - but that too was underwhelming and actually quite chewy. Yes, chewy veggies. Now let's talk highlights! The Bucket scores major points for a fire pit outside on the patio, daily blue plate specials, daily drink specials (including a Finlandia vodka and pineapple diddy!) and TV's in the bathrooms.Yes, TV's in the bathrooms.
(3)Amanda K.
i really enjoy this place. I'm not one for chain restaurants, but I can't deny how delicious the slider appetizer is, and the buffalo chicken sandwich is scrumptious! they have a nice patio, and service is typically great.
(4)Rusty G.
Great atmosphere, friendly staff, great neighborhood bar and grill. The food is very good for bar style menu.
(5)Tina F.
Awesome Martinis & Veggie Burgers! This is much better than your typical chain restaurant. The veggie burger is not from a box, but home made. It has lots of beans and some rice in it and it comes topped with a delicious roasted red pepper relish - so it is very juicy and flavorful. It comes with fries but for a little extra you can get the Double Nickel Salad - which is like the old 55 salad - very good - make sure to ask for no bacon if you're vegetarian! The Martinis are delicious - I love the Key Lime. It is sweet but not overly so, but I would still choose it for dessert! It is usually crowded, so you either have to wait for a table or sit outside. I usually sit outside on the big covered patio.
(4)Amanda B.
I headed here with a group of 12 friends on a Wednesday night. It's a pretty "normal" sports bar type of place, but the menu seems designed to be a bit classier than your average pub grub so I was interested in checking it out. Unfortunately, I was disappointed. The food was atrocious. I got the taco salad, which oddly looked more like cole slaw and was so bad that I took two bites and gave up (and I hate wasting food). My friend got fish that was so greasy that she also couldn't eat it. Some other folks at our table got the small pizzas, which were OK but also pretty greasy and nothing to write home about. The only thing that seemed to go over well at our table was the mac 'n cheese. Otherwise, everything seemed too bland, too greasy, too low-quality. I think they really missed the mark on aiming for classy pub food. This wasn't even decent pub food. The waitress and waiter at our table were friendly, and you could tell they were trying. But it was obvious they weren't prepared to handle a large table of people in addition to the rest of the crowd- I think they may have been understaffed. It took about 20-25 minutes for them to even take our orders. The food came out quickly once it was ordered though. The only plus I can see is the place looked comfortable and the staff was friendly. There was a big bar with plenty of seating and what looked like a pretty relaxed, friendly crowd. The patio looks like it would be nice in warm weather. Unfortunately, the cover and the heaters they used in an attempt to make it into cold weather seating weren't really enough and I was half freezing while I was waiting for my food. Overall, a pretty disappointing experience with a menu that at face-value looked like it had promise.
(2)Amanda H.
Star Clarification: 3 if you sit on the patio. 2 if you're forced to endure the arctic blast of the A/C, volume decibels rivaling an airport runway and (and this is strictly my opinion) a sad, sports zombie crowd inside. If you're not the sports bar type (and/or don't have a downy undercoat or three-inch layer of subcutaneous fat), don't bother with the Bucket indoors. The patio, however, is another world, and with the warm weather approaching, I'll finally be able to get back to this place. Don't expect anything spectacular form the menu - they do pub grub well, and even the "healthier" salmon and chicken dishes are nice, but overall it's what I'd call average. The service here has always been stellar, though, so I have no complaints there. A very friendly staff from management to hostess. They also handle kids well, with numerous kid menu choices and a family friendly atmosphere. For me, Rusty Bucket's niche is found in summer evenings on the patio having a drink and a bite to eat with the family. No fortune blown, but a satisfying experience.
(3)Ryan M.
Wanted to try a new restaurant out while I was down in Columbus shopping, thought this would be a fun place to try. -Service was pretty good, nothing to complain about -Lots of beer choices, prices seemed fair -Ordered the Mac N Cheese dinner platter, very disappointed on quantity, this could be sold as a side platter. it was good though -Reminds me of a TGIF, but with less of a deal. I probably would not eat there again, wasn't all impressed, but it wasn't horrible
(3)Jordan M.
Friendly service and consistent, quality food.
(4)Zack R.
Let's talk wings. They're a little pricy at around $9 per pound. They're a little small. In fact, I don't think you actually get a full pound in the "pound". All that said, they are some of the tastiest wings I've ever had ever. Period. I can't say anything bad about any of the flavors I tried: chipotle, sweet chili, Joe's original, and sriracha. All of them were excellent, and prepared perfectly. Not breading like Roosters does it either! Also our server, Lauren, was super friendly. Upon her recommendation, we also finished the night with the bread pudding cinnamon role thingy. Oh holy night, was that thing good. A soaked cinnamon roll with fresh whipped cream and vanilla ice cream. So simple, yet so damn good. And to no fault of hers, the place was slow. Like reeeaaaaly slow. They definitely lose a star for that. But I will say, when the wing crave comes calling, I will be back!
(3)Chrissy B.
Consistently good food with a gluten free menu. The staff is delightful and competent. They have Angry Orchard on tap. All things I look for in a restaurant. Safe eating with good service.
(4)Karen W.
Been here many times and never had a bad meal or experience here. The food is very good and they offer a variety of foods too. The atmosphere is perfect and if you can get a seat out on the patio, do it!! They keep the drinks coming so that you can enjoy your time at the restaurant!
(4)Marissa C.
We enjoy the ambiance and food at the Rusty Bucket. The patio is great - very relaxing and a nice place to enjoy a casual meal and drinks. The inside has the feel of a sports bar, with lots of TVs, making it a great place to catch a game. I've visited this location at a couple of different times and days, and there is a distinct difference in experience. While the service I have received is always friendly and attentive, and the food good, the biggest issue I notice is the amount of time it takes for the food to arrive after ordering. I won't go during a lunch hour any more, as it consistently has taken much too long for the food to arrive. That said, the one time when a group of us literally had to request the food to be boxed the moment it appeared on the table, the manager personally came over and apologized and gave us all of our meals free. That was much appreciated. On the other hand, we've had very good experiences with reasonable timing going in at different times, whether in a large group or just my husband and I. Now, as to the food specifically - my husband particularly enjoys the burgers and the buffalo chicken sandwich, and the generous portion of fries that comes with these dishes. I've sampled several items off of the gluten-free menu, all of which have been tasty, but my favorite is the Grilled BBQ Chicken plate. It comes with a large juicy piece of chicken slathered in a very tasty version of BBQ sauce, some creamy and completely sinful cheddar mashed potatoes, and skillet beans. Now, the first time I ordered this, I was not sure what to expect with "skillet beans." I LOVE them. They are crisp tender green beans with slivers of onion and red pepper and piece of bacon. Amazing - talk about comfort food! My mouth is watering just describing the dish. I also love that I can get a Woodchuck here.
(4)Tim S.
Not much that stands out here. I have not had terrible experiences, but certainly forgettable ones. Food is average to below average and service is about the same. I think they are confused on what type if restaurant they want to be as well...seems like a combination of a couple concepts. Drinks are nothing great, and weak.
(2)Lynnette S.
Great location, good food and impressed they had a gluten free menu. Our server was the major downer. We had to wait over five minutes for my daughter's meal to come. The server then asked how everything was so far--ummm...we have been waiting to start, don't know. Also, he flirted with the table next to us (two college ladies)--hovering, joking, talking, talking, talking...it was unprofessional and annoying. Food was good though, see pics here: dinnerswithourdaughter.b… .
(2)Megan M.
This place gets three stars for its deep-fried pickles, standard pub fare, extensive beer selection, etc. What I'd like to really talk about is the problem of the children. This restaurant is overrun with children. Running, screaming, bumping-into-you children. I had to move from the patio because two toddlers were running around at top speed, screaming so loud I couldn't hear my friend. So we moved to the bar, where I sat next to half of a soccer team of little girls. Maybe I'm just sounding grumpy here, but it's hard to enjoy my seasonal Oktoberfest brew while elbow-to-elbow with an eight-year-old in pigtails. So, if you'd like a peaceful, kid-free happy hour, I suggest you go somewhere else. If you are looking for a place to toss back a few drinks while your kids run amok, this restaurant is for you!
(3)Molly B.
During the day of the first OSU game, I was desperate to find a place to watch the game. I didn't want to go on campus but I didn't want to drive too far away from my house either. Rusty Bucket is within walking distance to my house, but I had never been there. I decided to call them to see if we could get a table. Not only could we get a table that day, but it wasn't crowded at all. Rusty Bucket saved the game for me. We sat on the patio and had a big TV to ourselves. The beer list is huge and the food is decent. I'd give it 4 stars if it weren't a chain.
(3)Brian B.
The Rusty Bucket is just your average chain restaurant. It's got decent atmosphere and tvs everywhere (including the bathroom) but for some reason it all feels manufactured. The food is decent but I just can't help thinking of all the other unique and local restaurants in Columbus that one could eat. Not bad, but not great.
(3)Mindy W.
This review is strictly for Whopper Jr....you know who you are. I love the finlandia cosmo, although yesterday I stuck with iced tea. I enjoy the Rusty Bucket, although it's not my favorite "tavern" on earth. The service is almost always good, the ambience is fun and the food is decent although nothing too exciting. I used to come here much more frequently when I lived over on Olde Henderson, but my trips are few and far between now that I don't live as close. Go for the burger, the cheesesteak, the fried pickles...hard to go wrong with those choices. It's definitely a good place for a group of people when nobody knows what they want!
(3)Hannah M.
Order the mac 'n cheese. Even if you're lactose intolerant, trust me. You won't regret it...really. The lemon chicken was pretty good as well and my boyfriend enjoyed his fish and chips, but I definitely snacked on my friend's mac 'n cheese throughout the meal (she told me to- I swear!). The server was nice and attentive, but I do wish they had a better selection of ciders. This place is supposed to have a solid beer selection and I get that ciders are a little alternative, but still. Woodchuck is good but it's not the only good cider around! Give me some options, please.
(4)Bill C.
So Yelp has compelled me to write this review, as I am "The Duke" of Rusty Bucket on Lane Ave. Okey dokey....here I go. I really really like the Rusty Bucket. I go there at least once a week. The atmosphere is comfy and warm, its usually busy and vibrant and has a very convenient location. let's start with the "meh" and finish strong: 1) Food. well, the food at the Bucket is pretty weak. I eat there every Tuesday for the spaghetti special (which is awesome) but otherwise, you'll find traditional tavern fare done just OK. The chili is good as are most sandwiches, but if it's an entree you're looking for....well just don't 2) Drinks. Great rectangular bar usually filled with interesting and friendly regulars. Good draught beer selection and very interesting signature cocktails. Fresh-squeezed juices and fresh fruit ingredients/garni make the cocktail menu verrry appealing. If I'm not eating spaghetti on Tues, I'm one of those regulars. 3) Staff/Service. Just awesome. From Management to hostii, the front of the house staff here is incredible. Always friendly, upbeat, efficient and product-knowledgeable, I don't know of a better ensemble of service folks (and trust me, I should) So, I'll continue my weekly+ Dukedom and encourage those who like a great environment with great staff to visit the Bucket ASAP. I'll be the devastatingly handsome fat guy drinking a Stella at the bar...say hi. :)
(4)L b.
I've eaten here three times which means this place has exhausted it's second chances. The most recent offender: the buffalo chicken sandwich. "Panko breaded chicken" = gross... although it sounded good. A grilled chicken breast would have been a lot better. A lot of buffalo sauce, and I'm not sure I actually spotted any blue cheese on it as advertised. When I let myself eat bar food, I want it to be delicious and worth the calories. I always find myself leavning this place wishing I'd had a salad.
(2)Ka T.
Considering this is right up the street from me, Ive chosen this resturant over other bar type food in the area. The staff is very friendly and the food has always been good.
(5)Andrew F.
I will not be going back to this location. Sadly, from now one we are making the extra long trip to the Bucket in Dublin where I have been many times and always been happy. My GF and I went here tonight and I was compelled to sign up with yelp just to tell how awful our entrees were. First of all, our waitress was very nice and she was trying hard to keep up. Still our service was very slow which was not her fault, but she barely checked on us after we got our food bc she was so overworked, not bc she didn't care. We had the fried pickles which were amazing as always, then it was all downhill from there. Our food was so over cooked that it ruined everything. I had the Saturday special BBQ ribs with fries and slaw and my GF had the taco salad. My ribs weren't burnt, but they were so dried out and flavorless I almost sent them back, but I always fear doing that. The fries tasted good, but were covered in BBQ sauce and squished bc they set the ribs on top of them. Then the slaw was sweet which I like, but was so watered down I took 2 bites and pushed it away. My GF's taco salad looked gross despite her pumping it up so much before she got her food. To me it looked like a big pile of watery shredded lettuce with a spoon of salsa on top. Apparently the beef was hidden under the salad, but I didn't see much beef. The tortilla shell on the bottom was so hard that she could hardly cut it and she was so disappointed. She said it was the worst taco salad she has ever had despite loving it every time at other Buckets. Then there were little kids everywhere and the whole restaurant was so loud I could hardly hear half of what my GF said throughout the meal. Again, I would have sent both of our meals back, but I always fear retaliation when it comes to that stuff. Dublin here we come baby!
(1)Randy S.
I've been drawn to the Rusty Bucket since I heard from a friend that it is similar to Old Bag of Nails -- a restaurant I dig a good bit. Somehow, I've waited a few years to try the Rusty Bucket. I finally visited the Lane Avenue location today. Just like that other C-bus chain, the Bucket specializes in pub grub. They've got deep-fried pickles, fish and chips, burgers and the like. However, they fall short of Old Bag of Nails' standard. I prefer Old Bag's slightly "pubbier" atmosphere. It's darker, has a better draft beer selection and just seems more local somehow. Food-wise, I prefer the Old Bag there too. Rusty Bucket does a good job with burgers (juicy and flavorful even when well cooked), but I miss the sliders at the Old Bag. I had the Elvis burger (lots of sauteed onions and Velveeta cheese), which was tasty but absurdly messy. The bun just couldn't hold up to the toppings. The fries were flavorful but a little overcooked. Above all, the experience felt a bit too much like a good day at a Max & Erma's.
(3)Emily D.
It's not my FAVORITE Irish pub, but they do have a pretty good fish sandwich. This location has a lot of TVs so it's good for watching a game. The servers are always nice and fast with your order, which is great because normally I'm just here to grab a bite between errands.
(3)Travis Z.
This is a fun establishment that has great bar food. It has nice decor inside and a nice patio.
(4)F Z.
I finally got the chance to see what the Rusty Bucket Corner Tavern is really all about. The reason? VetDoc needed a couple of beers. I've always driven by the place since it's in the same mall complex as New York and Company, one of my favorite stores, but have never actually felt the need to step inside since it's known for its comfort food. Apparently Rusty Bucket is known for its deep fried pickles with ranch dipping sauce. I love pickles... on my burgers. Not trans-fat loaded and, well, more trans-fat loaded assuming we take into account the ranch sauce. I was feeling somewhat healthful when I looked at the menu which probably explained my ordering the lemon chicken. VetDoc went straight for one of the manly dishes offered, the Turkey Club Sandwich. I took one look at his mayo-ladened sandwich and opted not to try it. (I silently vowed to run an extra 20 minutes on the treadmill at the gym for VetDoc later that day.) My lemon chicken looked and tasted healthy, despite the menu's claim that the sauce all over my plate was garlic sauce. The mashed potatoes, however, were far too lemony/sour and clashed with my palate and just how mashed potatoes should taste in general. I think Rusty Bucket tried a little too hard to make their menu sound somewhat ethnic infused. I mean, hummus as an appetizer option? Pan-seared salmon entree? I think they should just stick to the whole concept of being the place for comfort food -- and comfort food done right, for that matter. Rusty Bucket is exactly what it is: a tavern. So don't expect a fancy schmancy restaurant.
(2)Pete C.
The Rusty Bucket is an awesome little bar with loads more character than you'd expect from a place in a shiny new "Gateway" style plaza that was built with the hopes of pushing the ghetto just a few more blocks closer to the city. After all, this is Bexley; what would you expect? Anyways, this area is rather deprived of a bar scene, which makes the Rusty Bucket that much more valuable for actually being a decent place to drink and hang out. The drinks aren't as cheap as I'd like, but for a destination for just an hour or two of drinking and catching up with friends that have relocated to different sides of the cty after graduation, I couldn't ask for anything more. The tap selection is bountiful and has a few much-appreciated curveballs, the scenery is lowkey and surprisingly un-suburban, the porch is beautiful, and the bartenders tend to be the friendly lot that you can converse with before your friends arrive. Perhaps the proximity to Capital University lends to a younger feel at times, but either way I'm appreciative of the lack of Bexley snobbery that could potential ruin an otherwise decent bar.
(4)Walt S.
Setting the stage. The Buckeyes had just gotten kicked to the curb by the Badgers in hoops. I had just finished 4.5 hours of interior labor and was heading home and was hungry. The PGA TOUR at Riviera CC/L.A. had 2 hours to go and I love golf. So The Rusty Bucket Corner Tavern on Lane Avenue captured me. And it was A-OK! I was greeted by not one but two hostesses, both perky and kind. I chose the bar - they went back to chit-chatting. The place was about half full due to the Buckeye loss. I sat at the bar and was greeted by Courtney who works part-time, one day being Sunday; she was full of spirit and smiles. Nice! I had diet soda and ordered the Spinach Queso dip and the Ahi Tuna Wrap as an entree. The queso was surprisingly delicious even though in my brain I was expecting to see a more white queso than the more cheesier melt with spinach. Spicey! The dip had nice heat to it both from the oven and with spices. I sat, read the Dispatch and dipped quietly. Then came the Ahi Tuna Wrap with a side of cucumber tomato salad (that had goat cheese, I believe). This was a good meal; the wrap was bigger than planned so half went home with me. I enjoyed watching the PGA TOUR on TV (several options to watch; some too high up causing me to crane my neck - yes, nitpicking). Maybe it's me but to have a tuna wrap, dip and a diet soda.... for $22,... pricing isn't modest at this Rusty Bucket. The menu is diverse and I will return to try another entree' - I want to try their wings.
(3)Bobbi K.
Great experience! Went there with a daughter that has tons of allergies, Chef Jason and out awesome waitress Mary made a special meal for her that was in her words "amazing!!"! We will come here again. Only down side, it's a bit spendy. Price aside, this place is wonderful!
(4)Alaina C.
Consistently good food every time I eat here. I've never had a bad meal. Favorites include the bucket of shrimp, buffalo chicken sandwich, and the beef stroganoff (Wednesday special). Meatloaf is also good.
(4)Doug O.
There are a lot of wonderful independent bars in this city, and generally I would head to any one of them before going to a chain like this. That being said, I had a surprisingly good experience at The Rusty Bucket. My wife and I went with a few friends on a Wednesday night for the $5 whiskey special. There were plenty of seats at the bar, as they have built a nice, large wraparound bar. The bartenders were friendly and attentive. There was a surprisingly good beer list, and top shelf bourbons were on sale for $5, which is an offer I can't refuse. The bar had a warm and friendly atmosphere. The room was large and accommodating, and there were lots of nice TVs, so this might actually be a solid place to watch a game. It was too cold for the patio, but that looked pretty nice too. A lot better than I would have expected from a corporatey, chainy place. Don't sell it short just because it isn't terribly unique or original. It's actually a pretty solid place.
(3)Zach M.
I like Rusty Bucket, I really do. Good location. Good atmosphere, feels neighborhoody. Clean. Great drinks. But everytime I come here I always leave with the feeling it's not as good as I think it is. It's basically a TGI Friday with a better bar. The recent remodel came me that feeling more than ever. It's not bad, I'm sure I'll stop in again, but I always leave kind of unsatisfied. It's good for a quick bite though.
(3)L A.
I have received two follow ups from the manager, regarding our experience. When I spoke with Jen today, she was very through in explaining the evening, and situation, kind, and accommodating. Perhaps that night was a bad night for everyone. She assured things will be improved upon in the future regarding service. Will of course give it another shot.
(3)Karen M.
I went with a group of ladies...sixteen of us. The service was great for a group of that size. They had rogue beer on tap. And my burger was perfectly cooked. I would recommend this place and will go back! Um... Oops my fries were cold. The pizza looks delish as well!
(4)Doug W.
A nice ambience and good food will bring me back to the Rusty Bucket. I had a delicious reuben and sampled some of the pizza which was pretty good. It was very crowded on a Friday night, but so was every other place within a few miles. Worth the wait.
(4)Albert H.
My wife and I celebrated our 44th Anniversary at Rusty Bucket on Lane ave, we sat at the bar and had great service from the bar tender Ryan and Britney, I had the chicken parmesan which Ryan recommended and was excellent and my wife had the meatloaf which was good, we definitely will go back and highly recommend this restaurant!
(4)Steve D.
Not a bad place. Drinks and food are decent. Staff is cute and friendly enough. Issues though: Prices are a little high, congestion always at the door, parking is almost always full, the music and voices very loud, and there are buggin' TVs EVERYWHERE. You can't even take a leak without hearing people on TV cheering you on. I go back when friends are there, but that's about it.
(2)Stephen P.
Rusty Bucket has a great staff and beer selection. The food is mostly average, except for the buffalo chicken sandwich. I routinely stop by alone on lunch breaks solely for the buffalo chicken sandwich- I have never found one as good as the one at Rusty Bucket. Outside of that, I never really had anything that I disliked or could rave about like the buffalo chicken. Definitely a good place for a quick lunch, or to have a few drinks. The patio is great for relaxing and drinking on. Sidenote, they use these awesome devices attached to the check presenter that allows you to swipe your credit card at the table. The device then turns green so the server can pick it up and print your receipts. I had never seen anything like it, and thought it was pretty awesome.
(3)Erin S.
We recently moved from Worthington to UA area. We love the RB by Worthington Hills and decided to place a take out order at RB on Lane. My husband ordered fish and chips, my son had the kids mac n cheese, I had the asian tuna wrap with sweet potato fries, and we ordered two sticky bun bread puddings for dessert. We were so disappointed. We have ordered all of these items before (in house and take out) and it seems like the serving size for everything was cut in half. All of us ordered fries and each received less than a handful. My husband's fish was below average and ate only half of it and the tuna in my sandwich was tough. The only thing that was edible was the mac n cheese, small serving size of fries, and the ice cream that came with the bread pudding. Oh, the bread pudding was the biggest disappointment. Salt. We couldn't taste anything, but salt. We love this bread pudding and hoped that it would make up for everything else with our order. So sad. Unfortunately, we won't be going back any time soon.
(2)Russ R.
I have given the Bucket a couple tries but time to kick the bucket to the curb. Ok service at best and a horrible Rueben on its best day but made worse by it being ice cold. Good thing I have the option not to go back and I am gonna take it.
(2)Whitney S.
Rusty Bucket is always a great place for some good food! There aren't many places to get peel-n-eat shrimp in Columbus, but this is one!! They're smothered in old bay (of course) and come with cocktail sauce and their creamy Texas sauce... YUM. Wednesday's are Whiskey Wednesdays.. Any bourbon or whiskey (all the way to tip top shelf) are $6! They also have a patio to enjoy the increasingly nice weather!
(5)