Fresh and tasty! Perfect late night place for travelers ie. Pilots! Staff was friendly and the pizza was great!
(5)
Gerardo A.
If you are hungry at 4:00 AM in the morning, and you clubbing at White Plains, this is a good option to have a decent slice of pizza, afther you hit the bars. A disadvantage about Mario Pizza is that the place is very small, and their always a lot of people in this place. A good thing about the pizza is that their are fantastic. The slices are pretty large, had a thin/crispy bottom with a light fluff under the cheese, and topped with delicious cheese and sauce.
(3)
Joe R.
Best food for take out. The fries come crispy not soggy. Pizza is delicious, best bacon chicken ranch pizza in westcehster. Dinners are great, chicken marsala was amazing, comes with side and soup and plenty of bread!
(5)
Akshu J.
It is an ok place to go if you are looking for normal pizza. I prefer this joint when I am alone . I prefer ordering slice of pizza because those are larger than the normal pizza and are sufficient for a guy with average diet.
(3)
Jeff S.
If you eat at Mario's, your slices will most likely be great. Their delivery pizza in the other hand often arrives cold and crappy. Last 2 time we ordered, they gave us a 30 minute estimate, though the pizza arrived well after an hour. The driver apologized, but that didn't make the pizza any less sub-par. Perhaps it's time for Mario's to hire more drivers so they can get their pies out hot and fresh in a reasonable amount of time. But at the very least they should set more realistic delivery times so their customers don't wind up sitting around like silly geese nibbling on empty plates and folded napkins.
(3)
Murphy B.
Prices are so inconsistent!!! Whoever's behind the register decides what to run your pockets for. Nothing ever matches menu pricing, and they'll argue with you until close time over it. It really sucks because the pizza was good for the most part, but I can't stand feeling like I'm being taking advantage of when I'm giving you my business. There are just too many other options to have customers feeling this way.
(2)
Rick O.
Great pizza and delivery is consistently good. This is my go to pizza place in White Plains for traditional pizza and the whole wheat pizza is also excellent! They prep your pizza exactly as requested via onlne ordering. Don't change a thing!
(4)
Yesenia L.
Love the pizza ! Open late, great for a late night snack. My go to pizza place in White Plains. Garlic knots are sooo delicious
(5)
Myron G.
Best pizza for the cost in white plains. Generally i will only go here for pizza while im in town.
(4)
Anthony F.
Worst pizza in I had in a really long time unfortunately it was the only place open at the time for a cheap meal.
(1)
Jason L.
Great late night pizza place. Nobody was open but they were. Slices were good with a nice selection. The slices were also a good size. Two chicken slices and a soda for $9.25.
(4)
Ror S.
Nice atmosphere. Pizza was horrible, BBQ chicken pizza had no sauce on it and was dry as a bone.
(2)
Peter V.
Great pizza at a good price. This is our go to Friday night pizza place. There are a bunch of pizza places in White Plains, that are ok. Mario's wins out for take out. It is quick and delicious. We recently tried the Sicilian. Definitely a must try.
(5)
Giovanni H.
There's a short Spanish guy with glasses that works at Mario's who is very inappropriate. After enjoying my food, I go to leave and he opens the door for me(nice gesture right!) no! He rudely rubs against me as I leave. I feel violated. Unsatisfied customer!
(1)
Edward W.
The food was good. It's just the delivery/ driver was fresh. He did something uncalled for.
(3)
Itzel A.
This used to b my fab pizza in Wp but after last nights soggy old slice I must say they fell off .. The sauce tasted bland and the crust was really thin the cheese tasted old . And the cheese to top of ur slice is left outside something like that must places in fridge like other pizzerias.. Worst service avoid at all cost
(1)
Anuj S.
Pretty good slice. Big, floppy, and crispy, all at the same time and served piping hot. I think the sauce could've been a bit more flavorful. Great stop for a quick bite.
(4)
David D.
Mario's Pizza is the best pizza in white plains hands down...I've had them all. The regular slices offer everything that makes your mouth water in a slice of pizza including a thin crispy crust, a great blend of cheese, and a good tomatoe sauce. Cheese+sauce+dough=great balance. I also must insist that you try the sicilian slice(similar but not the same) as Sal's pizza in mamaroneck because the owners are cousins. But my absolute favorite pizza there is the chicken marsala pie!
(4)
Evita G.
This is a wonderful pizzeria hidden in plain sight. $3 for a solid reliable slice, hidden among all the very expensive places to eat in White Plains. Echoing some other views, slices are perfect around lunchtime, so try to go before 12:30
(5)
Maria C.
I always order Mario's sicilian pizza. Its huge!!! The price is awesome!!! It tastes just like home made!!!! The looks of the place are nothing great. But I order in and eat it home. I would never eat in the place. The dough is fresh, tasty & home made! Great pizza....hands down!!!
(5)
Ronnie K.
The pizza was real good but don't waste your money on the wings. They were soggy baked and you could tell they came from frozen.
(3)
Jimmy C.
The slice I got was bigger than at most places. It had lots of cheese, like I like it. With a bottle of diet coke: $4.50. The interior was clean, typical "pizza joint moderne," but a little cluttered. Like another poster mentioned, I like that you can see the pizza BEING MADE IN THE WINDOW! :) The staff seemed a little sullen, but it was a very nasty day, weather-wise, and business wasn't looking good.
(4)
Rob J.
After waiting an hour and a half for delivery it's not going to be a good review. Opening the box, the pizza looked like if had been through the ringer a bit. It was cold. Flavor wasn't bad though. The flavor got it an extra star.
(2)
Mike M.
I stopped in for a quick lunch one day in White Plains. I was really craving pizza and when I walked by this place, you could see the pizza being made through the glass window. That was enough for me to step in and order. The pizza was fantastic. The slices were pretty large, had a thin/crispy bottom with a light fluff under the cheese, and topped with delicious cheese and sauce. The crust was great as well - not too fluffy, but not too crispy. They didn't accept credit cards, contrary to what Yelp says, but maybe I was under the minimum order amount? My meal was about $7.00 and they told me no. Oh well - I'd still come back here. Recommended.
(4)
Moo J.
Giant slices, low prices!
(4)
Tedgrrr P.
I've been here a couple times, and the pre-made slices just aren't that good, and didn't taste very fresh. I imagine they probably spent a bit of time under heat lamps, before being re-heated. I'll probably keep coming from time to time because it's convenient, but I really wish it were better.
(2)
Alex F.
Slices here are pretty good and fairly priced. Great for a quick bite after work. At midnight on a Monday you'd be hard pressed to find a better option. For me, Mario's is the best pizza spot in this part of white plains. Loads better than Famiglia or Sunshine (that goes without saying) and slightly better than Nicky's across the street.
(4)
John M.
I must preface that I have never been here sober. I seem to end up here every time I go out in White Plains. The pizza is always good at 3am after drinking for 5hrs. Last time I was here I ate 2 plain slices, 1 Sicilian and 1 slice of pepperoni(which I wrapped around 2 pepperoni rolls). Like I said, I've never been here sober
(3)
Amy Y.
A great place for post-bar hopping munchies in White Plains. The slices aren't to-die for, but hey, you're going into a tiny pizza joint for a cheap slice. There's a decent seating area, and all you want is to fill your stomach right? Not bad at all.
(3)
Katie C.
Our go to pizza spot after bar hopping in White Plains. It's open late and the slices are big!
(3)
Stiph N.
I ordered some pies from this place today to feed my crew at a hotel in West Harrison. They delivered, and it was on time! The pizzas were better than I had anticipated, and the guy was patient with all my changes as I gave him my order. They also take credit card.
(4)
Matthew S.
I think we stopped here after the bar in white plains one night. From the business card I saved it says they have fast delivery, a $10 minimum, and they accept credit cards. Otherwise I got nothing.
(3)
Ray S.
Awesome sliced pizza, awesome Sicilian. Since it's not a gourmet item, sliced pizza to me falls into one of three categories: bad, mediocre, and great. I'm perfectly happy for the mediocre (nearby Pizza 2000), but Mario's is the sort of place I get excited for.
(5)
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
Address :23 Nelson Ave,Ste A
Staten Island, NY, 10308
Blake S.
Fresh and tasty! Perfect late night place for travelers ie. Pilots! Staff was friendly and the pizza was great!
(5)Gerardo A.
If you are hungry at 4:00 AM in the morning, and you clubbing at White Plains, this is a good option to have a decent slice of pizza, afther you hit the bars. A disadvantage about Mario Pizza is that the place is very small, and their always a lot of people in this place. A good thing about the pizza is that their are fantastic. The slices are pretty large, had a thin/crispy bottom with a light fluff under the cheese, and topped with delicious cheese and sauce.
(3)Joe R.
Best food for take out. The fries come crispy not soggy. Pizza is delicious, best bacon chicken ranch pizza in westcehster. Dinners are great, chicken marsala was amazing, comes with side and soup and plenty of bread!
(5)Akshu J.
It is an ok place to go if you are looking for normal pizza. I prefer this joint when I am alone . I prefer ordering slice of pizza because those are larger than the normal pizza and are sufficient for a guy with average diet.
(3)Jeff S.
If you eat at Mario's, your slices will most likely be great. Their delivery pizza in the other hand often arrives cold and crappy. Last 2 time we ordered, they gave us a 30 minute estimate, though the pizza arrived well after an hour. The driver apologized, but that didn't make the pizza any less sub-par. Perhaps it's time for Mario's to hire more drivers so they can get their pies out hot and fresh in a reasonable amount of time. But at the very least they should set more realistic delivery times so their customers don't wind up sitting around like silly geese nibbling on empty plates and folded napkins.
(3)Murphy B.
Prices are so inconsistent!!! Whoever's behind the register decides what to run your pockets for. Nothing ever matches menu pricing, and they'll argue with you until close time over it. It really sucks because the pizza was good for the most part, but I can't stand feeling like I'm being taking advantage of when I'm giving you my business. There are just too many other options to have customers feeling this way.
(2)Rick O.
Great pizza and delivery is consistently good. This is my go to pizza place in White Plains for traditional pizza and the whole wheat pizza is also excellent! They prep your pizza exactly as requested via onlne ordering. Don't change a thing!
(4)Yesenia L.
Love the pizza ! Open late, great for a late night snack. My go to pizza place in White Plains. Garlic knots are sooo delicious
(5)Myron G.
Best pizza for the cost in white plains. Generally i will only go here for pizza while im in town.
(4)Anthony F.
Worst pizza in I had in a really long time unfortunately it was the only place open at the time for a cheap meal.
(1)Jason L.
Great late night pizza place. Nobody was open but they were. Slices were good with a nice selection. The slices were also a good size. Two chicken slices and a soda for $9.25.
(4)Ror S.
Nice atmosphere. Pizza was horrible, BBQ chicken pizza had no sauce on it and was dry as a bone.
(2)Peter V.
Great pizza at a good price. This is our go to Friday night pizza place. There are a bunch of pizza places in White Plains, that are ok. Mario's wins out for take out. It is quick and delicious. We recently tried the Sicilian. Definitely a must try.
(5)Giovanni H.
There's a short Spanish guy with glasses that works at Mario's who is very inappropriate. After enjoying my food, I go to leave and he opens the door for me(nice gesture right!) no! He rudely rubs against me as I leave. I feel violated. Unsatisfied customer!
(1)Edward W.
The food was good. It's just the delivery/ driver was fresh. He did something uncalled for.
(3)Itzel A.
This used to b my fab pizza in Wp but after last nights soggy old slice I must say they fell off .. The sauce tasted bland and the crust was really thin the cheese tasted old . And the cheese to top of ur slice is left outside something like that must places in fridge like other pizzerias.. Worst service avoid at all cost
(1)Anuj S.
Pretty good slice. Big, floppy, and crispy, all at the same time and served piping hot. I think the sauce could've been a bit more flavorful. Great stop for a quick bite.
(4)David D.
Mario's Pizza is the best pizza in white plains hands down...I've had them all. The regular slices offer everything that makes your mouth water in a slice of pizza including a thin crispy crust, a great blend of cheese, and a good tomatoe sauce. Cheese+sauce+dough=great balance. I also must insist that you try the sicilian slice(similar but not the same) as Sal's pizza in mamaroneck because the owners are cousins. But my absolute favorite pizza there is the chicken marsala pie!
(4)Evita G.
This is a wonderful pizzeria hidden in plain sight. $3 for a solid reliable slice, hidden among all the very expensive places to eat in White Plains. Echoing some other views, slices are perfect around lunchtime, so try to go before 12:30
(5)Maria C.
I always order Mario's sicilian pizza. Its huge!!! The price is awesome!!! It tastes just like home made!!!! The looks of the place are nothing great. But I order in and eat it home. I would never eat in the place. The dough is fresh, tasty & home made! Great pizza....hands down!!!
(5)Ronnie K.
The pizza was real good but don't waste your money on the wings. They were soggy baked and you could tell they came from frozen.
(3)Jimmy C.
The slice I got was bigger than at most places. It had lots of cheese, like I like it. With a bottle of diet coke: $4.50. The interior was clean, typical "pizza joint moderne," but a little cluttered. Like another poster mentioned, I like that you can see the pizza BEING MADE IN THE WINDOW! :) The staff seemed a little sullen, but it was a very nasty day, weather-wise, and business wasn't looking good.
(4)Rob J.
After waiting an hour and a half for delivery it's not going to be a good review. Opening the box, the pizza looked like if had been through the ringer a bit. It was cold. Flavor wasn't bad though. The flavor got it an extra star.
(2)Mike M.
I stopped in for a quick lunch one day in White Plains. I was really craving pizza and when I walked by this place, you could see the pizza being made through the glass window. That was enough for me to step in and order. The pizza was fantastic. The slices were pretty large, had a thin/crispy bottom with a light fluff under the cheese, and topped with delicious cheese and sauce. The crust was great as well - not too fluffy, but not too crispy. They didn't accept credit cards, contrary to what Yelp says, but maybe I was under the minimum order amount? My meal was about $7.00 and they told me no. Oh well - I'd still come back here. Recommended.
(4)Moo J.
Giant slices, low prices!
(4)Tedgrrr P.
I've been here a couple times, and the pre-made slices just aren't that good, and didn't taste very fresh. I imagine they probably spent a bit of time under heat lamps, before being re-heated. I'll probably keep coming from time to time because it's convenient, but I really wish it were better.
(2)Alex F.
Slices here are pretty good and fairly priced. Great for a quick bite after work. At midnight on a Monday you'd be hard pressed to find a better option. For me, Mario's is the best pizza spot in this part of white plains. Loads better than Famiglia or Sunshine (that goes without saying) and slightly better than Nicky's across the street.
(4)John M.
I must preface that I have never been here sober. I seem to end up here every time I go out in White Plains. The pizza is always good at 3am after drinking for 5hrs. Last time I was here I ate 2 plain slices, 1 Sicilian and 1 slice of pepperoni(which I wrapped around 2 pepperoni rolls). Like I said, I've never been here sober
(3)Amy Y.
A great place for post-bar hopping munchies in White Plains. The slices aren't to-die for, but hey, you're going into a tiny pizza joint for a cheap slice. There's a decent seating area, and all you want is to fill your stomach right? Not bad at all.
(3)Katie C.
Our go to pizza spot after bar hopping in White Plains. It's open late and the slices are big!
(3)Stiph N.
I ordered some pies from this place today to feed my crew at a hotel in West Harrison. They delivered, and it was on time! The pizzas were better than I had anticipated, and the guy was patient with all my changes as I gave him my order. They also take credit card.
(4)Matthew S.
I think we stopped here after the bar in white plains one night. From the business card I saved it says they have fast delivery, a $10 minimum, and they accept credit cards. Otherwise I got nothing.
(3)Ray S.
Awesome sliced pizza, awesome Sicilian. Since it's not a gourmet item, sliced pizza to me falls into one of three categories: bad, mediocre, and great. I'm perfectly happy for the mediocre (nearby Pizza 2000), but Mario's is the sort of place I get excited for.
(5)