Key West Shrimp House
117 Ferry St, Madison, IN, 47250
Key West Shrimp House Menu
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.
Visit below restaurant in Madison for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Madison for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Madison for healthy meals suggestion.
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
-
Address :
117 Ferry St
Madison, IN, 47250 - Phone (812) 265-2831
- Website https://www.keywestshrimphouse.com/
- Click To Get Directions
Opening Hours
- Tue
Specialities
- Takes Reservations : No
Delivery : No
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Good For : Dinner
Parking : Private Lot
Bike Parking : Yes
Good for Kids : Yes
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Casual
Noise Level : Average
Alcohol : Full Bar
Outdoor Seating : No
Has TV : No
Waiter Service : Yes
Caters : No
WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES
Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online
Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.
Bob C.
Easter dinner with my family. There's only one choice for us and Key West is it. We were greeted by Susan and Brittney, who along with our server Andy, made sure we had a great experience from beginning to end. We ordered a variety of plates including crab cakes, coconut shrimp, and steaks, all of which was cooked as ordered and tasted great. There was also plenty to take home for later. The salad bar is great which includes their homemade cole slaw which I enjoyed a lot and went back for more. It would've been great to see Scott's cheerfulness too but we did get to sing happy birthday to a patron named John sitting next to us who was also having a great experience. I recommend you add Key West as your go to place for families or couples wanting to enjoy something extraordinary! Some things just make you go Woooo!
(5)Tim O.
Just don't go. You'll feel better hungry. Too much fried, fake, white bread, buttery fat laden crap. I guess the shrimp is OK. Anything else at your own risk. May have been good in days past. Not now.
(1)AJ R.
Is it possible to give a 1/2 star? VERY slow with our order. Food was average or less. Will not go back.
(1)Bethanie M.
My favorite place to eat in town. I am not a seafood eater, so I get the grilled chicken. It is to die for! So tasty! The only place in town worth getting grilled chicken. It is always fresh and hot! Today the owner, Scott brought out some home made BBQ sauce & man was it good! The salad bar is fresh and good! You've got to try the pasta salad while there. The hush puppies are delicious. If you have room for dessert definitely try one of their home made cheese cakes!!! Huge portions! The service is fantastic, You are always greeted with an upbeat smile. I always feel better leaving then when I come in. The wait staff is fantastic, clean, quick, funny! As a Madisonian I would definitely recommend stopping at the Shrimp house while in town!
(5)Andy W.
VERY pricey!!! Outdated decor. Servers are friendly and knowledgeable but slow. Had to ask for refills on water and drinks. Not worth the price.
(1)Chantelle O.
Place stinks like old folks home. 11 tables seated, rest not even pre-bussed.
(1)Rene M.
Driving through Madison and stopped here to eat after reading reviews and looking for a place on the river. Location is not on the river, but it does have a view depending on where you are seated. There are two separate seating sections. One with raised seating section with view of river, one with side view but obscured by bridge. Latter section had a great fireplace with mantle setting a nice atmosphere. It was on at the time of our visit. Based on Yelp reviews, I ordered fried shrimp. Coating was light and tasty. My husband had the Friday special of shrimp fettuccine. It was creamy with large pieces of shrimp and well worth a try. Both came with one side and salad bar. Salad bar was small, but well stocked with unique twists on bar fare. Wish I'd taken more of the mashed potato salad which was excellent as was the BQ? three bean salad. Decor is dated, but so is the historical building. Would suggest, however, doing something to hide the very visible wait service area as it was very cluttered and unsightly. Will be back.
(3)Andrea B.
We were greeted by the owner and were able to select a window table overlooking the river. Everyone was friendly and helpful, and service was excellent and prompt. My husband had the fried shrimp and baked potato, and I had the grilled oysters and we both had the salad bar. Everything was excellent and we really enjoyed the salad bar which features homemade salads. I would recommend this unique restaurant to anyone.
(5)Lorand M.
Awsome 1970's type american fish house... we aint serving it unless its FRIED !! actually..they do have some very healthy items....but...when in Madison...do as the Madisonians do ! Awsomely huge amounts of perfectly fried goodies....consider the "Captains Table"....intended for one..but trust moi.....split it ! Enjoy some Italian Margarhitas as well ! Wonderful and fun people that work there....the pony tailed maitre de is hilarious...just a really nice guy.....ooops...sorry can't remember his name....darnit ! This aint gourmet...but it is fun and good for the soul !
(4)Coty M.
My favorite place to eat in Madison. Love the Halibut and don't pass up the Seafood Chowder. To finish off, Bread Pudding w/whiskey sauce, Oh Yes! Good friendly service.
(4)Rachel O.
We're on our road trip of America and made our first stop in Madison. We wanted to go somewhere else, but it was closed and the locals made this recommendation. The atmosphere was just as sweet as the people, and the food was ok, but good for the price. The onion soup was really great and I even asked for a second cup. For the main dish I ordered the Seafood Platter: "A combination of French fried food including Shrimp, scallops, fish, frog legs, and clam strips. One of our most popular dishes." We opted to not have it fried to be a little healthy... that was a mistake. I think I've learned that its best to order things as they were meant to be. The fish was just a little bland although my mom really liked it and the frog legs did not taste like chicken... unless chicken lives in a pond.
(3)brett d.
I had the captains table which was a five course dinner. Tons of food and it came with two drinks for I believe $34.00.I thought everything was great. I cant wait to get back to Madison to have it again. The restaurant sits on the Ohio and has some great window seats with awesome views.
(4)Greg S.
Key West Shrimp House provides a lot of food for the money. I've been there four times and never had room for dessert. Dinners come with soup (step up to the seafood chowder for a little extra), a side (the twice-baked potato is the usual choice) and salad bar, which is less than amazing selection-wise, but has a delicious corn relish that's worth a second trip. Shrimp is obviously the specialty and is served in a bunch of different ways. There are other seafood options as well as a few steak and chicken choices. It's a ton of pretty tasty food.
(4)Karen M.
Wonderful. This was our second visit and most definitely will not be our last. We love the food, the service was great and the owner Cathy is wonderful
(5)Angela J.
It was just ok.... The view of the river is nice. The server was nice enough. But the place just looks like an old face that had makeup put all over it to try to make it pretty but it's still ugly. I had the mahi mahi and a side of green beans. The mahi was tough, like to the point where you almost need a knife. The blackened seasoning saved it. It's weird to rave about this because I never thought this would be something to mention but Dang were their green beans good! My mom said they are like homestyle green beans. Well whatever kind of style they were, they are the king of green beans. Very good and they saved this meal. The End.
(3)Tina K.
I had lunch here today and it was very good. Fried shrimp and a choice of rice, sweet potato fries or french fries. I upgraded to a twice baked potato. The shrimp was better than I've had at most other places. The potato was good but it needed sour cream. The salad bar is small but fresh. I didn't care for the garlic toast that came with the meal. It was too dry. Key lime pie was really good. The service was a bit slow but not excessively so. If you're in Madison I recommend giving this place a try.
(4)Mary K.
I love the key west shrimp House I go there every time I visit Madison The service is friendly and fast I love the view of the river the salad bars is fresh & delicious margaritas are so good! I always get the crab cakes & twice baked potatoes The key lime pie is delicious
(4)R. C.
It is great to see a long time restaurant doing even better under new ownership. The seafood Norfolk was excellent as were the fried shrimp and sweet potato fries. The little salad bar was very adequate. Our young male server was a real charmer. Will continue eating here when ever in Madison.
(5)Jennifer W.
Best seafood in Madison, IN. Be prepared to wait on special occasions like New Years, or Valentines Day.
(5)Todd M.
new owners! i had the red snapper. it was very good. wifey had the seafood norfolk. she was pleased. they have a great salad bar and good beer selection. full bar. service was good. i have given this place a questionable review in the past. but this visit brought some redemption. cautious 4 stars. we will give it another try soon.
(4)Chelsea W.
The food is so terrible, I couldn't even make myself finish the meal. And the key lime pie? Foam on dry crust. Disgusting! We will never eat here again.
(1)Laura B.
As always we were greeted with a warm Hello and smile. The service was excellent and the new owner even stopped by our table to see how we were doing. This is my favorite salad bar around. Our food was delicious and we even had to take some home. Can't ask for better service when we go here.
(5)Terri H.
The service and staff were excellent. The owner, Scott, was very upbeat and welcoming. Cassidy, our waitress, was not only an excellent waitress but offered tips on fun stuff to do while we were in town. My husband had steak and crab legs and I had the baked halibut oscar. Both dishes were amazing. They make great cosmopolitans also. If you are in Madison I highly recommend you dine here.
(5)Smiley B.
The smell as I walked in was overwhelming...it smelled like urine...but I'm not sure what it was. The garlic toast was cold and dry. The beef soup was greasy and tasted like Campbell's canned soup. The salad bar was average. The fried cod was overpriced and the twice baked potato was nasty. They said the Key Lime Pie was homemade, but it clearly wasn't. The hush puppy ( not hush puppies) was very small and overcooked. I think the restaurant needs a complete makeover and that includes getting rid of the kitchen help. When the server cleaned the dirty table I sat at, there was an empty glass on the table from the diners before me and she left that glass on the table!!!! And she poured my water in that glass and expected me to drink it!!! What a lazy server! I wanted to try it and since I have, I won't be back. What a shame.
(1)