Avoid. What a weird theme for a pizza joint. Mobsters? Really? I would have been more put-off by Sponge Bob, but still, it was not very kid friendly as the signage was profane. The four TVs were all on different stations and the volume was up on each, so you couldn't hear any of them clearly. The pizza didn't deserve the one star, it was more of a two star pizza, which is still not really worth driving there for. The girl working the counter was very sweet, happy and helpful. She gets a 4 star rating. She did her best to be the antidote to the morbid theme of the place. I'm pretty easy to please. I've posted almost 50 reviews on Yelp, and this is my first 1 rating. We were having such a fun time before we walked in here.
(1)
Jeremy B.
Spent forever trying to use their online-order tool...only to get COMPLETELY pissed when I got to the end and you can't use a credit card to pay. Do you think you could have mentioned that BEFORE I started down this yellow-brick road? Plus, I wanted a combo calzone, that comes with three toppings. I wanted bacon and double feta as my three - but you can't do that online - however, you can do TWO toppings and pay $.50 more for your third topping if you happen to want double of something. And the icing on the cake...even after being willing to pay an additional $.50 for a topping that should have been rightfully mine in the first place...when I had to call to place my order (see rant above about no credit cards taken online) - my total was $3 MORE on the phone. Their response? "Oh - the online prices are never the same as ours." Really? Really. If you can't do it right - don't even try to play with the big boys with your waste-of-time online ordering system and crap phone customer service. Thank god their calzones are really good...because their ability to effectively take an order with any level of customer service is beyond pathetic.
(2)
Fernando C.
I went here last week with some friends because I had heard that the place was recommended. That is the last time I go out to eat to a place before hitting it up on Yelp. I wasn't a whole lot hungry so I ordered some buffalo chicken strips. Worst I have ever eaten. They felt and tasted like pieces of burnt batter. Hardly any chicken (plus I think they made me sick). Even my friends complained that the food was bad. You will have a more pleasant meal at Burger King.
(1)
FoodLover S.
Ok late night food. Good taste and plenty of it for an cheap price. Went there late night at 3:00am and ordered a slice of pepperoni and a slice of meatball pizza. They didn't have meatball as a traditional topping but accommodated me. The total bill: $7.31. Can't beat that. The pizza slice was ginormous, a fourth of a 12-14" pizza. The Crust was nice and crunchy, had flavorful dough, and they used a pretty good sauce. The toppings were delicious. Yes, the pizza was a bit greasy, but that was expected with that much cheese on the pizza. Service was fast and I was out of the restaurant in 10 minutes with my take out. Definitely would go back here if other places are closed.
(3)
Ashley S.
The pizza is o.k. the location is convenient. I came twice and they seem inconsistent when it comes to quality ingredients. The wings were decent we received mild and a meat lovers pizza. The delivery drivers were arguing about getting work. That was unprofessional and the cashier did not look like she wanted to be there made me not want to return.
(2)
Kan R.
The food is good for the most part but the people that come here are usually the ghetto Atlanta ppl not for the classy types
(2)
Media M.
Ordered stomboli combo and it was good. Only problem was the cashier gave me attitude when I tried to change my order but the food made up for it
(5)
Tom L.
This place is terrible. Delivery service is awful - both times I've ordered I've had to walk out to get my food. Don't charge a delivery fee if you're not going to finish the job. The food also sucks. My calzone was super undercooked to the point that it was basically raw dough filled with ricotta that literally had ice crystals. The first time I ordered, delivery took twice as long as the quoted time, and the delivery guy "forgot" my pizza. He then asked me if I would like him to come back with it (I had prepaid for the order) as if it were an option to just not fulfill the order. The return trip took another hour for a total time of order placement to fulfillment of about 3 hours. Won't be repeating another try with them.
(1)
Kayla T.
Been to Atlanta a ton of times and have never been to this place until tonight. Heard about this place through a friend and again through the hotel clerk at the hotel we're staying at, decided to try it after the drive and walking around all day. The family got two orders of wings, one lemon pepper order (dad/mom) and one hot order (me). Wings are hot and delicious, if you order them with sauce they come basically bathed in the sauce of preference, so no dry wings. Wings are a good size and come with pretty good fries and your dressing preference. Also got the Spinach and Feta Calzone, Meatball Parm Sub, and Chicken Gyro Wrap. Spinach and Feta Cal was for my dad and it came hot, cheesey, and smelling good. He gives it two thumbs up. Meatball Sub for my bro, very saucy, good amount of cheese and seasoned well, also a two thumbs up. Chicken Gyro Wrap for mom, she loves these type of wraps and was very pleased. All and all this place is a good place to give if you want a snack between big meals or even get a meal since they offer some meals and also great for late night since they are open so late. Will definitely be coming back
(5)
Cathryn D.
After a long day of working then driving to Atlanta my husband who always likes to try a local pizza place where ever we go was recommended this place by our hotel clerk. It was after 9pm when we placed our order, one Greek pizza and one steak and cheese. We were told 45 minuets to an hour on delivery which was no problem for us. I would say food arrived between 20-30 which was a huge bonus because we were both hungry. I ordered the Greek, it's basically a gyro on pizza and it was good, enjoyable but just not my thing. My husband had the steak and cheese, lots of melted cheese and some "steak" looked kind of like ground beef or maybe even Italian sausage either way it was very delicious. My husband ended up having to share his with me because it was so good! I typically always look a restaurant up on here before we order from them and this was the one time I actually waited until AFTER we ate there. If I had of read some of these reviews first I probably would have looked elsewhere . I know everyone has their own opinions and service is different to each person but I was impressed and had no issues with goodfellas. If we were in town longer I'm sure my husband would order pizza again!
(4)
K. C.
Horrible restaurant when it comes to customer service, if you're a frequent customer, BEWARE! We have eaten both delivery & pickup for years, but when there is one issue with an employee regardless of if it's a wrong order or just being rude, they will write comments on your account that are not true just so they don't have to deal with you again. And the management won't investigate the situation. We're going to the owners with our situation but be careful on giving these ppl your number or address! Good customer service does not exist here!
(1)
Austin G.
The food was decent at best, a little too chewy. The pizzas best quality was the fact that it could be delivered at past midnight. If you want diarrhea and a bad stomach ache the next morning, then Goodfella's is the place to go. Otherwise stay away and beware.
(1)
Ian S.
Ordered delivery through Grub Hub. I called to check on the order after waiting 30 minutes past the expected delivery time without an update. After an additional 10 minutes on hold, I was told my pizza was finally on the way. The pizza arrived nearly an hour late and warm, but certainly not hot. The pizza was objectively pretty good. The sauce had a good flavor and they used just the amount of cheese. Overall it was pretty tasty and I'll probably order again. I just hope next time I don't have to wait so long to get it. I don't mind so much that it was late, but that I never received an update. I know Grub Hub has a mechanism to let your customers know if you're going to be late. I urge Goodfellas to please use that feature.
(3)
Michael D.
I only write a review when my experience is really great or really terrible.. This place is excellent, right before a GaTech game they were swamped and the owner made sure everyone was handled timely and excelled in customer service. As someone in F&B customer service goes MILES with me!! The food was great, makes me wanna second guess my initial preference of The Varsity and always go here.. Hard working staff and delicious food.. A1!
(5)
Mark P.
I had to work over night, and the only place open at 2:30am was Goodfellas. I ordered the Philly Cheese Steak. It was very good, and the fries were good as well (not too salty, not too plain). The service was fast, and friendly. I'd recommend Goodfellas to anyone looking for enjoyable late night grub.
(4)
Scott F.
Pleasantly surprised at this establishment! Fresh and hot food to please any taste... till 3am. Located across Spring St from the Varsity, They have a large menu that spans from salads, to subs, pizza, chicken tenders, and gyros. I've not been in this space since it was a Subway many many years ago. Tonight I ordered chicken tenders with crispy fries. It was all very delicious! They also offer delivery.
(4)
Katrina D.
**3.5 Stars** In reference to Kit F's review, this is yummy crap... This is crap you order when it is past 2, you've been drinking, and you are damn hungry (however, I believe I have ordered this one time during the day, and it was good then--- so there!!!... I typically eat healthy too). So, yes it is 11:54 when I write this, but unfortunately I have not eaten dinner and had a few drinks tonight... So, Goodfellas it is. Keep in mind, however, I would not drive out of my way for this place. It is pizza and wings, after all. I happen to live 1/2 a mile from here, so yes, I am certainly a fan (I like tasty food- wheteher it is healthy or not sometimes)! Goodfellas's hits the spot for drunk pizza that's for sure!!! It is very inexpensive too!!! I would say an 800 calorie piece (aka, a huge piece of pizza) is only $3.25 here... Tonight, I got mine with Feta and Jalapenos because I like to (attempt) to keep my metabolism going strong if I am going to be eating stuff like this late night! Additionally, their salads are surprisingly good and big as well (keep in mind this is all either delivery or take out) I have been eating here (randomly) for a couple of years and no, this is not a place that has the best food ever... But who would expect that from a place that serves until 3 and is this cheap? Nobody!.. I would think... If you are thinking about ordering Goodfellas, most likely it is late night and you have indulged in at least one thing. So get it... It is good for the bella, fella... At least when you wake up in the morning it will help your hangover as any pizza would... Even that in NYC! It is just cheaper (and who can resist that?!?).
(3)
Abdullah B.
What did I do to deserve this?!?!? I work hard for my money and it's like a slap in the face when i spend my hard earned money at your business I get this: 1. Processed chicken tenders that are made from the "pink slime" meat that has been all over the news recently. They tasted like they were overcooked, then left in a microwave. 2. The french fries were obviously left out too long as well. Either that or they were someone's leftovers that they boxed up and delivered to me. 3. The turkey sandwich was neither cold nor hot, but in some weird state of temperature that I am having trouble describing. The bread was room temperature, the turkey was kind of warm, and then the cheese, that i assume was supposed to be melted, had hardened into a solid blob. This food was soooo blatantly bad that I take it as an insult to the customer. Thanks for ripping me off. Don't eat here people!
(1)
Deandre L.
This place is awesome... There were four flat screen TVs making it a perfect place to watch the game. The food was the closest to Authentic New York Style I have found in Atlanta, and I have been looking. I loved the menu selection. They have everything from pizza and wings to pasta and shrimp. I got the Chicken Parm sub and fries. It was only $6.25 but trust me they could have easily charged 10 bucks. The portions are large but it's the food quality that makes it so yummy. If you have ever been to JR Crickets right around the corner on Spring Street then you know there is NO parking. That's the only bad part. Overall if you can get in this place you will not be disappointed. PLUS they deliver so if worse comes to worse just call.
(4)
Dean G.
Crappy service overall. Cashier was rude as hell and I waited over an hour for a pizza that was only supposed to take 15 minutes. And the pizza was terrible as well. Also Nothing was done to correct their terrible service when I mentioned how long I was waiting for a pizza. DO NOT EAT HERE.
(1)
David C.
For good delivery food this place is great when you are in a downtown hotel. They dont tack on a delivery fee. Food is fast, hot and good portion size for the money.
(3)
Vish B.
This place has the best chicken parm sub I've ever had. I can't even find the words to describe how perfect it tastes. The fries that come along with it are good too. It definitely has the "hole in the wall" vibe to it but it's a really cool atmosphere with all the funny signs and they always have sports on the TVs. The renovated seating area is a nice improvement. The service is fantastic. I've been there a few times and the people there actually remember my name and my order! They're very polite and friendly and always say hello and goodbye. Special shout-out to Samantha, the best one there!
(5)
Ryan R.
GoodFella's saved us from having to venture out into Midtown after a long day of driving. We stayed at the Indigo and GoodFella's delivered... and pretty quick... around 30 min. We got the 14" GoodFell's special w/o beef or gp. It was good pizza delivered at a decent pace. We got it again the next night.
(5)
Jovan E.
Its good and cheap for the area its located in plus the varsity is complete garbage. If u only have $15 or less then this place will hook u up. Ratchet food in Midtown.
(4)
James E.
Ordered through grub hub and my order was "displaced" by the restaurant so I never received my order. When I called the restaurant about the issue I was told by the manager that I wasn't getting my food tonight and "sometimes things don't work out in your favor". "Goodfellas", not so much, zero points.
(1)
Heather H.
Ordered the lemon pepper wings and fries and paid $26.00 included delivery and a tip. Very disappointed. Wings were plain with no real seasoning, fries were plain as well and they have me ranch when I requested blue cheese. Since I was staying at the Marriott Renaissance hotel and it was late and I was hungry, had to snack on it. Called the manager and he stayed that he never had a complaint about the food. Hmmmm. Wish I chose another spot.
(2)
Marvin M.
Underwhelmed by the quality of food. Everything was very mediocre from service/delivery to actual taste of food. Maybe it's great for late night and not lunch.
(2)
Ayala B.
Hungry + Lazy = Goodfellas! I decided to try this place out today and was pleasantly surprised. Based on the reviews below, I was nervous...but I decided to take a chance. I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and a Caesar salad for delivery. Delicious! The pizza was bomb.com and the salad was decent. I will definitely keep this place in mind when ordering pizza during football season
(4)
Anthony M.
Couldn't even place an order. The guy answering the phone was rude, kept putting me on hold, barked orders at me, and and then I eventually hung up when it seemed like he wasn't returning. Called back and was immediately put back on hold ("hang on"). Have no idea what the food is like. It's near impossible to even get it.
(1)
Paul B.
Goodfellas seemed like the best joint when you're having a midnight craving after barhopping but I was sadly mistaken. I figured it was gong to be authentic Italian food like the movie but it seems to be a mock of it. The store when you walk in seems friendly and enjoyable until you start your order. I had wanted the Philly cheese steak combo only to find out that I was being charged extra for the drink which in the picture seems included with the meal. The meal was already overpriced and now I'm paying extra? I had asked for it to be loaded with the included ingredients (onions, peppers, and mayo.) My order took close to half an hour to be ready and to my dismay, it only had cheese and onions. I was so dissatisfied. My cheesesteak was incredibly salty. My friends wings looked like they were bleeding like when you see steak bleed after you cook it. The food was gross and not worth my money. I will never recommend this place to a friend. If you do happen to go here though.. Their best combo is their no. 1 combo which is a slice with fries and drink for 4.50. Their slice is actually okay. Service was terrible. Everyone who worked there seemed to be in their own little world. Their frier was down and that's the reason our food took so long. The manager only apologized at the end. Just one word of advice.. Go down to Fellini's down the street.
(1)
diamond s.
Well the name would make you think I'm going to talk about pizza and wings... Well I'm not and you can't make me!!! (LOL) The best thing about Goodfella's are the subs.. Especially the Philly Steak, Chicken Parm and the Meatball Parm (you know Parmesean!) They are cooked to perfection and so delicious... It will soak up any hangover you may want or have... But that's it... Everything else is pretty low rate... The Fries... DISGUSTING (in my baby voice) clearly no one does french fries like American Deli but that's another review... The pizza... In a styrofoam container... (Note: all other pizza places have it in corregated cardboard of some sort... for a reason) so pizza is soggy after a while... The wings... Cooked for too long... Not enough seasoning... The chicken strips... as good as the wings (well what does that tell ya?) My advice: Stick with JR Crickets unless you want a good sub...
(3)
Dean S.
Best pizza in Atlanta with a neighborhood attitude. My true advice... The meatball sub, slathered in the homemade ranch.. Best sub of my life. Note they also deliver till late night.
(4)
Heather G.
This is my second time attempting to order here.The customer service is absolutely terrible. My first experience I had ordered their wings & requested to have them all flats, extra crispy. I was told there would be an extra charge for both of these requests. I agreed. Upon the arrival of my food I realized not only had the wings not been extra crispy & NOT all flats but they still charged me. I called in again to speak to a manager about getting a refund on the extra charge being that the request was not met & the woman told me that it was not an option b/c they "already closed out". No other form of compensation was provided so I hung up. The manager then calls back to apologize & offers me 20% off my next visit being that the kitchen staff had communication errors with the front. I just now after MUCH hesitation decide to give them a shot again. The man that picked up the front was cordial & I was excited to begin a new experience with these people. Boy was I wrong! When the man gave me my total I asked if there was still a note on file stating that I would receive 20% off my next order. He stated that he would not give me the discount b/c they have a "new procedure in which they are not allowed to authorize things like this" but that I was more than able to speak with a manager. I agreed to. As soon as the woman picks up the phone she asks me who the woman was that I spoke to. I told her that I do not remember but if she could look up my number on the system she would see the note made that the guy just saw when he said he couldn't authorize it. the whole time I am trying to speak she is interrupting me literally through every sentence. She then claims that there is nothing on file for my number. screw you guys man. I'm done trying & I hope people think twice by reading all your "great" reviews on whether they want to eat here. Good luck to anyone who feels brave enough.
(1)
Apryle A.
Pizza is really good. Wish the delivery was better. Every other time I seem to get the wrong order, or someone elses. Tonight it was plain chicken fingers instead of Buffalo and Mr Pibb instead of sprite.
(4)
Andrea P.
Great staff and great pizza. It's my go to spot when everything else is closed. I just stick with the pizza I ordered a veggie once and it was a mess. It wasn't on a burger bun it was on a hero sandwich I didn't even touch it. I've also had a taste of the lemon pepper wings and the teriyaki wings which were pretty decent.
(3)
Sifire M.
The lady at register keke was nice. My 1st time going. Was patience and helpful
(4)
Rodrick D.
Gross over cooked greasy wings. Have had better wings from a gas station. Didn't try the pizza.
(1)
Keesha M.
A bit over rated, pizza tasted very average. Honestly think pizza hut is better than this place. Really not what I was expecting
(2)
Doug M.
The restaurant looks very different from a few months ago, I asked the cashier and she said they were under a new owner. Whoever the owner is, has clearly added some quality to the place. It looks much cleaner than it did 6 months ago, and the food seems much better. We had the 10" house special pizza and opted to eat it there, this was the best pizza I have had all year. The crust was light and crispy, the toppings were fresh, sauce was just right and everything cooked up nicely. Very pleased that I happened to stop in here for a late night bite.
(4)
Gabriel N.
Being tired of the usual spots around the hotel I decided to order some pizza. I went with a recommendation from the hotel staff and tried out GoodFellas. The Greek pizza looked intriguing (Gyro meat, black olives, onions, tomatoes & feta) so I ordered a medium well done. The process was relatively pain free even though the guy on the phone was obviously new to the job. 30 minutes later my pizza arrived along with a bit of confusion. Seems the new guy who took my order told the delivery guy that the order was cash when in fact I had used my credit card to place it. Eventually it got sorted out, but was a glaring school boy error on their part. So was placing the hot pizza on a cold marble counter top while we waited to resolve the misunderstanding. It quickly turned the hot pizza into an almost warm dish. Not a fan of that. When I finally got the pizza back to my room I saw that it was more of a Chicago style crust than NY style. It wasn't bad, but without it being piping hot it really detracted from the meal. It was also lacking the firmness of a well done pizza with the cheese and toppings sliding off the slice. Overall this place is decidedly average. I might try them again or I might hit a new place if I'm feeling like pizza. Nothing popped enough to make me a repeat customer.
(3)
Tom V.
We won't order from this restaurant again. We ordered a pizza that was to be delivered by 8.10 pm. It's now 9.19 pm. No pizza. We called to ask what happened, were put on hold for several minutes, and then offered nothing but the news that the delivery guy was stuck in traffic and had six deliveries to go.
(1)
April T.
This place deserves 5 stars for the pizza alone.....it is that good! I consistently get hot delicious pizza in a timely fashion any time I order. They also have super yummy calzones. Seriosuly good stuff! I cant speak for the other food as I dont order anything but what I have already mentioned. Try it!
(5)
J H.
A must have when I'm in the A
(4)
John S.
GoodFella's is great late night food for anyone who doesn't care in the slightest that it's pretty incredibly greasy. But you can't really complain about that, its a given, and we all eat greasy food once in a while so I don't mind. I've been here twice, since personally I try to avoid greasy food, but as far as that goes this place isn't bad. I had the standard cheese pizza, which like everything else on the menu is pretty darn expensive for what you get, and I really liked it. It had tons of cheese melting off the sides. So yea, for what it is, it's pretty good, just too expensive for being so unhealthy. It's convenient that it's open so late though.
(3)
Matthew L.
My friend and I went to the Braves game and thought afterward that we would go to the Gladys Knight Chicken and Waffles joint in the area. But we couldn't, as it was thursday night, and the chicken and waffles place only stays open late on Friday and Saturday. And the Varsity was also closed. We were staying at the Renaissance. So our only food option was this place. I was excited to see strombolis on the menu, as I don't have them in my neck of the woods. But while the ones I tried in Philadelphia a few months back were pure godhead, this one made the concept of a stromboli sound completely gross to my friend. The Strombolis at GoodFella's are overstuffed with probably a full pound of low quality mozzarella cheese. I got a vegetarian one with mushrooms and spinach, so the combination was not too heavy overall. But a friend ordered one with sausage and it was pure overkill. The combo was just too greasy.
(2)
Richard B.
Horrible and Scary. I gave no idea why this place is rated anything but 1 star. The interior is drab and depressing. It's as dirty as they come. The only thing this pace probably has going for it are the prices, but I don't know if a cheap pizza is worth being yelled at by a homeless guy while standing in line.
(1)
Lo A.
10 piece combo. Hot. All flats. Extra crispy. Is that too much to ask for ? Clearly. I was told there was an extra charge for crispy & flats request. That's fine , I don't mind paying for what I want. I received my food halfway cold , stale fries , 7/10 of the wings are DRUMSTICKS & they're the slimiest wings I've ever had although I requested & PAID extra for this. Not to mention their ketchup packets tasted funny & so did their "ranch". I Called them back to inform them on the issue & they hung up !! I called BACK & told them that I do not want to be billed for something I did not get. The guy puts me on hold & a women picks up only to say "yeah?" So I'm like "yeah??" she then continues to say "oh sorry I got on the phone to see what the problem was". OKAAAAYYY so no introducing yourself or at least sounding like you cared about the job. I'm assuming she was management. I'm wondering how she got there with no customer service skills. I don't believe they took that off my bill either. The only thing pleasant about the whole experience was that the delivery man was nice. Other than that I'm never referring this place to anyone bc Id hate for them to get treated & fed the way I did.
(1)
Millie G.
Maybe I'm weird but whatever. Their pizza is delicious. It serves it's cheesy, greasy purpose and I can't complain. I will say that the cheese fries are best stayed away from...none too pleased.
(4)
Tameka W.
I ordered the lunch combo (pizza, side salad and drink). The side salad was unwashed rabbit food, but other than that the pizza was delicious. I normally get the calzones and Stromboli's, which are great! I don't understand the 1 star reviews.
(4)
Praful G.
I was terrified of walking into the place! Not sure why this place has a rating at all. No parking whatsover, called up the owner and he said to park at the varsity or go figure! Me and a friend placed an order and they called my number after 20 mins of ordering a personal sized pizza. The order was given to me in a to-go box. The onion rings tasted like dough all over. I guess they are catering to college crowds which would explain the cheap deal and take outs. I would most certainly never step into the place ever again!
(1)
Nikki L.
I went here after a night of clubbing in Midtown...there was a wait but it was worth it! I hear the special 1 slice, 6 wings, fries and a soda for $10. It was good and even better the next day!
(4)
Steven B.
This is the kind of customer service that is ruining eating in Atlanta. 45 minutes after ordering a pizza through the website we got a call telling us they couldn't deliver two blocks away. Literally two blocks away. It's a good time for poorly run restaurants to fail and make room for true professionals.
(1)
Tim D.
We eat here usually late at night, not much else open! This pizza is nothing to write about....its just PIZZA.
(2)
Marc M.
On my way to the Coca Cola factory and Aquarium I decided to stop in and grab a meal. Entree: Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich Drinks: Water The food was excellent and the service was good. Good atmosphere, pleasant environment and very attractive staff! :-)
(4)
Phillip K.
Better than The Varsity but they could do so much better with the wings. A little bit too hard (on both occasions). It's nice if your lazy and live close by. But for a nice meal, look around a little.
(3)
Joe S.
Recently contacted them via the concierge at the nearby Renaissance Hotel (apparently they have some sort of delivery agreement). Missed dinner with clients, came back to the room starving. The manager answered, had no idea what the Renaissance was, kept asking me for my address, to which I replied I wasn't sure of the exact address but the concierge had passed me on to her. She proceeded to tell me that I was being nasty and they wouldn't deliver food to me. Click. Perhaps she was in high school and isn't old enough to have learned customer service. If that's the case......LEARN! There are plenty of people of who are desperate for work, be grateful. Won't be calling them again.
(1)
Daniel Q.
Here's what they got going for them: They are cheap. They are better then fast food. They are open late. For what they are, they are ok. I'm not going to go out of my way to eat there, and I may well eat there again, if I'm hungry, and nothing better is open. The pizza slice I had was not great for a place with pizza in the name. It was edible. They made it a bit thick, and unwieldy - they sliced a smaller pie into quarters so it fits into a box easier, but doesn't make for easy eating. I also had a meatball sub and fries. The fries were alright, just normal fries, freshly fried, so that was ok. The sub was alright. The cheese was sloppy, and the sauce inconsistant, but the meatballs were tastey enough, and the portions were generous. The service was not great. These are not friendly happy workers, and the area is not terribly nice, but if you are afraid to go to that neighborhood, that's a lot worse places you won't be able to go.
(2)
Chloe W.
My First experience at goodfellas was AMAZING. I will definitely recommend to any and everybody to try it when your in atlanta.
(5)
Tristan W.
Horrible service. Called from a hotel just outside their 3 mile delivery radius, they charged my card and wouldn't deliver the product. When placing the order I gave them the hotel address and phone number but of course they didn't realize the mistake till after payment. DO NOT DINE HERE!!!
(1)
Greg A.
I've been here a good number of times since I live without walking distance, and I am very familiar with Italian food since I'm from Jersey. Honestly, this place has horrible pizza. Stay away from the pizza. The only reason I gave it two stars instead of one is because their cheese steaks are decent(but make sure you ask for no mayo). Their cheeseteaks don't resemble anything like a real Philly but they taste good. Their gyros are ok, but I've had much much better, and I was pleasantly surprised by their calzones the last time I went their. Overall, though this is a good place to go if you want to get some greasy late night food, but stay away from the pizza.
(2)
Theryl J.
One of the best late night places I've been too....the food was cooked to order (not waiting on me to order), the service was very FAST, and you still had the option to dine-in or carry out...not to mention that the pizza was actually very good...definitely would go back....also super inexpensive...I got a slice and a drink for under $5.
(4)
Mulltea C.
I have been actively seeking out all of the best pizzas in Atlanta because I believe it is one of the best and most perfect foods to have in a community. When I met the owners of Goodfella's Pizza and Wings and they told me about their establishment I had to check it out. Delighted, I ventured out on a beautiful Saturday Spring morning and strolled upon Goodfella's around 11 am. As I walked right up to the counter, eager to try some fun and tasty food for the soul I was enthusiastically greeted with a wonderful smile and disposition by a young lady named Yurbisha. It is true that the right customer service attitude can win over any meal, but the pizza was great too. It was exactly what I was looking for in a hand tossed pie. The consistency of the crust was dead on. Crunchy and chewy, ample amounts of cheese, great toppings and served hot. I saved a couple of leftover slices that I could not finish and they were good both cold and reheated. ( Which is another sign of a good pizza for me:) The price was astonishingly low for such a great product and their hours work for EVERYBODY! This is truly an every day pizza place with a nice community feel.
(5)
Brian F.
Ordered GoodFella's for delievery based on the recommendation from the staff at the Rennasiance hotel that I am staying on business.... The food was delievered quicker than the time given and it was very hot. The pizza is AMAZING with great flavor and a healthy amount of toppings and the Caesar salad I got delievered was very fresh and tasty..... Its nice to get good pizza and good service when ordering pizza to a hotel.
(5)
Joyce M.
I order takeout last night. I ordered some wings,fries, and jalapeno poppers. I must say I was not satisfied. The food arrived cold. I don't know why it was cold when I ordered the food from some condos located right down the street on Spring street. If I want cold wings I would've just eat wings straight from the freezer. Obviously they don't know what the term HOT WINGS means.The second issue I have with them is that there wasn't any blue cheese or ranch in the bag when I specifically asked them for ranch dressing. I've had Goodfellas before as dining in and loved it. I don't know what the issue is with their delivey. GOODFELLAS word of advice GET IT TOGETHER!
(1)
Kenneth H.
Meh. Welcome to average-ville, population this place... I've had work functions taking me to the Renaissance Downtown several days this week, so I've had an opportunity to sample some of the lunch offerings in walking distance. I did J.R. Crickets on Wednesday, and yesterday I decided to give GoodFella's a whirl. They have a 9$ pizza/wings combo, so I opted for that, as it gave me a chance to try out two of their entree items in one sitting. The pizza was, as mentioned below, run through a conveyor & plopped into a Styrofoam clam. The crust is freshly-made, but doesn't have the internal lightness & delicate crunchy crust you usually expect from a non-frozen crust. As mentioned below as well, the cheese was pretty rubbery. The three biggest parts of a pizza are going to be your cheese, crust & presentation, and if you've dropped the ball on those, even legendary sauce & toppings aren't going to rescue the slice from mediocrity. It didn't suck, but it wasn't something I would go out of my way to get again. On to the wings: Medium wings that were pulled from the fryer too soon. I'd be okay with the extra 60 seconds of waiting, if the wings are cooked up crispy. These were crispy in spots, but not over all. Restaurants do this because they don't want the wings to shrink & look chintzy, but small crispy wings are way better than texture-less medium ones. The bottle on the table reveals that this place uses Franks® Red Hot sauce for their wings. They have squirt bottles of the stuff on all the tables, so you can hose down your wings with more, if you like. That was a good thing for me, as they deliver them pretty dry, in my book. Again, the wings weren't horrible, but there is absolutely no reason to walk into this place for wings when ten extra steps down the sidewalk will get you in the door of a place that has good ones. Atmosphere: They at least know how to pick a theme & stick to it, here. It's all going to be Godfather/Scarface/generic mobster stuff on the walls. The ordering & dining areas are clean & uncluttered, and there are flat panel televisions placed around the walls; no shortage of stuff to look at while you eat. They had Faux News on the tvs when I was in there for lunch, which kind of negates the whole 'we have TVs' thing for me; maybe it floats your boat & would add some star power. There is outside seating, but it's going to be two tables crowded onto the narrow sidewalk, right on the corner in front of the Varsity...not great ambiance. Service: Counter service. Belly up, order your food, they plop it on a tray & you're off to the dining area. Everyone was courteous for my visit, but there's not much to critique about the service when it's fast-food style.
(2)
Marcus M.
I'm pretty surprised as to how low the reviews were for this place. I've always gotten good a food and good service; all while running the risk of parking across at the Varsity. But most of all, I love how they're open late and always a good... "bang for the buck"
(4)
Simon C.
I went to school in little italy in the Bronx, NY and will tell you that Goodfellas has absolutely nothing in common with New York style pizza. That being said I never really expected it to. Their pizza is not the tastiest in the world but their Philly Cheesesteak is not bad at all, their fries are a little large for my tastes, but their sandwiches are alright and low priced for large portions. Don't go here for gourmet pizza, but if you are looking for a good helping of food for a pretty reasonable price go for a sandwich or maybe their personal sized pies. Its across the street from the varsity and plays the part well...
(3)
Corey J.
Meh, I definitely would not call this gourmet pizza, there's absolutely nothing to distinguish from it. I ordered delivery, it came on time and was hott so that's where the 3 stars come from, and the wings were just average as well, some were really small and some were decent size. Honestly, Papa Johns or Pizza Hut would be a better choice if you ask me, oh and there's no way I'd buy from this place without having it delivered. Their location at Spring St and N. Ave would provide for an awkard and interesting walk from the restaurant to your car...I doubt you'd have your pizza much less any money left as you're sure to get mugged, harrassed, raped or maybe even all 3 on the short walk to your car.
(3)
Kristin C.
This is your average cheap and greasy late-night food. The service here is pretty quick, so if you're in the neighborhood at two or three in the morning, stop in and order some fries or a slice of pizza.
(2)
Javier F.
Don't even bother. We ordered wings from here and were disappointed by the entire experience. The wings were overcooked and considerably under-sauced. Although I obviously can't prove it, the wings appeared to have been cooked earlier and been sitting under a heat-lamp for a while. To add insult to injury, the little bit of sauce that was on the wings wasn't any good. We ended up breaking out hot sauce, BBQ sauce and ranch dressing from my own kitchen to try to save them. The order came with a basket of fries that wasn't worth eating. We threw away a quarter of the wings and most of the fries. Also, the delivery took 55 minutes to arrive and it wasn't even cheap! But hey, no disrespect, maybe their pizza is good.
(1)
Michael D.
Um the pizza sucks and i ordered take out and it took an hour and 45 min to get here and i had called four times to find out where it was and got hung up on called back 2 more times and talked to 2 different people and the second person was helpful and called the driver to find out where it was the only excuse they had was theres alot of traffic. I know atl traffic sucks but come on its 5 miles from my hours even in rush hour it shouldnt take more then 30 min to deliver this never would happen in nj or philly or i would get something free i mean the pizza was cold which if it was atleast good then i would have been fine with the wait.
(1)
Nicholas R.
I love the pizza and the other italian options, the wings are drenched in sauce to make up for a not so great chicken and the burgers and salads are less then desirable but no reason to give it a bad review. Good price for the area. The place is always packed when I drive by or when I call so I know people like it. Like it so much you have to wait up to an hour and a half to two hours for delivery. I work in the area and has become popular for people in my building. They are open super late on weekends so its a great go to spot for after the bars and clubs to soak up the alcohol. Its great give it a shot.
(3)
Foodie Buddha F.
So I've dined here a couple more times since my initial review. As much as I would like to keep them a 3 star, the place just isn't that great. Again, we're talking delivery, so keep that in mind. It's fine and will get the job done. Pizza is still decent, but anything more than 3 stars for this place is laughable at best.
(2)
Anna I.
I am a bit surprised to see a few negative reviews about Goodfellas. I have ordered delivery from this place about 5 -6 times before I decided to post a review because I was anxious to see when they would finally screw up. But they didn't. They have consistently delivered a piping hot, flavorful delicious pizza in 30 minutes. I have also ordered wings, eggplant parm sandwiches and it's all been delicious. I would recommend them to anyone and I will continue to order from them from now on. BTW, they are open until 3:30am and until 4am on Friday and Saturdays. How can you beat that???
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : Yes Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Late Night Parking : Street Bike Parking : Yes Wheelchair Accessible : Yes Good for Kids : No Good for Groups : No Attire : Casual Ambience : Divey Noise Level : Average Alcohol : No Outdoor Seating : No Wi-Fi : No Has TV : Yes Waiter Service : No Caters : No
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
Ryan B.
Avoid. What a weird theme for a pizza joint. Mobsters? Really? I would have been more put-off by Sponge Bob, but still, it was not very kid friendly as the signage was profane. The four TVs were all on different stations and the volume was up on each, so you couldn't hear any of them clearly. The pizza didn't deserve the one star, it was more of a two star pizza, which is still not really worth driving there for. The girl working the counter was very sweet, happy and helpful. She gets a 4 star rating. She did her best to be the antidote to the morbid theme of the place. I'm pretty easy to please. I've posted almost 50 reviews on Yelp, and this is my first 1 rating. We were having such a fun time before we walked in here.
(1)Jeremy B.
Spent forever trying to use their online-order tool...only to get COMPLETELY pissed when I got to the end and you can't use a credit card to pay. Do you think you could have mentioned that BEFORE I started down this yellow-brick road? Plus, I wanted a combo calzone, that comes with three toppings. I wanted bacon and double feta as my three - but you can't do that online - however, you can do TWO toppings and pay $.50 more for your third topping if you happen to want double of something. And the icing on the cake...even after being willing to pay an additional $.50 for a topping that should have been rightfully mine in the first place...when I had to call to place my order (see rant above about no credit cards taken online) - my total was $3 MORE on the phone. Their response? "Oh - the online prices are never the same as ours." Really? Really. If you can't do it right - don't even try to play with the big boys with your waste-of-time online ordering system and crap phone customer service. Thank god their calzones are really good...because their ability to effectively take an order with any level of customer service is beyond pathetic.
(2)Fernando C.
I went here last week with some friends because I had heard that the place was recommended. That is the last time I go out to eat to a place before hitting it up on Yelp. I wasn't a whole lot hungry so I ordered some buffalo chicken strips. Worst I have ever eaten. They felt and tasted like pieces of burnt batter. Hardly any chicken (plus I think they made me sick). Even my friends complained that the food was bad. You will have a more pleasant meal at Burger King.
(1)FoodLover S.
Ok late night food. Good taste and plenty of it for an cheap price. Went there late night at 3:00am and ordered a slice of pepperoni and a slice of meatball pizza. They didn't have meatball as a traditional topping but accommodated me. The total bill: $7.31. Can't beat that. The pizza slice was ginormous, a fourth of a 12-14" pizza. The Crust was nice and crunchy, had flavorful dough, and they used a pretty good sauce. The toppings were delicious. Yes, the pizza was a bit greasy, but that was expected with that much cheese on the pizza. Service was fast and I was out of the restaurant in 10 minutes with my take out. Definitely would go back here if other places are closed.
(3)Ashley S.
The pizza is o.k. the location is convenient. I came twice and they seem inconsistent when it comes to quality ingredients. The wings were decent we received mild and a meat lovers pizza. The delivery drivers were arguing about getting work. That was unprofessional and the cashier did not look like she wanted to be there made me not want to return.
(2)Kan R.
The food is good for the most part but the people that come here are usually the ghetto Atlanta ppl not for the classy types
(2)Media M.
Ordered stomboli combo and it was good. Only problem was the cashier gave me attitude when I tried to change my order but the food made up for it
(5)Tom L.
This place is terrible. Delivery service is awful - both times I've ordered I've had to walk out to get my food. Don't charge a delivery fee if you're not going to finish the job. The food also sucks. My calzone was super undercooked to the point that it was basically raw dough filled with ricotta that literally had ice crystals. The first time I ordered, delivery took twice as long as the quoted time, and the delivery guy "forgot" my pizza. He then asked me if I would like him to come back with it (I had prepaid for the order) as if it were an option to just not fulfill the order. The return trip took another hour for a total time of order placement to fulfillment of about 3 hours. Won't be repeating another try with them.
(1)Kayla T.
Been to Atlanta a ton of times and have never been to this place until tonight. Heard about this place through a friend and again through the hotel clerk at the hotel we're staying at, decided to try it after the drive and walking around all day. The family got two orders of wings, one lemon pepper order (dad/mom) and one hot order (me). Wings are hot and delicious, if you order them with sauce they come basically bathed in the sauce of preference, so no dry wings. Wings are a good size and come with pretty good fries and your dressing preference. Also got the Spinach and Feta Calzone, Meatball Parm Sub, and Chicken Gyro Wrap. Spinach and Feta Cal was for my dad and it came hot, cheesey, and smelling good. He gives it two thumbs up. Meatball Sub for my bro, very saucy, good amount of cheese and seasoned well, also a two thumbs up. Chicken Gyro Wrap for mom, she loves these type of wraps and was very pleased. All and all this place is a good place to give if you want a snack between big meals or even get a meal since they offer some meals and also great for late night since they are open so late. Will definitely be coming back
(5)Cathryn D.
After a long day of working then driving to Atlanta my husband who always likes to try a local pizza place where ever we go was recommended this place by our hotel clerk. It was after 9pm when we placed our order, one Greek pizza and one steak and cheese. We were told 45 minuets to an hour on delivery which was no problem for us. I would say food arrived between 20-30 which was a huge bonus because we were both hungry. I ordered the Greek, it's basically a gyro on pizza and it was good, enjoyable but just not my thing. My husband had the steak and cheese, lots of melted cheese and some "steak" looked kind of like ground beef or maybe even Italian sausage either way it was very delicious. My husband ended up having to share his with me because it was so good! I typically always look a restaurant up on here before we order from them and this was the one time I actually waited until AFTER we ate there. If I had of read some of these reviews first I probably would have looked elsewhere . I know everyone has their own opinions and service is different to each person but I was impressed and had no issues with goodfellas. If we were in town longer I'm sure my husband would order pizza again!
(4)K. C.
Horrible restaurant when it comes to customer service, if you're a frequent customer, BEWARE! We have eaten both delivery & pickup for years, but when there is one issue with an employee regardless of if it's a wrong order or just being rude, they will write comments on your account that are not true just so they don't have to deal with you again. And the management won't investigate the situation. We're going to the owners with our situation but be careful on giving these ppl your number or address! Good customer service does not exist here!
(1)Austin G.
The food was decent at best, a little too chewy. The pizzas best quality was the fact that it could be delivered at past midnight. If you want diarrhea and a bad stomach ache the next morning, then Goodfella's is the place to go. Otherwise stay away and beware.
(1)Ian S.
Ordered delivery through Grub Hub. I called to check on the order after waiting 30 minutes past the expected delivery time without an update. After an additional 10 minutes on hold, I was told my pizza was finally on the way. The pizza arrived nearly an hour late and warm, but certainly not hot. The pizza was objectively pretty good. The sauce had a good flavor and they used just the amount of cheese. Overall it was pretty tasty and I'll probably order again. I just hope next time I don't have to wait so long to get it. I don't mind so much that it was late, but that I never received an update. I know Grub Hub has a mechanism to let your customers know if you're going to be late. I urge Goodfellas to please use that feature.
(3)Michael D.
I only write a review when my experience is really great or really terrible.. This place is excellent, right before a GaTech game they were swamped and the owner made sure everyone was handled timely and excelled in customer service. As someone in F&B customer service goes MILES with me!! The food was great, makes me wanna second guess my initial preference of The Varsity and always go here.. Hard working staff and delicious food.. A1!
(5)Mark P.
I had to work over night, and the only place open at 2:30am was Goodfellas. I ordered the Philly Cheese Steak. It was very good, and the fries were good as well (not too salty, not too plain). The service was fast, and friendly. I'd recommend Goodfellas to anyone looking for enjoyable late night grub.
(4)Scott F.
Pleasantly surprised at this establishment! Fresh and hot food to please any taste... till 3am. Located across Spring St from the Varsity, They have a large menu that spans from salads, to subs, pizza, chicken tenders, and gyros. I've not been in this space since it was a Subway many many years ago. Tonight I ordered chicken tenders with crispy fries. It was all very delicious! They also offer delivery.
(4)Katrina D.
**3.5 Stars** In reference to Kit F's review, this is yummy crap... This is crap you order when it is past 2, you've been drinking, and you are damn hungry (however, I believe I have ordered this one time during the day, and it was good then--- so there!!!... I typically eat healthy too). So, yes it is 11:54 when I write this, but unfortunately I have not eaten dinner and had a few drinks tonight... So, Goodfellas it is. Keep in mind, however, I would not drive out of my way for this place. It is pizza and wings, after all. I happen to live 1/2 a mile from here, so yes, I am certainly a fan (I like tasty food- wheteher it is healthy or not sometimes)! Goodfellas's hits the spot for drunk pizza that's for sure!!! It is very inexpensive too!!! I would say an 800 calorie piece (aka, a huge piece of pizza) is only $3.25 here... Tonight, I got mine with Feta and Jalapenos because I like to (attempt) to keep my metabolism going strong if I am going to be eating stuff like this late night! Additionally, their salads are surprisingly good and big as well (keep in mind this is all either delivery or take out) I have been eating here (randomly) for a couple of years and no, this is not a place that has the best food ever... But who would expect that from a place that serves until 3 and is this cheap? Nobody!.. I would think... If you are thinking about ordering Goodfellas, most likely it is late night and you have indulged in at least one thing. So get it... It is good for the bella, fella... At least when you wake up in the morning it will help your hangover as any pizza would... Even that in NYC! It is just cheaper (and who can resist that?!?).
(3)Abdullah B.
What did I do to deserve this?!?!? I work hard for my money and it's like a slap in the face when i spend my hard earned money at your business I get this: 1. Processed chicken tenders that are made from the "pink slime" meat that has been all over the news recently. They tasted like they were overcooked, then left in a microwave. 2. The french fries were obviously left out too long as well. Either that or they were someone's leftovers that they boxed up and delivered to me. 3. The turkey sandwich was neither cold nor hot, but in some weird state of temperature that I am having trouble describing. The bread was room temperature, the turkey was kind of warm, and then the cheese, that i assume was supposed to be melted, had hardened into a solid blob. This food was soooo blatantly bad that I take it as an insult to the customer. Thanks for ripping me off. Don't eat here people!
(1)Deandre L.
This place is awesome... There were four flat screen TVs making it a perfect place to watch the game. The food was the closest to Authentic New York Style I have found in Atlanta, and I have been looking. I loved the menu selection. They have everything from pizza and wings to pasta and shrimp. I got the Chicken Parm sub and fries. It was only $6.25 but trust me they could have easily charged 10 bucks. The portions are large but it's the food quality that makes it so yummy. If you have ever been to JR Crickets right around the corner on Spring Street then you know there is NO parking. That's the only bad part. Overall if you can get in this place you will not be disappointed. PLUS they deliver so if worse comes to worse just call.
(4)Dean G.
Crappy service overall. Cashier was rude as hell and I waited over an hour for a pizza that was only supposed to take 15 minutes. And the pizza was terrible as well. Also Nothing was done to correct their terrible service when I mentioned how long I was waiting for a pizza. DO NOT EAT HERE.
(1)David C.
For good delivery food this place is great when you are in a downtown hotel. They dont tack on a delivery fee. Food is fast, hot and good portion size for the money.
(3)Vish B.
This place has the best chicken parm sub I've ever had. I can't even find the words to describe how perfect it tastes. The fries that come along with it are good too. It definitely has the "hole in the wall" vibe to it but it's a really cool atmosphere with all the funny signs and they always have sports on the TVs. The renovated seating area is a nice improvement. The service is fantastic. I've been there a few times and the people there actually remember my name and my order! They're very polite and friendly and always say hello and goodbye. Special shout-out to Samantha, the best one there!
(5)Ryan R.
GoodFella's saved us from having to venture out into Midtown after a long day of driving. We stayed at the Indigo and GoodFella's delivered... and pretty quick... around 30 min. We got the 14" GoodFell's special w/o beef or gp. It was good pizza delivered at a decent pace. We got it again the next night.
(5)Jovan E.
Its good and cheap for the area its located in plus the varsity is complete garbage. If u only have $15 or less then this place will hook u up. Ratchet food in Midtown.
(4)James E.
Ordered through grub hub and my order was "displaced" by the restaurant so I never received my order. When I called the restaurant about the issue I was told by the manager that I wasn't getting my food tonight and "sometimes things don't work out in your favor". "Goodfellas", not so much, zero points.
(1)Heather H.
Ordered the lemon pepper wings and fries and paid $26.00 included delivery and a tip. Very disappointed. Wings were plain with no real seasoning, fries were plain as well and they have me ranch when I requested blue cheese. Since I was staying at the Marriott Renaissance hotel and it was late and I was hungry, had to snack on it. Called the manager and he stayed that he never had a complaint about the food. Hmmmm. Wish I chose another spot.
(2)Marvin M.
Underwhelmed by the quality of food. Everything was very mediocre from service/delivery to actual taste of food. Maybe it's great for late night and not lunch.
(2)Ayala B.
Hungry + Lazy = Goodfellas! I decided to try this place out today and was pleasantly surprised. Based on the reviews below, I was nervous...but I decided to take a chance. I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and a Caesar salad for delivery. Delicious! The pizza was bomb.com and the salad was decent. I will definitely keep this place in mind when ordering pizza during football season
(4)Anthony M.
Couldn't even place an order. The guy answering the phone was rude, kept putting me on hold, barked orders at me, and and then I eventually hung up when it seemed like he wasn't returning. Called back and was immediately put back on hold ("hang on"). Have no idea what the food is like. It's near impossible to even get it.
(1)Paul B.
Goodfellas seemed like the best joint when you're having a midnight craving after barhopping but I was sadly mistaken. I figured it was gong to be authentic Italian food like the movie but it seems to be a mock of it. The store when you walk in seems friendly and enjoyable until you start your order. I had wanted the Philly cheese steak combo only to find out that I was being charged extra for the drink which in the picture seems included with the meal. The meal was already overpriced and now I'm paying extra? I had asked for it to be loaded with the included ingredients (onions, peppers, and mayo.) My order took close to half an hour to be ready and to my dismay, it only had cheese and onions. I was so dissatisfied. My cheesesteak was incredibly salty. My friends wings looked like they were bleeding like when you see steak bleed after you cook it. The food was gross and not worth my money. I will never recommend this place to a friend. If you do happen to go here though.. Their best combo is their no. 1 combo which is a slice with fries and drink for 4.50. Their slice is actually okay. Service was terrible. Everyone who worked there seemed to be in their own little world. Their frier was down and that's the reason our food took so long. The manager only apologized at the end. Just one word of advice.. Go down to Fellini's down the street.
(1)diamond s.
Well the name would make you think I'm going to talk about pizza and wings... Well I'm not and you can't make me!!! (LOL) The best thing about Goodfella's are the subs.. Especially the Philly Steak, Chicken Parm and the Meatball Parm (you know Parmesean!) They are cooked to perfection and so delicious... It will soak up any hangover you may want or have... But that's it... Everything else is pretty low rate... The Fries... DISGUSTING (in my baby voice) clearly no one does french fries like American Deli but that's another review... The pizza... In a styrofoam container... (Note: all other pizza places have it in corregated cardboard of some sort... for a reason) so pizza is soggy after a while... The wings... Cooked for too long... Not enough seasoning... The chicken strips... as good as the wings (well what does that tell ya?) My advice: Stick with JR Crickets unless you want a good sub...
(3)Dean S.
Best pizza in Atlanta with a neighborhood attitude. My true advice... The meatball sub, slathered in the homemade ranch.. Best sub of my life. Note they also deliver till late night.
(4)Heather G.
This is my second time attempting to order here.The customer service is absolutely terrible. My first experience I had ordered their wings & requested to have them all flats, extra crispy. I was told there would be an extra charge for both of these requests. I agreed. Upon the arrival of my food I realized not only had the wings not been extra crispy & NOT all flats but they still charged me. I called in again to speak to a manager about getting a refund on the extra charge being that the request was not met & the woman told me that it was not an option b/c they "already closed out". No other form of compensation was provided so I hung up. The manager then calls back to apologize & offers me 20% off my next visit being that the kitchen staff had communication errors with the front. I just now after MUCH hesitation decide to give them a shot again. The man that picked up the front was cordial & I was excited to begin a new experience with these people. Boy was I wrong! When the man gave me my total I asked if there was still a note on file stating that I would receive 20% off my next order. He stated that he would not give me the discount b/c they have a "new procedure in which they are not allowed to authorize things like this" but that I was more than able to speak with a manager. I agreed to. As soon as the woman picks up the phone she asks me who the woman was that I spoke to. I told her that I do not remember but if she could look up my number on the system she would see the note made that the guy just saw when he said he couldn't authorize it. the whole time I am trying to speak she is interrupting me literally through every sentence. She then claims that there is nothing on file for my number. screw you guys man. I'm done trying & I hope people think twice by reading all your "great" reviews on whether they want to eat here. Good luck to anyone who feels brave enough.
(1)Apryle A.
Pizza is really good. Wish the delivery was better. Every other time I seem to get the wrong order, or someone elses. Tonight it was plain chicken fingers instead of Buffalo and Mr Pibb instead of sprite.
(4)Andrea P.
Great staff and great pizza. It's my go to spot when everything else is closed. I just stick with the pizza I ordered a veggie once and it was a mess. It wasn't on a burger bun it was on a hero sandwich I didn't even touch it. I've also had a taste of the lemon pepper wings and the teriyaki wings which were pretty decent.
(3)Sifire M.
The lady at register keke was nice. My 1st time going. Was patience and helpful
(4)Rodrick D.
Gross over cooked greasy wings. Have had better wings from a gas station. Didn't try the pizza.
(1)Keesha M.
A bit over rated, pizza tasted very average. Honestly think pizza hut is better than this place. Really not what I was expecting
(2)Doug M.
The restaurant looks very different from a few months ago, I asked the cashier and she said they were under a new owner. Whoever the owner is, has clearly added some quality to the place. It looks much cleaner than it did 6 months ago, and the food seems much better. We had the 10" house special pizza and opted to eat it there, this was the best pizza I have had all year. The crust was light and crispy, the toppings were fresh, sauce was just right and everything cooked up nicely. Very pleased that I happened to stop in here for a late night bite.
(4)Gabriel N.
Being tired of the usual spots around the hotel I decided to order some pizza. I went with a recommendation from the hotel staff and tried out GoodFellas. The Greek pizza looked intriguing (Gyro meat, black olives, onions, tomatoes & feta) so I ordered a medium well done. The process was relatively pain free even though the guy on the phone was obviously new to the job. 30 minutes later my pizza arrived along with a bit of confusion. Seems the new guy who took my order told the delivery guy that the order was cash when in fact I had used my credit card to place it. Eventually it got sorted out, but was a glaring school boy error on their part. So was placing the hot pizza on a cold marble counter top while we waited to resolve the misunderstanding. It quickly turned the hot pizza into an almost warm dish. Not a fan of that. When I finally got the pizza back to my room I saw that it was more of a Chicago style crust than NY style. It wasn't bad, but without it being piping hot it really detracted from the meal. It was also lacking the firmness of a well done pizza with the cheese and toppings sliding off the slice. Overall this place is decidedly average. I might try them again or I might hit a new place if I'm feeling like pizza. Nothing popped enough to make me a repeat customer.
(3)Tom V.
We won't order from this restaurant again. We ordered a pizza that was to be delivered by 8.10 pm. It's now 9.19 pm. No pizza. We called to ask what happened, were put on hold for several minutes, and then offered nothing but the news that the delivery guy was stuck in traffic and had six deliveries to go.
(1)April T.
This place deserves 5 stars for the pizza alone.....it is that good! I consistently get hot delicious pizza in a timely fashion any time I order. They also have super yummy calzones. Seriosuly good stuff! I cant speak for the other food as I dont order anything but what I have already mentioned. Try it!
(5)J H.
A must have when I'm in the A
(4)John S.
GoodFella's is great late night food for anyone who doesn't care in the slightest that it's pretty incredibly greasy. But you can't really complain about that, its a given, and we all eat greasy food once in a while so I don't mind. I've been here twice, since personally I try to avoid greasy food, but as far as that goes this place isn't bad. I had the standard cheese pizza, which like everything else on the menu is pretty darn expensive for what you get, and I really liked it. It had tons of cheese melting off the sides. So yea, for what it is, it's pretty good, just too expensive for being so unhealthy. It's convenient that it's open so late though.
(3)Matthew L.
My friend and I went to the Braves game and thought afterward that we would go to the Gladys Knight Chicken and Waffles joint in the area. But we couldn't, as it was thursday night, and the chicken and waffles place only stays open late on Friday and Saturday. And the Varsity was also closed. We were staying at the Renaissance. So our only food option was this place. I was excited to see strombolis on the menu, as I don't have them in my neck of the woods. But while the ones I tried in Philadelphia a few months back were pure godhead, this one made the concept of a stromboli sound completely gross to my friend. The Strombolis at GoodFella's are overstuffed with probably a full pound of low quality mozzarella cheese. I got a vegetarian one with mushrooms and spinach, so the combination was not too heavy overall. But a friend ordered one with sausage and it was pure overkill. The combo was just too greasy.
(2)Richard B.
Horrible and Scary. I gave no idea why this place is rated anything but 1 star. The interior is drab and depressing. It's as dirty as they come. The only thing this pace probably has going for it are the prices, but I don't know if a cheap pizza is worth being yelled at by a homeless guy while standing in line.
(1)Lo A.
10 piece combo. Hot. All flats. Extra crispy. Is that too much to ask for ? Clearly. I was told there was an extra charge for crispy & flats request. That's fine , I don't mind paying for what I want. I received my food halfway cold , stale fries , 7/10 of the wings are DRUMSTICKS & they're the slimiest wings I've ever had although I requested & PAID extra for this. Not to mention their ketchup packets tasted funny & so did their "ranch". I Called them back to inform them on the issue & they hung up !! I called BACK & told them that I do not want to be billed for something I did not get. The guy puts me on hold & a women picks up only to say "yeah?" So I'm like "yeah??" she then continues to say "oh sorry I got on the phone to see what the problem was". OKAAAAYYY so no introducing yourself or at least sounding like you cared about the job. I'm assuming she was management. I'm wondering how she got there with no customer service skills. I don't believe they took that off my bill either. The only thing pleasant about the whole experience was that the delivery man was nice. Other than that I'm never referring this place to anyone bc Id hate for them to get treated & fed the way I did.
(1)Millie G.
Maybe I'm weird but whatever. Their pizza is delicious. It serves it's cheesy, greasy purpose and I can't complain. I will say that the cheese fries are best stayed away from...none too pleased.
(4)Tameka W.
I ordered the lunch combo (pizza, side salad and drink). The side salad was unwashed rabbit food, but other than that the pizza was delicious. I normally get the calzones and Stromboli's, which are great! I don't understand the 1 star reviews.
(4)Praful G.
I was terrified of walking into the place! Not sure why this place has a rating at all. No parking whatsover, called up the owner and he said to park at the varsity or go figure! Me and a friend placed an order and they called my number after 20 mins of ordering a personal sized pizza. The order was given to me in a to-go box. The onion rings tasted like dough all over. I guess they are catering to college crowds which would explain the cheap deal and take outs. I would most certainly never step into the place ever again!
(1)Nikki L.
I went here after a night of clubbing in Midtown...there was a wait but it was worth it! I hear the special 1 slice, 6 wings, fries and a soda for $10. It was good and even better the next day!
(4)Steven B.
This is the kind of customer service that is ruining eating in Atlanta. 45 minutes after ordering a pizza through the website we got a call telling us they couldn't deliver two blocks away. Literally two blocks away. It's a good time for poorly run restaurants to fail and make room for true professionals.
(1)Tim D.
We eat here usually late at night, not much else open! This pizza is nothing to write about....its just PIZZA.
(2)Marc M.
On my way to the Coca Cola factory and Aquarium I decided to stop in and grab a meal. Entree: Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich Drinks: Water The food was excellent and the service was good. Good atmosphere, pleasant environment and very attractive staff! :-)
(4)Phillip K.
Better than The Varsity but they could do so much better with the wings. A little bit too hard (on both occasions). It's nice if your lazy and live close by. But for a nice meal, look around a little.
(3)Joe S.
Recently contacted them via the concierge at the nearby Renaissance Hotel (apparently they have some sort of delivery agreement). Missed dinner with clients, came back to the room starving. The manager answered, had no idea what the Renaissance was, kept asking me for my address, to which I replied I wasn't sure of the exact address but the concierge had passed me on to her. She proceeded to tell me that I was being nasty and they wouldn't deliver food to me. Click. Perhaps she was in high school and isn't old enough to have learned customer service. If that's the case......LEARN! There are plenty of people of who are desperate for work, be grateful. Won't be calling them again.
(1)Daniel Q.
Here's what they got going for them: They are cheap. They are better then fast food. They are open late. For what they are, they are ok. I'm not going to go out of my way to eat there, and I may well eat there again, if I'm hungry, and nothing better is open. The pizza slice I had was not great for a place with pizza in the name. It was edible. They made it a bit thick, and unwieldy - they sliced a smaller pie into quarters so it fits into a box easier, but doesn't make for easy eating. I also had a meatball sub and fries. The fries were alright, just normal fries, freshly fried, so that was ok. The sub was alright. The cheese was sloppy, and the sauce inconsistant, but the meatballs were tastey enough, and the portions were generous. The service was not great. These are not friendly happy workers, and the area is not terribly nice, but if you are afraid to go to that neighborhood, that's a lot worse places you won't be able to go.
(2)Chloe W.
My First experience at goodfellas was AMAZING. I will definitely recommend to any and everybody to try it when your in atlanta.
(5)Tristan W.
Horrible service. Called from a hotel just outside their 3 mile delivery radius, they charged my card and wouldn't deliver the product. When placing the order I gave them the hotel address and phone number but of course they didn't realize the mistake till after payment. DO NOT DINE HERE!!!
(1)Greg A.
I've been here a good number of times since I live without walking distance, and I am very familiar with Italian food since I'm from Jersey. Honestly, this place has horrible pizza. Stay away from the pizza. The only reason I gave it two stars instead of one is because their cheese steaks are decent(but make sure you ask for no mayo). Their cheeseteaks don't resemble anything like a real Philly but they taste good. Their gyros are ok, but I've had much much better, and I was pleasantly surprised by their calzones the last time I went their. Overall, though this is a good place to go if you want to get some greasy late night food, but stay away from the pizza.
(2)Theryl J.
One of the best late night places I've been too....the food was cooked to order (not waiting on me to order), the service was very FAST, and you still had the option to dine-in or carry out...not to mention that the pizza was actually very good...definitely would go back....also super inexpensive...I got a slice and a drink for under $5.
(4)Mulltea C.
I have been actively seeking out all of the best pizzas in Atlanta because I believe it is one of the best and most perfect foods to have in a community. When I met the owners of Goodfella's Pizza and Wings and they told me about their establishment I had to check it out. Delighted, I ventured out on a beautiful Saturday Spring morning and strolled upon Goodfella's around 11 am. As I walked right up to the counter, eager to try some fun and tasty food for the soul I was enthusiastically greeted with a wonderful smile and disposition by a young lady named Yurbisha. It is true that the right customer service attitude can win over any meal, but the pizza was great too. It was exactly what I was looking for in a hand tossed pie. The consistency of the crust was dead on. Crunchy and chewy, ample amounts of cheese, great toppings and served hot. I saved a couple of leftover slices that I could not finish and they were good both cold and reheated. ( Which is another sign of a good pizza for me:) The price was astonishingly low for such a great product and their hours work for EVERYBODY! This is truly an every day pizza place with a nice community feel.
(5)Brian F.
Ordered GoodFella's for delievery based on the recommendation from the staff at the Rennasiance hotel that I am staying on business.... The food was delievered quicker than the time given and it was very hot. The pizza is AMAZING with great flavor and a healthy amount of toppings and the Caesar salad I got delievered was very fresh and tasty..... Its nice to get good pizza and good service when ordering pizza to a hotel.
(5)Joyce M.
I order takeout last night. I ordered some wings,fries, and jalapeno poppers. I must say I was not satisfied. The food arrived cold. I don't know why it was cold when I ordered the food from some condos located right down the street on Spring street. If I want cold wings I would've just eat wings straight from the freezer. Obviously they don't know what the term HOT WINGS means.The second issue I have with them is that there wasn't any blue cheese or ranch in the bag when I specifically asked them for ranch dressing. I've had Goodfellas before as dining in and loved it. I don't know what the issue is with their delivey. GOODFELLAS word of advice GET IT TOGETHER!
(1)Kenneth H.
Meh. Welcome to average-ville, population this place... I've had work functions taking me to the Renaissance Downtown several days this week, so I've had an opportunity to sample some of the lunch offerings in walking distance. I did J.R. Crickets on Wednesday, and yesterday I decided to give GoodFella's a whirl. They have a 9$ pizza/wings combo, so I opted for that, as it gave me a chance to try out two of their entree items in one sitting. The pizza was, as mentioned below, run through a conveyor & plopped into a Styrofoam clam. The crust is freshly-made, but doesn't have the internal lightness & delicate crunchy crust you usually expect from a non-frozen crust. As mentioned below as well, the cheese was pretty rubbery. The three biggest parts of a pizza are going to be your cheese, crust & presentation, and if you've dropped the ball on those, even legendary sauce & toppings aren't going to rescue the slice from mediocrity. It didn't suck, but it wasn't something I would go out of my way to get again. On to the wings: Medium wings that were pulled from the fryer too soon. I'd be okay with the extra 60 seconds of waiting, if the wings are cooked up crispy. These were crispy in spots, but not over all. Restaurants do this because they don't want the wings to shrink & look chintzy, but small crispy wings are way better than texture-less medium ones. The bottle on the table reveals that this place uses Franks® Red Hot sauce for their wings. They have squirt bottles of the stuff on all the tables, so you can hose down your wings with more, if you like. That was a good thing for me, as they deliver them pretty dry, in my book. Again, the wings weren't horrible, but there is absolutely no reason to walk into this place for wings when ten extra steps down the sidewalk will get you in the door of a place that has good ones. Atmosphere: They at least know how to pick a theme & stick to it, here. It's all going to be Godfather/Scarface/generic mobster stuff on the walls. The ordering & dining areas are clean & uncluttered, and there are flat panel televisions placed around the walls; no shortage of stuff to look at while you eat. They had Faux News on the tvs when I was in there for lunch, which kind of negates the whole 'we have TVs' thing for me; maybe it floats your boat & would add some star power. There is outside seating, but it's going to be two tables crowded onto the narrow sidewalk, right on the corner in front of the Varsity...not great ambiance. Service: Counter service. Belly up, order your food, they plop it on a tray & you're off to the dining area. Everyone was courteous for my visit, but there's not much to critique about the service when it's fast-food style.
(2)Marcus M.
I'm pretty surprised as to how low the reviews were for this place. I've always gotten good a food and good service; all while running the risk of parking across at the Varsity. But most of all, I love how they're open late and always a good... "bang for the buck"
(4)Simon C.
I went to school in little italy in the Bronx, NY and will tell you that Goodfellas has absolutely nothing in common with New York style pizza. That being said I never really expected it to. Their pizza is not the tastiest in the world but their Philly Cheesesteak is not bad at all, their fries are a little large for my tastes, but their sandwiches are alright and low priced for large portions. Don't go here for gourmet pizza, but if you are looking for a good helping of food for a pretty reasonable price go for a sandwich or maybe their personal sized pies. Its across the street from the varsity and plays the part well...
(3)Corey J.
Meh, I definitely would not call this gourmet pizza, there's absolutely nothing to distinguish from it. I ordered delivery, it came on time and was hott so that's where the 3 stars come from, and the wings were just average as well, some were really small and some were decent size. Honestly, Papa Johns or Pizza Hut would be a better choice if you ask me, oh and there's no way I'd buy from this place without having it delivered. Their location at Spring St and N. Ave would provide for an awkard and interesting walk from the restaurant to your car...I doubt you'd have your pizza much less any money left as you're sure to get mugged, harrassed, raped or maybe even all 3 on the short walk to your car.
(3)Kristin C.
This is your average cheap and greasy late-night food. The service here is pretty quick, so if you're in the neighborhood at two or three in the morning, stop in and order some fries or a slice of pizza.
(2)Javier F.
Don't even bother. We ordered wings from here and were disappointed by the entire experience. The wings were overcooked and considerably under-sauced. Although I obviously can't prove it, the wings appeared to have been cooked earlier and been sitting under a heat-lamp for a while. To add insult to injury, the little bit of sauce that was on the wings wasn't any good. We ended up breaking out hot sauce, BBQ sauce and ranch dressing from my own kitchen to try to save them. The order came with a basket of fries that wasn't worth eating. We threw away a quarter of the wings and most of the fries. Also, the delivery took 55 minutes to arrive and it wasn't even cheap! But hey, no disrespect, maybe their pizza is good.
(1)Michael D.
Um the pizza sucks and i ordered take out and it took an hour and 45 min to get here and i had called four times to find out where it was and got hung up on called back 2 more times and talked to 2 different people and the second person was helpful and called the driver to find out where it was the only excuse they had was theres alot of traffic. I know atl traffic sucks but come on its 5 miles from my hours even in rush hour it shouldnt take more then 30 min to deliver this never would happen in nj or philly or i would get something free i mean the pizza was cold which if it was atleast good then i would have been fine with the wait.
(1)Nicholas R.
I love the pizza and the other italian options, the wings are drenched in sauce to make up for a not so great chicken and the burgers and salads are less then desirable but no reason to give it a bad review. Good price for the area. The place is always packed when I drive by or when I call so I know people like it. Like it so much you have to wait up to an hour and a half to two hours for delivery. I work in the area and has become popular for people in my building. They are open super late on weekends so its a great go to spot for after the bars and clubs to soak up the alcohol. Its great give it a shot.
(3)Foodie Buddha F.
So I've dined here a couple more times since my initial review. As much as I would like to keep them a 3 star, the place just isn't that great. Again, we're talking delivery, so keep that in mind. It's fine and will get the job done. Pizza is still decent, but anything more than 3 stars for this place is laughable at best.
(2)Anna I.
I am a bit surprised to see a few negative reviews about Goodfellas. I have ordered delivery from this place about 5 -6 times before I decided to post a review because I was anxious to see when they would finally screw up. But they didn't. They have consistently delivered a piping hot, flavorful delicious pizza in 30 minutes. I have also ordered wings, eggplant parm sandwiches and it's all been delicious. I would recommend them to anyone and I will continue to order from them from now on. BTW, they are open until 3:30am and until 4am on Friday and Saturdays. How can you beat that???
(4)