Search Your Favourite Restaurants.

Name: Carroll Street Café
Address: 208 Carroll St SE, Atlanta, GA, 30312
Telephone: (404) 577-2700
Price range: Under $11
Rating: 3.86

Carroll Street Café

208 Carroll St SE, Atlanta, GA, 30312

(404) 577-2700
Store is closed

Carroll Street Café Menu

Appetizers

Roasted Red Bell Pepper Hummus

Almond Brie Rolls

Cheese Plate

Tomato Montrachet

Avocado Shrimp Cocktail
Salads

Spinach & Bacon

Thai Beef

Greek Salad

Nicoise

Farm House

Grilled Salad Toppers
Tapas

Meatballs Marinara

Portobello Caprese

Lamb Sliders

Crab Cakes

Sesame Seared Tuna

Basil Shrimp

Seared Scallops

Asparagus En Croute

Lobster Risotto

Sauteed Calamari

Pizza Portobello

Short Ribs
Sandwiches

Betty

Turkey Burger

Panoramic Veggie

Salmon Ciabatta

Chicken Focaccia

Veggie Burger

Carroll Street Blt

Veggie Wrap

Classic Cobb

Sashimi Tuna

Gyro

Crab Cake
Pastas

Salmon Linguini

Penne Albufera

Cheese Tortelloni

Seafood Penne

Basil Noodle Bowl
Entrees

Filet Mignon

Sashimi Tuna Steak

Curry Basil Chicken

New York Strip Steak

Trout
Desserts

Raspberry Chocolate Mousse

Coconut Cake

Orange Cake

Blueberry Cheesecake

Key Lime Pie

Chocolate Truffle

Chocolate Mousse

Midnight Express

Amaretto Cheesecake

B-52 Cheesecake

Peanut Butter Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Pecan Pie

Healthy Meal suggestions for Carroll Street Café

Appetizers

Roasted Red Bell Pepper Hummus [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Almond Brie Rolls [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Cheese Plate [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Tomato Montrachet [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Avocado Shrimp Cocktail [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]
Salads

Spinach & Bacon [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Thai Beef [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Greek Salad [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Nicoise [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Farm House [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Grilled Salad Toppers [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]
Tapas

Meatballs Marinara [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Portobello Caprese [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Lamb Sliders [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Crab Cakes [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Sesame Seared Tuna [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Basil Shrimp [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Seared Scallops [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Asparagus En Croute [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Lobster Risotto [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Sauteed Calamari [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Pizza Portobello [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Short Ribs [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]
Sandwiches

Betty [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Turkey Burger [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Panoramic Veggie [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Salmon Ciabatta [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Chicken Focaccia [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Veggie Burger [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Carroll Street Blt [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Veggie Wrap [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Classic Cobb [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Sashimi Tuna [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Gyro [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Crab Cake [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]
Pastas

Salmon Linguini [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Penne Albufera [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Cheese Tortelloni [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Seafood Penne [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Basil Noodle Bowl [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]
Entrees

Filet Mignon [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Sashimi Tuna Steak [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Curry Basil Chicken [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

New York Strip Steak [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Trout [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]
Desserts

Raspberry Chocolate Mousse [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Coconut Cake [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Orange Cake [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Blueberry Cheesecake [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Key Lime Pie [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Chocolate Truffle [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Chocolate Mousse [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Midnight Express [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Amaretto Cheesecake [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

B-52 Cheesecake [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Peanut Butter Chocolate Mousse [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Chocolate Pecan Pie [ Carbohydrates (ms): 0, Sodium (s): 0, Saturated Fat (ms) : 0, Calories: 0, Sugar (ms): 0 ]

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant blood pressure menu details.

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant cholesterol menu details.

Write An Anonymous Review

Jeff M.

I wish I lived a little bit closer. Or I wish I could master teleportation. The name is perfectly descriptive. This is a lazy morning type of place. A neighborhood joint. But hip and alternative. The place is welcoming and warm. You stare out the window and you see houses in the neighborhood. I went for breakfast. I had the Croissant Sandwich (turkey, scrambled eggs, tomato, spinach, Swiss cheese & bechamel sauce); delicious, gargantuan, and filling. It's strange in that this sandwich energizes you and also makes you feel sleepy. For me, anyways. You can kick back here. Chill out here. I'm a fan. I should wish it were closer to home.
(4)
Tina L.

Tucked into the folds of Cabbagetown, this hipster cafe reminded me of Austin, TX. I went in search of a quick lunch and they definitely delivered. In my short visit, I even went back again because I had to try out their brunch (narrowly missed the first day around). I was a bit concerned when I saw such a huge variety of offerings on the menu, but Carroll Street Cafe definitely delivered. There was also an amazing selection of coffees and a friendly staff to boot.
(4)
Mariana D.

As quant and cute as the place was I must admit I was very disappointed. The waitress was slow and got my order wrong even when I corrected her. The food was kind of slimy and tasteless-even my boyfriend who had recommended the place was disappointed. Other than that... the coffee was excellent. I might be willing to go back, just not any time soon.
(2)
Huzefa O.

CUte place with awesome foooood! Loved the waffles!
(4)
Lori G.

First it's the ambiance that gets you, an easy bohemian vibe, with rotating art shows, but it doesn't end there. The food has always rated from above average to spectacular, when I tried their special of seared scallops. The hipster servers know their way around the menu and can answer any questions. The libations are refreshing and it's cozy hanging out in the lounge area. Great sidewalk seating too and perfect for people watching.
(5)
Lloyd B.

The place is really nice, but the food is OK. I've been there twice now and each time left thinking the food could've been better. Although the vegan chocolate raspberry cake was delicious!
(3)
ernesto s.

whaaat. Birthday dinners don't come this close. a nirvana's nirvana. the tuna nicoise salad is the best i've had (also the first I've ordered, but it was dang good). the meatballs with goat cheese - mmmmm. we also shared an arugula salad that hit the spot. all we kept saying was how much better it was than last night's pleasant, yet heavy outing at H&F. we could eat here every day, that's how good it is. maybe it was the night, the combo of flavors?
(4)
Miss J.

Oh, the amount of times I went to Carroll Street Cafe for brunch and said I would only have 1 mimosa and ended up drinking 6. or 8. or 10. Those were the days. Love love love them! Awesome brunch, never made it for dinner. Laidback, and good for people watching!
(4)
Keith H.

this is a great place to take someone for a drink and maybe an appetizer but the entrees leave much to be desired....i got the ribeye and not only did it look like something you would get in a cafeteria, thin, fake grill marks, and abnormally flat, but it tasted like they had a salt fight in the kitchen and they were using my plate as a shield... so...good drinks...beautiful atmosphere...typical atl slow diner style service...well done appetizers...save your money for a real dinner
(3)
Coley W.

Carroll Street Cafe serves contemporary American cuisine. We're talking tropical talapia, New York strip steak, almond brie rolls, thai beef salad, salmon linguine, a "panoramic" veggie sandwich, gyros -- stop me when you're hungry. During the day, it's all served curbside, or by a big bay window. In the evenings, dine by candle light. This is the perfect, independently cool spot to anchor one of America's great neighborhoods -- Cabbagetown.
(4)
Shannon H.

In keeping with my review of apres diem... I love this place. It's comfy, cozy, and eclectic. The food is reliably good, with varied specials and excellent drinks. I've been for brunch and dinner, and enjoyed both. It's a little out of the way, and parking can be a challenge, so if you haven't been before it might help you to know there's a (small) parking lot just down the row of shops from the cafe.
(4)
Thien D.

Wow! I'm in love again and it's been a long time coming. This place has it! Cute, adorable, hip, swanky, and way way cool. I didn't go here today but I did the other day and I much need to yelp about this little one. I went here to meet some of my friends the other day and I had never been in here before. I've only seen the outside because it is right down the doors from Milltown Arms. I didn't think anything of it at first, but when I stepped in those doors, I knew this place was different. This place was just this cool hang out that people wine and dine at. I sat down with my friends and started with my usually appetizer. Three individual shots of Crown and a side of Coke. Haha guys! No sharing for you. This is all mine! Without fail, of course the Crown was wonderful lol. My friends looked at me like I was a madman for getting hammered at 1:00 in the afternoon but hey! You gotta start somewhere. So after I finish my Crowns, I decide to gaze through the menu. My eyes stopped on the crab cake appetizers and crab it was. I can't tell you how long it took for it to come out because I had lost track of reality by that time. It did come out though and it was goooooooood. The plating looked very upscale but served just right in the right place and it becomes hip instead. So the crab cakes didn't fill me nor did the crown. So I order another round and back to the menu I go. I look to my friends for suggestions because one of them use to work there. I think I had the salmon Alfredo or linguine....or something like that. I can't remember lol. I do remember it was good though. Any who, we all lounged around and all had drinks for however long and enjoyed every moment of it. One of the best scenes in the US me thinks. Come if and give it a try. I'm going again this coming week when I get back to Atlanta. twitter.com/10_k
(5)
Blake B.

Since when I go running I always take a route down Carroll St., I always wanted to remember to come eat here sometime--they have little tables out on the sidewalk that look like some kind of Parisian cafe. Somehow even living just across the street I always forget to come in, until finally a friend suggested we go in on the strength of their desserts. This place is way pricey for what you get. I think between the 3 of us we split a brie appetizer and 2 of us had 1 drink, and the total bill was $25. Pretty ridiculous, considering the drinks were both a couple sips each and the brie was always supposed to cost $6. I was hungry there but their other prices were so high I didn't feel like it was worth it, especially considering that Village Pizza is a couple doors down. I went in to look at the dessert case (the reason we were there) and they seemed to have the standard 'we have a dessert case' type stuff: Napoleons and rich slabs of cake. Nothing I'd gouge an eye out for. Their drink list was shmantzy and expensive. The service was spotty but the girl was overtly friendly when she did come back, and chatted us up as if she were on speed, which she might have been. She was nice. I was surprised that someone actually paid attention to refilling out water. Better service than their counterpart Apres Diem, but still a bit messy. Sitting outside was nice. Don't go out of your way.
(3)
Lauren T.

This is a great little place. I've only been on Sundays but never had to deal with a wait or an overwhelming Sunday Brunch crowd. The food is great (without being too expensive) and the service is good. The parking is a mess. Nobody seems to know whether or not Carroll Street is supposed to be a one-way street... but the road is only wide enough for one car! I've had to back into driveways in order to let other cars by. You'll probably have to drive around the corner and down a side street and then dust off those parallel parking skills!
(4)
Rina H.

I like the location, the crowd and the food. They serve late and I often don't sit down for dinner until 10pm...so the fact that they serve until midnight (I believe) is thrilling. Service is always good, food is good (not award winning) and the place is pretty charming.
(4)
Russ G.

Very cool place for lunch and early meals, this is a small little place nestled into Cabbagetown that you'll miss if you blink. Good selection of beer, wine, and liquor, and quite a few interesting menu items as well. Nights get a little crowded, and if you're in a group you may get split up since there's not a lot of space to begin with. Otherwise it's cozy, quaint, a sort of 'home' feel. Servers are knowledgeable about the food items and eager to help without dragging their heels too much.
(4)
Smita P.

I am a big fan of Carroll Street Cafe for Saturday or Sunday brunch. Its the best. I love the cool eclectic style of this restaurant. Any place that serves Mimosa's with fresh OJ is high in my list. I am a big fan of the Eggs Benedict and the Eggs Meurette. The omlettes are super too (per Jen and Marci who were with me and ordered them). The art and the couches (along the wall and by the windows) add a fun and cozy touch making it a place you can hang out for hours. I've never been there in the evenings but the bar seemed to list out some great cocktails and appetizers so I imagine its a good bet for non-brunch meals as well.
(4)
Foodie Buddha F.

So I promised the gang that I would give them their 15-minutes and include them in a review. So here you go guys and gals - this one is for you. I was lucky enough to get an invite to the most exclusive of birthday celebrations! It was so tough to score that even Mandi was S.O.L.!!!! That's saying something - she's famous enough that she only needs one name! Needless to say, I joined the lovely Elizabeth H (HAPPY B-DAY!!!!), magnanimous Ben O, inquisitive Chris & Leslie R (who I expect to read this entire review), and sexified Laura F, for brunch at Carroll Street CafÃ© this past Sunday. Though I must say - it's amazing how good looking and funny they all said I am! That was truly flattering. Now with that stuff out of the way, I will get on with the recapitulation. Carroll Street CafÃ© is a mid-sized joint packed in with a handful of other businesses that are oddly situated on the edge of Cabbagetown. The restaurant is split into two rooms - one part coffee shop - one part dining tavern. Though there is a clear distinction between the floor plans of each room - the dÃ©cor, menu, and service are ubiquitous throughout. I have eaten here a number of times - though it's never a place I'm dying to go to, given the price point and the overall atmosphere, it is certainly passable. Fortunately, for the purpose of this review, I found the meal this past week to be like most other meals I have had here. The menu is muddled to say the least. Speaking specifically to the brunch items - you will find the choices rambling between those of a contemporary American meal and traditional American breakfast. They also take a liking to a few things from our friends north of the border, as well as those to our south. If the quality of the food, the presentation, or the execution was better, than I might be inclined to say that the diversity was appealing. Instead, it just reminds you how remarkably unremarkable everything here is. They do not use fresh product, nothing is made in house, the spices and cooking techniques are straight out of some very basic cookbook. Though I think the words demi-glace appears somewhere on the menu, I seem to remember it being misspelled. I think the food buyer probably goes shopping in the frozen foods section of some nearby Kroger. While this may sound a little harsh, I think it is a fair assessment. Most of the items tend to come out fine. They are neither bad, nor good. It is generally edible, but never spectacular. A handful of the dishes I find to be particularly notable (for one reason or another). The lox plate is a true disappointment if you are expecting Zabar's ( yelp.com/biz/zabars-deliâ€¦ ). The lox are most certainly packaged and never the same. Sometimes you get lox, sometimes you get smoked salmon. The most aggravating thing about the entire restaurant is their cream cheese. I would be fine with them delivering Philadelphia cream cheese for you to spread. Unfortunately, they give you a friend of the single-serving variety. The red beans with poached eggs are non-eventful and what I select more often than not. The beans are canned, the poached eggs are never consistent, and the guac and the pico are packaged (sound familiar?). At this last meal, one of my poached eggs was over cooked, the other was under cooked. The taste is fine, though it's not particularly great, it's certainly agreeable. The best thing on the menu is the Shrimp and Grits. The grits are identified as coming from the queso/jalapeÃ±o genus, but the flavor is pretty mild. These are not up to snuff with some of the other places in town - but again - it will get you buy. The service is usually between ample and attentive; I've found many of the employees to be really personable (and not in that annoying/won't leave you alone sort of way). It has that slacker meets beatnik meets hippie vibe and dÃ©cor that is prominent throughout C-Town. They are fairly clean, though I have found a spot on my dish or my utensil once in a blue moon. Bottom line, given the price point - it's alright. For the six of us, it came out to just about $15/head. Keep in mind that's sans tip and alcohol, but also included an order of shrimp and grits that was split by the table. As far as breakfast/brunch goes, this place doesn't come anyway close to Atmosphere, Thumbs Up, or El Gato Bizco, but it will do when you are looking for different place to grab a bite at. However, I am not motivated to eat dinner here again. It is a neat late night spot if you are looking for some groovy tunes and a change of pace.
(3)
Anna F.

Carroll Street inspired me to start yelping again after a year-long hiatus. Yummy wines, tapas, intimate seating, candlelight... It's a super romantic spot on a cozy little street that feels worlds away from the rest of Atlanta. My favorite dish is their pork belly; their mussels in white wine sauce are also delish (although you won't find them on the menu, they're pretty much always available). Words really can't describe what an enjoyable place this is... just check it out; it's definitely worth the drive from uptown.
(5)
Layne B.

Every time we go here, I feel like I am somewhere in eastern europe. It has the neighborhood feel that you strive for in a city like Atlanta. A wonderful mix of every type of person of every color, nationality, and income. It has a large outdoor area; which is nice for catching up with a book and an expresso. I actually saw a guy with a goat tee and a beret, drinking an espresso and reading vonnegut; sitting next two italian guys have a heated discussion over fashion- nice. The food is very hearty and artfully prepared. We usually split our brunch because it is so big. We get the eggs benedict, and substitute the meat for soysage. The service has been impeccable every time we have been there. Which is also a rarity for Atlanta.
(4)
Lisa K.

Carroll Street Cafe serves some good food and the atmosphere is friendly. Well, maybe not friendly, exactly. More, in-group, out-group? The few times I've been here it felt like a scene in an old Western. I walk through the door and everyone looks up from their drink to size me up. Except, instead of weathered cowhands, picture a mix of yuppies, guppies and hipsters. One of them turns to me and says, "you're not from around here, are you?" Maybe it was my shoes? If you can get past that though, the food *is* good and the decor is charming. The service is average and the prices are ok. Maybe take a date here if you want him/her to think you're cool, hip, and with it.
(3)
Emily B.

So, my love for the food at Carroll Street Cafe cannot be challenged, but my last time there was less than spectacular. While it was not exactly the fault of the establishment (well, except for the way-too-close-together tables), I just had to update my review so that others may be on alert. Many of the tables at CSC line one long wall and don't have much space in-between them. Not such a big deal unless you have REALLY STRONG BODY ODOR GUY sitting right next to you. Yikes! I cannot some people cannot smell their own stink. IT NEARLY RUINED MY MEAL!!! I'm all for you naturalists and your lack of deodorant, but PLEASE have a friend check your stench status before you head out in public.
(4)
Eric W.

I am frequently at the Carroll Street Cafe. It might be because it is walking distance from my place. I only ever come here for a weekend brunch. The food is good, the portions are huge for the price, the ambiance is top notch. This is a great place to lounge around and enjoy a Sunday. I usually order the chicken hash and it is excellent. The Americano I order is made with great coffee beans and very strong. The Mimosa's are also good. Go with the "More-Mosa". The outdoor area is great for this time of year! The food is 4 out of 5 stars. The ambiance is 5 out of 5 stars. The drinks and drink prices are 4 out of 5 stars. It's in my top 10 brunch places.
(4)
Mustard Mayo I.

Pros: Good food, nice atmosphere, friendly waitstaff, dog-friendly Cons: Parking sucks It's a little gem of a place. The staff are super nice and will split the check 20 ways if you ask them to. We can bring our puppy here and sit outside on a nice day.
(4)
Minerva M.

Sweet street side spot in cozy neighborhood off the beaten path - great & yummy brunch & cabbage cappuccino's are a must after a late night - wonderful experience
(5)
Caitlin L.

I've been here a few times and I always end up with the same thing (not that there aren't other options, but again--I'm a creature of habit). Time and time again I order the panoramic veggie sandwich with the yummy side salad and fruit. The sandwich is made on French bread (that can be a bit too crunchy and had rubbed the roof of my mouth wrong once or twice) and full of provolone cheese, avocado, pepperoncini, mixed greens, and an assortment of other veggies. It is yummy!! There's obviously a reason behind me ordering it over and over again. The side salad is served with a vinaigrette dressing and always tastes super fresh. The only other thing I've tried here is their hummus. It was good, as all hummus is--I mean if you screw hummus up you probably shouldn't be in business. I definitely recommend this very cute and intimate spot tucked away in Cabbagetown.
(4)
Betty R.

Came for brunch at about 10 on Saturday, and the place was under half full. Cute space in a cute neighborhood! No one explained whether we should wait to be seated or just grab a table, but there were no signs and none of the staff seemed eager to help. So, we just parked at a table and hoped we hadn't violated protocol. After about 5 minutes, we got up and got our own menus. After another 5-10 minutes, a waiter came up and took drink orders. After another 5-10 minutes, we actually got those drinks. It was a slow start to the meal--and we weren't in a hurry or anything, but dammit, I wanted coffee, STAT! Note to all servers: most cranky customers can be made happy pronto by placing a cup of coffee or an alcoholic beverage in front of them. Food was plentiful and cheap, and it came out fairly quickly. I had the croissant sandwich with scrambled egg, turkey, cheese, spinach, and tomatoes, and everyone agreed it was the best dish of the morning. The only food-related disappointment was boyfriend's Belgian waffle, which was dry and tasteless. The strawberry butter that came with the waffle, though, was quite good. Like I said, cute place, good food, mostly happy times--but I'd be happier if the "very laid back staff" would start things off on a more attentive note. I'll forgive a lot after that, ya know?
(3)
steven c.

I have no complaints, and I left satisfied. At the same time, looking back, nothing stands out. It is certainly laid back, and I can appreciate that. It is a small space, but it was pretty full. I was amazed at the speed the food came out. In fact, I think it may have come out too fast. I went with an Entree, but I think next time I come back I'll just go with a sandwich.
(3)
Shonda K.

I really really enjoyed my meal here. The lobster risotto was delicious. The pork belly glazed with vinegar/brown sugar was delicious. I enjoyed the mushrooms. The tuna though was not all that great. It really lacked flavor. To finish it off I had a slice of coconut cake (not allowed since I have sworn off wheat) it was delicious also. The service was friendly but a little slow at times due to it being a Friday night I guess, but not too bad. Cute little spot, very cozy and laid back. Well definitely return for more of the lobster risotto. 41/2 stars!
(5)
Sarah T.

I've been living about a mile from Carroll Street Cafe for three years now, and am kicking myself for not giving it a chance sooner... Went for breakfast Sunday morning...The ambiance was right up my alley. Laid back, fun art, chalk board full of weekly specials, and coffee options. The crowd: The definition of "melting pot." Young professionals sipping mimosas, kids drinking hot chocolate, grandparents putting back water... There was gay, straight, black, brown, white, and every shade in-between. I loved the diversity! It just added to the overall ambiance. The Latte I started with wasn't the best I've ever had, but certainly not the worst. It had some kind of weird composition at the bottom that resembled a gel. Not sure if it was supposed to be there, but I stirred it in, and drank it anyway. Strong, which other yelpers warned about, but a nice way to start off my Sunday. The menu was extensive, and there were 3 or 4 options that I was drawn to...I had to "enie minie mineie moe" to decide. I ended up getting the Carroll Street Cafe Breakfast. Two eggs over easy, not too difficult. The bacon tasted just like my Mom's - since she lives 300 miles away, that is a bonus point. The breakfast potatoes were delish! They were fried with red peppers, and zucchini, and I ate every bite. A side of watermelon finished off my breakfast perfectly. The portions were large, so I really feel like you're getting every cents worth. The service wasn't overly friendly, but since we didn't have to wait for a seat, and our food came out less than 10 minutes after ordering, I really have no room to complain. Overall, I'm a big fan of Carroll Street Cafe, and I plan on giving it a go for lunch or dinner next time. Just to switch things up... I'll let you know how it goes my fellow yelpers!
(4)
Josie F.

I love Carroll Street! Been here probably 10 times and I have never had a bad experience! Delicious food, friendly service, and an adorable atmosphere. Perfect for a date, or a girls night out. Huge wine selection and a big case of fresh baked cakes, pies and treats. Must get dessert at this place! Also great deals on tapas, good portions and affordable prices.
(5)
Carlos C.

I'm sorry to drag the average star rating down but brain-dead servers are just a real pet peeve of mine. It is too bad because there is so much going for this place. Cool neighborhood. Decent food. Strong drinks. The waitstaff are good looking. Local art on the walls..and so on. But that just doesn't do it for me anymore. Any question about the menu smokes the confuser mechanism of the staff. Water refills take an eternity. Food shows up before drinks. I can't take it any more. Me: What types of muffins do you have today? CSC. Cranberry and Apple. Me: Great, I will have a cranberry muffin. CSC: (30 minutes later) Here's your banana muffin. Me: I ordered a cranberry muffin. CSC: We don't have cranberry muffins. Me: Oh, bummer - maybe next time. CSC: Do you want me to wrap that for you? Me: No, I don't care for banana muffins. CSC: Then why did you order it? Me: I didn't. CSC: Yes you did, I wrote it here my pad..See "c. muff". Me: Exactly CSC: Exactly what?! Me: Banana starts with a "B". CSC: I am aware of that. Me: Could you just remove it from my check please? CSC: But I have already unwrapped it, are you sure you don't want it. Me: So you unwrapped it, then walked over to ask me if I want it wrapped? CSC: What's your point? Me: Just the check please. I'm getting too old for this crap.
(2)
Mark T.

LIKE HALF-TURNED ZOMBIES WE WAKE UP on Sunday mornings and drive to the nearest spot that everyone else says is great. Always judging the food, the service and the diners in the next booth over, I fight the urge to take mental notes, trying not to distract myself from the experience at hand by writing the first draft of my yelp review in my head. I do it too often, ignoring my girlfriend or anyone else I'm with, as if I'm a stranger who happened to sit at the same table, lost in my own thoughts because habits are hard to break. This Sunday morning at Carroll Street is rare with barely another pair of diners filling in the entire cafe. The shrimp and grits are good in an odd european attempt, even if the seafood is slightly over seasoned and the serving a bit smaller than I'd like. But that's my fault since gluttons always want more.The space, with its perfectly imperfect tables of dark woods and slightly-off-but-matching everything else, is better than most attempts and fits in elegantly with the close quarters of anything on the actual Carroll Street itself. Like Sun in my Belly over in Kirkwood, any neighborhood would be made better with a spot like Carroll Street Cafe in Cabbagetown. With so many other breakfast locations, it's a great choice for two, not for families, not for you and your friends plus their friends all at once. Sitting there practically alone with my girlfriend, with the glass window between us and the street, and a table littered with breakfast plates that once had food... I am reminded of why I left Pheonix for Atlanta, to follow this girl and our endless stream of breakfast dates. ***1/33
(4)
Roy K.

Everyone once in a while i am disappointed by service....but by far this is a reliable joint and a great atmosphere. Food (have never had an 'entree'): sandwiches, pasta, apps, and tapas are all great bang for buck. They server Lavazza espresso which also makes my heart feel good. Go here. great for conversation. cool people over all.
(5)
Edward L.

Carroll Street Cafe is soo good I don't even want to return for at least a week because I don't want to get burned out. It doesn't hurt that several of the waitresses are quite lovely and that the guy in the corner with the 17 Macbook Pro is playing great music. If doesn't hurt that this is both a great date spot and as well as nieghborhood bar. It doesn't hurt that the legendary Carpe Diem owners are involved if not complete owners of this spot. It doesn't hurt that Carroll Street is probably in the center of the hippest nieghborhood in the A. Yeah, I'll be back.
(5)
Jo Jo C.

I stop here for dessert every now and then. It's like an Intermezzo on that side of town. I hear the mussels are good too!
(4)
Angela Y.

This is my new favorite place near my 'hood. The service was great and friendly and the food was awesome! I had the crab cakes and then I had a steak that was so good and tender ! My friend had the thai chicken salad that he really seemed to enjoy. It is a great place to bring your laptop and just relax and have great food. I am planning on visiting Carroll Street cafe on a regular basis now.
(4)
red l.

Food was mediocre. Wait staff was not that attentive.
(2)
Stephie Z.

I might be a bit biased, since I live right around the corner, but I have to say that I dug my first meal here. I woke up on Saturday morning with the sun streaming in the window and felt damn good. I figured this was the first nice day in awhile so I would walk my dog to the place around the corner. I was all prepared for a long wait for one of their outside tables- after all the sun was shining and though you still needed long sleeves, it felt great outside. I walk up and shockingly enough there was not a single person outside- fucking pansies. I ordered the Italian sausage omelet- you pick b/w pork, chicken, or soysage sausage- with goat cheese, and red peppers. Got my food and dug in. The omelet was mighty tasty and it came with potatoes and a biscuit- I certainly wasn't expecting those. The potatoes were decent. I would prefer them to be hot vs room temp and the lack of seasoning kind of turned me off, but on the bright side the biscuit was flaky and delicious. The one turnoff I had was that I was sitting directly outside the window of this lovely couple who kept gawking at me. I felt like they were invading my personal space despite the wall and window between us. I wanted to scream "quit judging me" but thats a whole other stoy that I won't get into here. Anyhoo my dog and I sucked up the sunlight and had some good food, minus the potatoes. A good start to an even better day.
(4)
Stephanie M.

The small bars and restaurants in Cabbage town are like finding little hidden treasures. Carroll Street Cafe is no exception. Very laid back, casual atmosphere. Great place to have a quiet lunch or enjoy a glass of wine late evening. Service was casual and fun. My cheese tortellini lasted me til lunch the next day, and mimosa's come in large and small. (Do you have to ask if i got the big'un?)
(4)
Leah T.

Breakfast at the Carroll Street Cafe on Saturday morning was a great start to the weekend, especially after a crazy week. The quirky buildings and random art along Carroll Street, coupled with the large, flower-box-lined windows, put me in a perfect bohemian mood. The menu has some great choices and the food was super-yum! I had the croissant sandwich, sans turkey. It came with tomatoes, mushrooms, scrambled eggs, cheese, and bechamel. I had the polenta as a side (that was just so-so). Plenty of food to fill me up, and I also appreciate not having my coffee cup filled every two seconds. I hate having to guard my cup from the unwanted refills you get at some places... I finally get my cuppa joe doctored up JUST right, and the second I take a sip and look away...bam! It's filled up with hot coffee again, throwing the taste and temperature off kilter. Grrrr. Fortunately, this was NOT a problem at Carroll Street- we were quietly asked twice, and only twice if we'd like a refill. Perfect. Carroll Street Cafe also gets bonus points for being open at 8:00 a.m. on the weekends! The mister and I tend to be early risers... it can be a tough stretch to wait until 9:00 or later for a decent breakfast.
(4)
Shannon C.

The food here is sooooooooooooooooooooo good. I always go here for brunch. The prices are typical. The only reason I give it a 4 is because their waitresses suck.
(4)
Melissa B.

I love Carroll Street! And I must say after going there a few hundred times for brunch, I've come to realize that it isn't necessarily the food I love but the total experience. Don't get me wrong, the food is usually really good whether it is brunch or dinner but I would never describe it as the best...as a matter of fact, I don't think I've ever craved anything off their menu. What I do crave is sitting in one of the cozy corner booths so I can look out at all of the other patrons, check out the art on the wall and the hanging plants on the porches across the street all while sipping on my coffee and talking with my friends. It's just an amazing place that way. When you brunch at Carroll Street on a pretty day, you will feel that all is right with the world for just a little while. The service can be spotty and inconsistent but usually not enough to break the spell of the place itself...unless you are just a densely negative person, then it will probably annoy the hell out of you.
(4)
Clare B.

This place is great. The Cabbagetown parking scares off most OTP-ers, the food is usually awesome, staff is always friendly, and the vibe is more cozy European or east village coffeehouse than hipster (though there's a touch of that too, in a good way.) In an increasingly chain-restaurant prone Atlanta, it's nice to know the strongholds like Carroll Street are still their lovely, eclectic, independent selves. I live pretty close so I've been here a lot, mostly for brunch, and it's always been delicious. The mimosas aren't bad either, and if it's packed you can always sit at the bar and order some food. Note of caution: the coffee is unbelievably strong, so if you're caffeine sensitive be careful or you may end up rebuilding someone's engine or cleaning your house with Q-tips after drinking a few cups.
(4)
Chris L.

This place is great. It is one of of the many hidden gems in the Cabbage town area. The ambiance is great, very faint music, nice dim lighing, a nice wine selection, and the food was excellent. I had some sort of Salmon Pasta bowl, it was great! The portion was pretty big, and I could not finsh it. The wine selection was decent, but I feel there could have been some improvements in that area. Overall, I was very much impressed. I will be coming back.
(4)
Kellyn W.

Lovely! Always!
(5)
Kay U.

Once or twice a month, my boyfriend and I will venture to CSC for breakfast. He likes the coffee, I like the Cabbagetown Breakfast. I almost always get the same thing so I can't speak for the rest of the entrees, but the breakfast is great!
(4)
Thee Andersons s.

The night crowd can get a bit stuffy, but the food is consistently great! Be sure to do a brunch or lunch, a vegetarian omelet or a betty sandwich. *Key tip: The bartenders are constantly inventing new drinks, try asking for something special
(4)
Howard W.

Yumm-e! Went tonight for the first time and we'll *definitely* even be back. We met another couple and had our 4 year-old in tow. The food was great. The atmosphere was perfect-- very laid back and mellow but also interesting. I had the asian noodles and they were great. A friend with us had the pizza with jalapenos-- also great. We had the crab cake appetizer and it was *good* but I'm from Baltimore, so ya probably shouldn't ask me whether I liked their version. (I've had *much* and even in Baltimore) One complaint. Our waitron was so high energy and pushy, ya kinda had to wonder what she was on? She talked faster than a New Yawkuh and didn't really read the situation that we weren't rushing into the menu. Outside of that, great place. HIGHLY recommen!
(4)
Marla P.

Great bloody Marys and brunch on the weekends. Small, coy and artsy.
(4)
Talib K.

this place is like apres diem on a street called 'carroll.' they have the same furniture with that well used, comfortable look. they have the same 'nice enough' staff and 'good enough menu.' they also have the same solid selection of wines, liquors, and beers. i wonder if they have anything else the same?????? i like this place. just like apres diem, the best time to go is during the mid afternoon. generallly, this is a solid selection for food, drink, and merry dialogue. the dining room can be a little tight on busy nights, but the sofas are really the place to be.
(3)
Malloy M.

Great food for a great price! Drinks are great too but the servers always seem to be operating at 45%. they're nice but you're not getting your cocktail til after they've finished chatting with each other first. Molassas slow service has never stopped me from going in and it shouldn't for you either, but if you're in a hurry, sit at the bar.
(4)
Patrick Q.

Carroll Street is a special street, and this cafe makes a great anchor for a handful of solid restaurants and bars. While it is a smaller version of Apres Diem, it feels more unique than a spin-off and over the years has developed a unique character and feel that fits with Cabbagetown and the clientele. Good cafe menu and drink selection, and when you can grab an outside table, excellent for reading or a wandering conversation. Very dog friendly.
(3)
D. B.

Carroll Street is best for brunch on a calm Sunday before the church crowds or hungover party animals get there. Great ambience and local art featured on the walls. I suggest sitting outside during the summer and enjoy the quirky parts of Cabbagetown. Eggs Meurette and the Croissant Sandwich are superb. Serves excellent coffee (Counter Culture). Also the lobster rissotto on half-off tapas night! Some nights during the week they have live music-- Piano, acoustic guitar, singer-songwriter stuff. It's a nice place for a date, or to take a friend that you haven't seen in a while. Service is so-so depending on the server.
(4)
RaShonda J.

After reading reviews about this place, I dragged my hubby down to the cafe since it was nice day today. Since it was too early for tapas we settled on turkey burger for me and pasta for him. Well, after placing our orders, I noticed something dripping onto our table. We moved to a new table and when I explained to the waitress why we moved she let us know that the A/C leaks on that table. ok...that would have been good to know ahead of time. Anyway, we sat waiting for our food for a good 25 minutes. The place was not crowded at all. During that time I made my way to the lady's restroom which smelled like bath & body works to my surprise...very nice. When the food arrived we got a semi-explanation for the delay but it was inaudible. My turkey burger was ok but nothing special. The pasta was pretty good but it came with a small piece of plastic wrap in the dish. Thankfully it was noticeable so no cpr was required. I was shocked at our bill of $24 considering what we ordered. Can't say I will return but this place may be known for their drinks. I saw quite a few people sipping what looked like bloody marys.
(3)
Claire S.

My how Cabbagetown has grown! I had not visited ATL in 1.5 yrs until this past May. Happy to see one of my favorite brunch institutions was still thriving. Love to sit out on the porch, drinking bloody mary's & eating the celery out of the drink while enjoying my eggs benedict. 2 hours later & several bloody mary's (or mimosas, depending upon my mood), stumbling back to Virginia's house, GOOD TIMES. Highly recommend this place for brunch. Good people watching & fun shops on Carroll St as well.
(4)
Daniel G.

Love this place. Whether it's brunch or dinner, the atmosphere, food, and service is always fantastic. Perfect for a first date.
(5)
Teri S.

Ate lunch here today and while the menu wasn't particularly inspiring, the food was well prepared and very fresh tasting. The iced latte was the best I've had in some time. But my favorite thing about the Carroll St. Cafe is the ambience. Just a wonderful neighborhood cafe with a very relaxed, comfortable feel. Parking is a bit of a challenge, but worth the effort. I wish this place was in my neighborhood!
(4)
Leeor N.

The service and food here were great. I live in San Francisco and have regular occasion to patronize restaurants that are held to a far higher standard, so I am at a loss to understand some of the negative reviews about the service. When my friend and I arrived, we asked for a seat outdoors and offered to wait because they all appeared to be taken and the weather was nice. As it turned out, one of the staff who had finished her shift was sitting by herself and offered to move to a neighboring table to sit with some of her friends so that we could be accommodated. She didn't have to do that and I thought that was very nice of her. As for ordering, my friend and I had no idea what to order, so just asked our waitperson to get us a few of whatever dishes she recommended. The dishes were all great, not life-altering, but if you want life-altering, you would not be justified walking into what is obviously a relaxed and charming local cafe. The neighborhood is also one of my favorites. I very nearly came back twice in one weekend.
(5)
Michael B.

I love this place! The food is quite good for such a small restaurant...or maybe that is why it is good. There is excellent sidewalk seating, if you can get it, and inside is dark, cozy, comfortable and artsy. My wife and I often find ourselves here on date night. It is owned by the Cafe Diem (remember that?) / Apres Diem folks, and the international syle of service actually holds true here. Apres Diem service sucks--sorry to say that, but European service doesn't mean, "ignore me and make me ask for you to bring my food, drink, check". So if you're inclined toward the Apres Diem menu, skip it and come to Carroll Street Cafe instead. Try the filet with cardiac bleu cheese, the mixed green salad with a salmon filet, tasty little artisan bread sandwiches and baked goods. They have a decent wine list, too, so ask for a recommendation. UPDATE: My wife and I went to Carroll Street for their Prix Fixe Valentine's day wine pairing....awesome! The only drawbacks? WAY too much salt in the lobster bisque and potatoes au gratin...otherwise amazing. The wine pairings were great: a flowery, fruity viognier with salad, a robust sirah with my tenderloin, and one of the best desserts we've ever had anywhere. They're supplied by Alon's, Southern Sweets, and some other great bakeries/patisseries in town. Sure beats the Publix sheet cakes that pass for desserts in some Atlanta restaurants. This is where it gets good. Our waiter, Keith, (youngish slender guy with black-framed glasses) gave us the most awesome service. He suggested that we get the orange cake and have it warmed up. Damn, that was good. Do yourself a favor and ask for Keith...tip him well. There was absolutely no pretense (he joked about not knowing how to set the order of the silverware), gave generous pours, and was really unintrusive but always available--super laid-back. Really a pleasant guy and a gracious departure from the typical fend-for-yourself waitrons notoriously endemic to the Apres restaurants. The meal was 4 stars, but Keith gets 5.
(4)
Kelley H.

i love this place - but i have only been there for breakfast and brunch. the food is really tasty - especially the waffles and french toast. it's casual with a really artistic feel with some outside dining. it's really a highlight of the neighborhood.
(4)
Vincent V.

The owners of Apres Diem successfully cloned and then shrank their restaurant and put it in Cabbagetown. And I shall call it...Mini Diem. Great drinks, desserts, and the tapas aren't bad. The only drawback to this place is that you might get stuck with a server who is more interested in being part of the scene than doing their job. Which is also a cloned feature of Apres Diem. I liked the brunch, but my one time there in the light of day was marred by some atrocious service. Whatever our little gal had done the night before, she hadn't finished coming down from it. She spaced out and vanished for ages at a time, got our order wrong three times, and was getting her tables confused. I felt bad that I had talked the place up to some friends and had that happen when they met me there. Overall, great food and atmosphere but you might hit a serious dud with the service at any given time.
(3)
josie p.

I love it here, although the parking situation leaves LOTS to be desired! In all honesty, I love all of the restaurants by this owner (Apres Diem in Midtown & Carpe Diem in Decatur)... each of them have such a European loungey vibe that just speaks to me in a good way. Carroll Street is the smallest of the 3 & feels the most like a coffee house or wine bar, although it is neither. The Panoramic Veggie Sandwich is my jam, but the pasta dishes are super yummy too. Really though, I just enjoy coming here to sip on some refreshing cocktail & chillax in the dark, candle-studded bar area... Perfect evening!
(5)
Peter B.

Carroll Street Cafe has the one of the tastiest brunch menu's in Atlanta at very good prices. Crab Cakes Benedict is superb. Crab cakes made fresh daily for like $8.95. Their house special grits or polenta are excellent sides. The brunch portions are overly satisfying. We go for dinner and lunch as well. The food is solid but not refined. The dessert case looks awesome. Unfortuneately, we go there so often I forbid myself from indulging.The place itself is intown cool. Local artists rotate their works on the walls to add to the eclectic decor.
(4)
Denise D.

Went for my first vist last night. What a wonderful find...staff was friendly and attentive. Good vibe, nice art...food was great!
(5)
Dawn S.

Whenever you roll out of bed for brunch, there always seems to be just enough room to sit down quickly at Carroll Street and have coffee and mimosa in front of you in no time. The hummus is terrific as is the ambiance--day or night.
(4)
Sunshine M.

This is like a hidden gem to me, I took my Husband here for his 30th birthday. We've been here many times but it's close to our house, and has great ambiance. The specials are always really fantastic, and the desserts are excellent, we had a chocolate ganache cake that would knock your socks off!
(5)
Erica J.

I love love love this place. I love going late at night when the place is dark and cozy. Their tapas and salads are delicious and I always order dessert even if I'm super full from dinner. You just can't go there without ending your meal with a moist slice of cake and a cup of coffee.
(5)
Tiffany L.

This place is so good! I love that it's "off the beaten path" and yet basically RIGHT off the beaten path. You drive past it all the time and don't even know it. The food and the service are great. Mid week at lunch-time, you can get in and out in an hour with delicious food to boot. Perfect.
(4)
Scottie M.

Awesome little cafe in an even awesome-r neighborhood. I absolutely love Cabbagetown and I think Carroll Street Cafe is a primary reason. Despite the fact that it's owned by the same people who own Apres Diem (which I hate - see my review), the folks down on Carroll Street actually do a decent job of serving up some great lunch plates. I had the Tilapia sandwich and it was pretty awesome. The accompanying salad and melon slices really made the meal. Great service and tons of cool art on the wall to keep your eyes occupied. Also really good to just run in real quick, sit and have a coffee with a buddy, and run out. Love this place.
(4)
Zadi M.

their menu is great and its got great ambience. the service is spotty, sometimes great sometimes not. but a great place to go with friends or SO without having to go to midtown or buckhead.
(3)
Lori F.

Cute little place for lunch or dinner. They serve brunch on the weekends, too. I like sitting by the bar on the left since it's a little less crowded. Their menu is pretty much the same as Apres Diem (same owners), so my fave is their awesome gyro sandwich. Cons: Parking in Cabbagetown sucks, servers are your typical "angsty-twenty-something-too-cool-for-you" types.
(3)
Avid C.

I lived in Germany for nine years and wound up back in Atlanta. I assumed that returning to the states would mean that I would likely never see another neighborhood restaurant which oozed with character, that is, until I visited the Carroll Street Cafe. This place is a "must visit," as their menu goes in a multitude of creative directions, all of which worth trying. I wish that they emphasized beer a little more, such as something on tap or in a pitcher, but everything else positions this place as an ideal candidate for a special evening. Whatever you do, make at least a random pick from their desert menu, as you would likely be delighted. Finally, if you have a dog, then you should consider this place a "must-must visit" restaurant as their outdoor seating is perfect. Strongly recommended.
(5)
J. D.

One star for being fiercly independent. One star for being gourmet without attitude. One star for being a true neighborhood gathering place. One star for being cool. Hey, that's four stars.
(4)
Drew S.

Great location, I love Cabbagetown. The ambience here is reminiscient of San Francisco. I hit this place for brunch and had a mixed experience. The biscuits and the potatoes were heavenly. My shrimp frittata however was burnt. Nothing says barf after a heavy night of drinking like burnt eggs. The coffee was wonderful as well as the fresh squeezed orange juice which seems to be a scarce commodity around here. Overall though I would have to say this was a fun place to brunch at and I am definitely going to give it a second chance.
(3)
Kris P.

carroll street cafe is PERFECT. especially for brunch - try crab cakes benedict. they are keen on the sweet/salty combos that i crave - pair your pancakes with soysage and fruit. it's worth a 30 minute wait, i promise. i know this is irrelevant, but i always hear people speaking spanish or french at carroll street. the international elite seem to know more about atlanta's hip cafes than locals. it's incredibly sexy at night. a great bar with great tapas and somewhat pricey drinks. i like the parmesan-encrused brie plate with fruit and french bread, although the brie is not really "encrusted". make sure you try their citrus cake with cream cheese frosting. avoid the waitress who calls everyone "sweetheart."
(5)
Elizabeth A.

I'm always looking for places that have GREAT vegetarian food and GREAT non-veg food as well. This has a lot of yummy options for both. I had the veggie burger and would put it in my top 5. It came with a small salad and fresh slices of watermelon and orange on the side - which was a nice surprise on a hot afternoon. And it was a decent price as well. (I want to say $7-8?) However my boyfriend got some kind of breakfast dish that came with bacon, toast, eggs, and potato and at $9 i felt like the plate should have been heaping with food or at least have something original about it. He said it was good but not great, slightly overpriced. Our waiter was a little shy but very attentive. And the place as a whole was just really beautiful. Great little place. I wanted to try just about everything on the menu.
(4)
Katie S.

I have been coming to Carroll Street Cafe for years. It's owned by the people who own Apres Diem, though I like Carroll Street much better. I love taking people here for their first visit. Sometimes it is a struggle to find a close parking spot because there is only parking on the street. It's a cute building with big windows that give a great view of the quaint street and patrons of Cabbage Town (which is enjoyable in itself). The food is consistently delicious (if they have the squash casserole, get it, it's AMAZING!!). I like how the menu has different sides every time you go. To explain, if you order the sirloin it comes with the "potato of the day", which could be hash browns or mashed potatoes, etc. It helps to keep the menu interesting in my opinion. The wine list is decent, but not that extensive, and I think it's better to buy the bottle because by the glass it's pricey! I also enjoy the brunch here, the bloody mary's are potent. This is a great date location though I suggest you get there some what early if you decide to go on a Friday or Saturday night because it's not a huge location and it will fill up.
(4)
Kim W.

Yes, they serve brunch, and it's awesome! Really good omelets. One of my favorite litle spots.
(3)
Three M.

When I used to live in Atlanta, the only time anyone would go to Cabbage Town was to try and find the guy selling dime bags. Now the area is brimming with cute little places to grab a drink or a nosh. Weird how 15 years will totally change a place. Anyway...Carroll Street is cute and artsy, with a full bar and a nice menu with yummy salads and sandwiches. I'm pretty sure they change their art installations monthly, and feature mainly local artists. I don't recall if they serve brunch, but sometimes a weekend lunch with a bloody mary is okay too. It seems like it would also be a nice place to have a mellow cocktail or 2 on a Friday night. The only negative - the staff was not so friendly. Not really mean, just not very warm. But if you're with good company - who cares? I would definitely go back.
(3)
Yinka T.

Nothing tickles my excitement better than satisfying brunch indulgence. Carroll was a good grub for a Sunday. Food: 4. I got the Benedict and managed to exceed my expectations. The dirty chai took it home but better top presentation next time. Service: 4. Attentive and pleasant. No long wait time past 10 mins. Ambience: 5. Pretty chic. Location is nice. Parking: They have comp valet about 250ft away. I'll be back.
(4)
Ebony H.

I had the Shrimp and Grits. It was amazing! Great portion shrimp seasoned and cooked perfectly. Staff was very attentive.
(5)
Monica G.

Was planning on having dinner at Agave, but the wait was an hour, so we decided to go to the nearest restaurant. And, I'm glad that we did! We ordered from their tapas menu and everything was delicious! We had the lamb sliders, shrimp, flank steak, scallops, pork belly and crab cakes. We also ordered their chocolate ganache, which was also very good. Oh, and their tapas are half off mon- thurs, from 3-7pm. The ambiance had a cool and relaxed vibe. The service was okay. They were attentive, but I kinda felt like the server wasn't very familiar with the menu. Parking is a pain but they do have complimentary valet.
(4)
Bianca N.

My friend suggest we go to this cafe near Krog street since we wanted brunch and I'm not from Atlanta. The cafe is cutely set up and the laidback atmosphere made my initial impression of this cafe positive at first. I ordered the Belgian Waffle dish and substituted eggs for potatoes. I have a sweet tooth that needed to be satisfied....and I was disappointed. The waffles were dry so there wasn't much flavor. The potatoes were cold as if they were cooked a while ago and just sat out for a while. Only delicious part of the dish was the pork sausage. I would give this place another try if I'm ever back in Atlanta but my brunch experience fell short of what I wanted.
(3)
Janet L.

I came with a party of 5 on a Saturday for brunch, and we were seated pretty quickly. It's a pretty cool, eclectic vibe. Parking is on street (although there might be free valet? Not sure)- but I had no issues finding a spot. I ordered the crab cake Benedict with the potatoes and sans fruit (mixed fruit generally has melon which I'm allergic to)... But I was kind of surprised when our waitress didn't offer me a substitute item. It didn't bug me too much. Generally, I wasn't too impressed. The meal was fine, but I expected it to be better than it was. I liked the crab cakes but my eggs were not poached well at all. One was completely overdone and one was half overdone. The potatoes were okay- compared to other really great brunch potatoes I've had before. The others in my group ordered either the bacon or sausage omelette. They said they were really good, so maybe I should have went with that instead. The atmosphere was fine with one exception- I found it way to loud to carry on conversation. Our waitress was good- polite, friendly, and prompt. Overall, I would come back if a friend wanted to or if I was in the area. I don't know that I'd go out of my way to come back.
(3)
Max M.

This place was a mixture. The Thai beef salad was OMG amazing -- literally the best salad I think I've ever eaten. A perfect blend of Asian and Italian elements. I will come back here a million times just for that. Just phenomenal. I was really glad (in a back-handed compliment kind of way) that nothing else on the menu looked appetizing enough for a reasonable price, so I was kind of forced to get the salad (and I never usually order a salad). On the other hand, the scallop appetizer was the worst scallop entree I think I've ever had. Normally when you order a scallop appetizer for that price, you expect them to be cooked to perfection. These were not. Almost tasted microwaved. The mushrooms that accompanied them were good though. And back to a compliment. The service by our server was really good. And I will definitely be back for that salad.
(3)
Tiffany B.

This place is tucked away on Caroll Street. I love how the area is a hidden laid back gem in the heart of the city. The restaurant is cozy. A good spot for happy hour or a date. Monday night is $5 on all Tapas. The wines were half off. I absolutely loved this and I ordered about 7 Tapas and the featured wine. Everything was cooked lovely. My favorite thing was the Caprese Salad and the Steak. So yummy. Still haven't sampled any entres but the wine was amazing. Dessert is worth trying too. Assorted cheesecakes and all. I must mention there is not a lot of parking options that are convenient but find one because its worth it!
(5)
Tesha H.

I love Love LOVE this place. The menu is so unexpected, but perfectly executed. Every time I go I'm never disappointed.
(5)
Jessica I.

I was in the area and it was pretty late. A few of my girl friends and I wanted to have something small to eat. We found this small strip by the Krog street tunnel. This place has some good vibes. It was kind of loud inside and dim lighting. The food was great. It tasted good, but a little pricey. I would love to come here again. It's a cute small place and they're open fairly late, which was nice.
(4)
Lisa C.

This place is INCREDIBLE! Amazing cocktails, tapas and entrees and reasonably priced! I had the portobello caprese and my dad had the gyro and we both cleaned our plates. If you come here you have got to ask for Kara! She's the sweetest and helped me pick out the perfect cocktail.
(5)
Domonic B.

Randomly met a friend here on her suggestion for lunch. I pass by this place often and have never noticed it. It's nestled on the very imfamous hell of a street called Carroll Street Cafe. If you have never been on Carroll Street, when you decide to visit you will see why i say this. I ordered the waffle platter which came with eggs, sausage of your choosing, a fruit bowl, and the waffle was also topped with fruit. The food came out surprisingly fast even tho the place wasn't that busy when we were there. The waffles topped with strawberries and blueberries were pretty good. The syrup accented them well. The best part of this meal in my opinion. It was of very good quality and was pretty decent size. I almost wish i had ordered another. The fruit bowl was a nice addition. It was a bowl of grapes and pineapples which I like a lot. The least enjoyable part of this meal was the eggs which were simply scrambled but had no flavor whatsoever. I added a bit of salt and pepper from the table to enjoy them. Overall the food was good and i'd order it again if i came here again. I'm big on service at places. I have worked in service jobs so I know that it can be overwhelming at times so i'm very patient also. As I said earlier, this place wasn't busy at all when we came for lunch. I must say that our server started out very well. He was very attentive and very informative about the menu but somewhere along the way he simply forgot about us. I had to get up to get straws for the table and my glass of water went unfilled for almost 30 minutes. It's like we had the Jekyll/Hyde of our server. It kind of baffled me. They have very delicious cake choices on display at the counter and I had my heart set on getting a slice of cake after finishing my entree. Between our server not checking on us I lost my taste for cake after my meal and then the cake slices(which aren't that big) being $6/slices....yeah...no bueno. I would've given this place 4 stars but the service definitely took a star away. The food is good but the service was definitely lacking. I hope lots of people don't have this experience here b/c this place has a lot of potential.
(3)
Jaycie H.

What a lovely place! We went for a late breakfast, there were probably 8 of us and they managed to get everything right and out in a speedy fashion. I had pork belly which was very well done. Everyone was happy with their food from what I could tell.
(5)
Judy S.

I will never grow tired of Carroll Street Cafe's delicious food and drinks. I ordered a Bloody Mary and their Chicken and Grits entre (which was cooked to perfection). The servers were friendly and attentive to all of their guests. Not only you will be satisfied with the food and service but also the setting of the cafÃ©. They change up their artwork every now and then which makes this cafÃ© so enjoyable. Every time I bring a friend to Carroll Street, it always wins the hearts of many.
(5)
Martha R.

Wowza, this place has good food! The service was lovely as well... she was attentive w/o being pesky, and offered to let me try out a couple of the wines before making a choice. What more can you want? The Malbec we chose was delicious and relatively cheap (around $30). The top choice of the things that we had: pork belly. Oh dear god, after falling in love w/ that stuff in Portland, I was happy to see it on the menu. Even happier to have it in my belly! The flank steak was also a top choice, perfectly cooked and slathered w/ garlic. Holy smokes, good thing the people I was hanging out w/ for the evening were going to have the same garlicky breath as I did! We had a couple appetizers, a few tapas, and one salad to split between 3 people. The other food stuffs that we had weren't really as wonderful as the two I mentioned, otherwise they could have hit the 5-star mark. So for $100, three people had one heck of a good meal. Highly suggest this place.
(4)
Tyler B.

This is a cute little restaurant that's located along a really lovely stretch of Cabbagetown. Five of us came here for a late dinner on Valentine's Day. The atmosphere is pretty romantic and it was clearly a popular spot that night. Even at 9:00, there was still a 45 minute wait. Our extended wait, however, allowed us to explore the area a little bit. There are several businesses along Carroll Street and we settled into a fun bar down the street to pass the time. It ended up working out really well and I wouldn't be disappointed if I came back and had to wait again. The atmosphere was perfect. I felt like I was in a really nice restaurant but it still maintained a down-to-earth, homey feel. We were able to sit right next to the window, which gave us a great view of the neighborhood's pretty houses across the street. Also, even though they were quite busy, the noise level was very reasonable for what's a pretty small, closely confined space. Overall, the food here is reasonably priced with entrees in the $20 range. They also had a list of pricier Valentine's Day specials, which I got sucked into ordering. For some reason, I was really, really craving some jambalaya and although it was really good, it wasn't worth $23. Sure, it was as good (or close to as good) as anything I've had in New Orleans but at more that twice the cost? No thank you. I had a bite of my friend's pasta, which was delicious and confirmed that I should have just stuck with their regular dishes.
(4)
Vanitha S.

Carroll Street Cafe will continue to be one of my favorite places in Atlanta. Though I've only been here for dessert the 3x I've been here, I'd vote that this is probably an awesome place for any meal of the day--whether it's brunch or dinner or coffee or wine or dessert. It's definitely hipster, divey and not-mainstream--lots of cool, colorful local art on the walls, flickering candles, deep soothing beats and friendly servers. Everyone just seems relaxed and happy here. I love the plush couch and coffee table that is always available that makes for a cozy intimate setting whether with friends or your loved one. They have some gluten free options (chocolate ganache-YUM!) and can substitute dairy milk for almond milk (chai tea latte-YUM!) which is a nice bonus.
(4)
Charity N.

Amazing!! You should come on Mondays its $5 Tapas and 1/2off on Tuesday. The foods is enough to get you really full if you buy 2 tapas. Amazing deserts too. Overall a very cool hippie vibe.
(5)
Jason D.

Great for brunch. Had the Benedict Scallop and the Crab cake Benedict. I like their jalapeno cheddar grits. And the bloody Mary hit the spot. Very chill. Atmosphere. Seems like the perfect place to escape and have food and drinks away from the daily grind.
(4)
Shawn F.

I really have nothing but great things to say about Carroll Street Cafe. I've been here twice already and both times have been excellent experiences. The first time I went was with my girlfriend for a late night dinner. We were looking on yelp for some good late night food close to GSU, and we came across here. It's in an interesting neighborhood, along a dark street at night and the parking is basically along the street or supposedly free valet a little bit further down the street. It's very quaint inside, dim lighting, candles, really has a homey feel to it. I like it. We ordered the steak sandwich and the seafood pasta. Both were excellent. The steak sandwich was cooked medium rare as ordered, the toppings and bread was tasty, along with the fries. The seafood pasta was delicious. A bit creamy and cheesy, but it was just what I wanted. There were mussels, shrimp, and salmon pieces. All were cooked just right and the pasta sauce was very flavorful. For dessert, we had the Tiramisu. It was delicious! Service was attentive and fairly friendly, nothing special. The second time we went, we got there pretty late at night and it was fairly busy, but no wait. We found a table inside and our server was somewhat of a ditz. She was just one of those awkward young servers that come and ask you stuff mid-bite and just has an awkward feel, but she was just ok. Had to flag her down a few times for water, the check, a to-go box, but it's whatever, the food was great. This time we ordered the penne ala vodka with chicken and the veggie wrap with chicken. The penne ala vodka was great, not as creamy as the seafood pasta we ordered last time but it was really tasty. There were pieces of bacon in the pasta too that added a great flavor. This was one of the better penne ala vodka's I've had in my life. The veggie wrap with chicken was delicious. We did not get desert this time, tempted to get the carrot cake, will have to try it next time. Overall, I love this place. They have a diverse menu, really anything you'd want to get, from filet mignon to a sandwich, pasta, chicken, small plates, they have something to cater to everyones palate. I understand it has a laid back friendly vibe, but I think the service needs a little bit improvement. I think the food is 5 Stars, but the service is 3 stars. So, I give this place a 4 stars, pretty darn good in my book.
(4)
Andy S.

This is a cool little spot in Cabbagetown. The staff was very friendly and the food was good. We went during Sunday brunch and I got the chicken cobb sandwich. Not sure this is the best name for it since it is essentially a bacon and avocado chicken sandwich. My girlfriend got the grilled chicken salad and she enjoyed it and the vinaigrette was tasty and light. I would recommend this place and will be returning soon. There is limited street parking but if you can't find something, there is complementary valet parking very nearby.
(4)
Nadim K.

Probably my favorite place in the downtown area of Atlanta. Their Tapas are delicious and leave space for their tasty cakes. The staff is very nice and the atmosphere is great. Lamb sliders, and the seared tuna are great.
(5)
Kisha M.

Delightful little spot off the beaten path. There were a few tables outside, but the inside dining room was pretty large. I loved the dimly lit room and unobtrusive tunes playing. Great spot for an intimate dinner. I had the fish special. It was really good. It was served with sauteed spinach and mashed potatoes. I cleaned my plate! They also had a dessert display that looked tasty, but we declined. Staff was super friendly. If I lived in the area I imagine I'd be there all the time.
(4)
Andy A.

The shrimp and grits are my favorite. I just wish the portions were a little larger. The service is excellent unless you are sitting at the bar. I think the place is a little pricey, though, and will prob push me next door to Cabbagetown pie more often.
(4)
Deborah G.

This place was quaint and eclectic! The atmosphere was welcoming and pleasing to the eyes and the food was fabulous. I had the Lobster omelette and it was full of lobster and great veggies and very flavorful! Definitely will be going back!
(5)
Linda V.

Service was great but food was okay compared toany of the brunch choices around town. We ordered the southwest omelet, belgium waffles, and shrimp & grits. Favorite dish was belgium waffles, it came with strawberries and blueberries not strawberries and bananas like the other yelp pictures. Least favorite was the shrimp and grits, do not get this dish here. You will be disappointed, shrimp tasted over salted and smokey which isn't a great combo for my taste buds. Grits were not creamy, the picture below tells it all. The southwest omelet was okay, nothing special. Fruit that came with the plate seemed a bit past the fresh stage.
(3)
Marvin B.

The food here is really good and flavorful. The service was great. The ambience has such character. This was a great first time experience. MOST OF ALL- there was NO WAIT. On a beautiful Sunday afternoon.
(4)
Andria C.

What an awesome little place. I really should go here more often. My most recent visit was for a friend's birthday dinner. It was a Thursday night, so it wasn't very busy. Most of the party was already seated when we arrived, so we just strolled in and sat down. The service here is always super friendly, albeit not the fastest. The food has never disappointed, whether it's Sunday brunch or a weeknight dinner. This spot is tiny, so don't be suprised if there is a bit of a wait during peak times. But no worries, because they have comfy couches. Parking can be a pain sometimes, but there is valet.
(4)
Kin N.

WHY?!?!? Why is this place located so close to my favorite restaurant? I'm going to have a tough decision when I come to this neighborhood. We arrived at 7:30 PM on a Saturday and the restaurant was almost empty (or was it slightly full?).....bad sign right? WRONG! Don't let it deceives you...they serve amazing food. Here is what we ordered: Lamb slider - Seriously good! Lamb is how it should taste like (yeah, gamey in a nice way), vegetable is fresh and crisp, and the tzatziki sauce just pairs so well with other ingredient. 4.5 Stars Empanada - Very good. Crispy crust with flavorful filling. You can't messed up a deep fried dough with meat filling, can you? That said, I rated this empanada among my top 3. 4 Stars Pizza - The menu changes daily and I don't remember the exact ingredients on mine. All I know is it's vegetarian, fresh, flavorful, and portion is huge for a tapas. 4 Stars Pork Belly with brandy sauce and flambeed peaches - fancy name for braised (?) pork belly with a sweet glaze and pieces cooked fruit. It's nice but every restaurant serves a similar dish in the past two years, and nothing sets this one apart from the pack. 3 Stars. Seafood Penne - I LOVE this dish. What makes it different from similar dishes at other places is the cream sauce. I could really taste the brininess and sweetness of seafood in the sauce. 5 Stars If you're a craft beer lover, they have about 15 kinds of bottle craft beers that we've never even heard of. We told our server what kind of popular beers we like and she did a phenomenal job of recommending a beer for us. Server's knowledge about beer - 5 Stars Just a side note: The menu says they serve tapas....well, it's not really "Tapas". Most of it was merely smaller portion of American food. Overall, it was a fantastic meal and I can't wait to come back. Just wish it wasn't located down the street from my favorite restaurant.
(4)
Oliver F.

Nice coffee shop atmosphere with a wide variety of breakfast foods to burgers/sandwiches/salads/noodle dishes, and my favorite: the seafood. Seafood Penne is amazing. Would def get it every time but I've been trying to branch out. Not to say the other dishes are not good, they're also great, but the Seafood Penne is just on another level. The only con, which it barely is one, one time I went with my boss on our lunch break and he got a completely different dish than he ordered. He ended up loving it (the Blackened Chicken Sandwich) and on top of that they axed our bill in half for the mistake. The cafe is never too crowded for lunch either. They also have daily lunch specials that typically aren't on the menu which are actually a pretty good deal. I've only been for lunch but I imagine dinner is just as good. Would definitely recommend.
(5)
Dbaby A.

Favorite chill spot for the hubby and I. The service is great & the food is great. We always get the salmon ciabatta its awesomeeee lol
(5)
Michelle K.

Visited this lovely cafe in Cabbage Town to have lunch with a friend for her birthday. I really wished, I'd visited them sooner because their food was quite delicious. You can't help but notice the coziness of the restaurant when you walk in. It certainly has that neighborhood field but open space so you don't feel claustrophobic. The wait staff was super pleasant. I just wished our server would stop by our table more often to refill my water glass. I had to ask at the very end when I received my check and was still quite thirsty but wasn't in the mood to get up and look for our server. Their brie appetizer is the best I've had so far in ATL. I love how they melt the brie in the phylo and serve it with lightly toasted french baguette pieces. Loved the entire experience and will definitely return for future visits with friends and family.
(4)
Rachel M.

Sophia (or Sophie), I am writing a review about you! Sophia was a great waitress. She explained from the beginning that they were short staffed and things may take longer than usual. They didn't! She suggested an amazing cocktail and upsold me into the salmon for my salad... both were fantastic! (Pear & gorganzola salad, trust Sophia. Add the salmon.) Beyond just a great, upbeat wait staff with incredible insight into the menu, the desserts were divine, the ambience was chill and relaxed. The music was a bit loud for large parties to talk, but overall great place. Great after hours spot. I'll be going back again!
(5)
Jack R.

Great place with a neighborhood vibe. Always good food, great happy hour deal on tapas, and brunch runs pretty late for us slugabeds. The sidewalk tables are wonderful for observing the Cabbagetown scene. Last time we were there we ended up at three different tables with old and new friends.
(4)
Emiene W.

Scallops and mushrooms, heavenly. Pork belly, delightfully savory with peach counterpoint. Churrasco was tasty but not special. Overall not too shabby at all. The vibe is like black Key West, without the black folks but still friendly.
(4)
Karen F.

Great little indie place. It's open late and I've been here a couple of times and never disappoints. Very good vibe, it has an indie / hipster type of vibe. The hot chocolate with soy milk is awesome and for food I recommend the gyro with feta cheese. The salads are all really good and healthy too. Very pleased with this little cafe, the staff is very friendly and the area is clever too.
(5)
Jess B.

I love their Crab Cakes Eggs Benedict, but decided to try their Huevos Rancheros. Big mistake, as it was boring and didn't come with the guacamole the menu promised. As long as you avoid that mess, this is a great restaurant. Friend got the California Cobb sandwich and loved it.
(4)
Shayna P.

Can I give a 5 for ambience, a 4 for service and a 3 for food? I've been wanting to come here for a while. It's really, really cute. Very Cabbagetown. It's intimate and little hipster and eclectic. It has tables outside and great window seats inside and very nice low lighting. I just really like it here. I could settle in for a long, long while. I went with a friend on a Friday night at 7. We got a table immediately, which was a nice surprise. We both ordered the veggie burger. It came with fries and a side salad. The side salad was a side salad. The fries were really good and perfectly crispy. I did not like the veggie burger itself. It was very bland and overcooked. It had taken on some of the characteristics of a hockey puck. There are so many good veggie burgers out there, but this tasted like it came out of a box from Trader Joe's. Bummer. It was on a nice onion roll though. The service was very attentive. The waitress consistently refilled our water glasses and brought everything out in a timely manner. I'd say move than satisfactory. I REALLY want to like the food here. I could use another neighborhood spot, and this one is just so cozy. I've heard good things about breakfast, so I'll have to give that a try.
(4)
Christina L.

This is one of my to go to places, so cute and I have always loved what they have served me. Also they have daily tapas specials that are awesome. Yummy and if you like to hang out at the bar its fun and happening as well!
(5)
Ashaleigh R.

I loveeeee Carroll Street Cafe! I've had Sunday brunch here 2 months straight! The fried chicken breast and the jalapeno grits are the best! No questions asked, I'm going back!
(5)
Ken W.

The only reason it's not a 5 star is due to the semi-moody staff. Great atmosphere, food, location with a hip crowd! Food is AMAZING!!! Surly wait staff more interested in their own fashion statement and/or what to do after work needs to go. Shrimp and Grits is OMG good!!!
(4)
Audrey A.

I GOT MY CAR BROKEN INTO!!! The restaurant is so adorable, very hipster -esque, but I paralleled parked my car just a few sidewalks down from the restaurant and within about 1 and half hours, someone smashed into my passenger window and took my belongings. Now, I know the restaurant isn't at fault for this, but you would think the area was nice considering the nice lit road and the neighborhood across the restaurant, but nope.... Love the food, enjoyed the atmosphere of the place, but BE CAREFUL parking your car and storing away your belongings!!!
(4)
Essence B.

I live in Indianapolis, but I will never into the state of Atlanta without stopping here for their salmon dishes.
(5)
Marla C.

We ended up here after getting tired of waiting in line at the nearby Thumbs Up Diner. We were hangry, having waiting longer than we should've to eat, so getting seated here immediately was a nice treat. It was a beautiful day, so we opted for one of the sidewalk tables, which was great for people watching and getting to chat with all the cute dogs and babies that cruised by on their afternoon walks. There was also a super friendly black cat who hung out with us for a while. But I digress... The service was friendly and attentive, but not at all overbearing. We ordered bloody marys to start (excellent) and then followed up with a house specialty cocktail called the Blackberry Leaf, which was extraordinary. So refreshing and flavorful. YUM! My brunch mates had the shrimp and grits and sausage omlette--both of which they raved about (their chicken sausage is soooooooooo good), and I had the chicken and grits. Oh. My. God. The jalepeno cheese grits made my eyes roll back in my head with their savory goodness. Wowzah. And the fried chicken was a rationally-sized portion that was crispy and flavorful. I ordered mine with scrambled eggs and a biscuit on the side--all good. This place is a gem--cool and lovely without being stuffy. Loved the vibe and will DEFINITELY be coming back the next time I'm in Atlanta.
(5)
Wes M.

Apparently I looked too employed to be served. If only I wore my striped sweater, maybe then could I have eaten lunch. Wah wah. After being stared at by all of the skinny-jeaned patrons and ignored by the bar and wait staff for 10 minutes, we just left. Sadly, even though we just moved into the neighborhood and would likely have been regulars, we won't be going back.
(1)
David B.

Damn good food, friendly staff, awesome environment, dog friendly. I love Carroll st. CafÃ©s food. Kind and polite service, they make sure my dog is also taken care of via water. Grateful to have a restaurant like this in town. Well managed, clean, and great place...overall A+
(5)
Juan M.

It's nice. We most recently went on a warm winter Sunday (the kind that people who live outside of the South experience and then decide that they want to live in Atlanta). I don't even remember what we ordered but it was good - yes, it is kinda hipster, but it was fine. One thing I DO remember is that they serve cafecito cubano (and even call it something similar to that). I was bleary eyed that morning and it was helpful to get me moving again.
(4)
Lauren S.

Cool local hangout. Cross between a french bistro, a boulangerie, and Cheers. Unassuming scale atmosphere with nice mood lighting and stellar food. The dessert case is just as stocked as Intermezzo's. Great service, too.
(5)
Brett W.

We live just down the street in Grant Park and decided to try this as a possible new go to brunch spot on a rainy summer Sunday. We were very happy with our decision! Parking in that area of Cabbagetown is also a little tricky, but Carroll Street's valet parking made it simple. For noon on a Sunday, we thought we would have to wait for a table, but we were able to find a seat quickly. The place was busy but not too packed. Our server was friendly and prompt through the meal - never felt like we had to wait long for drinks and food. Loved the comfortable cafe vibe. Food was very yummy! I had the shrimp frittata and it was loaded with shrimp. We ordered the honey brie croissant to share and it did not disappoint! My husband enjoyed his fried chicken and grits immensely. Overall, the good was solid and we enjoyed every bite. My mimosa was just the right size and my husband's rum punch reminded us exactly of the drinks we had in Jamaica on out honeymoon. Overall, it was a great first experience at Carroll Street and we are already planning to go back soon and try out a weeknight dinner special!
(4)
Alex D.

This is a very interesting spot. Located in cabbage town, which means some parts of the area are a but scary. Parking and navigating the tight road it's on made it hard for us to find or even get to a parking space. My steak was ok, ordered medium. Nothing too special really. The vegetables and mashed potatoes were tremendous though. My date had the seafood pasta which looked delicious and was delicious. Overall the service and steak were pretty fair, however the price was really good for the quality of food and the very quick service we received.
(4)
Molli V.

Service here is TERRIBLE! Servers here put no effort into providing a good dining experience. Our server literally came by when we finished eating, picked up our plates and walked away without asking us how it was, or if we needed the check, or even acknowledge that she was serving us. Me and my bf are the easiest people to serve and we are always super nice so it wasn't anything towards us, they're just horrible at customer service. And I've given them far too many chances (it's in the neighborhood, convenient for when I want just a salad.. I always think the next visit is gonna be better and that the previous experience was just a fluke). The Thai salad is garbage on a plate. It's nothing but lettuce stems and the beef is ALWAYS overcooked. The dressing used to be different but they changed it to some thick non vinegarette. The menu says served with a chili vinegarette, but don't try to point that out to them because the server will say that that thick orange dressing IS a vinegarette. Oh, and my bf saw a cockroach crawl across a table.
(1)
Arian G.

A nice neighborhood bar and restaurant, with a decent beer selection and a better wine selection. Also an espresso machine, if you're into the whole caffeine thing. Warning though- no beers on tap, bottles and cans only. The food is well prepared and varied, although I pretty much always get the Tomato Montrechet. If you do, order an extra baguette.
(4)
Emma G.

Adorable neighborhood joint with seriously mediocre food.
(2)
Nancy R.

I give this place a 3.5. This small, quaint eatery is located on a small street in Cabbagetown. Not the easiest place to find nor is finding street parking. FOOD: They have tapas and entrees, but I just got dessert with coffee. Good coffee and great dessert selections! I got the peanut butter with chocolate cake, yummy! My friend got the decadent white chocolate cheesecake. I would definitely come back to try their food.
(3)
Nic K.

I wish I could divide the ratings between food and service....or at least give half stars. Because this place is more of a 3.5. I met a large group for brunch since this is the favorite restaurant of one of the people in our party who was celebrating a birthday. I think I expected more in terms of food. I wasn't very impressed. I had the Huevos Rancheros which I found to be pretty bland. My husband wasn't too impressed with his meal either. Service, on the other hand, was impressive. Everyone was super nice and accommodating. We had a very large group, and they didn't even bat an eye when I told them how many people would be showing up. They quickly sectioned off a few tables for us and then sweetly led us to our section. The waitress was also very nice and bubbly.
(3)
Andi G.

My home away from home, these girls have my heart. Tarik will take good care of you at the bar, great dessert destination, rotating selection of cakes, pastries, and pies in the dessert case.
(5)
D.L H.

Always consistent. My favorites are, Curry Chicken and the empanadas. The hiring practices here are what is the most obvious thing here. If you like looking at good looking hipster chicks, well you have come to the right place. If you are a male, don't bother applying for the front of the house--unless you can pull off a good hipster drag look. Avoid the small portion of flank steak, unless you just want a tiny portion to snack on. Other than that this is a safe bet for a decent 31/2 star meal.
(4)
Gigi C.

I don't know where to start. I sat at the bar and was not acknowledge for 3 minutes. Until she said she will be with me after she finished making mimosas. While doing this she decide to have dialog with another customer. I decide to ask I assume the manger if I could sit at a table to get better service. He just says the same thing. It's been 5 minutes now. I get a 2 top in Sophia's section. Woohoo she is on it. Since I sat at the bar for so long I had plenty of time to memorize the brunch menu. I ordered the crab cake Benedict, eggs fried hard. Hard I say! The food appears looking very yummy. I taste the crab cake hmmm it's ok kinda low on temperature. The potatoes could use another 30 seconds in the microwave. I cut into my so fried hard egg and its runny. Really. I inform Sophia and she is on the task of getting me a friend egg. Yes, the fried hard egg arrives only to be as runny as the firsts. The food temp was not up to standard but I thought I could work thru it. I could not get it down. Aight horrible. But my waitress was a sweetheart. Not sure if I will try dinner at another time. It was a waste of money. 2 starts for the small attempt.
(2)
Rachel P.

In a city full of great brunch spots, this one just didn't stand out for me. It was pretty mediocre. I had the pork sausage omelette with red pepper, goat cheese, and basil and it was pretty good. The grits were alright and the biscuit didn't taste fresh. My partner had eggs meurette and the two poached eggs were overcooked. His plate was watery and his biscuit was hard. The potatoes were cold and raw in the middle. We ordered a chocolate croissant to give them a chance to redeem themselves and it really seemed microwaved. You know when you microwave a flaky pastry and it gets all soft and spongy? Yeah, that. Idk, maybe we will go back and try the tapas. But brunch was not super, at least for us. To be fair, it was a cute atmosphere and the server was nice and efficient.
(3)
Brittany M.

My friend and I had our joint birthday brunch here last week. I was very excited to go here since my favorite place: Carpe' Diem closed in downtown Decatur. The same people that owned that, owns Carroll St! Well they definitely didn't disappoint! I had a cappuccino, can't remember the specific name but it had brown sugar in it. Our waitress recommended it because I told her I want something sweet. It was great, didn't need any extra sugar or anything! At Carpe' I was absolutely in LOVE with the Shrimp and Grits with a side of potatoes. So I was more than ecstatic to see they had both on the menu at Carroll, only here the grits were like jalapeno cheese. I crossed my fingers in hopes to get the same magic that I got at Carpe'. I DID! The blackened shrimp was perfect and the grits had just the right amount of kick! And the potatoes with a mix of peppers and onions were everything too! The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because parking was no picnic. They do have complimentary valet parking not too far from the place, but of course after the majority of my party circled the perimeter and ended up parking a block and a half away, the guy drags the sign out notifying everyone of the parking smh. But I digress. I'll definitely be back!
(4)
Gillian R.

I met a friend here for dinner and drinks. It was mid-week and rainy outside, so it was a bit quiet, which was just what we were looking for. This place is so cozy! There were candles and flowers on the table, bench seats with pillows, a big comfy couch, and a nice standard bar. There was even a candle lit in the bathroom, which smelled heavenly. Yes, I just said that the bathroom smelled heavenly. This coming from someone who prefers to avoid public restrooms at all costs! Tapas are half off Tuesday through Thursday, which is a major score! I had an awesome veggie pizza for $4.50, she had crab cakes. I'd love to try a few more things here, because there was plenty that looked awesome on the menu, but my pizza was also more than enough to fill me up! And let's be real, I'm a bottomless pit when it comes to pizza. Classic martinis are $5 on Tuesdays, so I had a dirty martini and a beer. In total, my entire check for a pizza and two drinks: $15. Can't beat that! Our server, Tarik, was friendly and funny, there when we needed her and gone when we were deep in conversation. And she kept my water glass full, which was highly necessary given that mid-week drinks often lead to a mid-week hangover for me. They didn't this time, and I owe it all to Tarik for that! I am already planning my next trip here. You'd better believe I'll be back.
(4)
Rob F.

The Thai Beef salad was great. Friendly service. Great atmosphere. Wife got the veggie wrap and liked it.
(4)
Lesly W.

Perfect date night and favorite dinner spot to go to with my boyfriend! Come here at night and you'll get candle lighting at every table or sit outside to greet friendly neighbors walking by and to check out beautiful French and Spanish influenced architecture of nearby houses. Even the bathroom is candle light only adding on the ambiance of this amazing place. The steamed mussels are great for an appetizer and filled with so much flavor and the Seafood Penne' is my go to. This place is also a perfect spot for getting a drink or two with a friend. Come here for brunch and you'll get a different vibe! Huge windows letting in so much natural lighting and there is rarely a wait during brunch.Their Iced Chai Tea is one of my favorites in the city and pastries are amazing! Staff is always super friendly, wear the cutest outfits, and knowledgeable about the menu. Carroll Street is small, quaint and peaceful place that is a little gem in the city. Something about this place makes me feel so happy!
(5)
Erica P.

Very quaint little spot, kind of a hipster spot, interesting decor, had a delicious breakfast there when in town for the weekend. Cool menu, everything was delicious, especially the breakfast potatoes.
(4)
Thuy An H.

Went here for brunch because I saw good reviews on Yelps; however, I will not make a trip back to Carroll Street CafÃ©. The food to me was mediocre - eggs were "bleh" and waffles were hard and dry.
(2)
Bob N.

They actually are open earlier than posted on yelp. Omelet are great and love the coffe. Very pleasant atmosphere.
(5)
Hoho M.

Nice cozy spot with great drink and tapas specials. The ambiance is great at night & the waitresses are usually quick and courteous. Oh, and their weekend brunch food (omelettes, lox & bagel, steak & eggs, specials) is amazing!
(5)
Atiyah T.

Now if you ever lived in Brooklyn New York, this spot captures that essence. It's a cool, hipster type cafe with great food. Now since I'm newly resident of Atlanta, finding this place was sketchy so I had all thoughts going through my head on my way here. But the food and service made up for the worries... Carroll Cafe has a unique intimate, friendly atmosphere. And the food is great.
(4)
T B.

Loved the ambience but I was not completely satisfied with my meal. Went for a late lunch with a friend who lives in Cabbagetown. She ordered the Cobb Sandwhich. I ordered the Cobb Salad. Her meal looked delicious while my salad seriously looked like a side salad. I honestly could get a better salad at any other restaurant for $13. I left lunch hungry. I'm giving 3 stars because I would probably give them another try in the future. Just don't order the Cobb Salad.
(3)
Justin R.

Located in a quaint neighborhood, this eclectic restaurant has great out doors seating, but I wouldn't pass up on sitting inside either, as it is equally well adorned and visually stimulating as the view outside. The wait staff was great, service was great, and they were fairly busy, personally that's when I find service counts the most as a customer. The menu is diverse, lots of surf and turf with a few vegetarian dishes. Almost immediately the menu items that stuck out to me were the tapas. Not to downplay the rest of their offerings but this seemed to be the focal point for my taste. I ordered the flak steak with chimmichuri, which was season and prepared to perfect juicy morsels that my dog who we brought with us, probably would have murdered me to steal. My other dish was the seared tuna with white beans, also quite well prepared. Seared tuna is one of those dishes that is simple but easy to verkakte. The tuna was cooked and seasoned all to a light, taste worthy mouthful of paradise, compliment only further by the bed of beans. We also ordered a veggie burger which was amazing, it came with a side salad which I would say was slightly wilted and didn't seem as fresh as it could have, but it was a minor detail. As an appetizer we ordered the cheese plate, I guess you would ask, why I didn't start in consequential order, and mostly it's because I was least impressed with the quality of the dish. The cheese was served slightly warm as if it had been sitting out for too long, cut into hunks and adorned with a splotch of wilted lettuce and fruit, reminiscent of something I could have found at a much more cost effective establishment. It just felt rushed and a lot of short cuts were taken with the cheese plate, which IMHO is equal parts presentation and food. All-in-all great service, tapas, and entrees, and if you are in the ATL, I would recommend stopping by this neighborhood cafe.
(4)
Kyle H.

Carnivors delight, you can bring you vegetarian friends, but the veggies are salted (yay).
(4)
John C.

Saturday night the drunken manager at Carroll St. CafÃ© told me I was a douche bag and an asshole and then groped me at the bar. Apparently I'm a douche bag and an asshole because I get too drunk or too loud or opinionated or obnoxious or whatever at their bar. Or maybe it's the thousands of dollars I've spent on their mediocre food over the years or the fat tips I always leave that has them hot and bothered. It's not feedback I've ever received at any other establishment - although I'd be the first to admit I get a tad unruly when very drunk. I don't feel people up at the bar, though. I'm good friends with some of the staff that used to work there, but I dunno, man... I don't think I'm ever gonna go back.
(1)
Johnny W.

Cute place. The neighborhood sucks for parking and driving with the small streets. But sure to get there early because it is always crowded. I think the brunch menu ha a good selection but might be a little over priced for the quality. I would go again though because I was overall happy with my visit.
(3)
John C.

Are you fn kidding me? For 8 bucks you get 2 jalapeÃ±o poppers. 2 ! Wtf? And they came out kinda cold. Ok, well, we got the check after the server asked us about the jalapeÃ±o left on the plate, she didn't charge us for it. So, I can't really complain. Lol. I just won't order that again
(3)
Shawn W.

This review is based on a Monday $5 tapes. $16 bottle white or red. $3 beer special. Awesome dinner.b
(5)
Joseph W.

Fantastic food. NiÃ§oise salad went down very easily. Tuna was top quality as well. The lady had the scallops and mushrooms, perfectly done. The appetizers we ate, the portabello caprese and papas atomicas were equally as tasty. We will be back anytime we visit ATL.
(4)
Quentin J.

The house white, Viura/Verdejo, Fuente Milano, is an inoffensive, straightforward wine w fruit notes and clean lingering finish. Not to dry not to fruity. Good balance makes for a good standard. At $5 it's no brainier. Their food is next on the agenda. Will report back.
(4)
Mark W.

So lucky to have Carroll Street as my neighborhood bar. Amazing staff, delicious drinks, great vibe. Try the turkey burger and huevos rancheros.
(5)
Dan I.

I love this place. I come here with some friends a few times a week. It's got a quiet, intimate atmosphere that really appeals to me and I find the whole Cabbagetown aesthetic to be really charming. It looks like if someone tried to gentrify the apocalypse. The desserts are amazing. I recommend Midnight Express or the chocolate truffle cake. The staff can seem surly but they become nicer once you get to know them better.
(5)
Nissa E.

ok i'm totally caught off guard - as many times as i've been to Carroll Street Cafe, i have NOT reviewed it. *gasp* ok so love the atmosphere and my fave breakfast item is the french toast with fruit, no syrup necessary. trust me. i also like the shrimp and grits - and the bagels and lox...well heck i like pretty much the whole breakfast/brunch menu! And the bar is superb! GREAT brunch for a lazy Sunday! I've never done dinner or a during the week meal there so i can't speak for that. One of my girlfriends and I do an insane Saturday walk from Grant Park and end up all over Atlanta including the Cabbage Town area. So this is a stop off point either on the way to our multiple destinations OR on the way back to the car. Anyway - EAT here!!!
(4)
lisa b.

food is 4 star, service is zero. I love the menu, but some of the staff is very unfriendly and sometimes downright rude. aprÃ¨s diem has the service aspect down, so I'd much rather dine there even though Caroll street is right round the corner from me.
(2)
Apearl C.

I really like this spot. It is a combination of a cafe, bar, and lounge. The vibe is nice, staff is friendly, and food is good. I loved the mixture of the crowd as well. I went for lunch, but will try it for dinner next time.
(4)
Leslie W.

One of my favorites. ~The Food~ I can't get enough of the Salad Nicoise. Caroll Street Cafe's version is full of unexpected delights. The tuna is sashimi-grade, seared and Panko-breaded -- yum! The garnishes are lovely and include two substantial yet delicate Panko-crusted potato cakes, a smattering of sushi rice, capers, pepperoncini peppers, and cucumbers. The requisite tomatoes and and hard boiled eggs are included, and you can get it with or without anchovies (though I recommend them). On a Monday night, I skip the Salad Nicoise to enjoy $5 tapas. Since their normal tapas prices range from $8-11, this is a great deal. Bring a friend and sample several while enjoying the accompanying Monday night beer or wine special. ~Atmosphere~ The patrons are mostly hip Cabbagetowners. The lighting is dim. The candles are lit every evening. It's crowded enough to generate a low din but quiet enough to carry on an intimate conversation. All in all, a romantic place that rides the line between casual and upscale. ~Parking~ If you know the neighborhood (or have a little patience), free curbside parking can be found on Carroll Street as well as on nearby Reinhardt or Pickett . But Cabbagetown is a neighborhood of narrow, one-way streets, so if hunting for a spot irritates you, take advantage of the complementary valet parking available nights and weekends.
(4)
Zewditu D.

I have been here a couple times for brunch as my boyfriend loves it. There is limited outdoor seating, but we have been lucky and gotten it every time. Nice atmosphere. Parking is available along the street, but it is frequently packed. It is located along a narrow street that doesn't really accommodate two-way traffic. The omelettes are alright. I like that they give you an ample amount of fruit. The breakfast sandwich is also alright.
(3)
Sarah M.

Two words, eggs benedict. This is by far my favorite place to eat in Atlanta. Sunday morning brunch, if I'm in town, you'll see me there. The service is always impeccable, and sitting outside is always a treat, but it's generally hard to snag a seat. Their dinner menu is just as good as their breakfast/brunch. Tucked away in Cabbage town, down a strangled (should be one way) road is this fine jewel of Atlanta. Be on the lookout for Catlanta, he frequents the area.
(5)
Chinika T.

After doing a quick Yelp search for the site of our team lunch, I discovered this place. Many good reviews and a fairly close drive to our office made this the right choice. After having an indecisive moment reviewing the menu I settled on the Betty (turkey sandwich with bacon). I'm not a fan of cold sandwiches but the waiter had it heated for me. Its the small things that make for good service for me. My team mates opted for the salmon on ciabatta, chicken sandwiches, and basil noodle bowl. We all enjoyed our meals and will be making a return trip. To think I've been driving within a block of this place for nearly six years and did not know it existed.
(4)
Nekiba M.

I came here with a group of friends after passing two other restaurants. We all agree this look like a cool place to go for dinner on a Sunday so we ended up here. Great decision. The waitress and other staff was friendly and accomdating given the size of our party and not all of us were there. The inside is totally hipster with an eclatic array of paintings along the wall with low lighting but not took dark. We were seated on the bar side very narrow. I didn't realize until later there was a bigger area on the other side of bar. No big deal there was plenty of room for our party. Concerning the food, I give credit to the pictures posted here because nobody couldn't decide on what to order since this was our first time there. A friend of mine and myself looked through the photos and decided to order the seafood penne pasta. The seafood penne included salmon, shrimp, mussels, cilantro, basil topped with a lobster cream sause. Others odered the thai beef salad and the filet mignon. When the food came out and our mouths watered, the food looked so good. It taste good also because all talking ceased once we started eating. The seafood penne was good, it lacked a bit of salt but not much. The show thai beef salad looked really good so I have to try that. The filet mignon was cooked medium rare and tender. That's on my list to to try. The waitress was nice and they had no problem splitting the check. I'll be back again to try the filet mignon, thai beef, and to see how their nacoisse salad is.
(4)
J L.

Carrol Street Cafe beats the pants off of neighboring fine-dining. I can hardly express the joy I've felt while eating here. I've been to Carrol St. twice, now. Once for dinner, and once for brunch. Both were wonderful. The space is intimate and charming. I find that their food is prepared as thoughtfully as much "nicer", hyped up restaurants. G and I have had great servers each time we've eaten here. On our first date, he raved about their pastries, coffees and more. At the time, I was surprised that they had so much more to offer out of a little one-way street cafe. For dinner, G had the curry-basil chicken, which definitely topped my sashimi tuna steak, although I found it to be delicious. We happened to dine on a Tuesday, where we had the pleasure of one too many $5 martinis on their sidewalk patio. Don't be a bummer. We were walking. Again, the service was strong, as well as the presentation and taste of food. At brunch, just yesterday, we shared a chocolate croissant with our "chocochino" coffees, and ordered entrees that might certainly be on my "best-of-brunch" list. Prior to our Sunday brunch, we had been looking for Saturday brunch spots, and sadly, there are so very few. Count on Carrol St., they serve brunch on Saturday and Sunday! G had the Huevos Rancheros, which were served on tortillas with eggs, beans... the whole 9 yards. I had the Egg Meurette which, as described on the menu: "Two poached eggs over sauteed spinach and tomato, covered in a port-bacon demi-glaze, served with a biscuit." I mean holy crap y'all. Who thought that I would keel over for some sauteed spinach and tomatoes literally in a light garlic/butter/salt n' peppa combination. Easy? Probably. Delicious? I was sopping up the juice with the biscuit. Dare I say that the grits were far superior to Flying Biscuit's? I dare.
(5)
Zenoni A.

Tucked away on a small street near Oakland Cemetery, I love the cozy neighborhood feeling of this place. I went here for Saturday morning brunch around 11:30 expecting a struggle to park and a long wait to be seated, but surprisingly found neither. Carroll Street Cafe has complimentary valet parking about 50 feet down the street from the Cafe, which takes care of a potentially huge stress factor in the whole experience. The ambience inside is defined by the dark wooden floors and benches and the lull of chatter around you. On a slower, rainy day, I'd love to spend a long time here reading while slowly working my way through a meal. I appreciated that they weren't blasting music on top of everyone trying to converse, so you can actually hear the people you're with, or just sit here by yourself and read a book. The server and the patrons were really relaxed, and it was nice to see that among the couples and groups, there were a few people here on their own for a hearty Saturday morning breakfast. As to the breakfast foods, the portions are all huge, and they're pretty easygoing about changing things up for you a bit. I was with a friend who didn't want the whole Lox Platter, but just a side of salmon and goat cheese. The waitress didn't even blink an eye before saying it was no problem. I've had the shrimp and grits here as well as the crab cakes eggs benedict, both of which were mediocre. Their pretty standard combinations are made to be good or slightly better than good. There's nothing in their flavor combinations that really jumps out the way it needs to for a dish to pop, it all just kind of blends together. I would still like to go back and try their sandwiches just to see if they're a better pick. All in all, a relaxing place to have a conversation over a good meal.
(3)
Robert M.

The seared tuna entree was the best I've ever had! This cafe came highly recommended and it did not disappoint. We walked about a mile from our Bed and Breakfast in Inman Park enjoying the graffiti at along the way. Overall it was a pleasant experience.
(5)
Lindsay H.

I live across the street and every time we eat here we are impressed!! The price is more than reasonable, the portions are large and the food is really good! Breakfast is my favorite, their eggs benedict is amazing! You def need to check this place out if you are ever in the area!
(4)
Leanne E.

Awesome Saturday brunch. I ordered the Almond Brie to start, which was so good and cheesy, with a touch of honey and almond. Delish! I chose the shrimp frittata for my meal and it was excellent and made with fresh ingredients. I am pleased that this place took a bit of time to prepare it right. I will be back!
(4)
Juichia C.

Too be honest, the vibe is a bit too hipsterish for me. But this review isn't about the vibe, of course. The veggie omelette I had was very good, fresh and plentiful veggies. The sides were just okay, in fact, the fruits were surprisingly not fresh. Coffee is okay. The tapas here are hit or miss. Good service though! I would come back because it is now the closest cafe to my place, and I will probably just stick to the brunch menu here.
(3)
Leah D.

Walking down the narrow street lined with cars on both sides you can feel the atmosphere that is this sweet area of Atlanta known as Edgewood. It is a long walk since Carol Street Cafe does not have a lot but on a nice night, you can peak into the windows of tattoo parlors and cute shops. Nestled between silk curtain and a window view we were happy to people watch the hipsters that passed smoking their American Signature cigarettes. Tom, the self proclaimed man that "ran the place" stood at the bar and carefully watched the scene all night and spoke only when spoken to. Death Cab for Cutie played in the background and local artists line the walls. The atmosphere of Carol Street Cafe has to be why it was chosen on our list because it certainly wasn't my entree. We ordered our drinks, which were poured with a heavy hand and we quickly realized that this would be a single bottle of wine evening. Our appetizer was the baked brie, served with tart apple. After our stiff cocktails, the brie smelled and tasted delicious. The five of us ladies quickly ordered and enjoyed our conversations too loudly. My dish was a trout served with zucchini in a spicy caper tomato sauce. It was presented very well and the fish was a nice portion. The flavors just didn't match each other and left me with a weird after-taste. It was not hard to decide that I would not only be unable to finish the dish but would never order it again. On the other hand, every other dish at the table seemed to be much tastier than mine. The server recommended the Basil Noodle Bowl and after tasting it, was so much more disappointed in my trout. Another lady in my group had the mussels and somehow I couldn't resist dipping the remainder of our Brie bread into her juice from the mussels. Out of the five entrees at our table, two were significantly better than the others. All was right again in the world once we had the chocolate truffle cheesecake. It was devoured with five forks like it was fat free bacon. The inconsistency of the entrees really bothered me, along with the nonchalant manner of Tom. Maybe Edgewood just isn't my "scene".
(2)
Ashleigh P.

On a whim (okay... because Thumb's Up dinner was stacked with people waiting) I went here with 2 friends on Saturday for Brunch. Such a very awesome bit of providence... Let me tell you the slightly not awesome part(s) first Hipster Haven fo sho... Parking is not the easiest. My strawberries were cut on the same board the onions were... yep. Awesome sauce follows I got the French Toast. Creme Anglaise and smothered in strawberries (slightly flavored with onion), bananas and blackberries (you read me right, BLACKBERRIES!!!) So So SO SOOSOSOSOSOSOS nomnomnomMOMNOMNOMNOM really The coffee was better than good, our waitress was helpful, I have this friend who hates eggs, but loves eggs Benedict... for realsies. The waitress worked with her to get her the breakfast she wanted. It was a little chilly in there as well. We will be back
(5)
Joe L.

The breakfast here here is alright. The food is good, but priced just a tiny bit higher than other breakfast places I have been to. I came here on a sleepy Saturday to get some brunch and take advantage of a groupon I got a while back. I got the Italian Sausage omelet with house potatoes and a biscuit, a slice of their midnight cake and a chai latte. And yes I ate ALL of it by myself. Italian Sausage Omelet: Well made with real eggs and not the stuff in containers. It was light and fluffy, with no browning on the top (indicating to me that it was properly cooked). It was filled with Italian sausages and peppers. The peppers were diced, but I felt that they weren't sautÃ©ed enough. They still kind of had a crispness to them which made it hard to cut through them in the omelet. House Potatoes: Really good. The potatoes are cut into thick slices and pan fried with strips of peppers. Delicious. properly seasoned too. I wish the peppers that came with this came with the omelet. Biscuit: was alright. I usually judge a biscuit based on how good it tastes both by itself and with the accompanying jam. The biscuit here did not stand out. The midnight cakes: moist, chocolaty, but a little too sweet. Also, 6 dollars for a slice of cake is a little outrageous. Ok, not just a little, very outrageous. Chai Tea: very very good here. Don't really know what else to say. It wasn't overwhelmingly sweet like most other chai latte's that I have had. Overall, the brunch dishes here are very decently priced for the portion size. But I felt that the cake was way overpriced.
(3)
Jared C.

Prior to a few weeks ago, although I live in the neighborhood, I've avoided this place because of their complex and unappealing menu which was stuck in the 90s (think their parent owner, Apres Diem, with decor a la Madonna's Bedtime Stories - but not quite to Cafe Intermezzo levels of garishness). That has all changed. It's quite apparent that there is an active effort to drag their otherwise really awesome, charming cafe into the 21st century. They've simplified their menu with really awesome fresh pairings (pear and gorgonzola salad, anyone? sub $8 veggie wrap? beautifully presented belgian waffle?) and it appears are updating the ambiance to remove the air of pretension and just make it a comfortable and delicious place to be. After avoiding this place for being over-done for the last several years, it's back on my radar. Good food, still great desserts, mixed drinks, espresso drinks - all reasonably priced, and a nice, comfortable atmosphere.
(5)
H. H.

Well, we've (the wife and I, the dog eats at home) visited a new place each weekend for the last few weekends. Carroll Street's number came up. Here's what I liked. There was no wait. The service was quick. The coffee wasn't bad, not the best I've had but worth ordering. Coffee used to be cheap, but now it's $2-3 per person. ( Le Petite March & Rise-n-Dine have better coffee). Having said that, it was a little tough to get a refill. The food portions were substantial. We left satiated. Back to the no wait. If I were standing in line at one of the other usual breakfast establishments, I'd quickly run over here and grab breakfast.
(3)
Desiree G.

I came here on a Sunday afternoon as an obvious out-of-towner. My best friend's brother claimed that this was the spot for brunch. Now, I am very biased when it comes to brunch. Everyone thinks they can do it, but not everyone can do it well. So, I'm hungover, thirsty and starving and I'm not sure what kind of orange juice they use but it was THEE BEST! I literally ordered about 4 of them. I was upset that they don't serve alcohol on Sunday's in Atlanta until AFTER 12 PM but I didn't need much of anything after that orange juice. Moving along, I order the crabcake benedict which was delicious! It came with a side of grits and fresh fruit. The portion was that of any southern restaurant - extremely filling and HUGE. Plus, no one looked at me weird for wearing sunglasses at the table. Yeah, I'd return there.
(5)
Dalora S.

Heard lots of good things about it, so when things immediately went awry I thought, "Maybe today's an off day. I'll try again soon." But after the food came out cold and season-less with items missing and the waitress said the chef forgot and it would be 20 minutes to provide the item, if the kitchen staff were WILLING to go get it, the salt and pepper shakers were filled with water... But this was just a perfect storm of a bad dining experience that I wouldn't want to risk again because "fool me once..." WELL, I was fooled twice. Gave Carroll Street Cafe' another try and it was worst than the first. Our server was nowhere to be found, service overall was slow, and food was room temp when it finally arrived. I have to admit that the Bloody Mary made it all better, so 2 stars remain.
(2)
Damien B.

I have been here twice for dinner and it was good both times. My only complaint was the calimari. It was not even close to being fresh and it was really overcooked. I am not sure if it came overcooked out of the bag so it is hard to really judge the skill of the kitchen from it. But if one dish out of 10 is just not good i think that is pretty good odds. The dish was not so bad it would make you ill or just walk out but you would not want to ordre it again I am sure. Both times the service was good exceptable, you know they brought the food and drinks but were not very nice or informative and maybe slow at times. I really do like the space though. It has a charm and warmth to the place I think is great for a nice dinner.
(4)
Robert G.

Went on Monday which is $5 tapas night. Very good food, try the scallops! Our server was friendly but didn't seem super knowledgeable about the menu. If I had been on full price night (some tapas are $11 normally) I would definitely have expected a little more from our server. But for $5 bucks I couldn't complain!
(5)
Saffie Muna J.

Great place for a date night - simply love the food and the martinis are awesome- Saffie Muna Jeter
(5)
Tom S.

I like this place very much. I have eaten here for several years. I visited Carroll St. tonight with some folks that live across the street. I had the basil noodle bowl and the veggies burger. Everything was really great and I hope to go back soon. It made me happy.
(4)
Ivan S.

Situated in a formerly shady neighborhood far from the things of man? Just off a hard-to-navigate two way street barely wide enough for a Segway? Hit by a damned tornado?! Nothing seems to stop Carroll Street Cafe and, let's face it, that's a good thing. I've said it previously but it still applies here, Carroll Street is a hipster, boheme eatery in the same vein as its siblings, the Diem twins. In other words, it's shabby chic with interiors distressed, wine drinkers possessed, and servers with great breasts. The menu is sandwich driven with a selection of bistro-inspired entrees. The tapas fad took its liberties with the food long ago and still rears its ugly head, but mostly on the "specials"chalkboard. That said, mostly they're ok, but the mussels app is the standout. The food is much heartier than at Apres Diem and I, as a good eater, appreciate that. (No stinkin' $8 plates of tempeh and carrot sticks for me.) This all carries over to brunch which too often I forget they have but really ought to remember more. As with any hipster joint, Carroll Street has different themed music nights, DJs with cutesy pop culture-inspired names spinning their latest mashups. Sometimes this may interfere with a desire for intimate conversation, so just be aware. One of the worst things about visiting Carroll Street isn't the fault of the cafe, but the actual street itself. It's a narrow little thing that inconceivably still all traffic both ways. Top that off with off-the-street parking and the get a taste for the Cafe's Euro-style of life before you even get out of the car. This ain't no SUV-friendly, convenient AMERICAN road, I tells ya and unless you're comfortable with parallel parking, you may need to practice some before that big date, Hot Shot. Finally a star to Carroll Street Cafe alone for having a specialty drink named after the legendary Mr. Billy Ocean (see pic.) Oh Billy, what ever happened to you? Did you return to your Caribbean Queen? Is she an easy lover? Did you finally hear a sad song to make you cry? Or perhaps the going got tough, so you, as a tough person, got going? Billy, don't be a hero, come back and share one of your namesake drinks with us. Show us there's no better motion than Billy Ocean. So with that, 4 musical stars for the Carroll Street Cafe. That should be enough to prompt you to drive over to visit. That said Dear Yelper, get out of my dreams and into your car.
(4)
Tim D.

Food was good, the place was kind of creepy! Felt like a place you would find Harry Potter back in the back room with a couple of witches!
(2)
Gianna R.

I really missed this place of all my local spots that I used to go... I used to live around the corner and we would go here for lunch or dinner every other day.. My trip to Atlanta was short this time and could only make it in for Breakfast and this would be only the 2nd time I have had Breakfast here and it was very good, not as good as there lunch or dinner but I am partial.... But it was great I had the Cajun Shrimp and Grits and it was YUMMMMMMMM And you have to get a More Mosa its a delicious Super Sized Mimosa with nice fresh squeezed juice.... I love the vibe here and love the food.... Do yourself a favor and check it out....
(5)
David J.

I was over expecting and Carrol Street CafÃ© undelivered this weekend. I was looking for a dog-friendly restaurant with a patio and decided to try this place after reading online that this place met my criteria. I already knew that parking in Cabbagetown is a challenge because of the narrow streets. So this was no big deal, and in the morning there was ample street parking. However, the first thing I noticed was that the patio furniture was cheap wobbly metal with no umbrella above us. Given the constant pop-up showers in Atlanta having a proper umbrella is important. Fortunately there was no rain the morning we were there; but for a sit-down restaurant, I expected better patio furniture. Maybe there is some concern about property theft that is causing the lack of investment in better patio furniture. The food was hit or miss. The Egg Meurette were delicious, the grits were average, the Belgian Waffle was ok, but the coffee was disgusting. Also, there was a strand of hair in my eggs. I should have complained then, but did not want to burn any more of my Saturday so I kept quiet. For the price I was not overly satisfied. It is unlikely that I will be repeating my visit any time soon.
(3)
Dave T.

I've been here three or four times for breakfast. The food has been good, other than a miss this morning. But, adding to the really poorly done "bacon benedict" this morning, the service which is always pretty much distant, we'll get around to it and oh, you wanted me to respond as person to you being a person?, was non-existant this morning. Adding insult to injury, the server decided that keeping sixty cents in change was the right thing to do. I tip pretty good, today I was kicking myself for scrounging for change to give a 20% tip including the money the server kept. I should have left the sixty cents the server decided to keep and called it a morning. Each time I've been at the restaurant, there are fewer people, I'm beginning to think there is a reason that I've unfortunately experienced.
(2)
Paul S.

Gotta love me some Cabbagetown.... The quieter sister of Apres Diem sits on Carroll St (hence) in Cabbagetown. If you can navigate your way down the "two way" street that is Carroll St. you'll find this little cafe quite amazing. I've been a few times for dinner and I've never been let down, but recently we've discovered their lunch/brunch menu. This is where it's at people! Crab Cake Benedict for $9! NINE DOLLARS! Most places in Atlanta are gonna charge you at least $12+... AND it's great! You can sub out smoked salmon or bacon as well for the same price. If you ask me, which if you're reading this I guess you are, I'd stick with the homemade crab cakes. Try the Egg Meurette also for more of an earthy and rich way to start your day. With a port bacon demi glaze and a fresh home made biscuit this dish was also quite stellar. The mussels, pasta dishes, and desserts at night are also delicious. I want to come back and try the tapas. We've come a few times like I mentioned and never had a bad meal. They support local art, and have specials all the time. It's extremely cute and the restaurant's vibe is both relaxed and a little hipster chic. It gets a little dark and dare I say a tad romantic at night so it makes for a great date place.
(4)
Tamera B.

We came here a couple of weeks ago for brunch. Location/space is cool. Service left much to be desired. Waitress seemed uninterested. Menu had some items that sounded delicious. My first order was the croissant sandwich but she came back to say they were out of croissants. OK. So I went with a basic breakfast plate - sausage, eggs, grits, etc. My boyfriend had the pancakes. I've made far better breakfasts many times. Nothing special at all. And like someone else previously mentioned, the eggs were a dirty yellow. wtf? What really grabbed our attention - or who - was the girl at the bar area near the kitchen. I'm guessing she was making drinks...really not sure what she was doing besides being a walking No-No. First, I caught her absentmindedly moving to wipe her nose but she caught herself and did the fake-out. Then she dropped two small plates that made a lot of racket because they were doing wheelies before they landed (eating side down) on the filthy floor. She picked them up and put them on the counter. We looked at each other. And waited. I had my left eye on those plates....where would they end up? They should've never made it to the counter. After a few minutes, she put them both back on top of the pile of clean plates. Completely grossed out. I highly doubt I'll be venturing back to this one, there are far too many great brunch places in Atlanta to spend my time and money on something so mediocre with servers who don't seem to now basic food safety skills.
(2)
Katie C.

So my friend and I came here before that awesome Braves game against the Mets (13-1 baby!) to grab brunch with our scoutmob deal. We originally sat outside but the flies, the looming clouds, and the fact that we asked the waitress for coffee twice without getting it, made us ask to be moved inside. Should have taken the hint that this quick brunch was going to take forever because of the slooooooow service. It took a good 15 minutes to even be acknowledged, but once we got our giant mugs of coffee (which I appreciated) we just needed to make a decision on what to eat. Everything looked soooo good it was really hard to make a decision. We both ordered the turkey croissant sandwich, he got potatoes and I got jalapeÃ±o cheese grits. I was really surprised that the coffee was so incredibly bitter. I don't like adding sugar to my coffee but I must have dumped a couple tablespoons in there to take the edge off. The grits were OK, nothing I couldn't make at home and not nearly as good as Flying Biscuit. The menu didn't specify that the eggs were on the side, I thought they would be on the sandwich (and now that I think of it, if the eggs weren't on the sandwich the waitress should have asked how we wanted them cooked- which didn't happen). Instead they were scrambled on the side, nice and dry and brown (/sarcasm). I couldn't take one bite because they were so overcooked and dry, they should have put them on the sandwich to cover up the poor cooking skills. The sandwich itself was really messy and soaked in the bechamel sauce. I couldn't taste anything else the sauce was so overpowering. Oh, and a wonderfully helpful tip I wish someone would have told me: Don't sit under the A/C duct because the condensation drips and it was dripping all over me and the table and (hopefully not, but probably) the food. I would recommend Wahoo! Grill for brunch instead of here- better food, better service, great price and no stray drops from the ceiling in your food.
(2)
Angela F.

Tucked away in the city, this little gem made me sparkle with delight as my visit became more and more enchanted. The very "Friends" and "Cheers" atmosphere made me feel right at home. The rough, but cheery, decorations made me feel tucked away in a privately owned bookstore. Lots of couches to get comfortable, tables lined along the wall with throw pillows across the booth. Love it! I ordered something simple, French toast with fresh fruit, eggs, and bacon. I think they should have mentioned what kind of fruit they were putting on my toast because I'm allergic to bananas. No biggie...pushed the slivers off to the side before they settled in. Everything was fantastic! From the food (despite the poisonous peel) to the service to the ambience, everything was magical. Even my picky companion enjoyed his meal which I believe was a fretta? I'm not too sure since I was devouring my meal. Either way I can see myself coming back and making this place a part of my daily routine once I move back to the city.
(4)
Mike L.

Versatile atmosphere, being fitting for both breakfast and dinner, was a breath of fresh air compared to most diners I'd run across. Breakfast was tasty, though, fair warning, they make it a standard of adding jalapeÃ±o to their grits. Not overly spicy, but does have a bite when you're not expecting it. All told, definite dining experience, its being affordable was a nice surprise compared to many Atlanta cafes.
(5)
Richard S.

Very nice neighborhood bar/eatery. Surprisingly varied menu with small bites - tapas and such all the way to steaks and seafood meals. But also THE best dessert menu in the zip code. Best bet is to drive over to Cabbagetown find some street parking a block or two from Carrol Street and walk over. Enjoy the "intown" scene not typical of the 404 - decorated porches, neighbors walking and jogging here and there. Then grab a table on the sidewalk in front of Carrol Street Cafe and watch the world go by with a cool refreshing beverage and some conversation.
(5)
Attaicus C.

Got seated pretty quickly we sat outside. It was a lot people here,on memorial day I guess that explain the slow service. I ordered the shrimp and grits which was 10.95 for this small Harry Potter bowl with 5 seasoned shrimp on top of cheese and creamy jalepeno grits. I personally feel its way overpriced for the amount of food you get. It also came with a biscuit which taste just like a McDonald's biscuit. My friend got he Belgian waffle with bacon n eggs. It was OK nothing to write home about. Overall this place is more Foo Foo over good food quality. I have eaten brunch at much better places with better food that match up with the price. Don't get me wrong I don't mind paying for food even if expensive but it got to be worth it.
(1)
Kathryn J.

Great coffee, lovely tapas, nice prices in a charming, European style neighborhood cafe. Service was excellent and the staff is uncommonly attractive. :-)
(5)
Joey Flash A.

My parents were in town so we hit up Carroll Street Cafe for Sunday brunch. We expected to have a long wait, but were able to get a table for four on the sidewalk right away. It was a little bit chilly that morning, but still there's no better way to experience this Cabbagetown classic. The server, who was decked out in what could easily have been the latest Urban Outfitters collection, was very friendly, got us set up with coffees and teas and didn't rush us to order as we were chit-chatting - you know how it is when you haven't seen your folks for several months - a LOT to talk about. Anyway. We decided on entrees. Our server took our order without writing anything down, which seemed kind of risky, but I think she nailed it. She must be on ginkgo biloba or something. I had some sort of benedict with rockstar sautÃ©ed spinach and potatoes that was very GD tasty, but when I saw everyone else's grits I was kicking myself for choosing potatoes. Next time, grits, next time... As the sun's angle changed we warmed up considerably and had a wonderful time together. Great food in a great atmosphere, watching people walk dogs and traffic negotiate the tiny passage of Carroll Street and sharing good conversation.
(4)
Ettore M.

visiting atlanta again, i love all the cool restaurants and quaint neighborhoods that house them. dined at one of my favorite restaurants on carroll street in cabbagetown tonight. monday night $5 tapas. love my tapas. tonight we enjoyed crab cakes, grilled shrimp with plantains, sea scallops, veggie pizza, tuna tartar ++ cozy atmosphere & great staff. tomorrow back to krog bar in inman park for more tapas. it is located in the parking lot of rathbun steakhouse owned by chef kevin rathbun. so cool. looking forward to starting with white anchovy & artichoke toast, seared duck & figs, brie & local honey. yummy. good eating ettore chef & owner chez vous caterers
(5)
Dustin B.

I ate at Carroll Street Cafe for the first time this week. While I've heard great things about the breakfast at CSC, I ended up there for a business lunch. I went into CSC a bit frustrated because the parking situation is a hot mess; however, the atmosphere put me at ease. We had the Avocado Shrimp Cocktail for an appetizer. Shrimp. Avocado cut in half with a sauce in the middle. Cucumber and tomato slices. Oh my! It was amazing. I had the Greek Salad topped with chicken, which was delicious. I ordered extra Feta, and I have to say that if what I received is extra then I'd hate to see the amount of Feta that regularly comes on the Greek Salad. Even so, overall, it was a fun and enjoyable experience. I will definitely go back to Carroll Street Cafe.
(4)
Becky J.

This is our go-to for weekend brunch and I love it. With that said, I can only speak to the brunch experience. I love their food, their service and their sidewalk tables. It's a quiet street where we can sip our coffee, read our paper and eat our pancakes, fruit and oatmeal. I've eaten inside a few times and it's very nice. But the dessert display is WAY too tempting for me, so I prefer to sit outside! :) It's a small restaurant but we've never waited for a table and we've never had bad service. The parking is pretty bad sometimes since it's a very tight two-lane street but other than that, it's a perfect little brunch spot.
(5)
Marissa B.

The food and martinis were absolutely delicious but the meal was ruined because I literally wanted to punch our waitress in the face. Had she done just a little bit to hide her disdain at my asking the size of the flank steak (a question that she didn't really know the answer to) then this review would be entirely different.
(3)
Beauty A.

Went there again, to give it another try... and it was so dark but thank goodness my friend spotted a critter crawling near the painting hanging on the wall. We felt bad, so we stayed, quietly relocated to another table on the opposite side and had coffee, hope they get it together.
(2)
Benjamin T.

I went here on a Sunday afternoon with the intention of getting brunch but I got there right at 3 pm which was the time they stop serving brunch. So instead I got the chicken sandwich (can't remember the actual name) but it was pretty good and wasn't over priced. Service was average and the place has a hipster vibe to it which was interesting. My only complaints were the parking, I had to park a few streets over and walk.
(4)
Christin K.

I only visited because it was in walking distance to my friend's house, who wanted to go because 'my gf won't go with me because she thinks its too hipster'. LOL. Upon entering, its very cute, home-y. The servers don't have designated outfits, this was interesting because I saw one girl who turned out to be a server who I thought we could almost see her birth canal. Anyway, I like the vibe, and we sat ourselves in a corner. I wasn't too hungry, so I had the almond brie appetizer. I'm not a cheese aficionado but it was pretty delicious. Brie, heated, with almond glaze with a baguette and fruits (cantaloupe, grapes, etc). The almond glaze turned out to be a little too sweet at the end, but I really enjoyed it. However, I had a good chunk of brie left with no baguette, asked for another, did not realize its a dollar for the tiny baquette. O.o lesson learned. My friend had a turkey burger (dry), with fries. He kept asking the server what size the fries were, all she could do is shrug and say medium. Compared to McDonald's fries? 'I don't know, I've never been to McDonald's.' oh. hm.. Only because we prefer skinny fries. Tad bit condescending. Other than this, the cakes all looked delicious. I can't wait to go back and try them. Overall, personally wouldn't make it a destination unless I'm already here (er parking), Desserts look fantastic, so did the girl who showed them to me- super cute in a tegan and sara kind of way.
(3)
Todd L.

My wife and I dine here frequently for brunch. We usually visit here once every weekend. We enjoy the food and the coffee. They literally serve the best coffee in Atlanta. i have eaten once for dinner and it was good. The only negative to this place is the service. It is very slow. The servers typically stand around with the appearance of always being hung over or lacking sleep. They are very friendly, but you have to always wave your hand if you need something. Regardless of the service, we still enjoy visiting this place. I would definitely recommend it for brunch. Our favorite items on the menu are the lox and the soy sausage omelette.
(4)
Rose G.

Last night was my first visit to the Caroll Street Cafe and it will be my last. I went there with a friend at his request for his birthday dinner. I wish he would have picked just about any other restaurant in all of Atlanta! There were multiple issues with my and my friend's dining experience last night. While there was nothing tragically wrong with dinner last night, there were too many things that were not quite right. For example, the service was OK, the waitress, who's name I don't know because she never introduced herself, basically abandoned us after taking our entree order. I had a glass of wine with dinner and water as well, in the hour and a half we were there, she refilled my water glass a total of once. Not tragic, but not right either. Now, on to the food.... which took FOREVER to get after the appetizers.... the table next to us was served before us and they got there long after we did! (more about them further down in my review) My friend and I shared an appetizer of hummus and a tapas plate of flank steak. The hummus tasted, and looked, as if someone had simply scooped it out of a container of hummus from Kroger. The pita toast was stale and not warm, it was also not toast, it was crunchy.... more like a cracker and it was not seasoned at all. The flank steak was a disappointment as well... chewy, not tender like they make it at Top Flr. While my friend enjoyed his entree (Tortellini and Chicken), my Salmon Linguine was simply pitiful. It had clearly been left under a heat lamp for quite some time as the "grated" cheese that was on top of my pasta had melted into a congealed lump. The salmon perched on top of the linguine was dried out from the heat lamp and it was a dry, over cooked chore to eat. To add insult to injury, the menu made zero mention of any heat in the "garlic -pesto cream" sauce. I was quite taken aback by the lingering heat of red pepper flakes in the sauce. I dislike any kind of heat in my food, so even that small amount essentially ruined any chance of enjoying my dinner. This last thing has nothing at all to do with the Cafe or its staff, instead it's a heads up to the crass people who interrupted my and my friend's dinner last night... No, idiot, it is NOT ALRIGHT to ask perfect strangers to interrupt their own meal so that you can sit with friends that you had either been late meeting or had just run into... the proper thing to do is to move YOUR party to another location in the restaurant that is spacious enough to accommodate all of YOU. Oh, and another thing, if you don't know someone, and you've never even been introduced, it is (again) NOT ALRIGHT to touch that person. KEEP YOUR HANDS TO YOURSELF! All in all, it was an awful (and expensive) mess of an experience and one that I shan't repeat again. Birthday or not.
(1)
Sherry W.

Carroll Street Cafe is a cute indie/hipster-decorated coffee shop that blends in with the rest of Cabbagetown's ambiance. It's located on a ridiculously narrow street with ample seating inside, and some seating outside. Inside is peaceful and optimal for studying or chatting with friends. Can't comment on the food cause I've never gotten any, but the coffee drinks are good.
(4)
Kevin L.

Okay, really. How cute is Carroll Street CafÃ©? Pretty darn cute, I say. This seems to be a recurring theme with Cabbagetown businesses. Considering the spate of beautiful weather I happened to bring into Atlanta during my brief few-day stint there, we figured we'd take advantage of it as much as possible by finding a pleasant patio to park ourselves on (and it seems like everyone else who lives ITP did, too). The special challenge with seating at CSC is that it's first-come-first-serve, so get there early, and/or apply our approach of hovering until someone leaves. Bwahaha. After having had a burger for lunch, and prepping for a planned fried chicken feast the following day, it seemed reasonable to lean toward a slightly healthier dinner option here. Offering a varied assortment of stellar-sounding salads, I ended up being talked into the spinach and bacon one by our helpful server. Right up my alley! Fresh, broad, crunchy spinach leaves shared the bowl with savory bacon bits, shaved almonds, and bright, juicy cherry tomatoes that burst with goodness in my mouth. Also, the bottled beer selection offered a few surprises, too. I was tempted to stick to a reliable Chimay, but when our server described the Erdinger as being light and refreshing like Blue Moon but better, I knew I had to have it. Reportedly, it's fermented in the bottle, but I didn't have the problem of sediment when I poured my crisp, golden brew into the provided glass. I spoil myself by keeping frosted beer glasses in my freezer at all times - that would have been a nice added touch. Regardless, it's hard to find fault with spending a perfect evening outside, filling up on fresh foliage, and sipping a cold one... all in the presence of great company.
(4)
Bobbin W.

After several recent Carroll Street Cafe experiences, I've decided that I loathe the dinner options but like the brunch fare. My sister and I rushed to to this Apres Diem offshoot in search of a dessert, disappointed by the Kroger-like quality of our turtle cheesecake. After the nausea set in, we decided to order some "real food," too: the portobello caprese and garlic button mushrooms. The portobellos were dry and overcooked; the tomatoes, pink and devoid of flavor; and the mozzarella, old. The garlic button mushrooms were better but overly oily. Our waiter, Ben, was nice. "Do you play in a band?" I asked him. "You look like the guy from Fleet Foxes." "I'm not in a band, but people ask me that all the time," he nodded. "Someone told me once that I look like the lead singer from Band of Horses, so he calls me BEN of Horses." I went back today for brunch, propelled by a Scoutmob coupon and my friend's claim that Carroll Street's breakfast offerings soar above the lackluster dinner. I had the Spicy Red Bean Chili, which came on a plate with a bowl of beans, sides of pico de gallo and fresh avocado, pita slices and another chosen side. My meal was supposed to come with two poached eggs, which the cook forgot to place on my bean bowl. When I asked about the situation, our waitress immediately brought me two hot, white globes. I would've preferred soft (not hard) pita slices, but I still enjoyed slathering them with beans. Plus, I attacked the top cheesy layer of my jalapeno grits. I would never eat dinner at Carroll Street again, but the brunch saved this place's hide. After all, it's hard to mess up breakfast.
(3)
Kevin C.

Laid back, awesome staff and foodie deliciousness. A neighborhood gem!
(5)
arlene d.

I went here when they first opened and thought it was pretty good liked the atmosphere better than the food decided to give it another try and did not like it as much. I had a really hard time deciding on an entree. Was not feeling like a sandwich which they have plenty of. Went with the noodle bowl it was just ok nothing special . Also had a greek salad which was good. The prices were very reasonable. Sounds from others better choice for breakfast or brunch . Parking can be pretty tricky too
(3)
Ben D.

Tasty brunch with tasty, potent cocktails. The street is tighter than gnat booty, so when it's busy and people park on both sides of the street, it can be challenging logistically. I just usually pay a homeless person to shit on their windshield, so it's no big deal.
(4)
Darren H.

Sat Morning 4/11/09 For as long as I've been in Atlanta this has been my first introduction to Cabbagetown. Drove out of my way to get there after reviewing some of the other posts about this place, it reminds me of the funky little spots in the village (NYC). Strolled in for breakfast and the wait staff was very attentive and the portions were huge. My girlfriend and I couldn't finish everything. We are waiting for the weather to warm up a bit to hang out there outside. I highly recommend it as a cool, laid back place with good food.
(4)
Atl C.

Hands down my favorite spot in the ATL for both brunch and dinner. Foods awesome, cheap, and the atmosphere is great.If you don't like this, then check yourself first :)
(5)
Russell G.

Headed to a noon brunch at Carroll's St Cafe today - first time I've been able to make it out there. Driving down Carroll street, I'm immediately taken from the dusty heat of Glen Iris and Boulevard, blink, and then immersed in what looks like English influenced portions of central or south America. The streets are half as wide, there are twice the number of messy utility lines everywhere, the paint schemes are completely off the wall, and people sell hand-made wares and eat at small 2-tops right on the small sidewalk. Brunch was simple, yet excellent. A shared order of French Toast was heaping and topped with fruit and liquefied confectioners sugar. Topped with real maple syrup and with thick toast, it was delicious. The recommended chicken sausage also had a little spice on it - a great addition. Solid potatoes with onions and peppers, nothing too fancy. Only small complaint were eggs a little over-done (had asked for over-lightly). Almost grassy/dirty coffee with a ton of flavor and refilled constantly - brunch is usually one of those "ok i'm full now let's handle the rest of the day" moments but Carroll's added an atmosphere and experience I really enjoyed along with solid fare. A great experience, and at ~$13-15 per person for a quick, tasty brunch, definitely an excellent choice in a city which has locations serving brunch every 100 yards. Will definitely go back to try some tapas and a tasty beer at some point in the future.
(5)
D L.

Went for brunch. Self-seating. Only ordered appetizers. - hummus: came w/ crispy pita, tomato slices, and American cucumber slices. Don't recommend this, hummus was an ice cream scoop of dryness. - tomato thing with goat cheese: came with a crisped baguette, but not so crispy that you scratch the roof of your mouth. Tomato sauce was slightly spicy. Very tasty dish. Would order this again. - Greek salad: good-size bowl of salad. Some olives. Really tasty feta cheese. Would order this again. - "iced" coffee: not on the menu. You mix in your own cream and sweetener syrup. Slow service. The kind of place you go to talk and talk and talk.
(3)
Laura N.

This is my new favourite brunch stop! It's tucked into the neighborhood and almost seems forgotten by everyone except for those in the know, but still keeps a steady crowd. For being owned by Apre Diem, the place has a surprisingly independent vibe about it. I have only ever been in the early afternoon and have never had a problem immediately snagging a table. Service is good and the brunch menu has a large selection, if not slightly overwhelming with all the choices.
(4)
Kelly S.

3 of us headed to Carroll Street Cafe for my friend's birthday last night (after trying 2 other places in the area and finding that the wait times were freakin' insane), and I really enjoyed it. I had never been there before but have certainly read plenty about it on Yelp. We ordered booze first. They have $5 specialty cocktails on Thursdays - I got the Blackberry Leaf, and my friends got the Grace Kelly and some "Oranje . . ." drink. Mine was declared the winner . . . BIG TIME. The others were so bitter they were barely drinkable - the Oranje one because it had (presumably) too much bitters in it, and the Grace Kelly because it just tasted like club soda and DRUNK. For our appetizer, we ordered the Portabello Caprese (tomatoes, mozz, and basil) from the tapas menu. It was very yummy, but I probably won't order it again unless I'm there on half-price tapas day (Mondays?). It was pretty small (duh, tapas) and I didn't quite feel it was worth the price. When the server arrived to take our order, I still hadn't decided, because everything on the menu looked fantastic - so in a split-second decision, I chose the Panoramic Veggie sandwich. It was quite tasty, although I should learn that if I don't like something (in this case, olive tapenade), no matter how much I try to mind over matter it, that item is going to have a negative impact on the flavor of my food. But it was still good, with the hummus, cucumbers, pepperoncinis, tomatoes, etc. And the baguette it came on was PERFECT. BTW, the side salad they serve with the sandwiches (yay for health!) is AWESOME. It's basically just a little pile of weeds, but the dressing on it's DELICIOUS. It is very harsh (acidic), though, so if you prefer lighter-flavored/sweeter dressings, you might not enjoy it much. For dessert, we had a piece of dark chocolate cake with white chocolate icing, and my 2 friends split the brie app. I really dislike brie, but they were making all kinds of orgasmic sounds, so I'd put my money on it not sucking. The cake was perfect - not fancy, but moist and delicious. Service was friendly and attentive, if not quick. But I was enjoying soaking up the atmosphere, and chowing down like I just got released from prison, so I didn't mind waiting a bit. At least we didn't have to wait to sit down! The decor is warm and inviting, and there's an AWESOME illuminated palm tree (real tree, just with lighting) across the street that looks so darn pretty at night, especially nestled between the delightful remodeled Cabbagetown duplexes. Parking's a huge pain in the rear. That's all I can really say about that.
(4)
Alexa G.

Great spot for late night drinks and dessert! Can't bump it up to 4 stars since I only had some cake, but I look forward to my next visit there for lunch or dinner. I got the chocolate truffle cake and boooyyy was it rich and dark ( Just how I like my men..jk) The ambiance was very low key, dark, and smokey (If that's not your thing). Who knew this little place was tucked back there on those narrow streets.
(3)
Russell L.

I've been here a few times for meals and everything has been very good. But, I'm writing because Carroll Street is now my new place for after dinner dessert and coffee! It was amazing and close to home. I've added a photo. $2.25 for coffee and $5 for cake.
(4)
Dru M.

I love Cabbagetown and Carroll Street Cafe is a great addition. My boyfriend and I went for brunch today and enjoyed it. He ordered the brie appetizer, which he loved. I'm no a huge brie fan, but thought it was good. The portion size was huge...great value. I went with the turkey burger and he opted for pancakes. My meal came with a side salad and fruit...both very fresh and tasty. My burger was dry though. The meat was cut in half, which made me think that the cook was making sure it was cooked all the way, yet he overcooked it. The waitress didn't ask how I wanted it cooked either. Overall...food was fair this time, but I've had better...so I'll be back. Service was great, as always.
(3)
Keitha D.

I had heard alot about this place but had never made my way over there until this special guy decided it would be the location of our first date. And it was a GREAT choice. Just dark enough to be intimate and just loud enough to be fun and hip, I was immediately engaged by the atmosphere and cool location. The waitresses weren't pushy at all as we sat and chatted for a while without even ordering and they just let us be. I had a great adult beverage--the Grace Kelly which was made with perfection. For dinner I had the Seafood Penne as did the gentleman who dined with me. It was delish! Full of shrimp and mussels (i opted to eliminate the salmon) and very filling. I've heard their brunch is great so can't wait to go back and try it. I'll let you know how that goes :-)
(4)
Mariana R.

Due to the fact that I am obsessed with Cabbagetown and currently looking into moving there I am always in the area looking at places. This is how I got to the cutest block ever and Carroll Street cafe happens to be in it. I went there when the staff was in between shifts so it took a little while to be acknowledged but once that happened service was pretty much prompt and attentive. The food was good definitely nothing out of the extraordinary, it was edible but I don't think I would order any of that again I had some overly creamy pasta and some soup that were just okay, the desserts looked good but I didn't have any because I don't think the meal settled very well in my stomach. I might go back to the bar especially if indeed move to the area.
(3)
Jenn D.

I remembering going here for brunch a few years back and *really* enjoying myself. I finally got a chance to go back and see if it was all a dream, or if it was truly awesome. This time I went with a group of friends and shared some drinks and tapas. It was the first night of a Scoutmob deal, so it did take some time to get a seat, but drinks from the bar helped the wait. Service was awesome, really nice waitstaff. One person who helped us had only been there a week, but still was able to answer all of our questions. Also, I'm totally inspired by all the awesome clothing in the place...do your servers get/give fashion tips, too? Excellent choices - Kobe Meatballs (stuffed w/goat cheese!) and escargot Good choices - shrimp basil noodle bowl - pretty oily (gah, I think I need to start ordering stuff "easy on the oil", I feel like everything is drenched in it lately...), but still good flavors. One piece of shrimp still had the tail attached. My wine helped me ignore that non attention to detail. Avoid it - Pizza Margherita, whoa, we were bummed about that. Boring little thing. With the wine, atmosphere and great service it was a wonderful night out with friends, and we plan to do it again soon.
(4)
Janet G.

I can't help but wrinkle my nose at Vanessa T.'s opening line below: "Whoever likes this place must have poor taste." No need to bring other customers into your personal review, I think. Especially THIS reviewer--for I have impeccable taste, you see. :) Seriously, though: I consider myself pretty darned picky, and I have had two great experiences here. Delicious food (my guests have always agreed), good service, and a charming little location. Sit outside if you can.
(5)
Barath B.

Went here for brunch with some friends. I ordered the huevos rancheros - it was the most bland tasting food I have ever eaten. Really mushy and gross. Our personal table waitress was great but when she wasn't around, we summoned another waitress and asked if we could have some hot sauce. She offered Tabasco or Sriracha. When I asked if I could have both, she said "well you're an asshole." Are you kidding me? Is that the way you treat your patrons at a place of business? FAIL. NEVER GOING BACK. Is there a way to give zero stars?
(1)
Susan H.

Totally hipster spot but the best desserts! And great little after hours spot! Definitely worth a try for dessert!
(4)
Rob C.

Stopped in for brunch during the Chomp & Stomp a couple weeks ago. Overall somewhat unimpressed, though that may be the result of high expectations from everyone else's reviews. Pros: - Food was definitely good. Nothing out of this world, but certainly better than average. - Atmosphere is relaxed - really does have a coffee house vibe that other places struggle to manufacture. Outside tables looked great, basking in the cool autumn sun. Cons: - Service was a bit sub-par, but I didn't expect much. Am I the only one who had noticed the relationship between perceived coolness of neighborhood and general crappiness of service in Atlanta? I swear it makes me want to drive OTP sometimes. Of course I don't, but I like to think that I could. - Price was WAY too high for a breakfast. $10 for some chili and 2 poached eggs??? Isn't there a recession going on? You can definitely find better food at a much better price elsewhere in the city.
(2)
Lydia L.

Great. I love most things about Carroll Street Cafe: the neighborhood, the decor, the food (of course), the wine menu, and yes, the desserts. My only complaint was that service is slow during the lunch rush (excessively slow). Lots of options, even for the picky eater. If you're in the area, stop for food!
(3)
Steve T.

I was torn between 3 and 4 stars, but going for 4 stars as this is my favorite neighborhood restaurant. Everything I've had here is great, the service is friendly, atmosphere casual but cozy, and the pricing is really reasonable. Parking is tight over there but I'm hearing they have valet now? Breakfasts are great, too - usually not as crowded as the regular breakfast places in our hood.
(4)
Mona P.

I purchased a tapas book recently and have been fascinated by the number of squid dishes possible in the Spanish food fare. So I was extremely excited to try the chorizo stuffed squid, but sadly they had run out. Turns out, Monday is $5 tapas night and the place gets a hoppin' and favorites sell out, leading to a second denial of the lamb sliders tapa. Not all is lost. I did get to try quite a few other dishes. Calamari- First time I have had non-fried calamari and it was pretty tasty. The baguettes on the side served well to sop up the jalapeno-garlic broth the calamari was swimming in. It was good, not great. Kobe meatballs- Apparently the meatballs are stuffed with goat cheese. I was imagining a nice creamy glob of goat cheese in the center but I assume it was blended in with the meat. It was seasoned well and tasted fine. . .just less imaginative than I was expecting. Pizza Margherita- I enjoyed the crust of the pizza- thin and crispy. Lobster Risotto- The risotto comes with a cream sauce which I thought was a bit too heavy on the cream. The first bite was great but after a couple more bites I was over the heavy-hand of cream which overpowered the other flavors in the dish. Slow-roasted pork belly- Tasty and tender as pork belly should be. Paired with Erdinger beer on a cozy side street made for a pleasant evening. I thought the food was good but not great, although I plan to return to try the chorizon stuffed squid. Plus, it's a great deal to go on Monday, just make sure to venture over earlier in the evening.
(3)
Shamalien S.

service was very slow and the food came out ice cold.
(2)
M D.

The food is pretty good, tho not great. The desserts are excellent. But the food isn't the big draw here -- it's the delightful, cozy, intimate atmosphere in a great funky neighborhood. Completely charming. Also: very attractive (and nice, and competent) hipster waitstaff. A pleasant place to be, all around.
(4)
ATL n.

An awesome neighborhood spot. When I first moved here, my mom came to visit to set me up and such -- and we were looking for a local spot with some healthy lunch options (as great a southern food is, we were just dying for salad that was close-by and fresh). Carroll Street was a great discovery. We split a tuna tartare which was an incredible surprise, quite gourmet really and looked around only to decide my move to Atlanta was a very, very good thing. Love this place and hope to return for a few hours of studying over several course snacks that end in wine, inshallah
(4)
Margaret M.

The good... Carroll St. encourages that sensuous exquisite heavenly calm of being back in Europe. TIP.. I like to go on stormy nights when it seeps of intimacy. The bad... The subordinate relationship one must endure with navigating Cabbagetown's clotted backstreets for parking.
(4)
Rob P.

Good location.
(3)
Timber W.

Last night, my sister and I were in the mood to eat something sweet...or so we thought. When we arrived a Carroll Street Cafe, we went straight to the dessert case. We both ordered the turtle cheesecake, which was really good, but we regretted ordering only dessert about halfway through our respective slices and asked for carry out boxes. Sick but not full, we decided to peruse the tapas menu. On the suggestion of our server, we ordered the garlic button mushrooms and the portabella caprese. I wasn't impressed with either of the dishes. I thought the garlic button mushrooms, cooked in butter and garlic and served with bread, were much too peppery, but I was most disappointed with the caprese. I tried to cook a portabella with some spinach, red peppers, and mozzarella once before with disastrous results. What we ordered tasted much like my attempt. The portabella was overcooked and a little too tough. The mozzarella did not taste fresh, and the tomatoes didn't seem ripe enough. Aside from the food, I was disappointed with the service. Our server was really nice but largely negligent. After we ordered our dessert and sat down, we weren't offered any beverages. When the slices arrived, my sister ordered a drink, but before I could request one, the server walked away. I had to wait until her drink was delivered to order mine. We also waited patiently for the server to return when we were finished with our dessert. I kept trying to make eye contact, but it was useless. Finally, I had to walk up to the server to ask for carry out boxes and order more food. I don't think I've ever had to do that...anywhere...and because I don't want to repeat that experience, I won't be returning.
(3)
Courtney R.

How is it that I continue to find places that I frequent that I have yet to review? Proof I'm forgetful. With that said, Carroll Street Cafe is a great cafe located in the heart of Cabbagetown that also can be a fun chill bar to hang at night. Probably, it stands out most for its brunch options. I'm a fan of the Oso Grande (which basically is two poached eggs on top of toast points with spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes and a delicious sauce). I also like their Eggs Benedict that you order crab cakes with. Yum. Likely Carroll Street doesn't have the best Bloody Mary's in Atlanta, but decent enough (RIP Solstice that did have the best Bloodys). However, I would recommend getting their larger mimosas and just keep ordering them really. It makes for a nice, buzzed, brunch experience that is perfect for any Saturday/Sunday morning.
(4)
Laura C.

This place is delicious. Really really delicious. Love the calamari in jalapeno/white wine sauce. The basil pasta is also good. I'm totally going back on a Monday for $5 tapas and half-off wine bottles! It looks so cool inside at night, and during the day is plenty friendly.
(4)
Camille M.

As a resident of Cabbagetown for over three years, I thought that I should finally leave a review of this adorable little place. For a few weeks, Carroll Street has been completely swamped with people from Scout Mob coming to try out the cafe. I'm very glad that they have. However, these Cabbagetown newcomers have left some unsatisfying and overly critical reviews of such a quaint restaurant. Some of these more recent reviews by Scout Mobbers have inspired me to write one of my own. I have a soft spot in my heart for French cuisine, and I find that Carroll Street takes the time to add a little French flair to otherwise bland American cuisine. They play with flavor unlike other restaurants, and they provide many vegetarian options for people like me. All in all, I have never had a bad experience at this establishment. The service at Carroll Street Cafe is excellent. If you keep returning, the servers will remember you. All of them are very nice and pleasant. The bearded barista is one of my favorite characters here, as I see him often when I come in. He always makes delicious coffee drinks, and he's very knowledgeable. For a long time I have come to this restaurant, and I would give it 5 stars if the quality of the food that they bought for the kitchen was a little better. Including organic items on the menu and vegan desserts would be a huge improvement! You can tell that the food, sometimes, tastes a little bit cheap. All in all, Carroll Street is a wonderful experience for friends, families, and also for a date.
(4)
Ginger W.

Order the Brie appetizer. It's amazing. Sevice can be hot and cold. Parking is a problem sometimes.
(4)
Mick D.

Very eclectic menu at this Cabbagetown eatery. The food is excellent. I look forward to trying the brunch. Go and relax, have a good time, enjoy the good food. Service isn't always quick, but let me remind you that this isn't fast food. I've heard they have the best coffee in the city. (I'm not a coffee drinker, so you'll have to let me know.)
(4)
Elizabeth M.

Just met friends there for lunch for my first visit. Right away this place has great ambiance. We were there on a Tuesday afternoon and their special was half off the tapas menu. So, we tried almost everything: the lobster risotto, crab cakes, seared scallops, asparagus en croute (with goat cheese and wrapped in phillo dough, Yum!) and the portobello caprese. Very nice presentation and very tasty. Would definitely order the caprese and crab cakes again. For dessert we browsed their pastry case and decided on the cannoli cheese cake and it was amazing. Our server was very attentive and kept our club sodas filled. He was very friendly with honest food suggestions. Looking forward to going back and trying out their brunch menu! I am very happy to have discovered this little gem!
(4)
Mateo B.

Carroll Street Cafe is a bohemian-infused, New American cafe. The hand written chalk menu welcomes you as you enter into couches with tables and traditional two seating high tops. After walking off a night at The Thinking Man, I found this petit cafe with a friend during a road trip stop. The food was mostly traditional breakfast and brunch items (eggs, toast, etc.), with non traditional items (Mussels, full bar). The atmosphere is the true draw to the place. With local artists' work draped on the walls, there is a personal and eclectic vibe inside. Expect waitresses that would be kept in the back room at other restaurants, but don't mistake it for bad service. Whether it be the armpit hair or lax dress, their garb is really half the pleasure of the place.
(4)
Kathleen M.

I've always been a bit enchanted with Cabbagetown. I came to the neighborhood once in high school and it was my first experience with a "true" slightly gritty intown neighborhood, having spent most of my youth in Buckhead and Virginia Highlands, with the occasional foray into Midtown or Little Five. I loved Cabbagetown at first sight, with it's mixed residential/commercial streets, graffiti, friendly people, and in-the-process-of-being-converted lofts. It took me 10 years to return, sadly, but the wait was worth it. Bellied up to the bar at Carroll Street Cafe, I ordered a Chimay Blue from Anessa, the petite blonde behind the bar. As she poured my beer she recommended two of the new tapas dishes: artichoke bruschetta and the steak. We ordered both and I was blown away. Seriously, incredible and flavorful food that's not flashy or trying too hard: it was pretty much perfect, and I'd do it all over again in a heartbeat. While my palate was sufficiently cared for and my stomach was perfectly full, upon mentioning that I had yet to experience the midnight express my dining companion made sure to order a slice. Rich chocolate cake, smooth white chocolate icing... heaven on a plate? Methinks yes. A slice worth returning for. Carroll Street Cafe makes me want to move to Cabbagetown. It's the place I've been looking for since moving to Atlanta: a neighborhood bar that's equally perfect for a first date, the perfect spot to be a regular, where you can also bring your parents. I love it dearly, and will be sure to make the trek from Midtown a lot more often than once every 10 years. If for nothing else than the midnight express.
(5)
Ashley S.

Tuesday night was the second time I have been there (once for breakfast and now once for dinner). The food is fantastic, the servers are very nice and atmosphere is great. Parking is a hassle so be prepared and it can get kind of ahem...cozy (see loud and cramped) when they are busy. But I'll take cozy if busy means I can eat there any night of the week that I have a hankering for a stout and sammie.
(4)
Barry G.

One of my favorite places to be. Very cool location and laid back atmosphere. Local artwork, excellent food and drinks. Ask for the Kobe burger even if it's not offered. Drink a Billy Ocean or 2 then have somebody else drive you home! I've never had to abandon the trip but parking is a real concern over there. Good job I'm an artist when it comes to parallel parking!
(4)
Liz L.

omg i love this plaaaace! I had never been down Carroll Street before tonight and then I went there for dinner and now I want to move there, and I also drank their Cabbagcino, which is Cappuccino and I hope I spelled it right - it's Cappuccino with brown sugar and it's GREAT and must have about 50 tons of caffeine because I am REALLY caffeinated right now and it's 11:30 p.m. on a Sunday so that's sort of a problem. The food is super excellent there and it took me about 20 minutes just to decide what to eat which is super neat because usually I just eat the same four things all the time but there - no! There their food all sounds great and what I actually ate was excellent (the seafood pasta) and my friends had the gyros, which they said was REAL good too!! So yay for Carroll Street and Carroll Street Cafe and houses close to the street and double yay for CAFFEINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(5)
Vanessa V.

Whoever likes this place must have poor taste. The only thing they got right was the cocktail my friend ordered. We had the artichoke and ravioli tapas. HORRIBLE and over priced 'bar food'. The worst part was their Thai Beef Salad. The beef is cured as they tell you AFTER you get the salad but it is really gross raw beef that looks more like garbage. The dressing was enough to leave a bad taste in my mouth, the figs aren't fresh and the noodles are not even authentic thai noodles and I think there was some sort of Ramen seasoning on them. We had a few bites of it and pushed it aside. If you are into trashy food that you can get better at a drive through fast food joint then go for it. We went to Rosebud to get real good food after this. Oh and don't get the coffee, it is enough to make you gag. GROSS!
(1)
P J.

Good food, cool location, funky place. Great Sunday brunch.
(4)
Alicia M.

I was a little nervous about going to Carroll Street Cafe since I knew I had such a large party coming for brunch! I called ahead of time and they do not take reservations for parties during brunch but once I arrived Tim had us seated and we had enough space for my Brunch Club Gals! The food ::pause for a moment:: the food is superb x 2...I had the shrimp & grit with french toast and everything was amazing! The waitress was very attentive as well! Parking sucks but great brunch spot!
(5)
T. Shontel H.

I love this place. It's so quiet and quaint. Great for a date or dinner with friends. The bartender is generous as well! The stuffed salmon is a must try! Mmmm...good!
(4)
David D.

I went with a group of friends and must say that I had a blast. This place has a fantastic atmosphere and almost begs for deep conversations to ensue. It probably has something to do with how comfortable the place makes you feel. The local art on the wall was enjoyable and a plus because I love when a place supports the locals. It brings character and originality. I think there alcohol price tags are a little high, which made me down grade to a cappuccino...but I'm glad I did because it was well prepared and delicious. I'd say that if you are looking for a place that draws good conversation out of people...this place is a must.
(4)
Steve D.

I've dated a few women who really liked this place. For the life of me I can see nothing about it worth while. It is great if you are looking for a crampted, euro-trash feel. Food is given in small, over priced portions, that are not close to being tasty. If you want a mixed drink, by all means, sit at the bar. The wait staff have no clue as to what any term( such as tall) means. Faux Euro-trash for in town snobs that don't know better. Staff is very nice though!
(1)
James H.

Far more intimate and eclectic than its bustling sister restaurant Apres Diem, Carroll Street Cafe has a similar menu and dessert list. Art from local artists adorns the walls, frequently for sale, so between visits, the decor will often change. There's a limited "patio" area, essentially a couple of tables set up on the sidewalk, which are great for weekend brunch when you're either early or lucky enough to stake your claim. Most times we get a group to come here, I try to claim the sofa area, where a single sofa and ottoman flanks a coffee table, and our inevitable latecomers pull up a few chairs. The service is attentive, but also laid back. Back when we were listless and single, we even spent several hours of an afternoon here playing cards at a corner table. Of the food, as I mentioned Carroll Street boasts a menu very similar to Apres Diem, but the food in general seems better prepared, as if with greater care--given the traffic that Apres sees, I could certainly see their kitchen becoming a factory while Carroll Street's remaining akin to a den of artisans. Given the affordable food and intimacy of the space, Carroll Street is a great locale for a date.
(4)
Sloane S.

Met up with friends I had not seen in a while and Carroll St. Cafe was a great place to hang out for a few hours and catch up. The perfect laid-back vibe made us feel comfortable and not rushed. We never had the feeling we were keeping them from turning the table. Food was all tasty - great mussels, steak salad, creative cocktails (loved the cucumber one). Tapas menu looked good as well - will have to make it back during the week for their specials. Parking can be challenging in the neighborhood but lots of street parking is available - practice your parallel parking before you go. Don't go for the food alone - it's the location, atmosphere, staff and menu that work together to make it a great spot overall.
(4)
jeremy g.

we enjoy going to carroll street for brunch and dinner. the options are excellent. tori always (ALWAYS) get the cheese plate, which is usually heaping with 4 or 5 different types of cheeses and a generous selection of berries. i like to mix it up a little. the french toast is my favorite, but their different varieties of poached egg plates, most notably the oso grande, are definitely close runners-up. the coffee is always incredibly robust, just how i like it. we usually go with the tapas for dinner. their seared ahi tuna is good for the price and tori loves the lobster risotto. last time we visited, we shared the almond baked brie, which was wonderful. food presentation can vary, so if you're a gastro-snob, maybe this isn't the place for you. service has always been prompt and friendly and the staff does a wonderful job of making us feel welcome, even if we're not privileged enough to be included in their little gossip sessions that tend to spontaneously pop up at least once or twice each visit. far from being tacky or inconsiderate, as it would be considered at most establishments, it adds to the fun and quirky vibe that makes cabbagetown so unique -- it's appealing and appalling all at the same time. i love it!
(4)
Tracy S.

The blackened shrimp and cheese grits are awesome!!! Went this am with a Atlanta friend and my two kids and fell in love with the place ... very eclectic with friendly staff and a wonderful latte! Great place
(4)
Shayna P.

Can I give a 5 for ambience, a 4 for service and a 3 for food? I've been wanting to come here for a while. It's really, really cute. Very Cabbagetown. It's intimate and little hipster and eclectic. It has tables outside and great window seats inside and very nice low lighting. I just really like it here. I could settle in for a long, long while. I went with a friend on a Friday night at 7. We got a table immediately, which was a nice surprise. We both ordered the veggie burger. It came with fries and a side salad. The side salad was a side salad. The fries were really good and perfectly crispy. I did not like the veggie burger itself. It was very bland and overcooked. It had taken on some of the characteristics of a hockey puck. There are so many good veggie burgers out there, but this tasted like it came out of a box from Trader Joe's. Bummer. It was on a nice onion roll though. The service was very attentive. The waitress consistently refilled our water glasses and brought everything out in a timely manner. I'd say move than satisfactory. I REALLY want to like the food here. I could use another neighborhood spot, and this one is just so cozy. I've heard good things about breakfast, so I'll have to give that a try.
(4)
Christina L.

This is one of my to go to places, so cute and I have always loved what they have served me. Also they have daily tapas specials that are awesome. Yummy and if you like to hang out at the bar its fun and happening as well!
(5)
Ashaleigh R.

I loveeeee Carroll Street Cafe! I've had Sunday brunch here 2 months straight! The fried chicken breast and the jalapeno grits are the best! No questions asked, I'm going back!
(5)
Ken W.

The only reason it's not a 5 star is due to the semi-moody staff. Great atmosphere, food, location with a hip crowd! Food is AMAZING!!! Surly wait staff more interested in their own fashion statement and/or what to do after work needs to go. Shrimp and Grits is OMG good!!!
(4)
Audrey A.

I GOT MY CAR BROKEN INTO!!! The restaurant is so adorable, very hipster -esque, but I paralleled parked my car just a few sidewalks down from the restaurant and within about 1 and half hours, someone smashed into my passenger window and took my belongings. Now, I know the restaurant isn't at fault for this, but you would think the area was nice considering the nice lit road and the neighborhood across the restaurant, but nope.... Love the food, enjoyed the atmosphere of the place, but BE CAREFUL parking your car and storing away your belongings!!!
(4)
Essence B.

I live in Indianapolis, but I will never into the state of Atlanta without stopping here for their salmon dishes.
(5)
Marla C.

We ended up here after getting tired of waiting in line at the nearby Thumbs Up Diner. We were hangry, having waiting longer than we should've to eat, so getting seated here immediately was a nice treat. It was a beautiful day, so we opted for one of the sidewalk tables, which was great for people watching and getting to chat with all the cute dogs and babies that cruised by on their afternoon walks. There was also a super friendly black cat who hung out with us for a while. But I digress... The service was friendly and attentive, but not at all overbearing. We ordered bloody marys to start (excellent) and then followed up with a house specialty cocktail called the Blackberry Leaf, which was extraordinary. So refreshing and flavorful. YUM! My brunch mates had the shrimp and grits and sausage omlette--both of which they raved about (their chicken sausage is soooooooooo good), and I had the chicken and grits. Oh. My. God. The jalepeno cheese grits made my eyes roll back in my head with their savory goodness. Wowzah. And the fried chicken was a rationally-sized portion that was crispy and flavorful. I ordered mine with scrambled eggs and a biscuit on the side--all good. This place is a gem--cool and lovely without being stuffy. Loved the vibe and will DEFINITELY be coming back the next time I'm in Atlanta.
(5)
Wes M.

Apparently I looked too employed to be served. If only I wore my striped sweater, maybe then could I have eaten lunch. Wah wah. After being stared at by all of the skinny-jeaned patrons and ignored by the bar and wait staff for 10 minutes, we just left. Sadly, even though we just moved into the neighborhood and would likely have been regulars, we won't be going back.
(1)
David B.

Damn good food, friendly staff, awesome environment, dog friendly. I love Carroll st. CafÃ©s food. Kind and polite service, they make sure my dog is also taken care of via water. Grateful to have a restaurant like this in town. Well managed, clean, and great place...overall A+
(5)
Juan M.

It's nice. We most recently went on a warm winter Sunday (the kind that people who live outside of the South experience and then decide that they want to live in Atlanta). I don't even remember what we ordered but it was good - yes, it is kinda hipster, but it was fine. One thing I DO remember is that they serve cafecito cubano (and even call it something similar to that). I was bleary eyed that morning and it was helpful to get me moving again.
(4)
Lauren S.

Cool local hangout. Cross between a french bistro, a boulangerie, and Cheers. Unassuming scale atmosphere with nice mood lighting and stellar food. The dessert case is just as stocked as Intermezzo's. Great service, too.
(5)
Brett W.

We live just down the street in Grant Park and decided to try this as a possible new go to brunch spot on a rainy summer Sunday. We were very happy with our decision! Parking in that area of Cabbagetown is also a little tricky, but Carroll Street's valet parking made it simple. For noon on a Sunday, we thought we would have to wait for a table, but we were able to find a seat quickly. The place was busy but not too packed. Our server was friendly and prompt through the meal - never felt like we had to wait long for drinks and food. Loved the comfortable cafe vibe. Food was very yummy! I had the shrimp frittata and it was loaded with shrimp. We ordered the honey brie croissant to share and it did not disappoint! My husband enjoyed his fried chicken and grits immensely. Overall, the good was solid and we enjoyed every bite. My mimosa was just the right size and my husband's rum punch reminded us exactly of the drinks we had in Jamaica on out honeymoon. Overall, it was a great first experience at Carroll Street and we are already planning to go back soon and try out a weeknight dinner special!
(4)
Alex D.

This is a very interesting spot. Located in cabbage town, which means some parts of the area are a but scary. Parking and navigating the tight road it's on made it hard for us to find or even get to a parking space. My steak was ok, ordered medium. Nothing too special really. The vegetables and mashed potatoes were tremendous though. My date had the seafood pasta which looked delicious and was delicious. Overall the service and steak were pretty fair, however the price was really good for the quality of food and the very quick service we received.
(4)
Molli V.

Service here is TERRIBLE! Servers here put no effort into providing a good dining experience. Our server literally came by when we finished eating, picked up our plates and walked away without asking us how it was, or if we needed the check, or even acknowledge that she was serving us. Me and my bf are the easiest people to serve and we are always super nice so it wasn't anything towards us, they're just horrible at customer service. And I've given them far too many chances (it's in the neighborhood, convenient for when I want just a salad.. I always think the next visit is gonna be better and that the previous experience was just a fluke). The Thai salad is garbage on a plate. It's nothing but lettuce stems and the beef is ALWAYS overcooked. The dressing used to be different but they changed it to some thick non vinegarette. The menu says served with a chili vinegarette, but don't try to point that out to them because the server will say that that thick orange dressing IS a vinegarette. Oh, and my bf saw a cockroach crawl across a table.
(1)
Arian G.

A nice neighborhood bar and restaurant, with a decent beer selection and a better wine selection. Also an espresso machine, if you're into the whole caffeine thing. Warning though- no beers on tap, bottles and cans only. The food is well prepared and varied, although I pretty much always get the Tomato Montrechet. If you do, order an extra baguette.
(4)
Emma G.

Adorable neighborhood joint with seriously mediocre food.
(2)
Jess B.

I love their Crab Cakes Eggs Benedict, but decided to try their Huevos Rancheros. Big mistake, as it was boring and didn't come with the guacamole the menu promised. As long as you avoid that mess, this is a great restaurant. Friend got the California Cobb sandwich and loved it.
(4)
Nancy R.

I give this place a 3.5. This small, quaint eatery is located on a small street in Cabbagetown. Not the easiest place to find nor is finding street parking. FOOD: They have tapas and entrees, but I just got dessert with coffee. Good coffee and great dessert selections! I got the peanut butter with chocolate cake, yummy! My friend got the decadent white chocolate cheesecake. I would definitely come back to try their food.
(3)
Nic K.

I wish I could divide the ratings between food and service....or at least give half stars. Because this place is more of a 3.5. I met a large group for brunch since this is the favorite restaurant of one of the people in our party who was celebrating a birthday. I think I expected more in terms of food. I wasn't very impressed. I had the Huevos Rancheros which I found to be pretty bland. My husband wasn't too impressed with his meal either. Service, on the other hand, was impressive. Everyone was super nice and accommodating. We had a very large group, and they didn't even bat an eye when I told them how many people would be showing up. They quickly sectioned off a few tables for us and then sweetly led us to our section. The waitress was also very nice and bubbly.
(3)
Andi G.

My home away from home, these girls have my heart. Tarik will take good care of you at the bar, great dessert destination, rotating selection of cakes, pastries, and pies in the dessert case.
(5)
D.L H.

Always consistent. My favorites are, Curry Chicken and the empanadas. The hiring practices here are what is the most obvious thing here. If you like looking at good looking hipster chicks, well you have come to the right place. If you are a male, don't bother applying for the front of the house--unless you can pull off a good hipster drag look. Avoid the small portion of flank steak, unless you just want a tiny portion to snack on. Other than that this is a safe bet for a decent 31/2 star meal.
(4)
Gigi C.

I don't know where to start. I sat at the bar and was not acknowledge for 3 minutes. Until she said she will be with me after she finished making mimosas. While doing this she decide to have dialog with another customer. I decide to ask I assume the manger if I could sit at a table to get better service. He just says the same thing. It's been 5 minutes now. I get a 2 top in Sophia's section. Woohoo she is on it. Since I sat at the bar for so long I had plenty of time to memorize the brunch menu. I ordered the crab cake Benedict, eggs fried hard. Hard I say! The food appears looking very yummy. I taste the crab cake hmmm it's ok kinda low on temperature. The potatoes could use another 30 seconds in the microwave. I cut into my so fried hard egg and its runny. Really. I inform Sophia and she is on the task of getting me a friend egg. Yes, the fried hard egg arrives only to be as runny as the firsts. The food temp was not up to standard but I thought I could work thru it. I could not get it down. Aight horrible. But my waitress was a sweetheart. Not sure if I will try dinner at another time. It was a waste of money. 2 starts for the small attempt.
(2)
Rachel P.

In a city full of great brunch spots, this one just didn't stand out for me. It was pretty mediocre. I had the pork sausage omelette with red pepper, goat cheese, and basil and it was pretty good. The grits were alright and the biscuit didn't taste fresh. My partner had eggs meurette and the two poached eggs were overcooked. His plate was watery and his biscuit was hard. The potatoes were cold and raw in the middle. We ordered a chocolate croissant to give them a chance to redeem themselves and it really seemed microwaved. You know when you microwave a flaky pastry and it gets all soft and spongy? Yeah, that. Idk, maybe we will go back and try the tapas. But brunch was not super, at least for us. To be fair, it was a cute atmosphere and the server was nice and efficient.
(3)
T B.

Loved the ambience but I was not completely satisfied with my meal. Went for a late lunch with a friend who lives in Cabbagetown. She ordered the Cobb Sandwhich. I ordered the Cobb Salad. Her meal looked delicious while my salad seriously looked like a side salad. I honestly could get a better salad at any other restaurant for $13. I left lunch hungry. I'm giving 3 stars because I would probably give them another try in the future. Just don't order the Cobb Salad.
(3)
Brittany M.

My friend and I had our joint birthday brunch here last week. I was very excited to go here since my favorite place: Carpe' Diem closed in downtown Decatur. The same people that owned that, owns Carroll St! Well they definitely didn't disappoint! I had a cappuccino, can't remember the specific name but it had brown sugar in it. Our waitress recommended it because I told her I want something sweet. It was great, didn't need any extra sugar or anything! At Carpe' I was absolutely in LOVE with the Shrimp and Grits with a side of potatoes. So I was more than ecstatic to see they had both on the menu at Carroll, only here the grits were like jalapeno cheese. I crossed my fingers in hopes to get the same magic that I got at Carpe'. I DID! The blackened shrimp was perfect and the grits had just the right amount of kick! And the potatoes with a mix of peppers and onions were everything too! The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because parking was no picnic. They do have complimentary valet parking not too far from the place, but of course after the majority of my party circled the perimeter and ended up parking a block and a half away, the guy drags the sign out notifying everyone of the parking smh. But I digress. I'll definitely be back!
(4)
Gillian R.

I met a friend here for dinner and drinks. It was mid-week and rainy outside, so it was a bit quiet, which was just what we were looking for. This place is so cozy! There were candles and flowers on the table, bench seats with pillows, a big comfy couch, and a nice standard bar. There was even a candle lit in the bathroom, which smelled heavenly. Yes, I just said that the bathroom smelled heavenly. This coming from someone who prefers to avoid public restrooms at all costs! Tapas are half off Tuesday through Thursday, which is a major score! I had an awesome veggie pizza for $4.50, she had crab cakes. I'd love to try a few more things here, because there was plenty that looked awesome on the menu, but my pizza was also more than enough to fill me up! And let's be real, I'm a bottomless pit when it comes to pizza. Classic martinis are $5 on Tuesdays, so I had a dirty martini and a beer. In total, my entire check for a pizza and two drinks: $15. Can't beat that! Our server, Tarik, was friendly and funny, there when we needed her and gone when we were deep in conversation. And she kept my water glass full, which was highly necessary given that mid-week drinks often lead to a mid-week hangover for me. They didn't this time, and I owe it all to Tarik for that! I am already planning my next trip here. You'd better believe I'll be back.
(4)
Rob F.

The Thai Beef salad was great. Friendly service. Great atmosphere. Wife got the veggie wrap and liked it.
(4)
Atiyah T.

Now if you ever lived in Brooklyn New York, this spot captures that essence. It's a cool, hipster type cafe with great food. Now since I'm newly resident of Atlanta, finding this place was sketchy so I had all thoughts going through my head on my way here. But the food and service made up for the worries... Carroll Cafe has a unique intimate, friendly atmosphere. And the food is great.
(4)
Lesly W.

Perfect date night and favorite dinner spot to go to with my boyfriend! Come here at night and you'll get candle lighting at every table or sit outside to greet friendly neighbors walking by and to check out beautiful French and Spanish influenced architecture of nearby houses. Even the bathroom is candle light only adding on the ambiance of this amazing place. The steamed mussels are great for an appetizer and filled with so much flavor and the Seafood Penne' is my go to. This place is also a perfect spot for getting a drink or two with a friend. Come here for brunch and you'll get a different vibe! Huge windows letting in so much natural lighting and there is rarely a wait during brunch.Their Iced Chai Tea is one of my favorites in the city and pastries are amazing! Staff is always super friendly, wear the cutest outfits, and knowledgeable about the menu. Carroll Street is small, quaint and peaceful place that is a little gem in the city. Something about this place makes me feel so happy!
(5)
Erica P.

Very quaint little spot, kind of a hipster spot, interesting decor, had a delicious breakfast there when in town for the weekend. Cool menu, everything was delicious, especially the breakfast potatoes.
(4)
Thuy An H.

Went here for brunch because I saw good reviews on Yelps; however, I will not make a trip back to Carroll Street CafÃ©. The food to me was mediocre - eggs were "bleh" and waffles were hard and dry.
(2)
Bob N.

They actually are open earlier than posted on yelp. Omelet are great and love the coffe. Very pleasant atmosphere.
(5)
Hoho M.

Nice cozy spot with great drink and tapas specials. The ambiance is great at night & the waitresses are usually quick and courteous. Oh, and their weekend brunch food (omelettes, lox & bagel, steak & eggs, specials) is amazing!
(5)
Shawn W.

This review is based on a Monday $5 tapes. $16 bottle white or red. $3 beer special. Awesome dinner.b
(5)
Joseph W.

Fantastic food. NiÃ§oise salad went down very easily. Tuna was top quality as well. The lady had the scallops and mushrooms, perfectly done. The appetizers we ate, the portabello caprese and papas atomicas were equally as tasty. We will be back anytime we visit ATL.
(4)
Quentin J.

The house white, Viura/Verdejo, Fuente Milano, is an inoffensive, straightforward wine w fruit notes and clean lingering finish. Not to dry not to fruity. Good balance makes for a good standard. At $5 it's no brainier. Their food is next on the agenda. Will report back.
(4)
Mark W.

So lucky to have Carroll Street as my neighborhood bar. Amazing staff, delicious drinks, great vibe. Try the turkey burger and huevos rancheros.
(5)
Justin R.

Located in a quaint neighborhood, this eclectic restaurant has great out doors seating, but I wouldn't pass up on sitting inside either, as it is equally well adorned and visually stimulating as the view outside. The wait staff was great, service was great, and they were fairly busy, personally that's when I find service counts the most as a customer. The menu is diverse, lots of surf and turf with a few vegetarian dishes. Almost immediately the menu items that stuck out to me were the tapas. Not to downplay the rest of their offerings but this seemed to be the focal point for my taste. I ordered the flak steak with chimmichuri, which was season and prepared to perfect juicy morsels that my dog who we brought with us, probably would have murdered me to steal. My other dish was the seared tuna with white beans, also quite well prepared. Seared tuna is one of those dishes that is simple but easy to verkakte. The tuna was cooked and seasoned all to a light, taste worthy mouthful of paradise, compliment only further by the bed of beans. We also ordered a veggie burger which was amazing, it came with a side salad which I would say was slightly wilted and didn't seem as fresh as it could have, but it was a minor detail. As an appetizer we ordered the cheese plate, I guess you would ask, why I didn't start in consequential order, and mostly it's because I was least impressed with the quality of the dish. The cheese was served slightly warm as if it had been sitting out for too long, cut into hunks and adorned with a splotch of wilted lettuce and fruit, reminiscent of something I could have found at a much more cost effective establishment. It just felt rushed and a lot of short cuts were taken with the cheese plate, which IMHO is equal parts presentation and food. All-in-all great service, tapas, and entrees, and if you are in the ATL, I would recommend stopping by this neighborhood cafe.
(4)
Kyle H.

Carnivors delight, you can bring you vegetarian friends, but the veggies are salted (yay).
(4)
John C.

Saturday night the drunken manager at Carroll St. CafÃ© told me I was a douche bag and an asshole and then groped me at the bar. Apparently I'm a douche bag and an asshole because I get too drunk or too loud or opinionated or obnoxious or whatever at their bar. Or maybe it's the thousands of dollars I've spent on their mediocre food over the years or the fat tips I always leave that has them hot and bothered. It's not feedback I've ever received at any other establishment - although I'd be the first to admit I get a tad unruly when very drunk. I don't feel people up at the bar, though. I'm good friends with some of the staff that used to work there, but I dunno, man... I don't think I'm ever gonna go back.
(1)
Johnny W.

Cute place. The neighborhood sucks for parking and driving with the small streets. But sure to get there early because it is always crowded. I think the brunch menu ha a good selection but might be a little over priced for the quality. I would go again though because I was overall happy with my visit.
(3)
John C.

Are you fn kidding me? For 8 bucks you get 2 jalapeÃ±o poppers. 2 ! Wtf? And they came out kinda cold. Ok, well, we got the check after the server asked us about the jalapeÃ±o left on the plate, she didn't charge us for it. So, I can't really complain. Lol. I just won't order that again
(3)
Dan I.

I love this place. I come here with some friends a few times a week. It's got a quiet, intimate atmosphere that really appeals to me and I find the whole Cabbagetown aesthetic to be really charming. It looks like if someone tried to gentrify the apocalypse. The desserts are amazing. I recommend Midnight Express or the chocolate truffle cake. The staff can seem surly but they become nicer once you get to know them better.
(5)
Nissa E.

ok i'm totally caught off guard - as many times as i've been to Carroll Street Cafe, i have NOT reviewed it. *gasp* ok so love the atmosphere and my fave breakfast item is the french toast with fruit, no syrup necessary. trust me. i also like the shrimp and grits - and the bagels and lox...well heck i like pretty much the whole breakfast/brunch menu! And the bar is superb! GREAT brunch for a lazy Sunday! I've never done dinner or a during the week meal there so i can't speak for that. One of my girlfriends and I do an insane Saturday walk from Grant Park and end up all over Atlanta including the Cabbage Town area. So this is a stop off point either on the way to our multiple destinations OR on the way back to the car. Anyway - EAT here!!!
(4)
lisa b.

food is 4 star, service is zero. I love the menu, but some of the staff is very unfriendly and sometimes downright rude. aprÃ¨s diem has the service aspect down, so I'd much rather dine there even though Caroll street is right round the corner from me.
(2)
Apearl C.

I really like this spot. It is a combination of a cafe, bar, and lounge. The vibe is nice, staff is friendly, and food is good. I loved the mixture of the crowd as well. I went for lunch, but will try it for dinner next time.
(4)
Leslie W.

One of my favorites. ~The Food~ I can't get enough of the Salad Nicoise. Caroll Street Cafe's version is full of unexpected delights. The tuna is sashimi-grade, seared and Panko-breaded -- yum! The garnishes are lovely and include two substantial yet delicate Panko-crusted potato cakes, a smattering of sushi rice, capers, pepperoncini peppers, and cucumbers. The requisite tomatoes and and hard boiled eggs are included, and you can get it with or without anchovies (though I recommend them). On a Monday night, I skip the Salad Nicoise to enjoy $5 tapas. Since their normal tapas prices range from $8-11, this is a great deal. Bring a friend and sample several while enjoying the accompanying Monday night beer or wine special. ~Atmosphere~ The patrons are mostly hip Cabbagetowners. The lighting is dim. The candles are lit every evening. It's crowded enough to generate a low din but quiet enough to carry on an intimate conversation. All in all, a romantic place that rides the line between casual and upscale. ~Parking~ If you know the neighborhood (or have a little patience), free curbside parking can be found on Carroll Street as well as on nearby Reinhardt or Pickett . But Cabbagetown is a neighborhood of narrow, one-way streets, so if hunting for a spot irritates you, take advantage of the complementary valet parking available nights and weekends.
(4)
Zewditu D.

I have been here a couple times for brunch as my boyfriend loves it. There is limited outdoor seating, but we have been lucky and gotten it every time. Nice atmosphere. Parking is available along the street, but it is frequently packed. It is located along a narrow street that doesn't really accommodate two-way traffic. The omelettes are alright. I like that they give you an ample amount of fruit. The breakfast sandwich is also alright.
(3)
Sarah M.

Two words, eggs benedict. This is by far my favorite place to eat in Atlanta. Sunday morning brunch, if I'm in town, you'll see me there. The service is always impeccable, and sitting outside is always a treat, but it's generally hard to snag a seat. Their dinner menu is just as good as their breakfast/brunch. Tucked away in Cabbage town, down a strangled (should be one way) road is this fine jewel of Atlanta. Be on the lookout for Catlanta, he frequents the area.
(5)
Nekiba M.

I came here with a group of friends after passing two other restaurants. We all agree this look like a cool place to go for dinner on a Sunday so we ended up here. Great decision. The waitress and other staff was friendly and accomdating given the size of our party and not all of us were there. The inside is totally hipster with an eclatic array of paintings along the wall with low lighting but not took dark. We were seated on the bar side very narrow. I didn't realize until later there was a bigger area on the other side of bar. No big deal there was plenty of room for our party. Concerning the food, I give credit to the pictures posted here because nobody couldn't decide on what to order since this was our first time there. A friend of mine and myself looked through the photos and decided to order the seafood penne pasta. The seafood penne included salmon, shrimp, mussels, cilantro, basil topped with a lobster cream sause. Others odered the thai beef salad and the filet mignon. When the food came out and our mouths watered, the food looked so good. It taste good also because all talking ceased once we started eating. The seafood penne was good, it lacked a bit of salt but not much. The show thai beef salad looked really good so I have to try that. The filet mignon was cooked medium rare and tender. That's on my list to to try. The waitress was nice and they had no problem splitting the check. I'll be back again to try the filet mignon, thai beef, and to see how their nacoisse salad is.
(4)
Benjamin T.

I went here on a Sunday afternoon with the intention of getting brunch but I got there right at 3 pm which was the time they stop serving brunch. So instead I got the chicken sandwich (can't remember the actual name) but it was pretty good and wasn't over priced. Service was average and the place has a hipster vibe to it which was interesting. My only complaints were the parking, I had to park a few streets over and walk.
(4)
J L.

Carrol Street Cafe beats the pants off of neighboring fine-dining. I can hardly express the joy I've felt while eating here. I've been to Carrol St. twice, now. Once for dinner, and once for brunch. Both were wonderful. The space is intimate and charming. I find that their food is prepared as thoughtfully as much "nicer", hyped up restaurants. G and I have had great servers each time we've eaten here. On our first date, he raved about their pastries, coffees and more. At the time, I was surprised that they had so much more to offer out of a little one-way street cafe. For dinner, G had the curry-basil chicken, which definitely topped my sashimi tuna steak, although I found it to be delicious. We happened to dine on a Tuesday, where we had the pleasure of one too many $5 martinis on their sidewalk patio. Don't be a bummer. We were walking. Again, the service was strong, as well as the presentation and taste of food. At brunch, just yesterday, we shared a chocolate croissant with our "chocochino" coffees, and ordered entrees that might certainly be on my "best-of-brunch" list. Prior to our Sunday brunch, we had been looking for Saturday brunch spots, and sadly, there are so very few. Count on Carrol St., they serve brunch on Saturday and Sunday! G had the Huevos Rancheros, which were served on tortillas with eggs, beans... the whole 9 yards. I had the Egg Meurette which, as described on the menu: "Two poached eggs over sauteed spinach and tomato, covered in a port-bacon demi-glaze, served with a biscuit." I mean holy crap y'all. Who thought that I would keel over for some sauteed spinach and tomatoes literally in a light garlic/butter/salt n' peppa combination. Easy? Probably. Delicious? I was sopping up the juice with the biscuit. Dare I say that the grits were far superior to Flying Biscuit's? I dare.
(5)
Chinika T.

After doing a quick Yelp search for the site of our team lunch, I discovered this place. Many good reviews and a fairly close drive to our office made this the right choice. After having an indecisive moment reviewing the menu I settled on the Betty (turkey sandwich with bacon). I'm not a fan of cold sandwiches but the waiter had it heated for me. Its the small things that make for good service for me. My team mates opted for the salmon on ciabatta, chicken sandwiches, and basil noodle bowl. We all enjoyed our meals and will be making a return trip. To think I've been driving within a block of this place for nearly six years and did not know it existed.
(4)
Marissa B.

The food and martinis were absolutely delicious but the meal was ruined because I literally wanted to punch our waitress in the face. Had she done just a little bit to hide her disdain at my asking the size of the flank steak (a question that she didn't really know the answer to) then this review would be entirely different.
(3)
Beauty A.

Went there again, to give it another try... and it was so dark but thank goodness my friend spotted a critter crawling near the painting hanging on the wall. We felt bad, so we stayed, quietly relocated to another table on the opposite side and had coffee, hope they get it together.
(2)
Zenoni A.

Tucked away on a small street near Oakland Cemetery, I love the cozy neighborhood feeling of this place. I went here for Saturday morning brunch around 11:30 expecting a struggle to park and a long wait to be seated, but surprisingly found neither. Carroll Street Cafe has complimentary valet parking about 50 feet down the street from the Cafe, which takes care of a potentially huge stress factor in the whole experience. The ambience inside is defined by the dark wooden floors and benches and the lull of chatter around you. On a slower, rainy day, I'd love to spend a long time here reading while slowly working my way through a meal. I appreciated that they weren't blasting music on top of everyone trying to converse, so you can actually hear the people you're with, or just sit here by yourself and read a book. The server and the patrons were really relaxed, and it was nice to see that among the couples and groups, there were a few people here on their own for a hearty Saturday morning breakfast. As to the breakfast foods, the portions are all huge, and they're pretty easygoing about changing things up for you a bit. I was with a friend who didn't want the whole Lox Platter, but just a side of salmon and goat cheese. The waitress didn't even blink an eye before saying it was no problem. I've had the shrimp and grits here as well as the crab cakes eggs benedict, both of which were mediocre. Their pretty standard combinations are made to be good or slightly better than good. There's nothing in their flavor combinations that really jumps out the way it needs to for a dish to pop, it all just kind of blends together. I would still like to go back and try their sandwiches just to see if they're a better pick. All in all, a relaxing place to have a conversation over a good meal.
(3)
Robert M.

The seared tuna entree was the best I've ever had! This cafe came highly recommended and it did not disappoint. We walked about a mile from our Bed and Breakfast in Inman Park enjoying the graffiti at along the way. Overall it was a pleasant experience.
(5)
Lindsay H.

I live across the street and every time we eat here we are impressed!! The price is more than reasonable, the portions are large and the food is really good! Breakfast is my favorite, their eggs benedict is amazing! You def need to check this place out if you are ever in the area!
(4)
Leanne E.

Awesome Saturday brunch. I ordered the Almond Brie to start, which was so good and cheesy, with a touch of honey and almond. Delish! I chose the shrimp frittata for my meal and it was excellent and made with fresh ingredients. I am pleased that this place took a bit of time to prepare it right. I will be back!
(4)
Juichia C.

Too be honest, the vibe is a bit too hipsterish for me. But this review isn't about the vibe, of course. The veggie omelette I had was very good, fresh and plentiful veggies. The sides were just okay, in fact, the fruits were surprisingly not fresh. Coffee is okay. The tapas here are hit or miss. Good service though! I would come back because it is now the closest cafe to my place, and I will probably just stick to the brunch menu here.
(3)
Leah D.

Walking down the narrow street lined with cars on both sides you can feel the atmosphere that is this sweet area of Atlanta known as Edgewood. It is a long walk since Carol Street Cafe does not have a lot but on a nice night, you can peak into the windows of tattoo parlors and cute shops. Nestled between silk curtain and a window view we were happy to people watch the hipsters that passed smoking their American Signature cigarettes. Tom, the self proclaimed man that "ran the place" stood at the bar and carefully watched the scene all night and spoke only when spoken to. Death Cab for Cutie played in the background and local artists line the walls. The atmosphere of Carol Street Cafe has to be why it was chosen on our list because it certainly wasn't my entree. We ordered our drinks, which were poured with a heavy hand and we quickly realized that this would be a single bottle of wine evening. Our appetizer was the baked brie, served with tart apple. After our stiff cocktails, the brie smelled and tasted delicious. The five of us ladies quickly ordered and enjoyed our conversations too loudly. My dish was a trout served with zucchini in a spicy caper tomato sauce. It was presented very well and the fish was a nice portion. The flavors just didn't match each other and left me with a weird after-taste. It was not hard to decide that I would not only be unable to finish the dish but would never order it again. On the other hand, every other dish at the table seemed to be much tastier than mine. The server recommended the Basil Noodle Bowl and after tasting it, was so much more disappointed in my trout. Another lady in my group had the mussels and somehow I couldn't resist dipping the remainder of our Brie bread into her juice from the mussels. Out of the five entrees at our table, two were significantly better than the others. All was right again in the world once we had the chocolate truffle cheesecake. It was devoured with five forks like it was fat free bacon. The inconsistency of the entrees really bothered me, along with the nonchalant manner of Tom. Maybe Edgewood just isn't my "scene".
(2)
Ashleigh P.

On a whim (okay... because Thumb's Up dinner was stacked with people waiting) I went here with 2 friends on Saturday for Brunch. Such a very awesome bit of providence... Let me tell you the slightly not awesome part(s) first Hipster Haven fo sho... Parking is not the easiest. My strawberries were cut on the same board the onions were... yep. Awesome sauce follows I got the French Toast. Creme Anglaise and smothered in strawberries (slightly flavored with onion), bananas and blackberries (you read me right, BLACKBERRIES!!!) So So SO SOOSOSOSOSOSOS nomnomnomMOMNOMNOMNOM really The coffee was better than good, our waitress was helpful, I have this friend who hates eggs, but loves eggs Benedict... for realsies. The waitress worked with her to get her the breakfast she wanted. It was a little chilly in there as well. We will be back
(5)
Joe L.

The breakfast here here is alright. The food is good, but priced just a tiny bit higher than other breakfast places I have been to. I came here on a sleepy Saturday to get some brunch and take advantage of a groupon I got a while back. I got the Italian Sausage omelet with house potatoes and a biscuit, a slice of their midnight cake and a chai latte. And yes I ate ALL of it by myself. Italian Sausage Omelet: Well made with real eggs and not the stuff in containers. It was light and fluffy, with no browning on the top (indicating to me that it was properly cooked). It was filled with Italian sausages and peppers. The peppers were diced, but I felt that they weren't sautÃ©ed enough. They still kind of had a crispness to them which made it hard to cut through them in the omelet. House Potatoes: Really good. The potatoes are cut into thick slices and pan fried with strips of peppers. Delicious. properly seasoned too. I wish the peppers that came with this came with the omelet. Biscuit: was alright. I usually judge a biscuit based on how good it tastes both by itself and with the accompanying jam. The biscuit here did not stand out. The midnight cakes: moist, chocolaty, but a little too sweet. Also, 6 dollars for a slice of cake is a little outrageous. Ok, not just a little, very outrageous. Chai Tea: very very good here. Don't really know what else to say. It wasn't overwhelmingly sweet like most other chai latte's that I have had. Overall, the brunch dishes here are very decently priced for the portion size. But I felt that the cake was way overpriced.
(3)
Jared C.

Prior to a few weeks ago, although I live in the neighborhood, I've avoided this place because of their complex and unappealing menu which was stuck in the 90s (think their parent owner, Apres Diem, with decor a la Madonna's Bedtime Stories - but not quite to Cafe Intermezzo levels of garishness). That has all changed. It's quite apparent that there is an active effort to drag their otherwise really awesome, charming cafe into the 21st century. They've simplified their menu with really awesome fresh pairings (pear and gorgonzola salad, anyone? sub $8 veggie wrap? beautifully presented belgian waffle?) and it appears are updating the ambiance to remove the air of pretension and just make it a comfortable and delicious place to be. After avoiding this place for being over-done for the last several years, it's back on my radar. Good food, still great desserts, mixed drinks, espresso drinks - all reasonably priced, and a nice, comfortable atmosphere.
(5)
H. H.

Well, we've (the wife and I, the dog eats at home) visited a new place each weekend for the last few weekends. Carroll Street's number came up. Here's what I liked. There was no wait. The service was quick. The coffee wasn't bad, not the best I've had but worth ordering. Coffee used to be cheap, but now it's $2-3 per person. ( Le Petite March & Rise-n-Dine have better coffee). Having said that, it was a little tough to get a refill. The food portions were substantial. We left satiated. Back to the no wait. If I were standing in line at one of the other usual breakfast establishments, I'd quickly run over here and grab breakfast.
(3)
Desiree G.

I came here on a Sunday afternoon as an obvious out-of-towner. My best friend's brother claimed that this was the spot for brunch. Now, I am very biased when it comes to brunch. Everyone thinks they can do it, but not everyone can do it well. So, I'm hungover, thirsty and starving and I'm not sure what kind of orange juice they use but it was THEE BEST! I literally ordered about 4 of them. I was upset that they don't serve alcohol on Sunday's in Atlanta until AFTER 12 PM but I didn't need much of anything after that orange juice. Moving along, I order the crabcake benedict which was delicious! It came with a side of grits and fresh fruit. The portion was that of any southern restaurant - extremely filling and HUGE. Plus, no one looked at me weird for wearing sunglasses at the table. Yeah, I'd return there.
(5)
Dalora S.

Heard lots of good things about it, so when things immediately went awry I thought, "Maybe today's an off day. I'll try again soon." But after the food came out cold and season-less with items missing and the waitress said the chef forgot and it would be 20 minutes to provide the item, if the kitchen staff were WILLING to go get it, the salt and pepper shakers were filled with water... But this was just a perfect storm of a bad dining experience that I wouldn't want to risk again because "fool me once..." WELL, I was fooled twice. Gave Carroll Street Cafe' another try and it was worst than the first. Our server was nowhere to be found, service overall was slow, and food was room temp when it finally arrived. I have to admit that the Bloody Mary made it all better, so 2 stars remain.
(2)
Damien B.

I have been here twice for dinner and it was good both times. My only complaint was the calimari. It was not even close to being fresh and it was really overcooked. I am not sure if it came overcooked out of the bag so it is hard to really judge the skill of the kitchen from it. But if one dish out of 10 is just not good i think that is pretty good odds. The dish was not so bad it would make you ill or just walk out but you would not want to ordre it again I am sure. Both times the service was good exceptable, you know they brought the food and drinks but were not very nice or informative and maybe slow at times. I really do like the space though. It has a charm and warmth to the place I think is great for a nice dinner.
(4)
Gianna R.

I really missed this place of all my local spots that I used to go... I used to live around the corner and we would go here for lunch or dinner every other day.. My trip to Atlanta was short this time and could only make it in for Breakfast and this would be only the 2nd time I have had Breakfast here and it was very good, not as good as there lunch or dinner but I am partial.... But it was great I had the Cajun Shrimp and Grits and it was YUMMMMMMMM And you have to get a More Mosa its a delicious Super Sized Mimosa with nice fresh squeezed juice.... I love the vibe here and love the food.... Do yourself a favor and check it out....
(5)
Ivan S.

Situated in a formerly shady neighborhood far from the things of man? Just off a hard-to-navigate two way street barely wide enough for a Segway? Hit by a damned tornado?! Nothing seems to stop Carroll Street Cafe and, let's face it, that's a good thing. I've said it previously but it still applies here, Carroll Street is a hipster, boheme eatery in the same vein as its siblings, the Diem twins. In other words, it's shabby chic with interiors distressed, wine drinkers possessed, and servers with great breasts. The menu is sandwich driven with a selection of bistro-inspired entrees. The tapas fad took its liberties with the food long ago and still rears its ugly head, but mostly on the "specials"chalkboard. That said, mostly they're ok, but the mussels app is the standout. The food is much heartier than at Apres Diem and I, as a good eater, appreciate that. (No stinkin' $8 plates of tempeh and carrot sticks for me.) This all carries over to brunch which too often I forget they have but really ought to remember more. As with any hipster joint, Carroll Street has different themed music nights, DJs with cutesy pop culture-inspired names spinning their latest mashups. Sometimes this may interfere with a desire for intimate conversation, so just be aware. One of the worst things about visiting Carroll Street isn't the fault of the cafe, but the actual street itself. It's a narrow little thing that inconceivably still all traffic both ways. Top that off with off-the-street parking and the get a taste for the Cafe's Euro-style of life before you even get out of the car. This ain't no SUV-friendly, convenient AMERICAN road, I tells ya and unless you're comfortable with parallel parking, you may need to practice some before that big date, Hot Shot. Finally a star to Carroll Street Cafe alone for having a specialty drink named after the legendary Mr. Billy Ocean (see pic.) Oh Billy, what ever happened to you? Did you return to your Caribbean Queen? Is she an easy lover? Did you finally hear a sad song to make you cry? Or perhaps the going got tough, so you, as a tough person, got going? Billy, don't be a hero, come back and share one of your namesake drinks with us. Show us there's no better motion than Billy Ocean. So with that, 4 musical stars for the Carroll Street Cafe. That should be enough to prompt you to drive over to visit. That said Dear Yelper, get out of my dreams and into your car.
(4)
Tim D.

Food was good, the place was kind of creepy! Felt like a place you would find Harry Potter back in the back room with a couple of witches!
(2)
Robert G.

Went on Monday which is $5 tapas night. Very good food, try the scallops! Our server was friendly but didn't seem super knowledgeable about the menu. If I had been on full price night (some tapas are $11 normally) I would definitely have expected a little more from our server. But for $5 bucks I couldn't complain!
(5)
Saffie Muna J.

Great place for a date night - simply love the food and the martinis are awesome- Saffie Muna Jeter
(5)
Tom S.

I like this place very much. I have eaten here for several years. I visited Carroll St. tonight with some folks that live across the street. I had the basil noodle bowl and the veggies burger. Everything was really great and I hope to go back soon. It made me happy.
(4)
David J.

I was over expecting and Carrol Street CafÃ© undelivered this weekend. I was looking for a dog-friendly restaurant with a patio and decided to try this place after reading online that this place met my criteria. I already knew that parking in Cabbagetown is a challenge because of the narrow streets. So this was no big deal, and in the morning there was ample street parking. However, the first thing I noticed was that the patio furniture was cheap wobbly metal with no umbrella above us. Given the constant pop-up showers in Atlanta having a proper umbrella is important. Fortunately there was no rain the morning we were there; but for a sit-down restaurant, I expected better patio furniture. Maybe there is some concern about property theft that is causing the lack of investment in better patio furniture. The food was hit or miss. The Egg Meurette were delicious, the grits were average, the Belgian Waffle was ok, but the coffee was disgusting. Also, there was a strand of hair in my eggs. I should have complained then, but did not want to burn any more of my Saturday so I kept quiet. For the price I was not overly satisfied. It is unlikely that I will be repeating my visit any time soon.
(3)
Dave T.

I've been here three or four times for breakfast. The food has been good, other than a miss this morning. But, adding to the really poorly done "bacon benedict" this morning, the service which is always pretty much distant, we'll get around to it and oh, you wanted me to respond as person to you being a person?, was non-existant this morning. Adding insult to injury, the server decided that keeping sixty cents in change was the right thing to do. I tip pretty good, today I was kicking myself for scrounging for change to give a 20% tip including the money the server kept. I should have left the sixty cents the server decided to keep and called it a morning. Each time I've been at the restaurant, there are fewer people, I'm beginning to think there is a reason that I've unfortunately experienced.
(2)
Paul S.

Gotta love me some Cabbagetown.... The quieter sister of Apres Diem sits on Carroll St (hence) in Cabbagetown. If you can navigate your way down the "two way" street that is Carroll St. you'll find this little cafe quite amazing. I've been a few times for dinner and I've never been let down, but recently we've discovered their lunch/brunch menu. This is where it's at people! Crab Cake Benedict for $9! NINE DOLLARS! Most places in Atlanta are gonna charge you at least $12+... AND it's great! You can sub out smoked salmon or bacon as well for the same price. If you ask me, which if you're reading this I guess you are, I'd stick with the homemade crab cakes. Try the Egg Meurette also for more of an earthy and rich way to start your day. With a port bacon demi glaze and a fresh home made biscuit this dish was also quite stellar. The mussels, pasta dishes, and desserts at night are also delicious. I want to come back and try the tapas. We've come a few times like I mentioned and never had a bad meal. They support local art, and have specials all the time. It's extremely cute and the restaurant's vibe is both relaxed and a little hipster chic. It gets a little dark and dare I say a tad romantic at night so it makes for a great date place.
(4)
Tamera B.

We came here a couple of weeks ago for brunch. Location/space is cool. Service left much to be desired. Waitress seemed uninterested. Menu had some items that sounded delicious. My first order was the croissant sandwich but she came back to say they were out of croissants. OK. So I went with a basic breakfast plate - sausage, eggs, grits, etc. My boyfriend had the pancakes. I've made far better breakfasts many times. Nothing special at all. And like someone else previously mentioned, the eggs were a dirty yellow. wtf? What really grabbed our attention - or who - was the girl at the bar area near the kitchen. I'm guessing she was making drinks...really not sure what she was doing besides being a walking No-No. First, I caught her absentmindedly moving to wipe her nose but she caught herself and did the fake-out. Then she dropped two small plates that made a lot of racket because they were doing wheelies before they landed (eating side down) on the filthy floor. She picked them up and put them on the counter. We looked at each other. And waited. I had my left eye on those plates....where would they end up? They should've never made it to the counter. After a few minutes, she put them both back on top of the pile of clean plates. Completely grossed out. I highly doubt I'll be venturing back to this one, there are far too many great brunch places in Atlanta to spend my time and money on something so mediocre with servers who don't seem to now basic food safety skills.
(2)
Katie C.

So my friend and I came here before that awesome Braves game against the Mets (13-1 baby!) to grab brunch with our scoutmob deal. We originally sat outside but the flies, the looming clouds, and the fact that we asked the waitress for coffee twice without getting it, made us ask to be moved inside. Should have taken the hint that this quick brunch was going to take forever because of the slooooooow service. It took a good 15 minutes to even be acknowledged, but once we got our giant mugs of coffee (which I appreciated) we just needed to make a decision on what to eat. Everything looked soooo good it was really hard to make a decision. We both ordered the turkey croissant sandwich, he got potatoes and I got jalapeÃ±o cheese grits. I was really surprised that the coffee was so incredibly bitter. I don't like adding sugar to my coffee but I must have dumped a couple tablespoons in there to take the edge off. The grits were OK, nothing I couldn't make at home and not nearly as good as Flying Biscuit. The menu didn't specify that the eggs were on the side, I thought they would be on the sandwich (and now that I think of it, if the eggs weren't on the sandwich the waitress should have asked how we wanted them cooked- which didn't happen). Instead they were scrambled on the side, nice and dry and brown (/sarcasm). I couldn't take one bite because they were so overcooked and dry, they should have put them on the sandwich to cover up the poor cooking skills. The sandwich itself was really messy and soaked in the bechamel sauce. I couldn't taste anything else the sauce was so overpowering. Oh, and a wonderfully helpful tip I wish someone would have told me: Don't sit under the A/C duct because the condensation drips and it was dripping all over me and the table and (hopefully not, but probably) the food. I would recommend Wahoo! Grill for brunch instead of here- better food, better service, great price and no stray drops from the ceiling in your food.
(2)
Angela F.

Tucked away in the city, this little gem made me sparkle with delight as my visit became more and more enchanted. The very "Friends" and "Cheers" atmosphere made me feel right at home. The rough, but cheery, decorations made me feel tucked away in a privately owned bookstore. Lots of couches to get comfortable, tables lined along the wall with throw pillows across the booth. Love it! I ordered something simple, French toast with fresh fruit, eggs, and bacon. I think they should have mentioned what kind of fruit they were putting on my toast because I'm allergic to bananas. No biggie...pushed the slivers off to the side before they settled in. Everything was fantastic! From the food (despite the poisonous peel) to the service to the ambience, everything was magical. Even my picky companion enjoyed his meal which I believe was a fretta? I'm not too sure since I was devouring my meal. Either way I can see myself coming back and making this place a part of my daily routine once I move back to the city.
(4)
Mike L.

Versatile atmosphere, being fitting for both breakfast and dinner, was a breath of fresh air compared to most diners I'd run across. Breakfast was tasty, though, fair warning, they make it a standard of adding jalapeÃ±o to their grits. Not overly spicy, but does have a bite when you're not expecting it. All told, definite dining experience, its being affordable was a nice surprise compared to many Atlanta cafes.
(5)
Richard S.

Very nice neighborhood bar/eatery. Surprisingly varied menu with small bites - tapas and such all the way to steaks and seafood meals. But also THE best dessert menu in the zip code. Best bet is to drive over to Cabbagetown find some street parking a block or two from Carrol Street and walk over. Enjoy the "intown" scene not typical of the 404 - decorated porches, neighbors walking and jogging here and there. Then grab a table on the sidewalk in front of Carrol Street Cafe and watch the world go by with a cool refreshing beverage and some conversation.
(5)
Attaicus C.

Got seated pretty quickly we sat outside. It was a lot people here,on memorial day I guess that explain the slow service. I ordered the shrimp and grits which was 10.95 for this small Harry Potter bowl with 5 seasoned shrimp on top of cheese and creamy jalepeno grits. I personally feel its way overpriced for the amount of food you get. It also came with a biscuit which taste just like a McDonald's biscuit. My friend got he Belgian waffle with bacon n eggs. It was OK nothing to write home about. Overall this place is more Foo Foo over good food quality. I have eaten brunch at much better places with better food that match up with the price. Don't get me wrong I don't mind paying for food even if expensive but it got to be worth it.
(1)
Kathryn J.

Great coffee, lovely tapas, nice prices in a charming, European style neighborhood cafe. Service was excellent and the staff is uncommonly attractive. :-)
(5)
Joey Flash A.

My parents were in town so we hit up Carroll Street Cafe for Sunday brunch. We expected to have a long wait, but were able to get a table for four on the sidewalk right away. It was a little bit chilly that morning, but still there's no better way to experience this Cabbagetown classic. The server, who was decked out in what could easily have been the latest Urban Outfitters collection, was very friendly, got us set up with coffees and teas and didn't rush us to order as we were chit-chatting - you know how it is when you haven't seen your folks for several months - a LOT to talk about. Anyway. We decided on entrees. Our server took our order without writing anything down, which seemed kind of risky, but I think she nailed it. She must be on ginkgo biloba or something. I had some sort of benedict with rockstar sautÃ©ed spinach and potatoes that was very GD tasty, but when I saw everyone else's grits I was kicking myself for choosing potatoes. Next time, grits, next time... As the sun's angle changed we warmed up considerably and had a wonderful time together. Great food in a great atmosphere, watching people walk dogs and traffic negotiate the tiny passage of Carroll Street and sharing good conversation.
(4)
Ettore M.

visiting atlanta again, i love all the cool restaurants and quaint neighborhoods that house them. dined at one of my favorite restaurants on carroll street in cabbagetown tonight. monday night $5 tapas. love my tapas. tonight we enjoyed crab cakes, grilled shrimp with plantains, sea scallops, veggie pizza, tuna tartar ++ cozy atmosphere & great staff. tomorrow back to krog bar in inman park for more tapas. it is located in the parking lot of rathbun steakhouse owned by chef kevin rathbun. so cool. looking forward to starting with white anchovy & artichoke toast, seared duck & figs, brie & local honey. yummy. good eating ettore chef & owner chez vous caterers
(5)
Dustin B.

I ate at Carroll Street Cafe for the first time this week. While I've heard great things about the breakfast at CSC, I ended up there for a business lunch. I went into CSC a bit frustrated because the parking situation is a hot mess; however, the atmosphere put me at ease. We had the Avocado Shrimp Cocktail for an appetizer. Shrimp. Avocado cut in half with a sauce in the middle. Cucumber and tomato slices. Oh my! It was amazing. I had the Greek Salad topped with chicken, which was delicious. I ordered extra Feta, and I have to say that if what I received is extra then I'd hate to see the amount of Feta that regularly comes on the Greek Salad. Even so, overall, it was a fun and enjoyable experience. I will definitely go back to Carroll Street Cafe.
(4)
Becky J.

This is our go-to for weekend brunch and I love it. With that said, I can only speak to the brunch experience. I love their food, their service and their sidewalk tables. It's a quiet street where we can sip our coffee, read our paper and eat our pancakes, fruit and oatmeal. I've eaten inside a few times and it's very nice. But the dessert display is WAY too tempting for me, so I prefer to sit outside! :) It's a small restaurant but we've never waited for a table and we've never had bad service. The parking is pretty bad sometimes since it's a very tight two-lane street but other than that, it's a perfect little brunch spot.
(5)
Christin K.

I only visited because it was in walking distance to my friend's house, who wanted to go because 'my gf won't go with me because she thinks its too hipster'. LOL. Upon entering, its very cute, home-y. The servers don't have designated outfits, this was interesting because I saw one girl who turned out to be a server who I thought we could almost see her birth canal. Anyway, I like the vibe, and we sat ourselves in a corner. I wasn't too hungry, so I had the almond brie appetizer. I'm not a cheese aficionado but it was pretty delicious. Brie, heated, with almond glaze with a baguette and fruits (cantaloupe, grapes, etc). The almond glaze turned out to be a little too sweet at the end, but I really enjoyed it. However, I had a good chunk of brie left with no baguette, asked for another, did not realize its a dollar for the tiny baquette. O.o lesson learned. My friend had a turkey burger (dry), with fries. He kept asking the server what size the fries were, all she could do is shrug and say medium. Compared to McDonald's fries? 'I don't know, I've never been to McDonald's.' oh. hm.. Only because we prefer skinny fries. Tad bit condescending. Other than this, the cakes all looked delicious. I can't wait to go back and try them. Overall, personally wouldn't make it a destination unless I'm already here (er parking), Desserts look fantastic, so did the girl who showed them to me- super cute in a tegan and sara kind of way.
(3)
Todd L.

My wife and I dine here frequently for brunch. We usually visit here once every weekend. We enjoy the food and the coffee. They literally serve the best coffee in Atlanta. i have eaten once for dinner and it was good. The only negative to this place is the service. It is very slow. The servers typically stand around with the appearance of always being hung over or lacking sleep. They are very friendly, but you have to always wave your hand if you need something. Regardless of the service, we still enjoy visiting this place. I would definitely recommend it for brunch. Our favorite items on the menu are the lox and the soy sausage omelette.
(4)
Sherry W.

Carroll Street Cafe is a cute indie/hipster-decorated coffee shop that blends in with the rest of Cabbagetown's ambiance. It's located on a ridiculously narrow street with ample seating inside, and some seating outside. Inside is peaceful and optimal for studying or chatting with friends. Can't comment on the food cause I've never gotten any, but the coffee drinks are good.
(4)
arlene d.

I went here when they first opened and thought it was pretty good liked the atmosphere better than the food decided to give it another try and did not like it as much. I had a really hard time deciding on an entree. Was not feeling like a sandwich which they have plenty of. Went with the noodle bowl it was just ok nothing special . Also had a greek salad which was good. The prices were very reasonable. Sounds from others better choice for breakfast or brunch . Parking can be pretty tricky too
(3)
Ben D.

Tasty brunch with tasty, potent cocktails. The street is tighter than gnat booty, so when it's busy and people park on both sides of the street, it can be challenging logistically. I just usually pay a homeless person to shit on their windshield, so it's no big deal.
(4)
Rose G.

Last night was my first visit to the Caroll Street Cafe and it will be my last. I went there with a friend at his request for his birthday dinner. I wish he would have picked just about any other restaurant in all of Atlanta! There were multiple issues with my and my friend's dining experience last night. While there was nothing tragically wrong with dinner last night, there were too many things that were not quite right. For example, the service was OK, the waitress, who's name I don't know because she never introduced herself, basically abandoned us after taking our entree order. I had a glass of wine with dinner and water as well, in the hour and a half we were there, she refilled my water glass a total of once. Not tragic, but not right either. Now, on to the food.... which took FOREVER to get after the appetizers.... the table next to us was served before us and they got there long after we did! (more about them further down in my review) My friend and I shared an appetizer of hummus and a tapas plate of flank steak. The hummus tasted, and looked, as if someone had simply scooped it out of a container of hummus from Kroger. The pita toast was stale and not warm, it was also not toast, it was crunchy.... more like a cracker and it was not seasoned at all. The flank steak was a disappointment as well... chewy, not tender like they make it at Top Flr. While my friend enjoyed his entree (Tortellini and Chicken), my Salmon Linguine was simply pitiful. It had clearly been left under a heat lamp for quite some time as the "grated" cheese that was on top of my pasta had melted into a congealed lump. The salmon perched on top of the linguine was dried out from the heat lamp and it was a dry, over cooked chore to eat. To add insult to injury, the menu made zero mention of any heat in the "garlic -pesto cream" sauce. I was quite taken aback by the lingering heat of red pepper flakes in the sauce. I dislike any kind of heat in my food, so even that small amount essentially ruined any chance of enjoying my dinner. This last thing has nothing at all to do with the Cafe or its staff, instead it's a heads up to the crass people who interrupted my and my friend's dinner last night... No, idiot, it is NOT ALRIGHT to ask perfect strangers to interrupt their own meal so that you can sit with friends that you had either been late meeting or had just run into... the proper thing to do is to move YOUR party to another location in the restaurant that is spacious enough to accommodate all of YOU. Oh, and another thing, if you don't know someone, and you've never even been introduced, it is (again) NOT ALRIGHT to touch that person. KEEP YOUR HANDS TO YOURSELF! All in all, it was an awful (and expensive) mess of an experience and one that I shan't repeat again. Birthday or not.
(1)
Darren H.

Sat Morning 4/11/09 For as long as I've been in Atlanta this has been my first introduction to Cabbagetown. Drove out of my way to get there after reviewing some of the other posts about this place, it reminds me of the funky little spots in the village (NYC). Strolled in for breakfast and the wait staff was very attentive and the portions were huge. My girlfriend and I couldn't finish everything. We are waiting for the weather to warm up a bit to hang out there outside. I highly recommend it as a cool, laid back place with good food.
(4)
Atl C.

Hands down my favorite spot in the ATL for both brunch and dinner. Foods awesome, cheap, and the atmosphere is great.If you don't like this, then check yourself first :)
(5)
Kevin L.

Okay, really. How cute is Carroll Street CafÃ©? Pretty darn cute, I say. This seems to be a recurring theme with Cabbagetown businesses. Considering the spate of beautiful weather I happened to bring into Atlanta during my brief few-day stint there, we figured we'd take advantage of it as much as possible by finding a pleasant patio to park ourselves on (and it seems like everyone else who lives ITP did, too). The special challenge with seating at CSC is that it's first-come-first-serve, so get there early, and/or apply our approach of hovering until someone leaves. Bwahaha. After having had a burger for lunch, and prepping for a planned fried chicken feast the following day, it seemed reasonable to lean toward a slightly healthier dinner option here. Offering a varied assortment of stellar-sounding salads, I ended up being talked into the spinach and bacon one by our helpful server. Right up my alley! Fresh, broad, crunchy spinach leaves shared the bowl with savory bacon bits, shaved almonds, and bright, juicy cherry tomatoes that burst with goodness in my mouth. Also, the bottled beer selection offered a few surprises, too. I was tempted to stick to a reliable Chimay, but when our server described the Erdinger as being light and refreshing like Blue Moon but better, I knew I had to have it. Reportedly, it's fermented in the bottle, but I didn't have the problem of sediment when I poured my crisp, golden brew into the provided glass. I spoil myself by keeping frosted beer glasses in my freezer at all times - that would have been a nice added touch. Regardless, it's hard to find fault with spending a perfect evening outside, filling up on fresh foliage, and sipping a cold one... all in the presence of great company.
(4)
Bobbin W.

After several recent Carroll Street Cafe experiences, I've decided that I loathe the dinner options but like the brunch fare. My sister and I rushed to to this Apres Diem offshoot in search of a dessert, disappointed by the Kroger-like quality of our turtle cheesecake. After the nausea set in, we decided to order some "real food," too: the portobello caprese and garlic button mushrooms. The portobellos were dry and overcooked; the tomatoes, pink and devoid of flavor; and the mozzarella, old. The garlic button mushrooms were better but overly oily. Our waiter, Ben, was nice. "Do you play in a band?" I asked him. "You look like the guy from Fleet Foxes." "I'm not in a band, but people ask me that all the time," he nodded. "Someone told me once that I look like the lead singer from Band of Horses, so he calls me BEN of Horses." I went back today for brunch, propelled by a Scoutmob coupon and my friend's claim that Carroll Street's breakfast offerings soar above the lackluster dinner. I had the Spicy Red Bean Chili, which came on a plate with a bowl of beans, sides of pico de gallo and fresh avocado, pita slices and another chosen side. My meal was supposed to come with two poached eggs, which the cook forgot to place on my bean bowl. When I asked about the situation, our waitress immediately brought me two hot, white globes. I would've preferred soft (not hard) pita slices, but I still enjoyed slathering them with beans. Plus, I attacked the top cheesy layer of my jalapeno grits. I would never eat dinner at Carroll Street again, but the brunch saved this place's hide. After all, it's hard to mess up breakfast.
(3)
Kevin C.

Laid back, awesome staff and foodie deliciousness. A neighborhood gem!
(5)
Russell G.

Headed to a noon brunch at Carroll's St Cafe today - first time I've been able to make it out there. Driving down Carroll street, I'm immediately taken from the dusty heat of Glen Iris and Boulevard, blink, and then immersed in what looks like English influenced portions of central or south America. The streets are half as wide, there are twice the number of messy utility lines everywhere, the paint schemes are completely off the wall, and people sell hand-made wares and eat at small 2-tops right on the small sidewalk. Brunch was simple, yet excellent. A shared order of French Toast was heaping and topped with fruit and liquefied confectioners sugar. Topped with real maple syrup and with thick toast, it was delicious. The recommended chicken sausage also had a little spice on it - a great addition. Solid potatoes with onions and peppers, nothing too fancy. Only small complaint were eggs a little over-done (had asked for over-lightly). Almost grassy/dirty coffee with a ton of flavor and refilled constantly - brunch is usually one of those "ok i'm full now let's handle the rest of the day" moments but Carroll's added an atmosphere and experience I really enjoyed along with solid fare. A great experience, and at ~$13-15 per person for a quick, tasty brunch, definitely an excellent choice in a city which has locations serving brunch every 100 yards. Will definitely go back to try some tapas and a tasty beer at some point in the future.
(5)
D L.

Went for brunch. Self-seating. Only ordered appetizers. - hummus: came w/ crispy pita, tomato slices, and American cucumber slices. Don't recommend this, hummus was an ice cream scoop of dryness. - tomato thing with goat cheese: came with a crisped baguette, but not so crispy that you scratch the roof of your mouth. Tomato sauce was slightly spicy. Very tasty dish. Would order this again. - Greek salad: good-size bowl of salad. Some olives. Really tasty feta cheese. Would order this again. - "iced" coffee: not on the menu. You mix in your own cream and sweetener syrup. Slow service. The kind of place you go to talk and talk and talk.
(3)
Laura N.

This is my new favourite brunch stop! It's tucked into the neighborhood and almost seems forgotten by everyone except for those in the know, but still keeps a steady crowd. For being owned by Apre Diem, the place has a surprisingly independent vibe about it. I have only ever been in the early afternoon and have never had a problem immediately snagging a table. Service is good and the brunch menu has a large selection, if not slightly overwhelming with all the choices.
(4)
Janet G.

I can't help but wrinkle my nose at Vanessa T.'s opening line below: "Whoever likes this place must have poor taste." No need to bring other customers into your personal review, I think. Especially THIS reviewer--for I have impeccable taste, you see. :) Seriously, though: I consider myself pretty darned picky, and I have had two great experiences here. Delicious food (my guests have always agreed), good service, and a charming little location. Sit outside if you can.
(5)
Kelly S.

3 of us headed to Carroll Street Cafe for my friend's birthday last night (after trying 2 other places in the area and finding that the wait times were freakin' insane), and I really enjoyed it. I had never been there before but have certainly read plenty about it on Yelp. We ordered booze first. They have $5 specialty cocktails on Thursdays - I got the Blackberry Leaf, and my friends got the Grace Kelly and some "Oranje . . ." drink. Mine was declared the winner . . . BIG TIME. The others were so bitter they were barely drinkable - the Oranje one because it had (presumably) too much bitters in it, and the Grace Kelly because it just tasted like club soda and DRUNK. For our appetizer, we ordered the Portabello Caprese (tomatoes, mozz, and basil) from the tapas menu. It was very yummy, but I probably won't order it again unless I'm there on half-price tapas day (Mondays?). It was pretty small (duh, tapas) and I didn't quite feel it was worth the price. When the server arrived to take our order, I still hadn't decided, because everything on the menu looked fantastic - so in a split-second decision, I chose the Panoramic Veggie sandwich. It was quite tasty, although I should learn that if I don't like something (in this case, olive tapenade), no matter how much I try to mind over matter it, that item is going to have a negative impact on the flavor of my food. But it was still good, with the hummus, cucumbers, pepperoncinis, tomatoes, etc. And the baguette it came on was PERFECT. BTW, the side salad they serve with the sandwiches (yay for health!) is AWESOME. It's basically just a little pile of weeds, but the dressing on it's DELICIOUS. It is very harsh (acidic), though, so if you prefer lighter-flavored/sweeter dressings, you might not enjoy it much. For dessert, we had a piece of dark chocolate cake with white chocolate icing, and my 2 friends split the brie app. I really dislike brie, but they were making all kinds of orgasmic sounds, so I'd put my money on it not sucking. The cake was perfect - not fancy, but moist and delicious. Service was friendly and attentive, if not quick. But I was enjoying soaking up the atmosphere, and chowing down like I just got released from prison, so I didn't mind waiting a bit. At least we didn't have to wait to sit down! The decor is warm and inviting, and there's an AWESOME illuminated palm tree (real tree, just with lighting) across the street that looks so darn pretty at night, especially nestled between the delightful remodeled Cabbagetown duplexes. Parking's a huge pain in the rear. That's all I can really say about that.
(4)
Alexa G.

Great spot for late night drinks and dessert! Can't bump it up to 4 stars since I only had some cake, but I look forward to my next visit there for lunch or dinner. I got the chocolate truffle cake and boooyyy was it rich and dark ( Just how I like my men..jk) The ambiance was very low key, dark, and smokey (If that's not your thing). Who knew this little place was tucked back there on those narrow streets.
(3)
Russell L.

I've been here a few times for meals and everything has been very good. But, I'm writing because Carroll Street is now my new place for after dinner dessert and coffee! It was amazing and close to home. I've added a photo. $2.25 for coffee and $5 for cake.
(4)
Dru M.

I love Cabbagetown and Carroll Street Cafe is a great addition. My boyfriend and I went for brunch today and enjoyed it. He ordered the brie appetizer, which he loved. I'm no a huge brie fan, but thought it was good. The portion size was huge...great value. I went with the turkey burger and he opted for pancakes. My meal came with a side salad and fruit...both very fresh and tasty. My burger was dry though. The meat was cut in half, which made me think that the cook was making sure it was cooked all the way, yet he overcooked it. The waitress didn't ask how I wanted it cooked either. Overall...food was fair this time, but I've had better...so I'll be back. Service was great, as always.
(3)
Keitha D.

I had heard alot about this place but had never made my way over there until this special guy decided it would be the location of our first date. And it was a GREAT choice. Just dark enough to be intimate and just loud enough to be fun and hip, I was immediately engaged by the atmosphere and cool location. The waitresses weren't pushy at all as we sat and chatted for a while without even ordering and they just let us be. I had a great adult beverage--the Grace Kelly which was made with perfection. For dinner I had the Seafood Penne as did the gentleman who dined with me. It was delish! Full of shrimp and mussels (i opted to eliminate the salmon) and very filling. I've heard their brunch is great so can't wait to go back and try it. I'll let you know how that goes :-)
(4)
Mariana R.

Due to the fact that I am obsessed with Cabbagetown and currently looking into moving there I am always in the area looking at places. This is how I got to the cutest block ever and Carroll Street cafe happens to be in it. I went there when the staff was in between shifts so it took a little while to be acknowledged but once that happened service was pretty much prompt and attentive. The food was good definitely nothing out of the extraordinary, it was edible but I don't think I would order any of that again I had some overly creamy pasta and some soup that were just okay, the desserts looked good but I didn't have any because I don't think the meal settled very well in my stomach. I might go back to the bar especially if indeed move to the area.
(3)
Jenn D.

I remembering going here for brunch a few years back and *really* enjoying myself. I finally got a chance to go back and see if it was all a dream, or if it was truly awesome. This time I went with a group of friends and shared some drinks and tapas. It was the first night of a Scoutmob deal, so it did take some time to get a seat, but drinks from the bar helped the wait. Service was awesome, really nice waitstaff. One person who helped us had only been there a week, but still was able to answer all of our questions. Also, I'm totally inspired by all the awesome clothing in the place...do your servers get/give fashion tips, too? Excellent choices - Kobe Meatballs (stuffed w/goat cheese!) and escargot Good choices - shrimp basil noodle bowl - pretty oily (gah, I think I need to start ordering stuff "easy on the oil", I feel like everything is drenched in it lately...), but still good flavors. One piece of shrimp still had the tail attached. My wine helped me ignore that non attention to detail. Avoid it - Pizza Margherita, whoa, we were bummed about that. Boring little thing. With the wine, atmosphere and great service it was a wonderful night out with friends, and we plan to do it again soon.
(4)
Barath B.

Went here for brunch with some friends. I ordered the huevos rancheros - it was the most bland tasting food I have ever eaten. Really mushy and gross. Our personal table waitress was great but when she wasn't around, we summoned another waitress and asked if we could have some hot sauce. She offered Tabasco or Sriracha. When I asked if I could have both, she said "well you're an asshole." Are you kidding me? Is that the way you treat your patrons at a place of business? FAIL. NEVER GOING BACK. Is there a way to give zero stars?
(1)
Susan H.

Totally hipster spot but the best desserts! And great little after hours spot! Definitely worth a try for dessert!
(4)
Rob C.

Stopped in for brunch during the Chomp & Stomp a couple weeks ago. Overall somewhat unimpressed, though that may be the result of high expectations from everyone else's reviews. Pros: - Food was definitely good. Nothing out of this world, but certainly better than average. - Atmosphere is relaxed - really does have a coffee house vibe that other places struggle to manufacture. Outside tables looked great, basking in the cool autumn sun. Cons: - Service was a bit sub-par, but I didn't expect much. Am I the only one who had noticed the relationship between perceived coolness of neighborhood and general crappiness of service in Atlanta? I swear it makes me want to drive OTP sometimes. Of course I don't, but I like to think that I could. - Price was WAY too high for a breakfast. $10 for some chili and 2 poached eggs??? Isn't there a recession going on? You can definitely find better food at a much better price elsewhere in the city.
(2)
Lydia L.

Great. I love most things about Carroll Street Cafe: the neighborhood, the decor, the food (of course), the wine menu, and yes, the desserts. My only complaint was that service is slow during the lunch rush (excessively slow). Lots of options, even for the picky eater. If you're in the area, stop for food!
(3)
Steve T.

I was torn between 3 and 4 stars, but going for 4 stars as this is my favorite neighborhood restaurant. Everything I've had here is great, the service is friendly, atmosphere casual but cozy, and the pricing is really reasonable. Parking is tight over there but I'm hearing they have valet now? Breakfasts are great, too - usually not as crowded as the regular breakfast places in our hood.
(4)
Steve D.

I've dated a few women who really liked this place. For the life of me I can see nothing about it worth while. It is great if you are looking for a crampted, euro-trash feel. Food is given in small, over priced portions, that are not close to being tasty. If you want a mixed drink, by all means, sit at the bar. The wait staff have no clue as to what any term( such as tall) means. Faux Euro-trash for in town snobs that don't know better. Staff is very nice though!
(1)
Mona P.

I purchased a tapas book recently and have been fascinated by the number of squid dishes possible in the Spanish food fare. So I was extremely excited to try the chorizo stuffed squid, but sadly they had run out. Turns out, Monday is $5 tapas night and the place gets a hoppin' and favorites sell out, leading to a second denial of the lamb sliders tapa. Not all is lost. I did get to try quite a few other dishes. Calamari- First time I have had non-fried calamari and it was pretty tasty. The baguettes on the side served well to sop up the jalapeno-garlic broth the calamari was swimming in. It was good, not great. Kobe meatballs- Apparently the meatballs are stuffed with goat cheese. I was imagining a nice creamy glob of goat cheese in the center but I assume it was blended in with the meat. It was seasoned well and tasted fine. . .just less imaginative than I was expecting. Pizza Margherita- I enjoyed the crust of the pizza- thin and crispy. Lobster Risotto- The risotto comes with a cream sauce which I thought was a bit too heavy on the cream. The first bite was great but after a couple more bites I was over the heavy-hand of cream which overpowered the other flavors in the dish. Slow-roasted pork belly- Tasty and tender as pork belly should be. Paired with Erdinger beer on a cozy side street made for a pleasant evening. I thought the food was good but not great, although I plan to return to try the chorizon stuffed squid. Plus, it's a great deal to go on Monday, just make sure to venture over earlier in the evening.
(3)
Shamalien S.

service was very slow and the food came out ice cold.
(2)
M D.

The food is pretty good, tho not great. The desserts are excellent. But the food isn't the big draw here -- it's the delightful, cozy, intimate atmosphere in a great funky neighborhood. Completely charming. Also: very attractive (and nice, and competent) hipster waitstaff. A pleasant place to be, all around.
(4)
ATL n.

An awesome neighborhood spot. When I first moved here, my mom came to visit to set me up and such -- and we were looking for a local spot with some healthy lunch options (as great a southern food is, we were just dying for salad that was close-by and fresh). Carroll Street was a great discovery. We split a tuna tartare which was an incredible surprise, quite gourmet really and looked around only to decide my move to Atlanta was a very, very good thing. Love this place and hope to return for a few hours of studying over several course snacks that end in wine, inshallah
(4)
Margaret M.

The good... Carroll St. encourages that sensuous exquisite heavenly calm of being back in Europe. TIP.. I like to go on stormy nights when it seeps of intimacy. The bad... The subordinate relationship one must endure with navigating Cabbagetown's clotted backstreets for parking.
(4)
Rob P.

Good location.
(3)
Timber W.

Last night, my sister and I were in the mood to eat something sweet...or so we thought. When we arrived a Carroll Street Cafe, we went straight to the dessert case. We both ordered the turtle cheesecake, which was really good, but we regretted ordering only dessert about halfway through our respective slices and asked for carry out boxes. Sick but not full, we decided to peruse the tapas menu. On the suggestion of our server, we ordered the garlic button mushrooms and the portabella caprese. I wasn't impressed with either of the dishes. I thought the garlic button mushrooms, cooked in butter and garlic and served with bread, were much too peppery, but I was most disappointed with the caprese. I tried to cook a portabella with some spinach, red peppers, and mozzarella once before with disastrous results. What we ordered tasted much like my attempt. The portabella was overcooked and a little too tough. The mozzarella did not taste fresh, and the tomatoes didn't seem ripe enough. Aside from the food, I was disappointed with the service. Our server was really nice but largely negligent. After we ordered our dessert and sat down, we weren't offered any beverages. When the slices arrived, my sister ordered a drink, but before I could request one, the server walked away. I had to wait until her drink was delivered to order mine. We also waited patiently for the server to return when we were finished with our dessert. I kept trying to make eye contact, but it was useless. Finally, I had to walk up to the server to ask for carry out boxes and order more food. I don't think I've ever had to do that...anywhere...and because I don't want to repeat that experience, I won't be returning.
(3)
Courtney R.

How is it that I continue to find places that I frequent that I have yet to review? Proof I'm forgetful. With that said, Carroll Street Cafe is a great cafe located in the heart of Cabbagetown that also can be a fun chill bar to hang at night. Probably, it stands out most for its brunch options. I'm a fan of the Oso Grande (which basically is two poached eggs on top of toast points with spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes and a delicious sauce). I also like their Eggs Benedict that you order crab cakes with. Yum. Likely Carroll Street doesn't have the best Bloody Mary's in Atlanta, but decent enough (RIP Solstice that did have the best Bloodys). However, I would recommend getting their larger mimosas and just keep ordering them really. It makes for a nice, buzzed, brunch experience that is perfect for any Saturday/Sunday morning.
(4)
Laura C.

This place is delicious. Really really delicious. Love the calamari in jalapeno/white wine sauce. The basil pasta is also good. I'm totally going back on a Monday for $5 tapas and half-off wine bottles! It looks so cool inside at night, and during the day is plenty friendly.
(4)
Camille M.

As a resident of Cabbagetown for over three years, I thought that I should finally leave a review of this adorable little place. For a few weeks, Carroll Street has been completely swamped with people from Scout Mob coming to try out the cafe. I'm very glad that they have. However, these Cabbagetown newcomers have left some unsatisfying and overly critical reviews of such a quaint restaurant. Some of these more recent reviews by Scout Mobbers have inspired me to write one of my own. I have a soft spot in my heart for French cuisine, and I find that Carroll Street takes the time to add a little French flair to otherwise bland American cuisine. They play with flavor unlike other restaurants, and they provide many vegetarian options for people like me. All in all, I have never had a bad experience at this establishment. The service at Carroll Street Cafe is excellent. If you keep returning, the servers will remember you. All of them are very nice and pleasant. The bearded barista is one of my favorite characters here, as I see him often when I come in. He always makes delicious coffee drinks, and he's very knowledgeable. For a long time I have come to this restaurant, and I would give it 5 stars if the quality of the food that they bought for the kitchen was a little better. Including organic items on the menu and vegan desserts would be a huge improvement! You can tell that the food, sometimes, tastes a little bit cheap. All in all, Carroll Street is a wonderful experience for friends, families, and also for a date.
(4)
Ginger W.

Order the Brie appetizer. It's amazing. Sevice can be hot and cold. Parking is a problem sometimes.
(4)
Mick D.

Very eclectic menu at this Cabbagetown eatery. The food is excellent. I look forward to trying the brunch. Go and relax, have a good time, enjoy the good food. Service isn't always quick, but let me remind you that this isn't fast food. I've heard they have the best coffee in the city. (I'm not a coffee drinker, so you'll have to let me know.)
(4)
Elizabeth M.

Just met friends there for lunch for my first visit. Right away this place has great ambiance. We were there on a Tuesday afternoon and their special was half off the tapas menu. So, we tried almost everything: the lobster risotto, crab cakes, seared scallops, asparagus en croute (with goat cheese and wrapped in phillo dough, Yum!) and the portobello caprese. Very nice presentation and very tasty. Would definitely order the caprese and crab cakes again. For dessert we browsed their pastry case and decided on the cannoli cheese cake and it was amazing. Our server was very attentive and kept our club sodas filled. He was very friendly with honest food suggestions. Looking forward to going back and trying out their brunch menu! I am very happy to have discovered this little gem!
(4)
Mateo B.

Carroll Street Cafe is a bohemian-infused, New American cafe. The hand written chalk menu welcomes you as you enter into couches with tables and traditional two seating high tops. After walking off a night at The Thinking Man, I found this petit cafe with a friend during a road trip stop. The food was mostly traditional breakfast and brunch items (eggs, toast, etc.), with non traditional items (Mussels, full bar). The atmosphere is the true draw to the place. With local artists' work draped on the walls, there is a personal and eclectic vibe inside. Expect waitresses that would be kept in the back room at other restaurants, but don't mistake it for bad service. Whether it be the armpit hair or lax dress, their garb is really half the pleasure of the place.
(4)
Kathleen M.

I've always been a bit enchanted with Cabbagetown. I came to the neighborhood once in high school and it was my first experience with a "true" slightly gritty intown neighborhood, having spent most of my youth in Buckhead and Virginia Highlands, with the occasional foray into Midtown or Little Five. I loved Cabbagetown at first sight, with it's mixed residential/commercial streets, graffiti, friendly people, and in-the-process-of-being-converted lofts. It took me 10 years to return, sadly, but the wait was worth it. Bellied up to the bar at Carroll Street Cafe, I ordered a Chimay Blue from Anessa, the petite blonde behind the bar. As she poured my beer she recommended two of the new tapas dishes: artichoke bruschetta and the steak. We ordered both and I was blown away. Seriously, incredible and flavorful food that's not flashy or trying too hard: it was pretty much perfect, and I'd do it all over again in a heartbeat. While my palate was sufficiently cared for and my stomach was perfectly full, upon mentioning that I had yet to experience the midnight express my dining companion made sure to order a slice. Rich chocolate cake, smooth white chocolate icing... heaven on a plate? Methinks yes. A slice worth returning for. Carroll Street Cafe makes me want to move to Cabbagetown. It's the place I've been looking for since moving to Atlanta: a neighborhood bar that's equally perfect for a first date, the perfect spot to be a regular, where you can also bring your parents. I love it dearly, and will be sure to make the trek from Midtown a lot more often than once every 10 years. If for nothing else than the midnight express.
(5)
Ashley S.

Tuesday night was the second time I have been there (once for breakfast and now once for dinner). The food is fantastic, the servers are very nice and atmosphere is great. Parking is a hassle so be prepared and it can get kind of ahem...cozy (see loud and cramped) when they are busy. But I'll take cozy if busy means I can eat there any night of the week that I have a hankering for a stout and sammie.
(4)
Barry G.

One of my favorite places to be. Very cool location and laid back atmosphere. Local artwork, excellent food and drinks. Ask for the Kobe burger even if it's not offered. Drink a Billy Ocean or 2 then have somebody else drive you home! I've never had to abandon the trip but parking is a real concern over there. Good job I'm an artist when it comes to parallel parking!
(4)
Liz L.

omg i love this plaaaace! I had never been down Carroll Street before tonight and then I went there for dinner and now I want to move there, and I also drank their Cabbagcino, which is Cappuccino and I hope I spelled it right - it's Cappuccino with brown sugar and it's GREAT and must have about 50 tons of caffeine because I am REALLY caffeinated right now and it's 11:30 p.m. on a Sunday so that's sort of a problem. The food is super excellent there and it took me about 20 minutes just to decide what to eat which is super neat because usually I just eat the same four things all the time but there - no! There their food all sounds great and what I actually ate was excellent (the seafood pasta) and my friends had the gyros, which they said was REAL good too!! So yay for Carroll Street and Carroll Street Cafe and houses close to the street and double yay for CAFFEINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(5)
Vanessa V.

Whoever likes this place must have poor taste. The only thing they got right was the cocktail my friend ordered. We had the artichoke and ravioli tapas. HORRIBLE and over priced 'bar food'. The worst part was their Thai Beef Salad. The beef is cured as they tell you AFTER you get the salad but it is really gross raw beef that looks more like garbage. The dressing was enough to leave a bad taste in my mouth, the figs aren't fresh and the noodles are not even authentic thai noodles and I think there was some sort of Ramen seasoning on them. We had a few bites of it and pushed it aside. If you are into trashy food that you can get better at a drive through fast food joint then go for it. We went to Rosebud to get real good food after this. Oh and don't get the coffee, it is enough to make you gag. GROSS!
(1)
P J.

Good food, cool location, funky place. Great Sunday brunch.
(4)
Alicia M.

I was a little nervous about going to Carroll Street Cafe since I knew I had such a large party coming for brunch! I called ahead of time and they do not take reservations for parties during brunch but once I arrived Tim had us seated and we had enough space for my Brunch Club Gals! The food ::pause for a moment:: the food is superb x 2...I had the shrimp & grit with french toast and everything was amazing! The waitress was very attentive as well! Parking sucks but great brunch spot!
(5)
T. Shontel H.

I love this place. It's so quiet and quaint. Great for a date or dinner with friends. The bartender is generous as well! The stuffed salmon is a must try! Mmmm...good!
(4)
David D.

I went with a group of friends and must say that I had a blast. This place has a fantastic atmosphere and almost begs for deep conversations to ensue. It probably has something to do with how comfortable the place makes you feel. The local art on the wall was enjoyable and a plus because I love when a place supports the locals. It brings character and originality. I think there alcohol price tags are a little high, which made me down grade to a cappuccino...but I'm glad I did because it was well prepared and delicious. I'd say that if you are looking for a place that draws good conversation out of people...this place is a must.
(4)
James H.

Far more intimate and eclectic than its bustling sister restaurant Apres Diem, Carroll Street Cafe has a similar menu and dessert list. Art from local artists adorns the walls, frequently for sale, so between visits, the decor will often change. There's a limited "patio" area, essentially a couple of tables set up on the sidewalk, which are great for weekend brunch when you're either early or lucky enough to stake your claim. Most times we get a group to come here, I try to claim the sofa area, where a single sofa and ottoman flanks a coffee table, and our inevitable latecomers pull up a few chairs. The service is attentive, but also laid back. Back when we were listless and single, we even spent several hours of an afternoon here playing cards at a corner table. Of the food, as I mentioned Carroll Street boasts a menu very similar to Apres Diem, but the food in general seems better prepared, as if with greater care--given the traffic that Apres sees, I could certainly see their kitchen becoming a factory while Carroll Street's remaining akin to a den of artisans. Given the affordable food and intimacy of the space, Carroll Street is a great locale for a date.
(4)
Sloane S.

Met up with friends I had not seen in a while and Carroll St. Cafe was a great place to hang out for a few hours and catch up. The perfect laid-back vibe made us feel comfortable and not rushed. We never had the feeling we were keeping them from turning the table. Food was all tasty - great mussels, steak salad, creative cocktails (loved the cucumber one). Tapas menu looked good as well - will have to make it back during the week for their specials. Parking can be challenging in the neighborhood but lots of street parking is available - practice your parallel parking before you go. Don't go for the food alone - it's the location, atmosphere, staff and menu that work together to make it a great spot overall.
(4)
jeremy g.

we enjoy going to carroll street for brunch and dinner. the options are excellent. tori always (ALWAYS) get the cheese plate, which is usually heaping with 4 or 5 different types of cheeses and a generous selection of berries. i like to mix it up a little. the french toast is my favorite, but their different varieties of poached egg plates, most notably the oso grande, are definitely close runners-up. the coffee is always incredibly robust, just how i like it. we usually go with the tapas for dinner. their seared ahi tuna is good for the price and tori loves the lobster risotto. last time we visited, we shared the almond baked brie, which was wonderful. food presentation can vary, so if you're a gastro-snob, maybe this isn't the place for you. service has always been prompt and friendly and the staff does a wonderful job of making us feel welcome, even if we're not privileged enough to be included in their little gossip sessions that tend to spontaneously pop up at least once or twice each visit. far from being tacky or inconsiderate, as it would be considered at most establishments, it adds to the fun and quirky vibe that makes cabbagetown so unique -- it's appealing and appalling all at the same time. i love it!
(4)
Tracy S.

The blackened shrimp and cheese grits are awesome!!! Went this am with a Atlanta friend and my two kids and fell in love with the place ... very eclectic with friendly staff and a wonderful latte! Great place
(4)
Jeff M.

I wish I lived a little bit closer. Or I wish I could master teleportation. The name is perfectly descriptive. This is a lazy morning type of place. A neighborhood joint. But hip and alternative. The place is welcoming and warm. You stare out the window and you see houses in the neighborhood. I went for breakfast. I had the Croissant Sandwich (turkey, scrambled eggs, tomato, spinach, Swiss cheese & bechamel sauce); delicious, gargantuan, and filling. It's strange in that this sandwich energizes you and also makes you feel sleepy. For me, anyways. You can kick back here. Chill out here. I'm a fan. I should wish it were closer to home.
(4)
Anna F.

Carroll Street inspired me to start yelping again after a year-long hiatus. Yummy wines, tapas, intimate seating, candlelight... It's a super romantic spot on a cozy little street that feels worlds away from the rest of Atlanta. My favorite dish is their pork belly; their mussels in white wine sauce are also delish (although you won't find them on the menu, they're pretty much always available). Words really can't describe what an enjoyable place this is... just check it out; it's definitely worth the drive from uptown.
(5)
Thien D.

Wow! I'm in love again and it's been a long time coming. This place has it! Cute, adorable, hip, swanky, and way way cool. I didn't go here today but I did the other day and I much need to yelp about this little one. I went here to meet some of my friends the other day and I had never been in here before. I've only seen the outside because it is right down the doors from Milltown Arms. I didn't think anything of it at first, but when I stepped in those doors, I knew this place was different. This place was just this cool hang out that people wine and dine at. I sat down with my friends and started with my usually appetizer. Three individual shots of Crown and a side of Coke. Haha guys! No sharing for you. This is all mine! Without fail, of course the Crown was wonderful lol. My friends looked at me like I was a madman for getting hammered at 1:00 in the afternoon but hey! You gotta start somewhere. So after I finish my Crowns, I decide to gaze through the menu. My eyes stopped on the crab cake appetizers and crab it was. I can't tell you how long it took for it to come out because I had lost track of reality by that time. It did come out though and it was goooooooood. The plating looked very upscale but served just right in the right place and it becomes hip instead. So the crab cakes didn't fill me nor did the crown. So I order another round and back to the menu I go. I look to my friends for suggestions because one of them use to work there. I think I had the salmon Alfredo or linguine....or something like that. I can't remember lol. I do remember it was good though. Any who, we all lounged around and all had drinks for however long and enjoyed every moment of it. One of the best scenes in the US me thinks. Come if and give it a try. I'm going again this coming week when I get back to Atlanta. twitter.com/10_k
(5)
Layne B.

Every time we go here, I feel like I am somewhere in eastern europe. It has the neighborhood feel that you strive for in a city like Atlanta. A wonderful mix of every type of person of every color, nationality, and income. It has a large outdoor area; which is nice for catching up with a book and an expresso. I actually saw a guy with a goat tee and a beret, drinking an espresso and reading vonnegut; sitting next two italian guys have a heated discussion over fashion- nice. The food is very hearty and artfully prepared. We usually split our brunch because it is so big. We get the eggs benedict, and substitute the meat for soysage. The service has been impeccable every time we have been there. Which is also a rarity for Atlanta.
(4)
Lisa K.

Carroll Street Cafe serves some good food and the atmosphere is friendly. Well, maybe not friendly, exactly. More, in-group, out-group? The few times I've been here it felt like a scene in an old Western. I walk through the door and everyone looks up from their drink to size me up. Except, instead of weathered cowhands, picture a mix of yuppies, guppies and hipsters. One of them turns to me and says, "you're not from around here, are you?" Maybe it was my shoes? If you can get past that though, the food *is* good and the decor is charming. The service is average and the prices are ok. Maybe take a date here if you want him/her to think you're cool, hip, and with it.
(3)
Emily B.

So, my love for the food at Carroll Street Cafe cannot be challenged, but my last time there was less than spectacular. While it was not exactly the fault of the establishment (well, except for the way-too-close-together tables), I just had to update my review so that others may be on alert. Many of the tables at CSC line one long wall and don't have much space in-between them. Not such a big deal unless you have REALLY STRONG BODY ODOR GUY sitting right next to you. Yikes! I cannot some people cannot smell their own stink. IT NEARLY RUINED MY MEAL!!! I'm all for you naturalists and your lack of deodorant, but PLEASE have a friend check your stench status before you head out in public.
(4)
Eric W.

I am frequently at the Carroll Street Cafe. It might be because it is walking distance from my place. I only ever come here for a weekend brunch. The food is good, the portions are huge for the price, the ambiance is top notch. This is a great place to lounge around and enjoy a Sunday. I usually order the chicken hash and it is excellent. The Americano I order is made with great coffee beans and very strong. The Mimosa's are also good. Go with the "More-Mosa". The outdoor area is great for this time of year! The food is 4 out of 5 stars. The ambiance is 5 out of 5 stars. The drinks and drink prices are 4 out of 5 stars. It's in my top 10 brunch places.
(4)
Mustard Mayo I.

Pros: Good food, nice atmosphere, friendly waitstaff, dog-friendly Cons: Parking sucks It's a little gem of a place. The staff are super nice and will split the check 20 ways if you ask them to. We can bring our puppy here and sit outside on a nice day.
(4)
Minerva M.

Sweet street side spot in cozy neighborhood off the beaten path - great & yummy brunch & cabbage cappuccino's are a must after a late night - wonderful experience
(5)
Caitlin L.

I've been here a few times and I always end up with the same thing (not that there aren't other options, but again--I'm a creature of habit). Time and time again I order the panoramic veggie sandwich with the yummy side salad and fruit. The sandwich is made on French bread (that can be a bit too crunchy and had rubbed the roof of my mouth wrong once or twice) and full of provolone cheese, avocado, pepperoncini, mixed greens, and an assortment of other veggies. It is yummy!! There's obviously a reason behind me ordering it over and over again. The side salad is served with a vinaigrette dressing and always tastes super fresh. The only other thing I've tried here is their hummus. It was good, as all hummus is--I mean if you screw hummus up you probably shouldn't be in business. I definitely recommend this very cute and intimate spot tucked away in Cabbagetown.
(4)
Betty R.

Came for brunch at about 10 on Saturday, and the place was under half full. Cute space in a cute neighborhood! No one explained whether we should wait to be seated or just grab a table, but there were no signs and none of the staff seemed eager to help. So, we just parked at a table and hoped we hadn't violated protocol. After about 5 minutes, we got up and got our own menus. After another 5-10 minutes, a waiter came up and took drink orders. After another 5-10 minutes, we actually got those drinks. It was a slow start to the meal--and we weren't in a hurry or anything, but dammit, I wanted coffee, STAT! Note to all servers: most cranky customers can be made happy pronto by placing a cup of coffee or an alcoholic beverage in front of them. Food was plentiful and cheap, and it came out fairly quickly. I had the croissant sandwich with scrambled egg, turkey, cheese, spinach, and tomatoes, and everyone agreed it was the best dish of the morning. The only food-related disappointment was boyfriend's Belgian waffle, which was dry and tasteless. The strawberry butter that came with the waffle, though, was quite good. Like I said, cute place, good food, mostly happy times--but I'd be happier if the "very laid back staff" would start things off on a more attentive note. I'll forgive a lot after that, ya know?
(3)
steven c.

I have no complaints, and I left satisfied. At the same time, looking back, nothing stands out. It is certainly laid back, and I can appreciate that. It is a small space, but it was pretty full. I was amazed at the speed the food came out. In fact, I think it may have come out too fast. I went with an Entree, but I think next time I come back I'll just go with a sandwich.
(3)
Shonda K.

I really really enjoyed my meal here. The lobster risotto was delicious. The pork belly glazed with vinegar/brown sugar was delicious. I enjoyed the mushrooms. The tuna though was not all that great. It really lacked flavor. To finish it off I had a slice of coconut cake (not allowed since I have sworn off wheat) it was delicious also. The service was friendly but a little slow at times due to it being a Friday night I guess, but not too bad. Cute little spot, very cozy and laid back. Well definitely return for more of the lobster risotto. 41/2 stars!
(5)
Sarah T.

I've been living about a mile from Carroll Street Cafe for three years now, and am kicking myself for not giving it a chance sooner... Went for breakfast Sunday morning...The ambiance was right up my alley. Laid back, fun art, chalk board full of weekly specials, and coffee options. The crowd: The definition of "melting pot." Young professionals sipping mimosas, kids drinking hot chocolate, grandparents putting back water... There was gay, straight, black, brown, white, and every shade in-between. I loved the diversity! It just added to the overall ambiance. The Latte I started with wasn't the best I've ever had, but certainly not the worst. It had some kind of weird composition at the bottom that resembled a gel. Not sure if it was supposed to be there, but I stirred it in, and drank it anyway. Strong, which other yelpers warned about, but a nice way to start off my Sunday. The menu was extensive, and there were 3 or 4 options that I was drawn to...I had to "enie minie mineie moe" to decide. I ended up getting the Carroll Street Cafe Breakfast. Two eggs over easy, not too difficult. The bacon tasted just like my Mom's - since she lives 300 miles away, that is a bonus point. The breakfast potatoes were delish! They were fried with red peppers, and zucchini, and I ate every bite. A side of watermelon finished off my breakfast perfectly. The portions were large, so I really feel like you're getting every cents worth. The service wasn't overly friendly, but since we didn't have to wait for a seat, and our food came out less than 10 minutes after ordering, I really have no room to complain. Overall, I'm a big fan of Carroll Street Cafe, and I plan on giving it a go for lunch or dinner next time. Just to switch things up... I'll let you know how it goes my fellow yelpers!
(4)
Josie F.

I love Carroll Street! Been here probably 10 times and I have never had a bad experience! Delicious food, friendly service, and an adorable atmosphere. Perfect for a date, or a girls night out. Huge wine selection and a big case of fresh baked cakes, pies and treats. Must get dessert at this place! Also great deals on tapas, good portions and affordable prices.
(5)
Carlos C.

I'm sorry to drag the average star rating down but brain-dead servers are just a real pet peeve of mine. It is too bad because there is so much going for this place. Cool neighborhood. Decent food. Strong drinks. The waitstaff are good looking. Local art on the walls..and so on. But that just doesn't do it for me anymore. Any question about the menu smokes the confuser mechanism of the staff. Water refills take an eternity. Food shows up before drinks. I can't take it any more. Me: What types of muffins do you have today? CSC. Cranberry and Apple. Me: Great, I will have a cranberry muffin. CSC: (30 minutes later) Here's your banana muffin. Me: I ordered a cranberry muffin. CSC: We don't have cranberry muffins. Me: Oh, bummer - maybe next time. CSC: Do you want me to wrap that for you? Me: No, I don't care for banana muffins. CSC: Then why did you order it? Me: I didn't. CSC: Yes you did, I wrote it here my pad..See "c. muff". Me: Exactly CSC: Exactly what?! Me: Banana starts with a "B". CSC: I am aware of that. Me: Could you just remove it from my check please? CSC: But I have already unwrapped it, are you sure you don't want it. Me: So you unwrapped it, then walked over to ask me if I want it wrapped? CSC: What's your point? Me: Just the check please. I'm getting too old for this crap.
(2)
Lori G.

First it's the ambiance that gets you, an easy bohemian vibe, with rotating art shows, but it doesn't end there. The food has always rated from above average to spectacular, when I tried their special of seared scallops. The hipster servers know their way around the menu and can answer any questions. The libations are refreshing and it's cozy hanging out in the lounge area. Great sidewalk seating too and perfect for people watching.
(5)
Lloyd B.

The place is really nice, but the food is OK. I've been there twice now and each time left thinking the food could've been better. Although the vegan chocolate raspberry cake was delicious!
(3)
Tina L.

Tucked into the folds of Cabbagetown, this hipster cafe reminded me of Austin, TX. I went in search of a quick lunch and they definitely delivered. In my short visit, I even went back again because I had to try out their brunch (narrowly missed the first day around). I was a bit concerned when I saw such a huge variety of offerings on the menu, but Carroll Street Cafe definitely delivered. There was also an amazing selection of coffees and a friendly staff to boot.
(4)
Mark T.

LIKE HALF-TURNED ZOMBIES WE WAKE UP on Sunday mornings and drive to the nearest spot that everyone else says is great. Always judging the food, the service and the diners in the next booth over, I fight the urge to take mental notes, trying not to distract myself from the experience at hand by writing the first draft of my yelp review in my head. I do it too often, ignoring my girlfriend or anyone else I'm with, as if I'm a stranger who happened to sit at the same table, lost in my own thoughts because habits are hard to break. This Sunday morning at Carroll Street is rare with barely another pair of diners filling in the entire cafe. The shrimp and grits are good in an odd european attempt, even if the seafood is slightly over seasoned and the serving a bit smaller than I'd like. But that's my fault since gluttons always want more.The space, with its perfectly imperfect tables of dark woods and slightly-off-but-matching everything else, is better than most attempts and fits in elegantly with the close quarters of anything on the actual Carroll Street itself. Like Sun in my Belly over in Kirkwood, any neighborhood would be made better with a spot like Carroll Street Cafe in Cabbagetown. With so many other breakfast locations, it's a great choice for two, not for families, not for you and your friends plus their friends all at once. Sitting there practically alone with my girlfriend, with the glass window between us and the street, and a table littered with breakfast plates that once had food... I am reminded of why I left Pheonix for Atlanta, to follow this girl and our endless stream of breakfast dates. ***1/33
(4)
Roy K.

Everyone once in a while i am disappointed by service....but by far this is a reliable joint and a great atmosphere. Food (have never had an 'entree'): sandwiches, pasta, apps, and tapas are all great bang for buck. They server Lavazza espresso which also makes my heart feel good. Go here. great for conversation. cool people over all.
(5)
Edward L.

Carroll Street Cafe is soo good I don't even want to return for at least a week because I don't want to get burned out. It doesn't hurt that several of the waitresses are quite lovely and that the guy in the corner with the 17 Macbook Pro is playing great music. If doesn't hurt that this is both a great date spot and as well as nieghborhood bar. It doesn't hurt that the legendary Carpe Diem owners are involved if not complete owners of this spot. It doesn't hurt that Carroll Street is probably in the center of the hippest nieghborhood in the A. Yeah, I'll be back.
(5)
Jo Jo C.

I stop here for dessert every now and then. It's like an Intermezzo on that side of town. I hear the mussels are good too!
(4)
Stephie Z.

I might be a bit biased, since I live right around the corner, but I have to say that I dug my first meal here. I woke up on Saturday morning with the sun streaming in the window and felt damn good. I figured this was the first nice day in awhile so I would walk my dog to the place around the corner. I was all prepared for a long wait for one of their outside tables- after all the sun was shining and though you still needed long sleeves, it felt great outside. I walk up and shockingly enough there was not a single person outside- fucking pansies. I ordered the Italian sausage omelet- you pick b/w pork, chicken, or soysage sausage- with goat cheese, and red peppers. Got my food and dug in. The omelet was mighty tasty and it came with potatoes and a biscuit- I certainly wasn't expecting those. The potatoes were decent. I would prefer them to be hot vs room temp and the lack of seasoning kind of turned me off, but on the bright side the biscuit was flaky and delicious. The one turnoff I had was that I was sitting directly outside the window of this lovely couple who kept gawking at me. I felt like they were invading my personal space despite the wall and window between us. I wanted to scream "quit judging me" but thats a whole other stoy that I won't get into here. Anyhoo my dog and I sucked up the sunlight and had some good food, minus the potatoes. A good start to an even better day.
(4)
Stephanie M.

The small bars and restaurants in Cabbage town are like finding little hidden treasures. Carroll Street Cafe is no exception. Very laid back, casual atmosphere. Great place to have a quiet lunch or enjoy a glass of wine late evening. Service was casual and fun. My cheese tortellini lasted me til lunch the next day, and mimosa's come in large and small. (Do you have to ask if i got the big'un?)
(4)
Chris L.

This place is great. It is one of of the many hidden gems in the Cabbage town area. The ambiance is great, very faint music, nice dim lighing, a nice wine selection, and the food was excellent. I had some sort of Salmon Pasta bowl, it was great! The portion was pretty big, and I could not finsh it. The wine selection was decent, but I feel there could have been some improvements in that area. Overall, I was very much impressed. I will be coming back.
(4)
Kellyn W.

Lovely! Always!
(5)
Leah T.

Breakfast at the Carroll Street Cafe on Saturday morning was a great start to the weekend, especially after a crazy week. The quirky buildings and random art along Carroll Street, coupled with the large, flower-box-lined windows, put me in a perfect bohemian mood. The menu has some great choices and the food was super-yum! I had the croissant sandwich, sans turkey. It came with tomatoes, mushrooms, scrambled eggs, cheese, and bechamel. I had the polenta as a side (that was just so-so). Plenty of food to fill me up, and I also appreciate not having my coffee cup filled every two seconds. I hate having to guard my cup from the unwanted refills you get at some places... I finally get my cuppa joe doctored up JUST right, and the second I take a sip and look away...bam! It's filled up with hot coffee again, throwing the taste and temperature off kilter. Grrrr. Fortunately, this was NOT a problem at Carroll Street- we were quietly asked twice, and only twice if we'd like a refill. Perfect. Carroll Street Cafe also gets bonus points for being open at 8:00 a.m. on the weekends! The mister and I tend to be early risers... it can be a tough stretch to wait until 9:00 or later for a decent breakfast.
(4)
Shannon C.

The food here is sooooooooooooooooooooo good. I always go here for brunch. The prices are typical. The only reason I give it a 4 is because their waitresses suck.
(4)
Melissa B.

I love Carroll Street! And I must say after going there a few hundred times for brunch, I've come to realize that it isn't necessarily the food I love but the total experience. Don't get me wrong, the food is usually really good whether it is brunch or dinner but I would never describe it as the best...as a matter of fact, I don't think I've ever craved anything off their menu. What I do crave is sitting in one of the cozy corner booths so I can look out at all of the other patrons, check out the art on the wall and the hanging plants on the porches across the street all while sipping on my coffee and talking with my friends. It's just an amazing place that way. When you brunch at Carroll Street on a pretty day, you will feel that all is right with the world for just a little while. The service can be spotty and inconsistent but usually not enough to break the spell of the place itself...unless you are just a densely negative person, then it will probably annoy the hell out of you.
(4)
Clare B.

This place is great. The Cabbagetown parking scares off most OTP-ers, the food is usually awesome, staff is always friendly, and the vibe is more cozy European or east village coffeehouse than hipster (though there's a touch of that too, in a good way.) In an increasingly chain-restaurant prone Atlanta, it's nice to know the strongholds like Carroll Street are still their lovely, eclectic, independent selves. I live pretty close so I've been here a lot, mostly for brunch, and it's always been delicious. The mimosas aren't bad either, and if it's packed you can always sit at the bar and order some food. Note of caution: the coffee is unbelievably strong, so if you're caffeine sensitive be careful or you may end up rebuilding someone's engine or cleaning your house with Q-tips after drinking a few cups.
(4)
Kay U.

Once or twice a month, my boyfriend and I will venture to CSC for breakfast. He likes the coffee, I like the Cabbagetown Breakfast. I almost always get the same thing so I can't speak for the rest of the entrees, but the breakfast is great!
(4)
Thee Andersons s.

The night crowd can get a bit stuffy, but the food is consistently great! Be sure to do a brunch or lunch, a vegetarian omelet or a betty sandwich. *Key tip: The bartenders are constantly inventing new drinks, try asking for something special
(4)
Howard W.

Yumm-e! Went tonight for the first time and we'll *definitely* even be back. We met another couple and had our 4 year-old in tow. The food was great. The atmosphere was perfect-- very laid back and mellow but also interesting. I had the asian noodles and they were great. A friend with us had the pizza with jalapenos-- also great. We had the crab cake appetizer and it was *good* but I'm from Baltimore, so ya probably shouldn't ask me whether I liked their version. (I've had *much* and even in Baltimore) One complaint. Our waitron was so high energy and pushy, ya kinda had to wonder what she was on? She talked faster than a New Yawkuh and didn't really read the situation that we weren't rushing into the menu. Outside of that, great place. HIGHLY recommen!
(4)
Marla P.

Great bloody Marys and brunch on the weekends. Small, coy and artsy.
(4)
Talib K.

this place is like apres diem on a street called 'carroll.' they have the same furniture with that well used, comfortable look. they have the same 'nice enough' staff and 'good enough menu.' they also have the same solid selection of wines, liquors, and beers. i wonder if they have anything else the same?????? i like this place. just like apres diem, the best time to go is during the mid afternoon. generallly, this is a solid selection for food, drink, and merry dialogue. the dining room can be a little tight on busy nights, but the sofas are really the place to be.
(3)
Malloy M.

Great food for a great price! Drinks are great too but the servers always seem to be operating at 45%. they're nice but you're not getting your cocktail til after they've finished chatting with each other first. Molassas slow service has never stopped me from going in and it shouldn't for you either, but if you're in a hurry, sit at the bar.
(4)
Patrick Q.

Carroll Street is a special street, and this cafe makes a great anchor for a handful of solid restaurants and bars. While it is a smaller version of Apres Diem, it feels more unique than a spin-off and over the years has developed a unique character and feel that fits with Cabbagetown and the clientele. Good cafe menu and drink selection, and when you can grab an outside table, excellent for reading or a wandering conversation. Very dog friendly.
(3)
D. B.

Carroll Street is best for brunch on a calm Sunday before the church crowds or hungover party animals get there. Great ambience and local art featured on the walls. I suggest sitting outside during the summer and enjoy the quirky parts of Cabbagetown. Eggs Meurette and the Croissant Sandwich are superb. Serves excellent coffee (Counter Culture). Also the lobster rissotto on half-off tapas night! Some nights during the week they have live music-- Piano, acoustic guitar, singer-songwriter stuff. It's a nice place for a date, or to take a friend that you haven't seen in a while. Service is so-so depending on the server.
(4)
RaShonda J.

After reading reviews about this place, I dragged my hubby down to the cafe since it was nice day today. Since it was too early for tapas we settled on turkey burger for me and pasta for him. Well, after placing our orders, I noticed something dripping onto our table. We moved to a new table and when I explained to the waitress why we moved she let us know that the A/C leaks on that table. ok...that would have been good to know ahead of time. Anyway, we sat waiting for our food for a good 25 minutes. The place was not crowded at all. During that time I made my way to the lady's restroom which smelled like bath & body works to my surprise...very nice. When the food arrived we got a semi-explanation for the delay but it was inaudible. My turkey burger was ok but nothing special. The pasta was pretty good but it came with a small piece of plastic wrap in the dish. Thankfully it was noticeable so no cpr was required. I was shocked at our bill of $24 considering what we ordered. Can't say I will return but this place may be known for their drinks. I saw quite a few people sipping what looked like bloody marys.
(3)
Claire S.

My how Cabbagetown has grown! I had not visited ATL in 1.5 yrs until this past May. Happy to see one of my favorite brunch institutions was still thriving. Love to sit out on the porch, drinking bloody mary's & eating the celery out of the drink while enjoying my eggs benedict. 2 hours later & several bloody mary's (or mimosas, depending upon my mood), stumbling back to Virginia's house, GOOD TIMES. Highly recommend this place for brunch. Good people watching & fun shops on Carroll St as well.
(4)
Daniel G.

Love this place. Whether it's brunch or dinner, the atmosphere, food, and service is always fantastic. Perfect for a first date.
(5)
Teri S.

Ate lunch here today and while the menu wasn't particularly inspiring, the food was well prepared and very fresh tasting. The iced latte was the best I've had in some time. But my favorite thing about the Carroll St. Cafe is the ambience. Just a wonderful neighborhood cafe with a very relaxed, comfortable feel. Parking is a bit of a challenge, but worth the effort. I wish this place was in my neighborhood!
(4)
Blake B.

Since when I go running I always take a route down Carroll St., I always wanted to remember to come eat here sometime--they have little tables out on the sidewalk that look like some kind of Parisian cafe. Somehow even living just across the street I always forget to come in, until finally a friend suggested we go in on the strength of their desserts. This place is way pricey for what you get. I think between the 3 of us we split a brie appetizer and 2 of us had 1 drink, and the total bill was $25. Pretty ridiculous, considering the drinks were both a couple sips each and the brie was always supposed to cost $6. I was hungry there but their other prices were so high I didn't feel like it was worth it, especially considering that Village Pizza is a couple doors down. I went in to look at the dessert case (the reason we were there) and they seemed to have the standard 'we have a dessert case' type stuff: Napoleons and rich slabs of cake. Nothing I'd gouge an eye out for. Their drink list was shmantzy and expensive. The service was spotty but the girl was overtly friendly when she did come back, and chatted us up as if she were on speed, which she might have been. She was nice. I was surprised that someone actually paid attention to refilling out water. Better service than their counterpart Apres Diem, but still a bit messy. Sitting outside was nice. Don't go out of your way.
(3)
Lauren T.

This is a great little place. I've only been on Sundays but never had to deal with a wait or an overwhelming Sunday Brunch crowd. The food is great (without being too expensive) and the service is good. The parking is a mess. Nobody seems to know whether or not Carroll Street is supposed to be a one-way street... but the road is only wide enough for one car! I've had to back into driveways in order to let other cars by. You'll probably have to drive around the corner and down a side street and then dust off those parallel parking skills!
(4)
Angela Y.

This is my new favorite place near my 'hood. The service was great and friendly and the food was awesome! I had the crab cakes and then I had a steak that was so good and tender ! My friend had the thai chicken salad that he really seemed to enjoy. It is a great place to bring your laptop and just relax and have great food. I am planning on visiting Carroll Street cafe on a regular basis now.
(4)
Mariana D.

As quant and cute as the place was I must admit I was very disappointed. The waitress was slow and got my order wrong even when I corrected her. The food was kind of slimy and tasteless-even my boyfriend who had recommended the place was disappointed. Other than that... the coffee was excellent. I might be willing to go back, just not any time soon.
(2)
Huzefa O.

CUte place with awesome foooood! Loved the waffles!
(4)
ernesto s.

whaaat. Birthday dinners don't come this close. a nirvana's nirvana. the tuna nicoise salad is the best i've had (also the first I've ordered, but it was dang good). the meatballs with goat cheese - mmmmm. we also shared an arugula salad that hit the spot. all we kept saying was how much better it was than last night's pleasant, yet heavy outing at H&F. we could eat here every day, that's how good it is. maybe it was the night, the combo of flavors?
(4)
Miss J.

Oh, the amount of times I went to Carroll Street Cafe for brunch and said I would only have 1 mimosa and ended up drinking 6. or 8. or 10. Those were the days. Love love love them! Awesome brunch, never made it for dinner. Laidback, and good for people watching!
(4)
Keith H.

this is a great place to take someone for a drink and maybe an appetizer but the entrees leave much to be desired....i got the ribeye and not only did it look like something you would get in a cafeteria, thin, fake grill marks, and abnormally flat, but it tasted like they had a salt fight in the kitchen and they were using my plate as a shield... so...good drinks...beautiful atmosphere...typical atl slow diner style service...well done appetizers...save your money for a real dinner
(3)
Coley W.

Carroll Street Cafe serves contemporary American cuisine. We're talking tropical talapia, New York strip steak, almond brie rolls, thai beef salad, salmon linguine, a "panoramic" veggie sandwich, gyros -- stop me when you're hungry. During the day, it's all served curbside, or by a big bay window. In the evenings, dine by candle light. This is the perfect, independently cool spot to anchor one of America's great neighborhoods -- Cabbagetown.
(4)
Shannon H.

In keeping with my review of apres diem... I love this place. It's comfy, cozy, and eclectic. The food is reliably good, with varied specials and excellent drinks. I've been for brunch and dinner, and enjoyed both. It's a little out of the way, and parking can be a challenge, so if you haven't been before it might help you to know there's a (small) parking lot just down the row of shops from the cafe.
(4)
Leeor N.

The service and food here were great. I live in San Francisco and have regular occasion to patronize restaurants that are held to a far higher standard, so I am at a loss to understand some of the negative reviews about the service. When my friend and I arrived, we asked for a seat outdoors and offered to wait because they all appeared to be taken and the weather was nice. As it turned out, one of the staff who had finished her shift was sitting by herself and offered to move to a neighboring table to sit with some of her friends so that we could be accommodated. She didn't have to do that and I thought that was very nice of her. As for ordering, my friend and I had no idea what to order, so just asked our waitperson to get us a few of whatever dishes she recommended. The dishes were all great, not life-altering, but if you want life-altering, you would not be justified walking into what is obviously a relaxed and charming local cafe. The neighborhood is also one of my favorites. I very nearly came back twice in one weekend.
(5)
Michael B.

I love this place! The food is quite good for such a small restaurant...or maybe that is why it is good. There is excellent sidewalk seating, if you can get it, and inside is dark, cozy, comfortable and artsy. My wife and I often find ourselves here on date night. It is owned by the Cafe Diem (remember that?) / Apres Diem folks, and the international syle of service actually holds true here. Apres Diem service sucks--sorry to say that, but European service doesn't mean, "ignore me and make me ask for you to bring my food, drink, check". So if you're inclined toward the Apres Diem menu, skip it and come to Carroll Street Cafe instead. Try the filet with cardiac bleu cheese, the mixed green salad with a salmon filet, tasty little artisan bread sandwiches and baked goods. They have a decent wine list, too, so ask for a recommendation. UPDATE: My wife and I went to Carroll Street for their Prix Fixe Valentine's day wine pairing....awesome! The only drawbacks? WAY too much salt in the lobster bisque and potatoes au gratin...otherwise amazing. The wine pairings were great: a flowery, fruity viognier with salad, a robust sirah with my tenderloin, and one of the best desserts we've ever had anywhere. They're supplied by Alon's, Southern Sweets, and some other great bakeries/patisseries in town. Sure beats the Publix sheet cakes that pass for desserts in some Atlanta restaurants. This is where it gets good. Our waiter, Keith, (youngish slender guy with black-framed glasses) gave us the most awesome service. He suggested that we get the orange cake and have it warmed up. Damn, that was good. Do yourself a favor and ask for Keith...tip him well. There was absolutely no pretense (he joked about not knowing how to set the order of the silverware), gave generous pours, and was really unintrusive but always available--super laid-back. Really a pleasant guy and a gracious departure from the typical fend-for-yourself waitrons notoriously endemic to the Apres restaurants. The meal was 4 stars, but Keith gets 5.
(4)
Kelley H.

i love this place - but i have only been there for breakfast and brunch. the food is really tasty - especially the waffles and french toast. it's casual with a really artistic feel with some outside dining. it's really a highlight of the neighborhood.
(4)
Smita P.

I am a big fan of Carroll Street Cafe for Saturday or Sunday brunch. Its the best. I love the cool eclectic style of this restaurant. Any place that serves Mimosa's with fresh OJ is high in my list. I am a big fan of the Eggs Benedict and the Eggs Meurette. The omlettes are super too (per Jen and Marci who were with me and ordered them). The art and the couches (along the wall and by the windows) add a fun and cozy touch making it a place you can hang out for hours. I've never been there in the evenings but the bar seemed to list out some great cocktails and appetizers so I imagine its a good bet for non-brunch meals as well.
(4)
Foodie Buddha F.

So I promised the gang that I would give them their 15-minutes and include them in a review. So here you go guys and gals - this one is for you. I was lucky enough to get an invite to the most exclusive of birthday celebrations! It was so tough to score that even Mandi was S.O.L.!!!! That's saying something - she's famous enough that she only needs one name! Needless to say, I joined the lovely Elizabeth H (HAPPY B-DAY!!!!), magnanimous Ben O, inquisitive Chris & Leslie R (who I expect to read this entire review), and sexified Laura F, for brunch at Carroll Street CafÃ© this past Sunday. Though I must say - it's amazing how good looking and funny they all said I am! That was truly flattering. Now with that stuff out of the way, I will get on with the recapitulation. Carroll Street CafÃ© is a mid-sized joint packed in with a handful of other businesses that are oddly situated on the edge of Cabbagetown. The restaurant is split into two rooms - one part coffee shop - one part dining tavern. Though there is a clear distinction between the floor plans of each room - the dÃ©cor, menu, and service are ubiquitous throughout. I have eaten here a number of times - though it's never a place I'm dying to go to, given the price point and the overall atmosphere, it is certainly passable. Fortunately, for the purpose of this review, I found the meal this past week to be like most other meals I have had here. The menu is muddled to say the least. Speaking specifically to the brunch items - you will find the choices rambling between those of a contemporary American meal and traditional American breakfast. They also take a liking to a few things from our friends north of the border, as well as those to our south. If the quality of the food, the presentation, or the execution was better, than I might be inclined to say that the diversity was appealing. Instead, it just reminds you how remarkably unremarkable everything here is. They do not use fresh product, nothing is made in house, the spices and cooking techniques are straight out of some very basic cookbook. Though I think the words demi-glace appears somewhere on the menu, I seem to remember it being misspelled. I think the food buyer probably goes shopping in the frozen foods section of some nearby Kroger. While this may sound a little harsh, I think it is a fair assessment. Most of the items tend to come out fine. They are neither bad, nor good. It is generally edible, but never spectacular. A handful of the dishes I find to be particularly notable (for one reason or another). The lox plate is a true disappointment if you are expecting Zabar's ( yelp.com/biz/zabars-deliâ€¦ ). The lox are most certainly packaged and never the same. Sometimes you get lox, sometimes you get smoked salmon. The most aggravating thing about the entire restaurant is their cream cheese. I would be fine with them delivering Philadelphia cream cheese for you to spread. Unfortunately, they give you a friend of the single-serving variety. The red beans with poached eggs are non-eventful and what I select more often than not. The beans are canned, the poached eggs are never consistent, and the guac and the pico are packaged (sound familiar?). At this last meal, one of my poached eggs was over cooked, the other was under cooked. The taste is fine, though it's not particularly great, it's certainly agreeable. The best thing on the menu is the Shrimp and Grits. The grits are identified as coming from the queso/jalapeÃ±o genus, but the flavor is pretty mild. These are not up to snuff with some of the other places in town - but again - it will get you buy. The service is usually between ample and attentive; I've found many of the employees to be really personable (and not in that annoying/won't leave you alone sort of way). It has that slacker meets beatnik meets hippie vibe and dÃ©cor that is prominent throughout C-Town. They are fairly clean, though I have found a spot on my dish or my utensil once in a blue moon. Bottom line, given the price point - it's alright. For the six of us, it came out to just about $15/head. Keep in mind that's sans tip and alcohol, but also included an order of shrimp and grits that was split by the table. As far as breakfast/brunch goes, this place doesn't come anyway close to Atmosphere, Thumbs Up, or El Gato Bizco, but it will do when you are looking for different place to grab a bite at. However, I am not motivated to eat dinner here again. It is a neat late night spot if you are looking for some groovy tunes and a change of pace.
(3)
Rina H.

I like the location, the crowd and the food. They serve late and I often don't sit down for dinner until 10pm...so the fact that they serve until midnight (I believe) is thrilling. Service is always good, food is good (not award winning) and the place is pretty charming.
(4)
Russ G.

Very cool place for lunch and early meals, this is a small little place nestled into Cabbagetown that you'll miss if you blink. Good selection of beer, wine, and liquor, and quite a few interesting menu items as well. Nights get a little crowded, and if you're in a group you may get split up since there's not a lot of space to begin with. Otherwise it's cozy, quaint, a sort of 'home' feel. Servers are knowledgeable about the food items and eager to help without dragging their heels too much.
(4)
Vincent V.

The owners of Apres Diem successfully cloned and then shrank their restaurant and put it in Cabbagetown. And I shall call it...Mini Diem. Great drinks, desserts, and the tapas aren't bad. The only drawback to this place is that you might get stuck with a server who is more interested in being part of the scene than doing their job. Which is also a cloned feature of Apres Diem. I liked the brunch, but my one time there in the light of day was marred by some atrocious service. Whatever our little gal had done the night before, she hadn't finished coming down from it. She spaced out and vanished for ages at a time, got our order wrong three times, and was getting her tables confused. I felt bad that I had talked the place up to some friends and had that happen when they met me there. Overall, great food and atmosphere but you might hit a serious dud with the service at any given time.
(3)
josie p.

I love it here, although the parking situation leaves LOTS to be desired! In all honesty, I love all of the restaurants by this owner (Apres Diem in Midtown & Carpe Diem in Decatur)... each of them have such a European loungey vibe that just speaks to me in a good way. Carroll Street is the smallest of the 3 & feels the most like a coffee house or wine bar, although it is neither. The Panoramic Veggie Sandwich is my jam, but the pasta dishes are super yummy too. Really though, I just enjoy coming here to sip on some refreshing cocktail & chillax in the dark, candle-studded bar area... Perfect evening!
(5)
Peter B.

Carroll Street Cafe has the one of the tastiest brunch menu's in Atlanta at very good prices. Crab Cakes Benedict is superb. Crab cakes made fresh daily for like $8.95. Their house special grits or polenta are excellent sides. The brunch portions are overly satisfying. We go for dinner and lunch as well. The food is solid but not refined. The dessert case looks awesome. Unfortuneately, we go there so often I forbid myself from indulging.The place itself is intown cool. Local artists rotate their works on the walls to add to the eclectic decor.
(4)
Denise D.

Went for my first vist last night. What a wonderful find...staff was friendly and attentive. Good vibe, nice art...food was great!
(5)
Dawn S.

Whenever you roll out of bed for brunch, there always seems to be just enough room to sit down quickly at Carroll Street and have coffee and mimosa in front of you in no time. The hummus is terrific as is the ambiance--day or night.
(4)
Sunshine M.

This is like a hidden gem to me, I took my Husband here for his 30th birthday. We've been here many times but it's close to our house, and has great ambiance. The specials are always really fantastic, and the desserts are excellent, we had a chocolate ganache cake that would knock your socks off!
(5)
Erica J.

I love love love this place. I love going late at night when the place is dark and cozy. Their tapas and salads are delicious and I always order dessert even if I'm super full from dinner. You just can't go there without ending your meal with a moist slice of cake and a cup of coffee.
(5)
Tiffany L.

This place is so good! I love that it's "off the beaten path" and yet basically RIGHT off the beaten path. You drive past it all the time and don't even know it. The food and the service are great. Mid week at lunch-time, you can get in and out in an hour with delicious food to boot. Perfect.
(4)
Scottie M.

Awesome little cafe in an even awesome-r neighborhood. I absolutely love Cabbagetown and I think Carroll Street Cafe is a primary reason. Despite the fact that it's owned by the same people who own Apres Diem (which I hate - see my review), the folks down on Carroll Street actually do a decent job of serving up some great lunch plates. I had the Tilapia sandwich and it was pretty awesome. The accompanying salad and melon slices really made the meal. Great service and tons of cool art on the wall to keep your eyes occupied. Also really good to just run in real quick, sit and have a coffee with a buddy, and run out. Love this place.
(4)
Zadi M.

their menu is great and its got great ambience. the service is spotty, sometimes great sometimes not. but a great place to go with friends or SO without having to go to midtown or buckhead.
(3)
Lori F.

Cute little place for lunch or dinner. They serve brunch on the weekends, too. I like sitting by the bar on the left since it's a little less crowded. Their menu is pretty much the same as Apres Diem (same owners), so my fave is their awesome gyro sandwich. Cons: Parking in Cabbagetown sucks, servers are your typical "angsty-twenty-something-too-cool-for-you" types.
(3)
Avid C.

I lived in Germany for nine years and wound up back in Atlanta. I assumed that returning to the states would mean that I would likely never see another neighborhood restaurant which oozed with character, that is, until I visited the Carroll Street Cafe. This place is a "must visit," as their menu goes in a multitude of creative directions, all of which worth trying. I wish that they emphasized beer a little more, such as something on tap or in a pitcher, but everything else positions this place as an ideal candidate for a special evening. Whatever you do, make at least a random pick from their desert menu, as you would likely be delighted. Finally, if you have a dog, then you should consider this place a "must-must visit" restaurant as their outdoor seating is perfect. Strongly recommended.
(5)
J. D.

One star for being fiercly independent. One star for being gourmet without attitude. One star for being a true neighborhood gathering place. One star for being cool. Hey, that's four stars.
(4)
Drew S.

Great location, I love Cabbagetown. The ambience here is reminiscient of San Francisco. I hit this place for brunch and had a mixed experience. The biscuits and the potatoes were heavenly. My shrimp frittata however was burnt. Nothing says barf after a heavy night of drinking like burnt eggs. The coffee was wonderful as well as the fresh squeezed orange juice which seems to be a scarce commodity around here. Overall though I would have to say this was a fun place to brunch at and I am definitely going to give it a second chance.
(3)
red l.

Food was mediocre. Wait staff was not that attentive.
(2)
Kris P.

carroll street cafe is PERFECT. especially for brunch - try crab cakes benedict. they are keen on the sweet/salty combos that i crave - pair your pancakes with soysage and fruit. it's worth a 30 minute wait, i promise. i know this is irrelevant, but i always hear people speaking spanish or french at carroll street. the international elite seem to know more about atlanta's hip cafes than locals. it's incredibly sexy at night. a great bar with great tapas and somewhat pricey drinks. i like the parmesan-encrused brie plate with fruit and french bread, although the brie is not really "encrusted". make sure you try their citrus cake with cream cheese frosting. avoid the waitress who calls everyone "sweetheart."
(5)
Elizabeth A.

I'm always looking for places that have GREAT vegetarian food and GREAT non-veg food as well. This has a lot of yummy options for both. I had the veggie burger and would put it in my top 5. It came with a small salad and fresh slices of watermelon and orange on the side - which was a nice surprise on a hot afternoon. And it was a decent price as well. (I want to say $7-8?) However my boyfriend got some kind of breakfast dish that came with bacon, toast, eggs, and potato and at $9 i felt like the plate should have been heaping with food or at least have something original about it. He said it was good but not great, slightly overpriced. Our waiter was a little shy but very attentive. And the place as a whole was just really beautiful. Great little place. I wanted to try just about everything on the menu.
(4)
Katie S.

I have been coming to Carroll Street Cafe for years. It's owned by the people who own Apres Diem, though I like Carroll Street much better. I love taking people here for their first visit. Sometimes it is a struggle to find a close parking spot because there is only parking on the street. It's a cute building with big windows that give a great view of the quaint street and patrons of Cabbage Town (which is enjoyable in itself). The food is consistently delicious (if they have the squash casserole, get it, it's AMAZING!!). I like how the menu has different sides every time you go. To explain, if you order the sirloin it comes with the "potato of the day", which could be hash browns or mashed potatoes, etc. It helps to keep the menu interesting in my opinion. The wine list is decent, but not that extensive, and I think it's better to buy the bottle because by the glass it's pricey! I also enjoy the brunch here, the bloody mary's are potent. This is a great date location though I suggest you get there some what early if you decide to go on a Friday or Saturday night because it's not a huge location and it will fill up.
(4)
Kim W.

Yes, they serve brunch, and it's awesome! Really good omelets. One of my favorite litle spots.
(3)
Three M.

When I used to live in Atlanta, the only time anyone would go to Cabbage Town was to try and find the guy selling dime bags. Now the area is brimming with cute little places to grab a drink or a nosh. Weird how 15 years will totally change a place. Anyway...Carroll Street is cute and artsy, with a full bar and a nice menu with yummy salads and sandwiches. I'm pretty sure they change their art installations monthly, and feature mainly local artists. I don't recall if they serve brunch, but sometimes a weekend lunch with a bloody mary is okay too. It seems like it would also be a nice place to have a mellow cocktail or 2 on a Friday night. The only negative - the staff was not so friendly. Not really mean, just not very warm. But if you're with good company - who cares? I would definitely go back.
(3)
Monica G.

Was planning on having dinner at Agave, but the wait was an hour, so we decided to go to the nearest restaurant. And, I'm glad that we did! We ordered from their tapas menu and everything was delicious! We had the lamb sliders, shrimp, flank steak, scallops, pork belly and crab cakes. We also ordered their chocolate ganache, which was also very good. Oh, and their tapas are half off mon- thurs, from 3-7pm. The ambiance had a cool and relaxed vibe. The service was okay. They were attentive, but I kinda felt like the server wasn't very familiar with the menu. Parking is a pain but they do have complimentary valet.
(4)
Bianca N.

My friend suggest we go to this cafe near Krog street since we wanted brunch and I'm not from Atlanta. The cafe is cutely set up and the laidback atmosphere made my initial impression of this cafe positive at first. I ordered the Belgian Waffle dish and substituted eggs for potatoes. I have a sweet tooth that needed to be satisfied....and I was disappointed. The waffles were dry so there wasn't much flavor. The potatoes were cold as if they were cooked a while ago and just sat out for a while. Only delicious part of the dish was the pork sausage. I would give this place another try if I'm ever back in Atlanta but my brunch experience fell short of what I wanted.
(3)
Janet L.

I came with a party of 5 on a Saturday for brunch, and we were seated pretty quickly. It's a pretty cool, eclectic vibe. Parking is on street (although there might be free valet? Not sure)- but I had no issues finding a spot. I ordered the crab cake Benedict with the potatoes and sans fruit (mixed fruit generally has melon which I'm allergic to)... But I was kind of surprised when our waitress didn't offer me a substitute item. It didn't bug me too much. Generally, I wasn't too impressed. The meal was fine, but I expected it to be better than it was. I liked the crab cakes but my eggs were not poached well at all. One was completely overdone and one was half overdone. The potatoes were okay- compared to other really great brunch potatoes I've had before. The others in my group ordered either the bacon or sausage omelette. They said they were really good, so maybe I should have went with that instead. The atmosphere was fine with one exception- I found it way to loud to carry on conversation. Our waitress was good- polite, friendly, and prompt. Overall, I would come back if a friend wanted to or if I was in the area. I don't know that I'd go out of my way to come back.
(3)
Max M.

This place was a mixture. The Thai beef salad was OMG amazing -- literally the best salad I think I've ever eaten. A perfect blend of Asian and Italian elements. I will come back here a million times just for that. Just phenomenal. I was really glad (in a back-handed compliment kind of way) that nothing else on the menu looked appetizing enough for a reasonable price, so I was kind of forced to get the salad (and I never usually order a salad). On the other hand, the scallop appetizer was the worst scallop entree I think I've ever had. Normally when you order a scallop appetizer for that price, you expect them to be cooked to perfection. These were not. Almost tasted microwaved. The mushrooms that accompanied them were good though. And back to a compliment. The service by our server was really good. And I will definitely be back for that salad.
(3)
Tiffany B.

This place is tucked away on Caroll Street. I love how the area is a hidden laid back gem in the heart of the city. The restaurant is cozy. A good spot for happy hour or a date. Monday night is $5 on all Tapas. The wines were half off. I absolutely loved this and I ordered about 7 Tapas and the featured wine. Everything was cooked lovely. My favorite thing was the Caprese Salad and the Steak. So yummy. Still haven't sampled any entres but the wine was amazing. Dessert is worth trying too. Assorted cheesecakes and all. I must mention there is not a lot of parking options that are convenient but find one because its worth it!
(5)
Tesha H.

I love Love LOVE this place. The menu is so unexpected, but perfectly executed. Every time I go I'm never disappointed.
(5)
Jessica I.

I was in the area and it was pretty late. A few of my girl friends and I wanted to have something small to eat. We found this small strip by the Krog street tunnel. This place has some good vibes. It was kind of loud inside and dim lighting. The food was great. It tasted good, but a little pricey. I would love to come here again. It's a cute small place and they're open fairly late, which was nice.
(4)
Yinka T.

Nothing tickles my excitement better than satisfying brunch indulgence. Carroll was a good grub for a Sunday. Food: 4. I got the Benedict and managed to exceed my expectations. The dirty chai took it home but better top presentation next time. Service: 4. Attentive and pleasant. No long wait time past 10 mins. Ambience: 5. Pretty chic. Location is nice. Parking: They have comp valet about 250ft away. I'll be back.
(4)
Ebony H.

I had the Shrimp and Grits. It was amazing! Great portion shrimp seasoned and cooked perfectly. Staff was very attentive.
(5)
Lisa C.

This place is INCREDIBLE! Amazing cocktails, tapas and entrees and reasonably priced! I had the portobello caprese and my dad had the gyro and we both cleaned our plates. If you come here you have got to ask for Kara! She's the sweetest and helped me pick out the perfect cocktail.
(5)
Domonic B.

Randomly met a friend here on her suggestion for lunch. I pass by this place often and have never noticed it. It's nestled on the very imfamous hell of a street called Carroll Street Cafe. If you have never been on Carroll Street, when you decide to visit you will see why i say this. I ordered the waffle platter which came with eggs, sausage of your choosing, a fruit bowl, and the waffle was also topped with fruit. The food came out surprisingly fast even tho the place wasn't that busy when we were there. The waffles topped with strawberries and blueberries were pretty good. The syrup accented them well. The best part of this meal in my opinion. It was of very good quality and was pretty decent size. I almost wish i had ordered another. The fruit bowl was a nice addition. It was a bowl of grapes and pineapples which I like a lot. The least enjoyable part of this meal was the eggs which were simply scrambled but had no flavor whatsoever. I added a bit of salt and pepper from the table to enjoy them. Overall the food was good and i'd order it again if i came here again. I'm big on service at places. I have worked in service jobs so I know that it can be overwhelming at times so i'm very patient also. As I said earlier, this place wasn't busy at all when we came for lunch. I must say that our server started out very well. He was very attentive and very informative about the menu but somewhere along the way he simply forgot about us. I had to get up to get straws for the table and my glass of water went unfilled for almost 30 minutes. It's like we had the Jekyll/Hyde of our server. It kind of baffled me. They have very delicious cake choices on display at the counter and I had my heart set on getting a slice of cake after finishing my entree. Between our server not checking on us I lost my taste for cake after my meal and then the cake slices(which aren't that big) being $6/slices....yeah...no bueno. I would've given this place 4 stars but the service definitely took a star away. The food is good but the service was definitely lacking. I hope lots of people don't have this experience here b/c this place has a lot of potential.
(3)
Jaycie H.

What a lovely place! We went for a late breakfast, there were probably 8 of us and they managed to get everything right and out in a speedy fashion. I had pork belly which was very well done. Everyone was happy with their food from what I could tell.
(5)
Martha R.

Wowza, this place has good food! The service was lovely as well... she was attentive w/o being pesky, and offered to let me try out a couple of the wines before making a choice. What more can you want? The Malbec we chose was delicious and relatively cheap (around $30). The top choice of the things that we had: pork belly. Oh dear god, after falling in love w/ that stuff in Portland, I was happy to see it on the menu. Even happier to have it in my belly! The flank steak was also a top choice, perfectly cooked and slathered w/ garlic. Holy smokes, good thing the people I was hanging out w/ for the evening were going to have the same garlicky breath as I did! We had a couple appetizers, a few tapas, and one salad to split between 3 people. The other food stuffs that we had weren't really as wonderful as the two I mentioned, otherwise they could have hit the 5-star mark. So for $100, three people had one heck of a good meal. Highly suggest this place.
(4)
Tyler B.

This is a cute little restaurant that's located along a really lovely stretch of Cabbagetown. Five of us came here for a late dinner on Valentine's Day. The atmosphere is pretty romantic and it was clearly a popular spot that night. Even at 9:00, there was still a 45 minute wait. Our extended wait, however, allowed us to explore the area a little bit. There are several businesses along Carroll Street and we settled into a fun bar down the street to pass the time. It ended up working out really well and I wouldn't be disappointed if I came back and had to wait again. The atmosphere was perfect. I felt like I was in a really nice restaurant but it still maintained a down-to-earth, homey feel. We were able to sit right next to the window, which gave us a great view of the neighborhood's pretty houses across the street. Also, even though they were quite busy, the noise level was very reasonable for what's a pretty small, closely confined space. Overall, the food here is reasonably priced with entrees in the $20 range. They also had a list of pricier Valentine's Day specials, which I got sucked into ordering. For some reason, I was really, really craving some jambalaya and although it was really good, it wasn't worth $23. Sure, it was as good (or close to as good) as anything I've had in New Orleans but at more that twice the cost? No thank you. I had a bite of my friend's pasta, which was delicious and confirmed that I should have just stuck with their regular dishes.
(4)
Vanitha S.

Carroll Street Cafe will continue to be one of my favorite places in Atlanta. Though I've only been here for dessert the 3x I've been here, I'd vote that this is probably an awesome place for any meal of the day--whether it's brunch or dinner or coffee or wine or dessert. It's definitely hipster, divey and not-mainstream--lots of cool, colorful local art on the walls, flickering candles, deep soothing beats and friendly servers. Everyone just seems relaxed and happy here. I love the plush couch and coffee table that is always available that makes for a cozy intimate setting whether with friends or your loved one. They have some gluten free options (chocolate ganache-YUM!) and can substitute dairy milk for almond milk (chai tea latte-YUM!) which is a nice bonus.
(4)
Judy S.

I will never grow tired of Carroll Street Cafe's delicious food and drinks. I ordered a Bloody Mary and their Chicken and Grits entre (which was cooked to perfection). The servers were friendly and attentive to all of their guests. Not only you will be satisfied with the food and service but also the setting of the cafÃ©. They change up their artwork every now and then which makes this cafÃ© so enjoyable. Every time I bring a friend to Carroll Street, it always wins the hearts of many.
(5)
Charity N.

Amazing!! You should come on Mondays its $5 Tapas and 1/2off on Tuesday. The foods is enough to get you really full if you buy 2 tapas. Amazing deserts too. Overall a very cool hippie vibe.
(5)
Jason D.

Great for brunch. Had the Benedict Scallop and the Crab cake Benedict. I like their jalapeno cheddar grits. And the bloody Mary hit the spot. Very chill. Atmosphere. Seems like the perfect place to escape and have food and drinks away from the daily grind.
(4)
Shawn F.

I really have nothing but great things to say about Carroll Street Cafe. I've been here twice already and both times have been excellent experiences. The first time I went was with my girlfriend for a late night dinner. We were looking on yelp for some good late night food close to GSU, and we came across here. It's in an interesting neighborhood, along a dark street at night and the parking is basically along the street or supposedly free valet a little bit further down the street. It's very quaint inside, dim lighting, candles, really has a homey feel to it. I like it. We ordered the steak sandwich and the seafood pasta. Both were excellent. The steak sandwich was cooked medium rare as ordered, the toppings and bread was tasty, along with the fries. The seafood pasta was delicious. A bit creamy and cheesy, but it was just what I wanted. There were mussels, shrimp, and salmon pieces. All were cooked just right and the pasta sauce was very flavorful. For dessert, we had the Tiramisu. It was delicious! Service was attentive and fairly friendly, nothing special. The second time we went, we got there pretty late at night and it was fairly busy, but no wait. We found a table inside and our server was somewhat of a ditz. She was just one of those awkward young servers that come and ask you stuff mid-bite and just has an awkward feel, but she was just ok. Had to flag her down a few times for water, the check, a to-go box, but it's whatever, the food was great. This time we ordered the penne ala vodka with chicken and the veggie wrap with chicken. The penne ala vodka was great, not as creamy as the seafood pasta we ordered last time but it was really tasty. There were pieces of bacon in the pasta too that added a great flavor. This was one of the better penne ala vodka's I've had in my life. The veggie wrap with chicken was delicious. We did not get desert this time, tempted to get the carrot cake, will have to try it next time. Overall, I love this place. They have a diverse menu, really anything you'd want to get, from filet mignon to a sandwich, pasta, chicken, small plates, they have something to cater to everyones palate. I understand it has a laid back friendly vibe, but I think the service needs a little bit improvement. I think the food is 5 Stars, but the service is 3 stars. So, I give this place a 4 stars, pretty darn good in my book.
(4)
Andy S.

This is a cool little spot in Cabbagetown. The staff was very friendly and the food was good. We went during Sunday brunch and I got the chicken cobb sandwich. Not sure this is the best name for it since it is essentially a bacon and avocado chicken sandwich. My girlfriend got the grilled chicken salad and she enjoyed it and the vinaigrette was tasty and light. I would recommend this place and will be returning soon. There is limited street parking but if you can't find something, there is complementary valet parking very nearby.
(4)
Nadim K.

Probably my favorite place in the downtown area of Atlanta. Their Tapas are delicious and leave space for their tasty cakes. The staff is very nice and the atmosphere is great. Lamb sliders, and the seared tuna are great.
(5)
Kisha M.

Delightful little spot off the beaten path. There were a few tables outside, but the inside dining room was pretty large. I loved the dimly lit room and unobtrusive tunes playing. Great spot for an intimate dinner. I had the fish special. It was really good. It was served with sauteed spinach and mashed potatoes. I cleaned my plate! They also had a dessert display that looked tasty, but we declined. Staff was super friendly. If I lived in the area I imagine I'd be there all the time.
(4)
Andy A.

The shrimp and grits are my favorite. I just wish the portions were a little larger. The service is excellent unless you are sitting at the bar. I think the place is a little pricey, though, and will prob push me next door to Cabbagetown pie more often.
(4)
Deborah G.

This place was quaint and eclectic! The atmosphere was welcoming and pleasing to the eyes and the food was fabulous. I had the Lobster omelette and it was full of lobster and great veggies and very flavorful! Definitely will be going back!
(5)
Linda V.

Service was great but food was okay compared toany of the brunch choices around town. We ordered the southwest omelet, belgium waffles, and shrimp & grits. Favorite dish was belgium waffles, it came with strawberries and blueberries not strawberries and bananas like the other yelp pictures. Least favorite was the shrimp and grits, do not get this dish here. You will be disappointed, shrimp tasted over salted and smokey which isn't a great combo for my taste buds. Grits were not creamy, the picture below tells it all. The southwest omelet was okay, nothing special. Fruit that came with the plate seemed a bit past the fresh stage.
(3)
Marvin B.

The food here is really good and flavorful. The service was great. The ambience has such character. This was a great first time experience. MOST OF ALL- there was NO WAIT. On a beautiful Sunday afternoon.
(4)
Andria C.

What an awesome little place. I really should go here more often. My most recent visit was for a friend's birthday dinner. It was a Thursday night, so it wasn't very busy. Most of the party was already seated when we arrived, so we just strolled in and sat down. The service here is always super friendly, albeit not the fastest. The food has never disappointed, whether it's Sunday brunch or a weeknight dinner. This spot is tiny, so don't be suprised if there is a bit of a wait during peak times. But no worries, because they have comfy couches. Parking can be a pain sometimes, but there is valet.
(4)
Kin N.

WHY?!?!? Why is this place located so close to my favorite restaurant? I'm going to have a tough decision when I come to this neighborhood. We arrived at 7:30 PM on a Saturday and the restaurant was almost empty (or was it slightly full?).....bad sign right? WRONG! Don't let it deceives you...they serve amazing food. Here is what we ordered: Lamb slider - Seriously good! Lamb is how it should taste like (yeah, gamey in a nice way), vegetable is fresh and crisp, and the tzatziki sauce just pairs so well with other ingredient. 4.5 Stars Empanada - Very good. Crispy crust with flavorful filling. You can't messed up a deep fried dough with meat filling, can you? That said, I rated this empanada among my top 3. 4 Stars Pizza - The menu changes daily and I don't remember the exact ingredients on mine. All I know is it's vegetarian, fresh, flavorful, and portion is huge for a tapas. 4 Stars Pork Belly with brandy sauce and flambeed peaches - fancy name for braised (?) pork belly with a sweet glaze and pieces cooked fruit. It's nice but every restaurant serves a similar dish in the past two years, and nothing sets this one apart from the pack. 3 Stars. Seafood Penne - I LOVE this dish. What makes it different from similar dishes at other places is the cream sauce. I could really taste the brininess and sweetness of seafood in the sauce. 5 Stars If you're a craft beer lover, they have about 15 kinds of bottle craft beers that we've never even heard of. We told our server what kind of popular beers we like and she did a phenomenal job of recommending a beer for us. Server's knowledge about beer - 5 Stars Just a side note: The menu says they serve tapas....well, it's not really "Tapas". Most of it was merely smaller portion of American food. Overall, it was a fantastic meal and I can't wait to come back. Just wish it wasn't located down the street from my favorite restaurant.
(4)
Oliver F.

Nice coffee shop atmosphere with a wide variety of breakfast foods to burgers/sandwiches/salads/noodle dishes, and my favorite: the seafood. Seafood Penne is amazing. Would def get it every time but I've been trying to branch out. Not to say the other dishes are not good, they're also great, but the Seafood Penne is just on another level. The only con, which it barely is one, one time I went with my boss on our lunch break and he got a completely different dish than he ordered. He ended up loving it (the Blackened Chicken Sandwich) and on top of that they axed our bill in half for the mistake. The cafe is never too crowded for lunch either. They also have daily lunch specials that typically aren't on the menu which are actually a pretty good deal. I've only been for lunch but I imagine dinner is just as good. Would definitely recommend.
(5)
Dbaby A.

Favorite chill spot for the hubby and I. The service is great & the food is great. We always get the salmon ciabatta its awesomeeee lol
(5)
Michelle K.

Visited this lovely cafe in Cabbage Town to have lunch with a friend for her birthday. I really wished, I'd visited them sooner because their food was quite delicious. You can't help but notice the coziness of the restaurant when you walk in. It certainly has that neighborhood field but open space so you don't feel claustrophobic. The wait staff was super pleasant. I just wished our server would stop by our table more often to refill my water glass. I had to ask at the very end when I received my check and was still quite thirsty but wasn't in the mood to get up and look for our server. Their brie appetizer is the best I've had so far in ATL. I love how they melt the brie in the phylo and serve it with lightly toasted french baguette pieces. Loved the entire experience and will definitely return for future visits with friends and family.
(4)
Rachel M.

Sophia (or Sophie), I am writing a review about you! Sophia was a great waitress. She explained from the beginning that they were short staffed and things may take longer than usual. They didn't! She suggested an amazing cocktail and upsold me into the salmon for my salad... both were fantastic! (Pear & gorganzola salad, trust Sophia. Add the salmon.) Beyond just a great, upbeat wait staff with incredible insight into the menu, the desserts were divine, the ambience was chill and relaxed. The music was a bit loud for large parties to talk, but overall great place. Great after hours spot. I'll be going back again!
(5)
Jack R.

Great place with a neighborhood vibe. Always good food, great happy hour deal on tapas, and brunch runs pretty late for us slugabeds. The sidewalk tables are wonderful for observing the Cabbagetown scene. Last time we were there we ended up at three different tables with old and new friends.
(4)
Emiene W.

Scallops and mushrooms, heavenly. Pork belly, delightfully savory with peach counterpoint. Churrasco was tasty but not special. Overall not too shabby at all. The vibe is like black Key West, without the black folks but still friendly.
(4)
Karen F.

Great little indie place. It's open late and I've been here a couple of times and never disappoints. Very good vibe, it has an indie / hipster type of vibe. The hot chocolate with soy milk is awesome and for food I recommend the gyro with feta cheese. The salads are all really good and healthy too. Very pleased with this little cafe, the staff is very friendly and the area is clever too.
(5)

Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.

Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.

Address : 208 Carroll St SE
Atlanta, GA, 30312
Phone (404) 577-2700
Website https://carrollstreetcabbagetown.com
Click To Get Directions

Opening Hours

Mon :11:00 am - 12

Specialities

Takes Reservations : Yes
Delivery : No
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Good For : Brunch
Parking : Street
Bike Parking : Yes
Wheelchair Accessible : Yes
Good for Kids : No
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Hipster
Noise Level : Average
Music : DJ
Good For Dancing : No
Alcohol : Full Bar
Happy Hour : Yes
Best Nights : Fri, Sat, Sun
Coat Check : No
Smoking : Outdoor Area/ Patio Only
Outdoor Seating : Yes
Wi-Fi : No
Has TV : No
Waiter Service : Yes
Caters : No

Claim Restaurant

WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES

Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online

Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.

Search Your Favourite Restaurants.

Carroll Street Café

208 Carroll St SE, Atlanta, GA, 30312

Carroll Street Café Menu

Appetizers

Salads

Tapas

Sandwiches

Pastas

Entrees

Desserts

Healthy Meal suggestions for Carroll Street Café

Appetizers

Salads

Tapas

Sandwiches

Pastas

Entrees

Desserts

Jeff M.

Tina L.

Mariana D.

Huzefa O.

Lori G.

Lloyd B.

ernesto s.

Miss J.

Keith H.

Coley W.

Shannon H.

Thien D.

Blake B.

Lauren T.

Rina H.

Russ G.

Smita P.

Foodie Buddha F.

Anna F.

Layne B.

Lisa K.

Emily B.

Eric W.

Mustard Mayo I.

Minerva M.

Caitlin L.

Betty R.

steven c.

Shonda K.

Sarah T.

Josie F.

Carlos C.

Mark T.

Roy K.

Edward L.

Jo Jo C.

Angela Y.

red l.

Stephie Z.

Stephanie M.

Leah T.

Shannon C.

Melissa B.

Clare B.

Chris L.

Kellyn W.

Kay U.

Thee Andersons s.

Howard W.

Marla P.

Talib K.

Malloy M.

Patrick Q.

D. B.

RaShonda J.

Claire S.

Daniel G.

Teri S.

Leeor N.

Michael B.

Kelley H.