Finding well seasoned and cooked lamb can be tough in TLH. Here, the lamb kebabs are moist and flavorful - and more importantly, perfectly grilled. Each time I've ordered them - they've come cooked no more than medium (I prefer medium rare/rare, but I also refrain from complicating my orders if not asked) and this is good. Although gazpacho is a cold soup, soups are only offered during the colder months - so that wasn't an option today. The couscous was accompanied by a melange of tomatoes, cucumbers and what appeared to be fava beans. It could have used a pat of butter - or any moisture - but again, I didn't ask for it. What is different from my last visit (perhaps 6 months ago) is the tea house section. There is a comprehensive selection of black, green, white and herbal teas. The separate sitting area is quite inviting as well. There aren't many middle eastern joints in town - and none quite like this, where customers queue up to the counter and choose from a broad range of options. I like it every bit as much as Sahara (I really do) and know there's not much I can't get here.
(4)
Alex D.
If you are looking for great greek food in Tallahassee this is the best I have found by far! You have to have the Pita Fries! The gyros are always delicious and they throw a ton of meat in them. I love Greek salad and theirs is great as well. Not my favorite style of dressing, theirs is a bit more tangy than I like. Service is quick and usually most people take takeout so the dining room is full of tables even though it gets busy. This is a must go for any Greek lover or foodie!
1st time here! & it was fantastic! My husbands 1st gyro also and he was very impressed. We will definitely be back. Nice atmosphere and reasonable prices.
(4)
Kate M.
Cheap, quick and consistent food is the love language of anyone with a timed lunch break. Pitaria is a quicker walk from my office than driving and hits the spot every time. My go-to is the greek deluxe salad, which is a greek salad with falafel patties and feta added. Dressing is a wee bit acidic for my taste but with the creamy feta, it balances out. Falafel is tasty and not overly salty. If you haven't been, you're missing out!
(4)
Brett P.
Talk about young trendy cool places to eat in Tallahassee! Great prices, great food, great customer service by Kaylee! Thank you! And I will be back.
(5)
Jessica C.
Food was amazing ! I ordered from Door Step Delivery and my food was fresh and delicious. I found this place on Yelp, narrowing down to places that delivered, since I was in town for work and needed to have something delivered to my room. I ordered the chicken Greek salad with the dressing in the side and the hummus and falafel platter. The salad was so fresh and to die for. The chicken was nice and hot and the salad was fresh as well and the portions was just the right size. The hummus and falafel platter was also very generous. The falafel wasn't as hot, but not disappointing because it's expected when you order something like that for delivery. I can only imagine how yummy it tastes freshly cooked. Overall, I will be ordering from here again.
(5)
Allison N.
I am shocked and surprised I haven't written a review for Pitaria yet as it's quickly become one of my favorite places to eat in Tallahassee. It's very close to downtown and to Florida State, so it often gets incredibly busy on the weekdays. If you go during the "off hours" or the weekends, however, it's an entirely different story and the line moves fairly quickly. I usually order the lamb salad with a side of tzatziki. The portions are really huge and full of feta cheese, delicious, tender lamb and fresh lettuce, cucumbers and tomatoes. The price is pretty standard -- around $10 for the salad plus the tzatziki. Their raspberry vinaigrette is not my favorite, so I usually don't use it at all. I've had the baklava too and it's really delicious. Service is always really friendly and generally quick. Expect a lot of college kids here chowing down on pita fries and falafel. Definitely a must-try in Tallahassee.
(5)
Kevin Y.
When I have friends in town, I always stop by Pitaria. The pita fries never disappoint and their tzatziki sauce is cool, smooth, and refreshing. This is one of the few places I miss when I leave Tally for extended periods of time. The falafel pita is my usual, and at $5.99 I think it's well worth it!
(5)
Christa H.
When I was going to school at FSU, I would go here once a week for dinner after classes. It is located right next to the campus which is really convenient because the parking lot is really difficult. It's impossible to turn left when leaving and the parking spaces aren't really made for anything bigger than a sedan. My go-to meal was always one of the combos, usually a chicken gyro. I'd get a side of hummus that came with fresh pieces of cucumber and pita bread. I could eat that hummus all day everyday. It was spiced really well and super creamy. My mouth is watering just thinking about the hummus. Don't forget to get some pita fries. They are strips of pita bread that has been fried and served with tzatziki sauce. I've never seen them anywhere else and they are so tasty. The menu is simple and very inexpensive. Perfect for a college student lifestyle.
(4)
Vanessa C.
Close to campus, quick, and delicious. If I'm not mistaken, I think I read somewhere that's the college-kid trifecta. Opt out of the McD's across the street and get some Pita Fries instead by making your meal a Combo meal for less than $10 bucks. Sure, it is a splurge compared to the dollar menu but I guarantee their falafels, gyros, soups, and salads won't be featured in any Huffington Post pieces on how artificial they are that mold won't grow on them. Perfect for a bite off-campus but will get you back in time for class. Or get it to go and eat your delectable meal next to your jealous classmates and enjoy the haterade with some evil side-eye you will get...don't sweat it, it's worth it.
(4)
Helen C.
This is the greek place FSU students go to eat gyro for cheap. Its located next to atomic coffee, gumbys, and target copy. There is parking in the back but good luck finding any! The food here isn't super fresh or anything but its still pretty good (and did I mention cheap?). What everyone gets is the combo meals. Basically get a lamb (or chicken) gyro, and pita fries with a drink. The greek fries are good to but its basically just french fries cut into crinkle circles (for those that don't like pita). You can get all that for like $8. I say thats a pretty good deal. Oh, and they have baklava! Overall, great little greek place, its cheap and fast and pretty tasty.
(4)
Lara M.
Very good Greek food. The gyro royale was delicious. The tabouli lacked lemon, garlic and bulgar wheat. All the things that make tabouli so wonderful! Over all. Good experience with fresh ingredients.
(4)
Breanna W.
Pita fries are amazing, gyro was great, staff was nice, prices are great. This was better than expected. Would really recommend this place! The building is pretty run down and old however.
(4)
Zach H.
This place is a Tallahassee institution and a local favorite. So I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place yet because I lived in Tally for 7 years and have been to this place too many times to count... but two words: Pita Fries. I promise that you will not find Pita Fries anywhere else. I know that I've looked tirelessly to find some, but no such luck. This is your no frills, walk-up counter type of Greek place but the food is not to be taken lightly. All of the pita sandwiches are liberally stuffed with the filling of your choice. My favorites are the Gyro Royale and the Gyro Supreme. The Greek Fries also deserve an honorable mention because these aren't your average fries, they are little fried coins of deliciousness. Be sure to check out the daily special, because those are worth considering too. Overall, the service is generally pretty good and the food will always leave you appropriately satisfied. Pitaria is and always will be a Tallahassee favorite... especially for the Pita Fries.
(4)
Jessica C.
I once found that the cook accidentally cooked a screw from the grill in my pita, and that still doesnt hold me back from leaving a good review. Pita fries, hummus, chicken pita, cheese steak pita... you name it, this place is deeeeelish. Just try to avoid the lunch rush if you don't like waiting in line!
(4)
Gerry F.
Good food although the air conditioning was broken and they were out of half the sodas in the soda fountain. Probably won't be back. Where else are they cutting corners?
(1)
Morgan S.
In town for a few days and I had a craving for Mediterranean. This place hit the spot. It is pretty unassuming from both the outside and the inside, and it definitely had a university vibe going on. But, the food was good for a Tallahassee Mediterranean spot. I had the veggie plate. The tabouli was delicious, hummus was creamy, and the pita was fresh and warm. The falafel was lacking a bit of flavor, but overall I was satisfied.
(4)
Ljs B.
Oh my pitaria, xoxoxo. I haven't had GYRO in a million years. It was my perfect comeback experience the euro is fresh and perfectly crisped. The tzatiki was delicious cool and refreshing. I love the supreme w/ feta cheese in the gyro and the tea was so good. I'm really excited about taking Caroline back up to FSU in the fall just so I can eat there again
(5)
Alyssa H.
Pita fries are amazing. The food is delicious. But today I had a bad experience. It was EXTREMELY hot inside. Almost as if they don't have the A/C on in the middle of July... We found a seat with a vent blowing a little air but still were uncomfortable and tried to leave quickly. Also three of the sodas were flat, I gave up trying to find some with carbonation.
(3)
Zhuo S.
I ordered the gyro royale and my boyfriend a chicken fajita pita, he doesn't like his, said the chicken is not flavored enough, but quite enjoyed my goat meat. I have to say though it doesn't look very appetizing but the goat meat is real good!!
(4)
Diane A.
Pitaria 10 years later still doesn't fail! Only thing in 10 years that has changed is the price, of course! My days at FSU were from 2001-2006 (5 year plan thanks to the college of Engineering lol) and I've probably gone to Pitaria more than 60 times hahaha. Still have my college house in Tally (up for sale now that bro is done with college) & when we would go to visit we would always visit Pitaria! I always get my regular - chicken supreme with pita fries. Pita fries are my hands down fav menu item. Recently went to Pitaria before watching the FSU vs Miami game this year and we stopped by Pitaria....lord knew devoured those pita fries. Parking is located in the back and shared with establishments on that strip. Don't forget to try Gumbys while there!
(5)
Johnny M.
I will first note that it is a big pet peeve of mine when businesses publish coupons and then give you a very hard time about honoring them. Be very alert when trying to use any buy one get one half off as it is very limited as to what it applies too. The manager ultimately worked with me but both he and the staff person were somewhat inconsiderate and not very eager to help. The staff person was trained very poorly in this regard. That being said, the food was pretty good and the prices aren't unreasonable. The pita was very tasty and the fillings good as well. I would consider eating here again but I am very turned off my the service I received.
(3)
Christopher H.
This would be the place I would go whenever my friends would go to Jenny's or Atomic. I loved the Pita Fries so much that I've even made them at home. It is divey enough to keep some people out and local. The food was always good. I'd get a sandwich or a gyro, everytime never let down. The decor was wood and divey. I liked it, always had a nice vibe in there. Pricing was decent for a kid on a college budget. I can't complain.
(4)
George F.
I stopped in for lunch while in town on business. The gyro was good but the Greek chips were disappointing. The service and atmosphere were fine. I'd rate it a 3 1/2 if I could but not a 4.
(3)
Sarah K.
Pitaria has really good food! It has awesome pitas and great pita fries. It also has vegetarian and vegan options. It has good prices and hours.
(5)
Jessica L.
Oh how I will miss my Pitaria!!! Can you guys open up in Tampa, too?! My friend introduced me to it and the first time I got a roast beef pita and (at her insistence) the pita fries with dip. While not the most Greek and adventurous, the roast beef pita reminded me of a yummy cheeseburger but it's the only thing I have ever ordered. Also the pita fries are PHENOMENAL strips of pita fried up and served with an amazing dipping sauce. We got the cinnamon pita fries once and they were great but the pita fries are just outstanding. Pretty plain interior and decor but there's a market next door and there's plenty of seating both in and outside. Parking can also be an issue behind the building but overall totally totally worth it! Go try it, you won't be disappointed!
(5)
David A.
Nice college atmosphere about a block off the FSU campus. Large sized sandwiches and salads that are served fresh and made to order. Prices are reasonable for the portion size and quality. I had the vegetarian platter which had falafel and hummus. It was tasty but just not off the charts, clean your plate quality. Servicable and good. Tried my daughters grilled chicken greek salad and I have the same opinion of this dish. Good, but not great. Indoor and outdoor seating. It was busy but the line moves quick and food is served very fast. A good lunch while visiting the campus. I am sure it beats the options at the school.
(3)
Dave B.
Some of my coworkers walked into the office with some takeout and I knew instantly I needed to have some. I've been here dozens of times and love the food. Gyro Royals combo with Greek Fries and a Sweet Tea is what I always get. Today was no different. Value: The price of the food is very affordable for the quantity and quality of food you get. I never leave hungry. My meal was $8 and change. Taste: The taste is what keeps me coming back. They gyro is flavorful and the Greek fries are a relic on their own. I've come many times just for the fries. Today, my meal doesn't disappoint. The sweet tea is fresh and perfectly sweetened. 4 stars! Unfortunately, I have to drop to 3 for one, very important reason: cleanliness. The place could use a real good hose down. Dust on the Plants. Sticky counters. Grime on the table legs. Avoid the restroom! Disgusting. Dirty. No soap. No paper towel. Grafitti. Just plain nasty. The latCe night crowd might not mind, but as a daytime professional looking for lunch, this could be a real turnoff. Im
(3)
Tyler L.
Food is good and priced good, location is great walking distance to some business and parts of FSU. Only thing I didn't care for is me and a friend paid, the cashier said "Our dining room is closed, you'll have to take your order to go" although there was an ample amount of people still there, and it was 15 min before closing time. The proper business practice is that you stop taking orders by locking the door at closing time, and your paid customers can dine as they please, not start clearing house because you want to leave at 5 after closing!. But that was sometime ago.
(4)
Paula S.
The pita fries are amazing! Their soda machine is really dirty and you can see the grime build up clear as day. The overall restaurant isn't very clean but the food is delicious! Make sure the baklava is fresh before buying--the one time I added it to my meal it was stale.
(3)
Jennifer I.
Pretty good! I've had better Greek food down near Tampa, but that's because there is a huge Greek population down there...so maybe my hopes are always too high. Pitaria, however, is good enough and satisfies my Mediterranean needs. The gyro is good, the chicken caesar pita is good, and the pita fries are delicious. It gets extremely busy around 12:30-1pm, so get there early if you want to avoid the line!
(4)
Mizz V.
Oh Pitaria, my hopes were so high! I love a good Gyro and when I saw they had Fattoush, I knew exactly what my meal would be. After reading through the reviews, I knew this wasn't authentic by any means, but it sounded delicious nonetheless. Based on those reviews I added an order of Pita Fries as well. I called in the order ahead of time on a Sunday evening and was told it would be 10 minutes. After 45 minutes of waiting, I still had no food but plenty of opportunity to watch this place in action. With only 2 tables with 2 customers at each and no one on line, I couldn't understand the wait time. No one was calling in, no one was picking up orders. Weird. I was so excited about my pita fries, and so hungry from waiting that I opened my to-go box right on the patio and took a bite of steaming hot crispiness. Perfect texture, but WTF??? What is the over salted seasoning that these poor fries got bathed in? I figured in my greediness I just took one over salted one from the top, so I dug in and tried again. WTF?! More salt! Now just to reference, by no means am I adverse to salt or seasonings, but this was gross. The meat and pita fries tasted like they were made with old oil and then covered in seasoned salt to cover up the mediocre flavor. Unfortunately the gyro, the salad and the salad were all seasoned with the same exact seasoning blend, so not only did it all taste way too salty - it all tasted like crap. If you're a broke, stoned college student then I'm sure you'll love the food, but mine went straight into the garbage can.
(2)
Milton V.
Killer gyros/chicken pitas. No lie, I credit this place with my insatiable appetite for Greek things. Lol.
(4)
Tara S.
II used to live in Peabody Mass where there was a large Greek population and a ton of great restaurants. When I saw that Pitaria was a Mom and Pop joint I had high hopes for some good eats. Not so much. Chicken kabob plate was awful as well as the spinakopita. If you want great Greek food in Tally just wait for the Greek festival and pig out.
(2)
Bunny N.
Ok, the negative first: I wasn't too impressed with the inside of Pitaria. The table and chairs were old, and my chair was uneven that it rocked back and forth. It was a hot summer day in Florida during the middle of June, and the a/c didn't seem to be blowing out enough cold air. Despite the temperature of the restaurant, Pitaria's food was amazing! I had a gyro with hummus on the side. I was so surprised how stuffed the pita was, and how much hummus came with it. It was delicious! The food was so good that it canceled out the negative! I would go back to the Pitaria again, but maybe get "take out" the next time around it's a hot summer day.
(4)
Y A.
Food is great and a good bang for the buck.
(4)
Tom S.
This place is overrated. The chicken and beef kabobs were just okay but the meat wasn't that tender and the portion was small. The hummous was some of the grittiest I've ever had and flavor wasn't great.
(2)
Erin J.
Delicious food, large servings, quick service, good value.
(5)
MICHELLE C.
Pita fries, yummy. Steak and cheese with mushrooms, onions, and mayo wrapped in a thick soft pita. Opa!! Authentic great greek food with great service from a very friendly staff. Prices, well what can I say other than Tallahassee has so many places that are so reasonable for all the college students. Forget the big name chain restaurants, this place and many other's are small holes, nothing fancy with excellent food and prices. :) Gyro sandwich hubby said was really good. But onto the fries, they are seasones pita fries, long, thick and we got our's with hummus on the side to dip. Pure delightful!!! Three people for dinner $26.....and we were full and happy... Great place and awesome friendly staff...
(4)
Hank S.
Once upon a time, I went here way too often for a chicken supreme pita with no onions and extra peppers in a combo with pita fries and really good tea, and I ate that at least once a week because it is mfin delicious and also fairly cheap and not greasy fast food, and I suggest it to anyone who likes good Greek casual food, but not if your favorite is hummus because that is their weak spot. The End
(4)
Maria D.
Have you ever seen the episode of Seinfeld with the soup nazi? Well, this is exactly how it felt talking to the "manager" at Pitaria. I was skipped over by about 8 people, so I asked where my food was. 3 orders later, my food came out. Naturally, I wanted to talk to the manager to see if he could compensate me for my time. He proceeded to YELL at me. "ABSOLUTELY NOT! I GAVE YOU YOUR FOOD RIGHT? GET OUT OF HERE!" I asked him if he was serious. Seems like he was. Mind you I am a young professional living in Tallahassee (seemingly contradictory I know), who was courteously trying to lodge a complaint with management. I asked him his name and he absolutely refused, "WHY DO YOU WANT MY NAME?". Stay far away from this place as they do not care about their customers, and head over to the friendly, professional and delicious Little Athens gyro around the corner.
(1)
Matt W.
Solid gyro place. I went during the lunch rush and the place the packed, but service was still very fast. I had a standard gyro with the "Greek fries" which were large, round-cut french fries. The fries were pretty basic, but their novel shape made them a little less boring. The gyro itself was very good. Nothing incredible, but with tasty meat and a warm pita. At the Pitaria you order at the counter, and then they will bring to food to you. The restaurant is pretty small, but has a little "grocery" section adjoining the dining room where they sell specialty items. I enjoyed the Pitaria, and prices were decent. The combo meals, which include fries and a drink all seemed to be priced around $8. The only complaint I really had was that the only parking lot is behind the building and very cramped. Give it a shot if you are near FSU's campus!
(3)
Mai T.
I haven't had much experience with greek food, so this is not a review on the "Greekness" of the place but just the quality. Great place to eat. The pitas are a little smaller than I originally thought but loads better than pita pit (aka subway in a pita). I have never heard of pita fries till I went here. Something good to try. Really constantly nice workers and nice atmosphere. It is just kinda difficult to get to but that shouldn't stop you from going. One of the better places to eat in Tally.
(3)
Rema K.
They have an amaizing greek food , try the gyro IT iS THE BEST , also try the fatoch salad , shawerma , hummus ,
(4)
Edward J.
It was good, that's all you need to know.
(4)
Leah H.
Great combo specials, falafel wraps, hummus, and pita fries! Not going to lie, I was a bit skeptical of these pita fries but they turned out to be absolutely addicting! The seasoning is really tasty and they're a decent size. Falafel wraps are large and filling for the low prices. Side portions of hummus are also a generous size. I'll definitely be back next time I am visiting Tallahassee
(4)
Shawna K.
The best hangover food that costs very little dinero can be found at Pitaria in the form of their gyro And we can't forget the pita fries slices of heaven and huge in size If I was a young college co-ed this would be my go to spot rolling out of bed But I would stick to only their Greek menu fare the meatball sub and wings, I'd only eat on a dare Hence the reason for only four stars but again, their greek eats are way above par Can't to visit Tally and my son again soon So I can drink too much and then eat here at noon!
(4)
Vito G.
I lived really close to where the largest congregation of Greek-Americans in the world lived, so I'm used to really authenti-tasting Greek. When you go to a place like this, some fast food version of a great people's culinary accomplishments, it feels like you've been ripped off a bit. I mean, I'll eat their gyros. I dig their chicken pitas. Their hummus is tasteless but palatable. It is the first place I ever tried falafel, so there's that. I'm mostly bored by this place, but I don't mind it when I'm there. My friends can't get enough of it, it seems. Weird. I also don't know if it's pronounced as if it rhymes with pizzeria, or pee-tar-e-uh.
(3)
Andreea S.
The tzatziki sauce was way too salty... everything was salty... I'm not anal about greek food but this was a let-down. Honestly, I didnt even bother finishing my meal ... go to Little Athens across the street- it is a massive improvement for about the same price! And the tzatziki sauce actually tastes like tzatziki sauce. I won't be coming here again.
(2)
Coty S.
I miss their Pita Fries ($3.50)! There is nowhere else that I have found to make them for me. They are slices of fried pita bread, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Seasoned with just the right amount of spices and served with delicious sour cream and cucumber dipping sauce. Sigh... Their classic Gyro is also nothing to laugh at, filled with twice the meat of most places, add feta for true bliss. They are within walking distance from campus, and parking is a nightmare. Just walk there, and walk off those pita fries. They also have yummy desserts, and a free refill soda fountain. Cash only, but there is an ATM.
(4)
J D.
Have had the pita fries, the gyro, the veggie plate, the falafel. Gyro is pretty standard, nothing special, but good for Tallahassee. I believe they Pita fries are pretty good and seasoned well. The Gyros use the standard Kronos meat which is a premade gyro. Veggie platter is good, hummus isn't the greatest. The desert items from the grocery store next door however are excellent. Try the angel kisses. They are catering to college students so I understand why they can't take it up a notch and make the flavors more authentic. Falafel is pretty good, nice and green, and one of the better ones in Tallahassee if not the best, out of maybe 5 choices, so take that as you will. It tastes and looks like falafel but isn't missing that gooey inside and some more flavoring. If you need some greek food, this place does it but don't expect to be wowed unless you aren't very experienced with greek food in places that have large greek populations for instance.
(3)
Darlene R.
Went in with my son as a first time visit. Cashier was so sweet. Offered to make my little boy a simple grilled chicken with fries dish, since he's picky and they don't have a kids menu. I had a gyro, added feta, with Greek fries. It was delicious. Even their regular fries are awesome. I will definitely be back.
(5)
KyungAh L.
Their gyros aren't the best in Tallahassee, but their pita fries are to die for! They probably have one of the best pita fries I've ever tasted and their gyros are decent too.
(3)
April K.
Love their pita fries, hummus, and Gyros! Too good. Great spot for waiting for your next class on campus or for grabbing a quick bite if you happen to be on that side of town. I have never not liked anything I have eaten there.
(4)
Catherine H.
This restaurant is close to the music building on campus, so I walk here every once in awhile for a quick bite. I usually have a falafel and hummus platter or a gyro. The falafel is delicious, and the gyros are pretty amazing. The hummus has great flavor but can be a little dry. Olive oil is your friend, Pitaria! I also recommend the pita fries.
(3)
Hazel P.
5 stars for their PITA FRIES! Have been going here for years, even after college I crave their pita fries! A definite must during your undergrad college years. Other than the pita fries, the gyro wraps are pretty good too. They have an amazing Mediterranean creamy tomato soup the owner makes once in a blue moon that is def. to die for as well. Don't expect five star service though, remember it is just your regular college joint, just have a side of the pita fries and it'll be all good.
(5)
Kristina T.
Bottom line: Pitaria makes excellent pitas, falafels, and fries of all kinds. Their falafel pitas are filling, cheap, and super delicious and paired with pita or greek fries is one of my favorite meals. Get the tzatziki instead of the tahini in your pita, it is yummy! Also, a kind of odd comment, their soda machine has always tasted off to me. I would usually get the Diet Pepsi and it always had a weird taste. I tried other drinks from the same fountain and they, too, tasted wrong. Maybe it's the water?
(5)
Adina F.
The food is just ok, and to be honest its pretty overrated. When asked if they had any souvlaki, the cashier girl gave me the blankest stare I ever received while ordering food, so obviously this place isn't the most authentic you'll visit. The falafel is pretty good but what I usually get is gyro with tzaziki in a pita. The pita fries are the best thing on the menu here, for sure. As for the interior, its pretty ugly so I just sit outside.
(3)
Justin F.
I don't know why, but it seems, as of late, I don't feel like places I go fall neatly into the 5 star scheme. Here, I would give Pitaria 3.75 stars. I do enjoy it, but saying I am a fan seems just a TAD to much. Anyhoo, most of the food here is pretty simple "greek" food. I put it in quotes because of one of my favs, the fajita pita (something tells me that isn't a classic Greek dish). I have had a couple other dishes here and they have all been pretty good, but not exceptional. I have always enjoyed it, but the have been a couple hiccups (my fiancee's greek fries were pretty bad last time). I have heard complaints about the staff, but I have always found them to be pretty friendly. And I don't know about the parking complaints. The lot behind iit has never been full when I went. All-in-all it is a cool little place with decent prices that I definitely recommend trying out.
(4)
Cherry J.
Gotta correct some other reviews: this place is definitely NOT cash-only and the parking situation isn't bad at all. Sure, it's not a huge or glamorous parking lot, but there has always been a spot for me when I go there. Onto the food. YUM. The gyros are about as good as they come, and the pita fries are TO DIE FOR. You must get them. They don't seem to exist outside of this restaurant, so not only are they delicious, but also super-special. Service is okay. I've had some strange moments there. For instance, when I wanted a refund because the soda machine was out of what I wanted, and the cashier looked at me like I was an alien, telling me that the two drinks I bought "only cost a few cents." Well excuse me! Other than that, no issues. Awesome food. Go forth.
(5)
Marisa R.
How I wish I was into Mediterranean food as much as I am now back when I lived in Tallahassee. Came back to visit and tried Pitaria to fix a falafel craving. The falafel pieces are probably the best I've had thus far. It was my favorite part of the meal. I also had a lamb kabob and a beef kabob. The beef was just okay, but the lamb was very tasty and tender. The hummus tasted very fresh, a big plus, but it could've used a bit more garlic and lemon. The pitas were also surprisingly good considering that I normally don't care for pita. (Only a few restaurants have gotten me to actually enjoy it as a food instead of a cardboard-like food holder.) I did have to take off one star for the decor. The tables felt very mismatched and dirty, and this always makes me a little wary. I think the restaurant would benefit greatly from a modern, clean makeover. Of course, food is the most essential element for a restaurant, right? And the food was fresh and delicious. I'm not sure if I'll be visiting again before I end my vacation, but I'll definitely go back the next time I'm in town.
(4)
Tiffany G.
Hummus and Tabouli pita, pita fries, feta and tomato salad with that red dressing they leave out at the tables!!!! Yum!! I miss Pitaria!!!
(5)
Whitnae P.
I like this place. They have a wide variety of options for you to choose from and very rarely do I leave the place not feeling satisfied. Also because it has falafel and hummus and other common greek foods on the menu, it's vegan friendly... if you dig that kind of stuff. I will say though, do not order the fish. It has made many of my friends sick after they ate it.
(3)
Keagan W.
I love Pitaria. I first went there when I was working for Doorstep Delivery and the food always looked so good, that I had to try it. I've been 3 times and loved my gyro every time. I think that the gyros are about even with Little Athens, but Little Athens has much better pita fries. You can see right back into the kitchen and trust who's making your food and the staff has always been friendly.
(5)
J R.
Great place open on sundays. Best gyro ever get the supreme.
(4)
Allen B.
I work at FSU and walk to Pitaria at least once a week. This is the only restaurant that I'm willing to walk off campus for on a regular basis. The food is outstanding, authentic Greek food. I haven't found another Greek restaurant in Tallahassee that comes close, and I love Greek food. Prices are reasonable, the lunch special with a drink costs me about $8.50 including tax. My favorite meals are the regular gyro or the chicken gyro, with pita fries. If you get nothing else from Pitaria, make sure you get the pita fries. They are unbelievable. The service is interesting. It's always the same people in the back, and almost always the same cashier. I definitely wouldn't call it friendly service, in fact I'm almost scared to talk to anyone but the cashier. Sort of like a Seinfeld episode - order, sit down, and wait. But the food is fantastic, served quickly, and I make a point of taking my out of town guests here. None of them have ever been disappointed.
(5)
Danielle C.
Pitaria is good, cheap, and fast. I always get the pitas. They have several different kinds and they are very filling. You can get a combo with a side of your choice and a drink for around 8 dollars. My favorite is definitely the pita fries. I haven't been in Tallahassee all summer and I definitely missed them. I usually get their hummus too, which is pretty authentic. This is a must for fast paced college students!
(4)
Danny B.
Gyro: excellent. Falafel: excellent. Pita fries: excellent. Hummus: excellent. The pitas themselves are thick and soft. The baklava is good. The price is very good, but not absolutely amazing. Still, a very good value for incredible food.
(5)
Hannah P.
I love love love Pitaria! I usually just get the regular gyro, which is really good, but the last time I went I got the falafel gyro and it was fantastic! It may not be the prettiest place, but definitely go there for the food, you won't be sorry! (Be sure to get the pita fries too). :)
(5)
Lauren E.
Unfortunately I only started eating at Pitaria about 2 months before I left Tallahassee... big mistake. The food is tasty and relatively quick. It's a healthier option than a lot of take-out places in the area and the menu is fairly extensive. The pita fries are AMAZING! I never had anything less than a good meal here. Parking is a pain, so walk here if you can.
(4)
Andy E.
Yea, that's right - "Woohoo!, As good as it gets!" Why? Well to start, Pitaria is basically right on campus... Well worth the few extra steps past the "same old, same old" Subway that gives you like 4 slices of turkey and a ton of lettuce on your foot-long... the pitas here are enormous! I eat a lot and just one of these babies and a side of AMAZING pita fries filled me up (Subway leaves me hungry). And you can't beat the price! ***Pitaria will cost you less than lunch or dinner at Suwanee/Fresh*** I can't think of a better place to grab a hearty dinner around here. The atmosphere is really nice. You'll feel like you're on a Greek island (You'll understand that cheesy joke once you get there). Most food joints around campus are either boring franchises or greasy holes-in-the-wall. Pitaria is extremely healthy and the staff is surprisingly helpful, but most importantly - good eats!
(5)
Magnus H.
Not sure why people are orgasing on themselves over this place. It's fine. Just your basic Middle Eastern fare. enjoy.
(3)
Anne P.
I've been going to Pitaria since I was in high school and keep going back. Sure, the location and decor isn't so great (I liked it a lot better when it was next door and there was a mural of Athens), but the food is awesome and consistent. I always get Fozi's falafel pita and pita fries. The falafel is really good, crunchy on the outside and warm and soft on the inside. Also, bonus points for being green!
(5)
Kat D.
I have to say this isn't a very authentic greek restaurant, but it's quick and pretty darn delicious. The pita fries alone are reason enough to keep me coming back, but their falafel pita and salads are top notch as well. The food is pretty cheap for what you get so on a college student budget, it's definitely worth stopping by.
(4)
Gary W.
Only had a minute to get a supreme gyros and a falafel, but what we had was great. It's not a fancy place, primarily serving the college crowd, but it was quick (except for the credit card machine, hopefully that was a temporary glitch) clean and delicious.
(4)
Max F.
Parking lot in the back, which was convenient, if a little tight. Lots of seating and open space, and the food was delicious. Subtracting one star because my girlfriend bit into an olive pit and the employees offered little more than an "ehh, it happens." Examine your gyros and you should be good.
(4)
Krystal H.
I had a gyro and let me say it was great. The meat was seasoned and cooked beautifully, there was just the right amount of filling for the pita. Very good.
(5)
Leslie E.
I really love Pitaria! I get their Chicken Caesar pita with Greek fries and I never regret it. The service is fast/good and there are always plenty of places to sit. The food always tastes fresh, too. My only complaint is the parking: there basically isn't any. There's a parking lot in the back for about 2 other restaurants, and like 10 parking spaces in total. If you're a student with decal, you can park in a teacher's lot (after 5pm M-F), but it's still a walk. If you're not a student, you're probably out of luck when it comes to parking. But that's not their fault. :)
(4)
Y Y.
Good place for a casual, tasty meal. Extensive menu of sandwiches and pitas. They have several combo meals such as any sandwich or pita, pita fries or Greek fries and a drink for around $7.50. They also have combos with salads. There is also a good variety of vegetarian options on the menu. Place and pay for your order and then they will bring it to you. There are tables inside and several outside. The portions are reasonable. Parking is behind the store and during peak times can be a little tight. They're open until late at night. You can order their food through CapitalCityFood.com and so you can get an idea of their menu and prices at capitalcityfood.com/rest…
(4)
Adam O.
The fries, greek style, are amazing. The gyros were okay but bland. It's a great place for cheap and quick casual food.
(3)
Emily B.
Pitaria. Struggling to find a suitable place to eat dinner on our first night in Tallahassee, we hoped Pitaria would deliver the good Greek food that we read about on yelp reviews. It is located near the FSU campus, and we noticed the worn-out look of its parking lot and interior, as sometimes accompanies campus favorites. We both liked the taste of our falafel pitas and bean pitas, with delicious pita fries and tahini sauce dip, but unfortunately there was a large olive pit in one of our pitas.
(4)
David S.
Not impressed with gyros.
(2)
Molly H.
falafel and pita fries are to die for. best in town.
(5)
Cassidy L.
Pitaria does good business for a reason! I really enjoyed my gyro- it was flavorful and not greasy or dry. The Greek fries are yummy (though a few were dry), but they need more seasoning. I wish it were a bit cheaper, but I can't quibble too much with good food.
(5)
Natascha P.
Very reasonably priced and delicious!!! Every time I leave there I am satisfied- sometimes stuffed. Even my vegan friends love it! The gyros and felafel pitas are excellent, and I also like the cheese steak and caesar pitas as well. When you go, you MUST get the pita fries. They're addicting and come with a yummy tzatziki dipping sauce. Mmmmm.
(5)
Scottie B.
If I could eat at Pitaria every single day, I would. The food here is exceptionally good and provides a unique departure from most of the food in Tallahassee. Gyros, pita fries with tzaziki, cinnapitas... I'm starting to drool. Also, the service staff are cool and pierced.
(4)
Ari W.
Pitaria is one of my favorite place in Tallahassee. Most of the reviews here are pretty right-on, so I'll just say that my favorite is their Greek Salad with gyro meat. Their vinaigrette dressing is super yum!!!
(5)
Renee B.
I love this place!! Always went there for lunch when I lived in Tally!!
(5)
Jaryd G.
terrible, if you are expecting something good to eat try going somwhere else. we came here and had gyros, they were terrible. it had good reviews, and i use yelp weekly and have never been let down but this place sucks.
(1)
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
Address :631 W Tennessee St
Tallahassee, FL, 32304
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : No Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Lunch Parking : Private Lot Bike Parking : No Wheelchair Accessible : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Ambience : Casual Noise Level : Average Alcohol : No Outdoor Seating : Yes Wi-Fi : Free Has TV : No Waiter Service : No Caters : Yes
Greek food is a fine melody of the finest pressed olive oil, fresh fermented bread, colorful vegetables, juicy meat, sea food all cooked in spices and fresh rosemary. The people from Greek were great scholars who aimed to excel in everything they do. The results are quite visible in their food as they are the inventors of olive oil which is beneficial to health. Greeks also made different type of wines from the best quality of grapes fermented in controlled environment.
Today, you can find hundreds of restaurants offering authentic Greek food or popularly termed as Mediterranean cuisine in New York city alone. People wait in line to taste the exotic Greek dishes like saganaki, taramasalata, souvlaki, loukoumades, spanakopita, moussaka, and many more. One thing which most people like about these authentic Greek dishes is abundant use of lemon juice, olive oil, fresh rosemary and sea salt. A smart mix of few ingredients can virtually take you on the pebble streets of beautiful city of Greece.
For those who don't have time to enjoy fine dining should try tasting the famous souvlaki with pita which is type of meat dish, also a trademark Greek fast food. For those who are vegetarian, or vegan can try different versions of Greek Salad. So, if you wish to enjoy a hearty yet healthy meal that tastes divine then try dining at the best Greek restaurant in your city. Greek cuisine not only tastes good but also help maintain your body in a natural way through healthy diet.
Daniel P.
Finding well seasoned and cooked lamb can be tough in TLH. Here, the lamb kebabs are moist and flavorful - and more importantly, perfectly grilled. Each time I've ordered them - they've come cooked no more than medium (I prefer medium rare/rare, but I also refrain from complicating my orders if not asked) and this is good. Although gazpacho is a cold soup, soups are only offered during the colder months - so that wasn't an option today. The couscous was accompanied by a melange of tomatoes, cucumbers and what appeared to be fava beans. It could have used a pat of butter - or any moisture - but again, I didn't ask for it. What is different from my last visit (perhaps 6 months ago) is the tea house section. There is a comprehensive selection of black, green, white and herbal teas. The separate sitting area is quite inviting as well. There aren't many middle eastern joints in town - and none quite like this, where customers queue up to the counter and choose from a broad range of options. I like it every bit as much as Sahara (I really do) and know there's not much I can't get here.
(4)Alex D.
If you are looking for great greek food in Tallahassee this is the best I have found by far! You have to have the Pita Fries! The gyros are always delicious and they throw a ton of meat in them. I love Greek salad and theirs is great as well. Not my favorite style of dressing, theirs is a bit more tangy than I like. Service is quick and usually most people take takeout so the dining room is full of tables even though it gets busy. This is a must go for any Greek lover or foodie!
(5)Matthew C.
"Give me only what I need/it doesn't take too much to keep me satisfied." I'm borrowing lyrics from one of my favorite rock bands to express not only my outlook on life, but my admiration for the sidewalk Greek stand. Situated on Tennessee Street, next to Gumby's Pizza and what use to be Atomic Coffee, Pitaria succeeds at pumping out street food with a taste of home. Pitaria was one of the very first restaurants I visited when I moved to Tallahassee many years ago. It's your classic hole-in-the-wall restaurant. Décor isn't a priority, but seating is ample and the food inexpensive. MUST: an order of the Greek fries. Crisp, a little bit salty, and served with a cool, tzatziki sauce guaranteed to stop a baby from crying. In all my years, I've devoured close to everything on the menu. However, during my most recent visits, I've been branching out by trying many of the vegetarian items. I never say this, but I don't miss meat at all, forgive me fellow carnivores! A few days back, the Tabouleh and Hummus Pita worked wonders. Immediately my taste buds were awoken by the fresh tabouleh salad. Then, the creamy hummus jumped on board to bring the sandwich full circle. My Greek roots are swinging on the dance floor after a pita like this. Everything from the Gyros to the Chicken Pitas to the Falafels are astonishing. Pitaria fills a much needed hole in the college town scene. Although, the line can be out the door during prime lunch hour, the service is quick while still warm, and the wait time is appropriate. Tallahassee has surprisingly great Mediterranean options, (even a competitor directly near Pitaria) however I've been hooked here since day one. Pitaria has my business, my loyalty and a piece of my heart.
(5)Denise T.
1st time here! & it was fantastic! My husbands 1st gyro also and he was very impressed. We will definitely be back. Nice atmosphere and reasonable prices.
(4)Kate M.
Cheap, quick and consistent food is the love language of anyone with a timed lunch break. Pitaria is a quicker walk from my office than driving and hits the spot every time. My go-to is the greek deluxe salad, which is a greek salad with falafel patties and feta added. Dressing is a wee bit acidic for my taste but with the creamy feta, it balances out. Falafel is tasty and not overly salty. If you haven't been, you're missing out!
(4)Brett P.
Talk about young trendy cool places to eat in Tallahassee! Great prices, great food, great customer service by Kaylee! Thank you! And I will be back.
(5)Jessica C.
Food was amazing ! I ordered from Door Step Delivery and my food was fresh and delicious. I found this place on Yelp, narrowing down to places that delivered, since I was in town for work and needed to have something delivered to my room. I ordered the chicken Greek salad with the dressing in the side and the hummus and falafel platter. The salad was so fresh and to die for. The chicken was nice and hot and the salad was fresh as well and the portions was just the right size. The hummus and falafel platter was also very generous. The falafel wasn't as hot, but not disappointing because it's expected when you order something like that for delivery. I can only imagine how yummy it tastes freshly cooked. Overall, I will be ordering from here again.
(5)Allison N.
I am shocked and surprised I haven't written a review for Pitaria yet as it's quickly become one of my favorite places to eat in Tallahassee. It's very close to downtown and to Florida State, so it often gets incredibly busy on the weekdays. If you go during the "off hours" or the weekends, however, it's an entirely different story and the line moves fairly quickly. I usually order the lamb salad with a side of tzatziki. The portions are really huge and full of feta cheese, delicious, tender lamb and fresh lettuce, cucumbers and tomatoes. The price is pretty standard -- around $10 for the salad plus the tzatziki. Their raspberry vinaigrette is not my favorite, so I usually don't use it at all. I've had the baklava too and it's really delicious. Service is always really friendly and generally quick. Expect a lot of college kids here chowing down on pita fries and falafel. Definitely a must-try in Tallahassee.
(5)Kevin Y.
When I have friends in town, I always stop by Pitaria. The pita fries never disappoint and their tzatziki sauce is cool, smooth, and refreshing. This is one of the few places I miss when I leave Tally for extended periods of time. The falafel pita is my usual, and at $5.99 I think it's well worth it!
(5)Christa H.
When I was going to school at FSU, I would go here once a week for dinner after classes. It is located right next to the campus which is really convenient because the parking lot is really difficult. It's impossible to turn left when leaving and the parking spaces aren't really made for anything bigger than a sedan. My go-to meal was always one of the combos, usually a chicken gyro. I'd get a side of hummus that came with fresh pieces of cucumber and pita bread. I could eat that hummus all day everyday. It was spiced really well and super creamy. My mouth is watering just thinking about the hummus. Don't forget to get some pita fries. They are strips of pita bread that has been fried and served with tzatziki sauce. I've never seen them anywhere else and they are so tasty. The menu is simple and very inexpensive. Perfect for a college student lifestyle.
(4)Vanessa C.
Close to campus, quick, and delicious. If I'm not mistaken, I think I read somewhere that's the college-kid trifecta. Opt out of the McD's across the street and get some Pita Fries instead by making your meal a Combo meal for less than $10 bucks. Sure, it is a splurge compared to the dollar menu but I guarantee their falafels, gyros, soups, and salads won't be featured in any Huffington Post pieces on how artificial they are that mold won't grow on them. Perfect for a bite off-campus but will get you back in time for class. Or get it to go and eat your delectable meal next to your jealous classmates and enjoy the haterade with some evil side-eye you will get...don't sweat it, it's worth it.
(4)Helen C.
This is the greek place FSU students go to eat gyro for cheap. Its located next to atomic coffee, gumbys, and target copy. There is parking in the back but good luck finding any! The food here isn't super fresh or anything but its still pretty good (and did I mention cheap?). What everyone gets is the combo meals. Basically get a lamb (or chicken) gyro, and pita fries with a drink. The greek fries are good to but its basically just french fries cut into crinkle circles (for those that don't like pita). You can get all that for like $8. I say thats a pretty good deal. Oh, and they have baklava! Overall, great little greek place, its cheap and fast and pretty tasty.
(4)Lara M.
Very good Greek food. The gyro royale was delicious. The tabouli lacked lemon, garlic and bulgar wheat. All the things that make tabouli so wonderful! Over all. Good experience with fresh ingredients.
(4)Breanna W.
Pita fries are amazing, gyro was great, staff was nice, prices are great. This was better than expected. Would really recommend this place! The building is pretty run down and old however.
(4)Zach H.
This place is a Tallahassee institution and a local favorite. So I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place yet because I lived in Tally for 7 years and have been to this place too many times to count... but two words: Pita Fries. I promise that you will not find Pita Fries anywhere else. I know that I've looked tirelessly to find some, but no such luck. This is your no frills, walk-up counter type of Greek place but the food is not to be taken lightly. All of the pita sandwiches are liberally stuffed with the filling of your choice. My favorites are the Gyro Royale and the Gyro Supreme. The Greek Fries also deserve an honorable mention because these aren't your average fries, they are little fried coins of deliciousness. Be sure to check out the daily special, because those are worth considering too. Overall, the service is generally pretty good and the food will always leave you appropriately satisfied. Pitaria is and always will be a Tallahassee favorite... especially for the Pita Fries.
(4)Jessica C.
I once found that the cook accidentally cooked a screw from the grill in my pita, and that still doesnt hold me back from leaving a good review. Pita fries, hummus, chicken pita, cheese steak pita... you name it, this place is deeeeelish. Just try to avoid the lunch rush if you don't like waiting in line!
(4)Gerry F.
Good food although the air conditioning was broken and they were out of half the sodas in the soda fountain. Probably won't be back. Where else are they cutting corners?
(1)Morgan S.
In town for a few days and I had a craving for Mediterranean. This place hit the spot. It is pretty unassuming from both the outside and the inside, and it definitely had a university vibe going on. But, the food was good for a Tallahassee Mediterranean spot. I had the veggie plate. The tabouli was delicious, hummus was creamy, and the pita was fresh and warm. The falafel was lacking a bit of flavor, but overall I was satisfied.
(4)Ljs B.
Oh my pitaria, xoxoxo. I haven't had GYRO in a million years. It was my perfect comeback experience the euro is fresh and perfectly crisped. The tzatiki was delicious cool and refreshing. I love the supreme w/ feta cheese in the gyro and the tea was so good. I'm really excited about taking Caroline back up to FSU in the fall just so I can eat there again
(5)Alyssa H.
Pita fries are amazing. The food is delicious. But today I had a bad experience. It was EXTREMELY hot inside. Almost as if they don't have the A/C on in the middle of July... We found a seat with a vent blowing a little air but still were uncomfortable and tried to leave quickly. Also three of the sodas were flat, I gave up trying to find some with carbonation.
(3)Zhuo S.
I ordered the gyro royale and my boyfriend a chicken fajita pita, he doesn't like his, said the chicken is not flavored enough, but quite enjoyed my goat meat. I have to say though it doesn't look very appetizing but the goat meat is real good!!
(4)Diane A.
Pitaria 10 years later still doesn't fail! Only thing in 10 years that has changed is the price, of course! My days at FSU were from 2001-2006 (5 year plan thanks to the college of Engineering lol) and I've probably gone to Pitaria more than 60 times hahaha. Still have my college house in Tally (up for sale now that bro is done with college) & when we would go to visit we would always visit Pitaria! I always get my regular - chicken supreme with pita fries. Pita fries are my hands down fav menu item. Recently went to Pitaria before watching the FSU vs Miami game this year and we stopped by Pitaria....lord knew devoured those pita fries. Parking is located in the back and shared with establishments on that strip. Don't forget to try Gumbys while there!
(5)Johnny M.
I will first note that it is a big pet peeve of mine when businesses publish coupons and then give you a very hard time about honoring them. Be very alert when trying to use any buy one get one half off as it is very limited as to what it applies too. The manager ultimately worked with me but both he and the staff person were somewhat inconsiderate and not very eager to help. The staff person was trained very poorly in this regard. That being said, the food was pretty good and the prices aren't unreasonable. The pita was very tasty and the fillings good as well. I would consider eating here again but I am very turned off my the service I received.
(3)Christopher H.
This would be the place I would go whenever my friends would go to Jenny's or Atomic. I loved the Pita Fries so much that I've even made them at home. It is divey enough to keep some people out and local. The food was always good. I'd get a sandwich or a gyro, everytime never let down. The decor was wood and divey. I liked it, always had a nice vibe in there. Pricing was decent for a kid on a college budget. I can't complain.
(4)George F.
I stopped in for lunch while in town on business. The gyro was good but the Greek chips were disappointing. The service and atmosphere were fine. I'd rate it a 3 1/2 if I could but not a 4.
(3)Sarah K.
Pitaria has really good food! It has awesome pitas and great pita fries. It also has vegetarian and vegan options. It has good prices and hours.
(5)Jessica L.
Oh how I will miss my Pitaria!!! Can you guys open up in Tampa, too?! My friend introduced me to it and the first time I got a roast beef pita and (at her insistence) the pita fries with dip. While not the most Greek and adventurous, the roast beef pita reminded me of a yummy cheeseburger but it's the only thing I have ever ordered. Also the pita fries are PHENOMENAL strips of pita fried up and served with an amazing dipping sauce. We got the cinnamon pita fries once and they were great but the pita fries are just outstanding. Pretty plain interior and decor but there's a market next door and there's plenty of seating both in and outside. Parking can also be an issue behind the building but overall totally totally worth it! Go try it, you won't be disappointed!
(5)David A.
Nice college atmosphere about a block off the FSU campus. Large sized sandwiches and salads that are served fresh and made to order. Prices are reasonable for the portion size and quality. I had the vegetarian platter which had falafel and hummus. It was tasty but just not off the charts, clean your plate quality. Servicable and good. Tried my daughters grilled chicken greek salad and I have the same opinion of this dish. Good, but not great. Indoor and outdoor seating. It was busy but the line moves quick and food is served very fast. A good lunch while visiting the campus. I am sure it beats the options at the school.
(3)Dave B.
Some of my coworkers walked into the office with some takeout and I knew instantly I needed to have some. I've been here dozens of times and love the food. Gyro Royals combo with Greek Fries and a Sweet Tea is what I always get. Today was no different. Value: The price of the food is very affordable for the quantity and quality of food you get. I never leave hungry. My meal was $8 and change. Taste: The taste is what keeps me coming back. They gyro is flavorful and the Greek fries are a relic on their own. I've come many times just for the fries. Today, my meal doesn't disappoint. The sweet tea is fresh and perfectly sweetened. 4 stars! Unfortunately, I have to drop to 3 for one, very important reason: cleanliness. The place could use a real good hose down. Dust on the Plants. Sticky counters. Grime on the table legs. Avoid the restroom! Disgusting. Dirty. No soap. No paper towel. Grafitti. Just plain nasty. The latCe night crowd might not mind, but as a daytime professional looking for lunch, this could be a real turnoff. Im
(3)Tyler L.
Food is good and priced good, location is great walking distance to some business and parts of FSU. Only thing I didn't care for is me and a friend paid, the cashier said "Our dining room is closed, you'll have to take your order to go" although there was an ample amount of people still there, and it was 15 min before closing time. The proper business practice is that you stop taking orders by locking the door at closing time, and your paid customers can dine as they please, not start clearing house because you want to leave at 5 after closing!. But that was sometime ago.
(4)Paula S.
The pita fries are amazing! Their soda machine is really dirty and you can see the grime build up clear as day. The overall restaurant isn't very clean but the food is delicious! Make sure the baklava is fresh before buying--the one time I added it to my meal it was stale.
(3)Jennifer I.
Pretty good! I've had better Greek food down near Tampa, but that's because there is a huge Greek population down there...so maybe my hopes are always too high. Pitaria, however, is good enough and satisfies my Mediterranean needs. The gyro is good, the chicken caesar pita is good, and the pita fries are delicious. It gets extremely busy around 12:30-1pm, so get there early if you want to avoid the line!
(4)Mizz V.
Oh Pitaria, my hopes were so high! I love a good Gyro and when I saw they had Fattoush, I knew exactly what my meal would be. After reading through the reviews, I knew this wasn't authentic by any means, but it sounded delicious nonetheless. Based on those reviews I added an order of Pita Fries as well. I called in the order ahead of time on a Sunday evening and was told it would be 10 minutes. After 45 minutes of waiting, I still had no food but plenty of opportunity to watch this place in action. With only 2 tables with 2 customers at each and no one on line, I couldn't understand the wait time. No one was calling in, no one was picking up orders. Weird. I was so excited about my pita fries, and so hungry from waiting that I opened my to-go box right on the patio and took a bite of steaming hot crispiness. Perfect texture, but WTF??? What is the over salted seasoning that these poor fries got bathed in? I figured in my greediness I just took one over salted one from the top, so I dug in and tried again. WTF?! More salt! Now just to reference, by no means am I adverse to salt or seasonings, but this was gross. The meat and pita fries tasted like they were made with old oil and then covered in seasoned salt to cover up the mediocre flavor. Unfortunately the gyro, the salad and the salad were all seasoned with the same exact seasoning blend, so not only did it all taste way too salty - it all tasted like crap. If you're a broke, stoned college student then I'm sure you'll love the food, but mine went straight into the garbage can.
(2)Milton V.
Killer gyros/chicken pitas. No lie, I credit this place with my insatiable appetite for Greek things. Lol.
(4)Tara S.
II used to live in Peabody Mass where there was a large Greek population and a ton of great restaurants. When I saw that Pitaria was a Mom and Pop joint I had high hopes for some good eats. Not so much. Chicken kabob plate was awful as well as the spinakopita. If you want great Greek food in Tally just wait for the Greek festival and pig out.
(2)Bunny N.
Ok, the negative first: I wasn't too impressed with the inside of Pitaria. The table and chairs were old, and my chair was uneven that it rocked back and forth. It was a hot summer day in Florida during the middle of June, and the a/c didn't seem to be blowing out enough cold air. Despite the temperature of the restaurant, Pitaria's food was amazing! I had a gyro with hummus on the side. I was so surprised how stuffed the pita was, and how much hummus came with it. It was delicious! The food was so good that it canceled out the negative! I would go back to the Pitaria again, but maybe get "take out" the next time around it's a hot summer day.
(4)Y A.
Food is great and a good bang for the buck.
(4)Tom S.
This place is overrated. The chicken and beef kabobs were just okay but the meat wasn't that tender and the portion was small. The hummous was some of the grittiest I've ever had and flavor wasn't great.
(2)Erin J.
Delicious food, large servings, quick service, good value.
(5)MICHELLE C.
Pita fries, yummy. Steak and cheese with mushrooms, onions, and mayo wrapped in a thick soft pita. Opa!! Authentic great greek food with great service from a very friendly staff. Prices, well what can I say other than Tallahassee has so many places that are so reasonable for all the college students. Forget the big name chain restaurants, this place and many other's are small holes, nothing fancy with excellent food and prices. :) Gyro sandwich hubby said was really good. But onto the fries, they are seasones pita fries, long, thick and we got our's with hummus on the side to dip. Pure delightful!!! Three people for dinner $26.....and we were full and happy... Great place and awesome friendly staff...
(4)Hank S.
Once upon a time, I went here way too often for a chicken supreme pita with no onions and extra peppers in a combo with pita fries and really good tea, and I ate that at least once a week because it is mfin delicious and also fairly cheap and not greasy fast food, and I suggest it to anyone who likes good Greek casual food, but not if your favorite is hummus because that is their weak spot. The End
(4)Maria D.
Have you ever seen the episode of Seinfeld with the soup nazi? Well, this is exactly how it felt talking to the "manager" at Pitaria. I was skipped over by about 8 people, so I asked where my food was. 3 orders later, my food came out. Naturally, I wanted to talk to the manager to see if he could compensate me for my time. He proceeded to YELL at me. "ABSOLUTELY NOT! I GAVE YOU YOUR FOOD RIGHT? GET OUT OF HERE!" I asked him if he was serious. Seems like he was. Mind you I am a young professional living in Tallahassee (seemingly contradictory I know), who was courteously trying to lodge a complaint with management. I asked him his name and he absolutely refused, "WHY DO YOU WANT MY NAME?". Stay far away from this place as they do not care about their customers, and head over to the friendly, professional and delicious Little Athens gyro around the corner.
(1)Matt W.
Solid gyro place. I went during the lunch rush and the place the packed, but service was still very fast. I had a standard gyro with the "Greek fries" which were large, round-cut french fries. The fries were pretty basic, but their novel shape made them a little less boring. The gyro itself was very good. Nothing incredible, but with tasty meat and a warm pita. At the Pitaria you order at the counter, and then they will bring to food to you. The restaurant is pretty small, but has a little "grocery" section adjoining the dining room where they sell specialty items. I enjoyed the Pitaria, and prices were decent. The combo meals, which include fries and a drink all seemed to be priced around $8. The only complaint I really had was that the only parking lot is behind the building and very cramped. Give it a shot if you are near FSU's campus!
(3)Mai T.
I haven't had much experience with greek food, so this is not a review on the "Greekness" of the place but just the quality. Great place to eat. The pitas are a little smaller than I originally thought but loads better than pita pit (aka subway in a pita). I have never heard of pita fries till I went here. Something good to try. Really constantly nice workers and nice atmosphere. It is just kinda difficult to get to but that shouldn't stop you from going. One of the better places to eat in Tally.
(3)Rema K.
They have an amaizing greek food , try the gyro IT iS THE BEST , also try the fatoch salad , shawerma , hummus ,
(4)Edward J.
It was good, that's all you need to know.
(4)Leah H.
Great combo specials, falafel wraps, hummus, and pita fries! Not going to lie, I was a bit skeptical of these pita fries but they turned out to be absolutely addicting! The seasoning is really tasty and they're a decent size. Falafel wraps are large and filling for the low prices. Side portions of hummus are also a generous size. I'll definitely be back next time I am visiting Tallahassee
(4)Shawna K.
The best hangover food that costs very little dinero can be found at Pitaria in the form of their gyro And we can't forget the pita fries slices of heaven and huge in size If I was a young college co-ed this would be my go to spot rolling out of bed But I would stick to only their Greek menu fare the meatball sub and wings, I'd only eat on a dare Hence the reason for only four stars but again, their greek eats are way above par Can't to visit Tally and my son again soon So I can drink too much and then eat here at noon!
(4)Vito G.
I lived really close to where the largest congregation of Greek-Americans in the world lived, so I'm used to really authenti-tasting Greek. When you go to a place like this, some fast food version of a great people's culinary accomplishments, it feels like you've been ripped off a bit. I mean, I'll eat their gyros. I dig their chicken pitas. Their hummus is tasteless but palatable. It is the first place I ever tried falafel, so there's that. I'm mostly bored by this place, but I don't mind it when I'm there. My friends can't get enough of it, it seems. Weird. I also don't know if it's pronounced as if it rhymes with pizzeria, or pee-tar-e-uh.
(3)Andreea S.
The tzatziki sauce was way too salty... everything was salty... I'm not anal about greek food but this was a let-down. Honestly, I didnt even bother finishing my meal ... go to Little Athens across the street- it is a massive improvement for about the same price! And the tzatziki sauce actually tastes like tzatziki sauce. I won't be coming here again.
(2)Coty S.
I miss their Pita Fries ($3.50)! There is nowhere else that I have found to make them for me. They are slices of fried pita bread, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Seasoned with just the right amount of spices and served with delicious sour cream and cucumber dipping sauce. Sigh... Their classic Gyro is also nothing to laugh at, filled with twice the meat of most places, add feta for true bliss. They are within walking distance from campus, and parking is a nightmare. Just walk there, and walk off those pita fries. They also have yummy desserts, and a free refill soda fountain. Cash only, but there is an ATM.
(4)J D.
Have had the pita fries, the gyro, the veggie plate, the falafel. Gyro is pretty standard, nothing special, but good for Tallahassee. I believe they Pita fries are pretty good and seasoned well. The Gyros use the standard Kronos meat which is a premade gyro. Veggie platter is good, hummus isn't the greatest. The desert items from the grocery store next door however are excellent. Try the angel kisses. They are catering to college students so I understand why they can't take it up a notch and make the flavors more authentic. Falafel is pretty good, nice and green, and one of the better ones in Tallahassee if not the best, out of maybe 5 choices, so take that as you will. It tastes and looks like falafel but isn't missing that gooey inside and some more flavoring. If you need some greek food, this place does it but don't expect to be wowed unless you aren't very experienced with greek food in places that have large greek populations for instance.
(3)Darlene R.
Went in with my son as a first time visit. Cashier was so sweet. Offered to make my little boy a simple grilled chicken with fries dish, since he's picky and they don't have a kids menu. I had a gyro, added feta, with Greek fries. It was delicious. Even their regular fries are awesome. I will definitely be back.
(5)KyungAh L.
Their gyros aren't the best in Tallahassee, but their pita fries are to die for! They probably have one of the best pita fries I've ever tasted and their gyros are decent too.
(3)April K.
Love their pita fries, hummus, and Gyros! Too good. Great spot for waiting for your next class on campus or for grabbing a quick bite if you happen to be on that side of town. I have never not liked anything I have eaten there.
(4)Catherine H.
This restaurant is close to the music building on campus, so I walk here every once in awhile for a quick bite. I usually have a falafel and hummus platter or a gyro. The falafel is delicious, and the gyros are pretty amazing. The hummus has great flavor but can be a little dry. Olive oil is your friend, Pitaria! I also recommend the pita fries.
(3)Hazel P.
5 stars for their PITA FRIES! Have been going here for years, even after college I crave their pita fries! A definite must during your undergrad college years. Other than the pita fries, the gyro wraps are pretty good too. They have an amazing Mediterranean creamy tomato soup the owner makes once in a blue moon that is def. to die for as well. Don't expect five star service though, remember it is just your regular college joint, just have a side of the pita fries and it'll be all good.
(5)Kristina T.
Bottom line: Pitaria makes excellent pitas, falafels, and fries of all kinds. Their falafel pitas are filling, cheap, and super delicious and paired with pita or greek fries is one of my favorite meals. Get the tzatziki instead of the tahini in your pita, it is yummy! Also, a kind of odd comment, their soda machine has always tasted off to me. I would usually get the Diet Pepsi and it always had a weird taste. I tried other drinks from the same fountain and they, too, tasted wrong. Maybe it's the water?
(5)Adina F.
The food is just ok, and to be honest its pretty overrated. When asked if they had any souvlaki, the cashier girl gave me the blankest stare I ever received while ordering food, so obviously this place isn't the most authentic you'll visit. The falafel is pretty good but what I usually get is gyro with tzaziki in a pita. The pita fries are the best thing on the menu here, for sure. As for the interior, its pretty ugly so I just sit outside.
(3)Justin F.
I don't know why, but it seems, as of late, I don't feel like places I go fall neatly into the 5 star scheme. Here, I would give Pitaria 3.75 stars. I do enjoy it, but saying I am a fan seems just a TAD to much. Anyhoo, most of the food here is pretty simple "greek" food. I put it in quotes because of one of my favs, the fajita pita (something tells me that isn't a classic Greek dish). I have had a couple other dishes here and they have all been pretty good, but not exceptional. I have always enjoyed it, but the have been a couple hiccups (my fiancee's greek fries were pretty bad last time). I have heard complaints about the staff, but I have always found them to be pretty friendly. And I don't know about the parking complaints. The lot behind iit has never been full when I went. All-in-all it is a cool little place with decent prices that I definitely recommend trying out.
(4)Cherry J.
Gotta correct some other reviews: this place is definitely NOT cash-only and the parking situation isn't bad at all. Sure, it's not a huge or glamorous parking lot, but there has always been a spot for me when I go there. Onto the food. YUM. The gyros are about as good as they come, and the pita fries are TO DIE FOR. You must get them. They don't seem to exist outside of this restaurant, so not only are they delicious, but also super-special. Service is okay. I've had some strange moments there. For instance, when I wanted a refund because the soda machine was out of what I wanted, and the cashier looked at me like I was an alien, telling me that the two drinks I bought "only cost a few cents." Well excuse me! Other than that, no issues. Awesome food. Go forth.
(5)Marisa R.
How I wish I was into Mediterranean food as much as I am now back when I lived in Tallahassee. Came back to visit and tried Pitaria to fix a falafel craving. The falafel pieces are probably the best I've had thus far. It was my favorite part of the meal. I also had a lamb kabob and a beef kabob. The beef was just okay, but the lamb was very tasty and tender. The hummus tasted very fresh, a big plus, but it could've used a bit more garlic and lemon. The pitas were also surprisingly good considering that I normally don't care for pita. (Only a few restaurants have gotten me to actually enjoy it as a food instead of a cardboard-like food holder.) I did have to take off one star for the decor. The tables felt very mismatched and dirty, and this always makes me a little wary. I think the restaurant would benefit greatly from a modern, clean makeover. Of course, food is the most essential element for a restaurant, right? And the food was fresh and delicious. I'm not sure if I'll be visiting again before I end my vacation, but I'll definitely go back the next time I'm in town.
(4)Tiffany G.
Hummus and Tabouli pita, pita fries, feta and tomato salad with that red dressing they leave out at the tables!!!! Yum!! I miss Pitaria!!!
(5)Whitnae P.
I like this place. They have a wide variety of options for you to choose from and very rarely do I leave the place not feeling satisfied. Also because it has falafel and hummus and other common greek foods on the menu, it's vegan friendly... if you dig that kind of stuff. I will say though, do not order the fish. It has made many of my friends sick after they ate it.
(3)Keagan W.
I love Pitaria. I first went there when I was working for Doorstep Delivery and the food always looked so good, that I had to try it. I've been 3 times and loved my gyro every time. I think that the gyros are about even with Little Athens, but Little Athens has much better pita fries. You can see right back into the kitchen and trust who's making your food and the staff has always been friendly.
(5)J R.
Great place open on sundays. Best gyro ever get the supreme.
(4)Allen B.
I work at FSU and walk to Pitaria at least once a week. This is the only restaurant that I'm willing to walk off campus for on a regular basis. The food is outstanding, authentic Greek food. I haven't found another Greek restaurant in Tallahassee that comes close, and I love Greek food. Prices are reasonable, the lunch special with a drink costs me about $8.50 including tax. My favorite meals are the regular gyro or the chicken gyro, with pita fries. If you get nothing else from Pitaria, make sure you get the pita fries. They are unbelievable. The service is interesting. It's always the same people in the back, and almost always the same cashier. I definitely wouldn't call it friendly service, in fact I'm almost scared to talk to anyone but the cashier. Sort of like a Seinfeld episode - order, sit down, and wait. But the food is fantastic, served quickly, and I make a point of taking my out of town guests here. None of them have ever been disappointed.
(5)Danielle C.
Pitaria is good, cheap, and fast. I always get the pitas. They have several different kinds and they are very filling. You can get a combo with a side of your choice and a drink for around 8 dollars. My favorite is definitely the pita fries. I haven't been in Tallahassee all summer and I definitely missed them. I usually get their hummus too, which is pretty authentic. This is a must for fast paced college students!
(4)Danny B.
Gyro: excellent. Falafel: excellent. Pita fries: excellent. Hummus: excellent. The pitas themselves are thick and soft. The baklava is good. The price is very good, but not absolutely amazing. Still, a very good value for incredible food.
(5)Hannah P.
I love love love Pitaria! I usually just get the regular gyro, which is really good, but the last time I went I got the falafel gyro and it was fantastic! It may not be the prettiest place, but definitely go there for the food, you won't be sorry! (Be sure to get the pita fries too). :)
(5)Lauren E.
Unfortunately I only started eating at Pitaria about 2 months before I left Tallahassee... big mistake. The food is tasty and relatively quick. It's a healthier option than a lot of take-out places in the area and the menu is fairly extensive. The pita fries are AMAZING! I never had anything less than a good meal here. Parking is a pain, so walk here if you can.
(4)Andy E.
Yea, that's right - "Woohoo!, As good as it gets!" Why? Well to start, Pitaria is basically right on campus... Well worth the few extra steps past the "same old, same old" Subway that gives you like 4 slices of turkey and a ton of lettuce on your foot-long... the pitas here are enormous! I eat a lot and just one of these babies and a side of AMAZING pita fries filled me up (Subway leaves me hungry). And you can't beat the price! ***Pitaria will cost you less than lunch or dinner at Suwanee/Fresh*** I can't think of a better place to grab a hearty dinner around here. The atmosphere is really nice. You'll feel like you're on a Greek island (You'll understand that cheesy joke once you get there). Most food joints around campus are either boring franchises or greasy holes-in-the-wall. Pitaria is extremely healthy and the staff is surprisingly helpful, but most importantly - good eats!
(5)Magnus H.
Not sure why people are orgasing on themselves over this place. It's fine. Just your basic Middle Eastern fare. enjoy.
(3)Anne P.
I've been going to Pitaria since I was in high school and keep going back. Sure, the location and decor isn't so great (I liked it a lot better when it was next door and there was a mural of Athens), but the food is awesome and consistent. I always get Fozi's falafel pita and pita fries. The falafel is really good, crunchy on the outside and warm and soft on the inside. Also, bonus points for being green!
(5)Kat D.
I have to say this isn't a very authentic greek restaurant, but it's quick and pretty darn delicious. The pita fries alone are reason enough to keep me coming back, but their falafel pita and salads are top notch as well. The food is pretty cheap for what you get so on a college student budget, it's definitely worth stopping by.
(4)Gary W.
Only had a minute to get a supreme gyros and a falafel, but what we had was great. It's not a fancy place, primarily serving the college crowd, but it was quick (except for the credit card machine, hopefully that was a temporary glitch) clean and delicious.
(4)Max F.
Parking lot in the back, which was convenient, if a little tight. Lots of seating and open space, and the food was delicious. Subtracting one star because my girlfriend bit into an olive pit and the employees offered little more than an "ehh, it happens." Examine your gyros and you should be good.
(4)Krystal H.
I had a gyro and let me say it was great. The meat was seasoned and cooked beautifully, there was just the right amount of filling for the pita. Very good.
(5)Leslie E.
I really love Pitaria! I get their Chicken Caesar pita with Greek fries and I never regret it. The service is fast/good and there are always plenty of places to sit. The food always tastes fresh, too. My only complaint is the parking: there basically isn't any. There's a parking lot in the back for about 2 other restaurants, and like 10 parking spaces in total. If you're a student with decal, you can park in a teacher's lot (after 5pm M-F), but it's still a walk. If you're not a student, you're probably out of luck when it comes to parking. But that's not their fault. :)
(4)Y Y.
Good place for a casual, tasty meal. Extensive menu of sandwiches and pitas. They have several combo meals such as any sandwich or pita, pita fries or Greek fries and a drink for around $7.50. They also have combos with salads. There is also a good variety of vegetarian options on the menu. Place and pay for your order and then they will bring it to you. There are tables inside and several outside. The portions are reasonable. Parking is behind the store and during peak times can be a little tight. They're open until late at night. You can order their food through CapitalCityFood.com and so you can get an idea of their menu and prices at capitalcityfood.com/rest…
(4)Adam O.
The fries, greek style, are amazing. The gyros were okay but bland. It's a great place for cheap and quick casual food.
(3)Emily B.
Pitaria. Struggling to find a suitable place to eat dinner on our first night in Tallahassee, we hoped Pitaria would deliver the good Greek food that we read about on yelp reviews. It is located near the FSU campus, and we noticed the worn-out look of its parking lot and interior, as sometimes accompanies campus favorites. We both liked the taste of our falafel pitas and bean pitas, with delicious pita fries and tahini sauce dip, but unfortunately there was a large olive pit in one of our pitas.
(4)David S.
Not impressed with gyros.
(2)Molly H.
falafel and pita fries are to die for. best in town.
(5)Cassidy L.
Pitaria does good business for a reason! I really enjoyed my gyro- it was flavorful and not greasy or dry. The Greek fries are yummy (though a few were dry), but they need more seasoning. I wish it were a bit cheaper, but I can't quibble too much with good food.
(5)Natascha P.
Very reasonably priced and delicious!!! Every time I leave there I am satisfied- sometimes stuffed. Even my vegan friends love it! The gyros and felafel pitas are excellent, and I also like the cheese steak and caesar pitas as well. When you go, you MUST get the pita fries. They're addicting and come with a yummy tzatziki dipping sauce. Mmmmm.
(5)Scottie B.
If I could eat at Pitaria every single day, I would. The food here is exceptionally good and provides a unique departure from most of the food in Tallahassee. Gyros, pita fries with tzaziki, cinnapitas... I'm starting to drool. Also, the service staff are cool and pierced.
(4)Ari W.
Pitaria is one of my favorite place in Tallahassee. Most of the reviews here are pretty right-on, so I'll just say that my favorite is their Greek Salad with gyro meat. Their vinaigrette dressing is super yum!!!
(5)Renee B.
I love this place!! Always went there for lunch when I lived in Tally!!
(5)Jaryd G.
terrible, if you are expecting something good to eat try going somwhere else. we came here and had gyros, they were terrible. it had good reviews, and i use yelp weekly and have never been let down but this place sucks.
(1)