Chicken salad sandwich is bae!!!! Mandarin orange salad with honey vinaigrette is pretty decent. You must must must try the house dressing, HOLY SMOKES!!!!!! Seriously, I could see coming back to this place again and again and again. The workers were fun and super quirky. The hipster customers make me feel like I've entered a new dimension. What a fascinating culture at The Gelato Co! Dinner and a show, what could be better!?!?!?
(5)
Alayna D.
Atmosphere Quaint and cute local Gainesville gelato and lunch spot for great sandwiches and salads. Seriously, don't go just for the gelato - albeit well worth the trip alone just for the sweet treat - the food is just as good! Rustic little hidden gem in downtown Gainesville. Save room after dining downtown and stop in for dessert here. A few tables inside and outside. Sometimes there's live music on the piano to add to the quaintness feel which I love. Service I don't frequent the place, but when I go I'm usually greeted with happy staff who offer as many samplings of gelato until my taste buds find the right one which I'm thankful for. Friendly people and always with smiles the times I've gone. Food/Gelato As I said, the sandwiches and salads are just as good as the gelato. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because I do wish there was a way to know ahead of time which gelatos they had featured each day somehow online so I knew when to stop in for my favorites, but I tend to find at least a few I like each time I go so no complaints. Like I said, you can sample the gelatos to your hearts content, too! The salads and sandwiches are plentiful and FRESH - love them! TIP: You can get more than one gelato flavor in your cup; don't be shy! Be daring and mix it up with multiple flavors guys and gals. :) Why I'd go back...whether a big salad or great sandwich on yummy toasted bread or after dinner cup of creamy gelato, my reasons to return are abundant! Stay dreamy, Gelato Company!
(4)
Honest R.
This review is based solely on their gelato. Yes, the servings are small and the prices are high per oz BUT the gelato has a unique texture and flavor to justify it. I recommend the lime or raspberry flavors. The place is small and has a new-age European feel to it; it has character. Perfect place to stop by dessert with your significant other and eat it outside on the tables out front.
(5)
Coty S.
Great location, but no parking. I hope they get tons of dessert businesses from all of the restaurants in the area. They could get more of a late night crowd if they were open until after the clubs let out on the weekends, but they might want to avoid the hassle. The people that work here are extremely nice. They do not have that many interesting flavors to choose from. I came hoping for some of the stranger flavors listed on their website- honeydew, watermelon, cantaloupe, amaretto, or chai tea, . They don't have a problem with letting you taste a ton of flavors before making a decision. And, they are willing to pack more than 5 flavors in a small serving. I really liked the Bittersweet Chocolate flavor, it is nice to have chocolate that is not super sweet. It is great to see so many local ice cream shops opening in the area.
(3)
Chelsea B.
Although I've been to the Gelato Co. several times before, I've always resisted writing a review. I'm not a huge fan of Gelato (I go when I'm with friends--everyone else seems to love gelato, except me!), so I always thought it would be a little unfair. But I recently tried the food and need to share my disappointing meal. The sandwich I ordered sounded promising (Very Berry Turkey: Turkey with dried cranberries, Swiss cheese, and tomato with honey mustard mayonnaise) but when it arrived I could tell something was way off.... -The turkey looked and tasted like Oscar Mayer sandwich meat (or rubber). -The swiss cheese looked and tasted like white movie theater nacho cheese (how do you ruin swiss cheese?!) -The sourdough bread looked and tasted like toasted Wonder Bread (that stuff is nasty....one aspect of my childhood I wish I could forget) Really, though, it was the soupy cheese that ruined what could have been a salvageable sandwich. I'm sure I will return, but it will be against my will. But come to think of it....now that I know how terrible the food is, the gelato doesn't seem so bad anymore.
(2)
Stan R.
Went downhill. Used to have a diverse selection and now they dont. Also the last 2 times I was in there the gelato serving area looked really messy and I didnt even order anything.
(2)
Michelle H.
A solid array of flavors that include some sorbettos that don't suck--hello banana. Their small cup is way bigger than most smalls I've ever seen, and you'll get that sweet cookie on top. I was super surprised to see that they a) were open super late [like 3:30am], b) had a huge food menu for being a "gelato company," and c) supposedly sold a killer cheese steak. Cheese steak and gelato don't seem as apparent as peas and carrots to me, but I think I could make it work.
(5)
Adam N.
Fresh, fresh, fresh! Great salads that are fresh and healthy. Incredible gelato options with many unique choices and all of them delicious. Plus they let you test out each type (which I studiously avoid doing out of principle. Be bold! Go for it! Your order isn't your last meal or last time there ya know). The staff are always friendly and gregarious. I love the brick wall lined sitting area or the chance to sit outside and enjoy the downtown atmosphere (brick paved roads). This place is the tops. Oh, they also do specials regularly via FB or email list.
(4)
Julie A.
So college chick took me to Cold Stone Creamery, being the chain dame she is. But I wanted to introduce her to the mother of all ice cream -- gelato! (Cue the Lizzie McGuire movie... wait.. nobody here knows what I'm talkin bout? Hahaha Nevermind youtube.com/watch?v=4KCn… at 8:45.) I can't remember the exact flavor now, but it was rich with flavor. I'm sure my son would enjoy it, too. =D
(4)
Megan G.
Best lunch in Gainesville if you like a gourmet sandwich and great gelato. I'd go for a panini or the turkey and apple sandwich. Sooooo good!
(5)
Robert P.
They have good sandwiches and great gelato. There are so many flavors of gelato and they change over time - so it keeps you coming back to see what they have available now. As of this writing their regular special is buy an entree & drink and get a free gelato. Usually around $10.
(4)
Sniks L.
Gelato Company provides excellent service and remains one of my favorite breakfast/lunch restaurants; I recommend either the new egg breakfast sandwich or the Sweet and Smokey turkey sandwich. Their homemade gelato flavors also present a wonderful surprise to the end of a good meal. I hear they are opening one in the midtown area as well!
(4)
Damien S.
Gimme that Jersey fat cheesesteak. Gimme a fountain drank. Gimme that gelato. Oh, it comes with a free small gelato? Hey girl hey. A glorious gamut of gourmet sandwiches, but when the owner says "You've got to try the Fat Cheesesteak," well sir, I listen. Not quite the whiz wit, and regional in its own right, this sloppy mess packs onions, peppers and mushrooms, is a caloric indulgence that's bound to end up (in part) on your withered dewlap. The half ($7.50) is fine for lunch, especially when you consider each sandwich comes with two sides. I was a little confused, however, as the Fatty allegedly came standard with Funyuns as a side (NJ Law), yet none were to be found, and the staffer at the register relayed the cheesesteak only comes with a single side. Methinks a mistake in communication? Add a self-serve soda or iced tea to the mix, and you'll get a small (and it's small) gelato on the house. Which you owe it to yourself to try - the salted caramel and pretzel in dark chocolate had a killer consistency and wasn't overly sweet. It's a solid $10 lunch with a sweet nightcap, and I'd assume hot messes like the Fat Cheesesteak bring in the after-hours crowds. *reads other reviews* Yep. Will definitely stop by again to dabble in something a bit healthier. But I won't be happy about it.
(4)
James O.
I love sandwiches. I also love Gelato, not nearly as much as sandwiches..but you get the point. The Gelato Co. does both well. I had the raspberry turkey. Plenty of sauce, my only complaint was that they turkey was a little dry. But for the price and quality its hard to beat!
(4)
Mel V.
Better coffee than Starbucks. Awesome atmosphere and flavorful breakfast sandwiches. The gelato flavors are creative and taste so good.
(5)
Jessica K.
Sweet lunch deal. Sandwiches come with two sides and if you add a drink you get gelato for free or a dollar or something. My vegetarian sammie had avo, cashews, dill havarti and other stuff on it and was totally good. Tomato soup was fine. Service was fine. Pretty varied menu including crepes, paninis and sandwiches. Choices for a pretty wide group and totally fair prices. Will be back. Interior is pretty sparse and basic. There's also a small patio with a few tables. Owner seemed down to earth and like the kind of small business owner you want to keep in business.
(3)
Moni M.
So I've been a HUGE lover of Gelato Co for a while. Ever since I moved to Gainesville 3 years ago, I always looked forward to the delicious and carefully prepared sandwiches that they have. Every time I go there I get the same thing: Pollo Pesto panini with double sides of potato salad. And everytime when I take a bite out of that delicious buttery pressed bakery bread I smile and I am in heaven. You think by the above that I would be giving them a 5+ star rating, right? Gelato Co's food used to take me to a heavenly euphoria. I emphasize "used to." But the sad truth of it all is The Gelato Co is not the same. I went a few weeks ago and ordered my usual, and I literally could not bite into the sandwich. Someone had not known how to make a panini and forgotten butter or something because I could have knocked someone out with that sandwich. But to give them credit, the potato salad is always delicious and has this nice sweet taste that just melts in your mouth. Thankfully one of the owners were there and they personally made me another sandwich which was just like it used to be, Panini euphoria! I was ecstatic and went on my merry way. Now today I order The Gelato Co to go. Again same order. But to my dismay when I get home with my delicious lunch and come to find out that the panini is again dry, hard and not tasty. I added some of my own tomato since they had forgotten to put it on, but still it was not enjoyable. I ate for the sheer fact that I was already home and I was very hungry. But I know at least my double potato salad would be good and give me the happy vibes I was searching for. I took a bite and to my surprise it was SO SALTY and mustardy and none of the sweet delicious taste that I had come to love for 3 years. I was so disheartened and so this is why I am making a review. I wish I would have done a review when I first tried Gelato Co. But the sad truth is that I never felt the need since it was always so good. *sigh* So please owners of The Gelato Co. teach your new staff the care and perfection that you used when creating your artisan masterpieces. I hate to say it, but I don't know if I will ever go back to eat here since i have been burned twice and their food is not cheap. It's just sad how the quality of some things start to disintegrate with time.
(2)
Kelly A.
My favorite lunch place in Gainesville! The most unique and tasty sandwiches. And of course the gelato is to die for. They always have a great variety of flavors. They let you sample before you pick your flavor out which is great. The staff is always very friendly. If it's a nice day, I recommend sitting outside. I highly recommend this place for lunch or a light dinner.
(5)
Natalie B.
This place is my FAVORITE sandwich place in Gainesville. All of their sandwiches are delicious and come with delicious sides. And if you buy a drink with a meal, you get a free small gelato. Always good customer service, a small spot but never fails to be a delicious meal. Can't go wrong with a panini.
(5)
Gaurav G.
Took my now girlfriend on our first date 6 years ago to this restaurant. We loved the gelato there and always the service. Cool place to visit when downtown. The food and the gelato are amazing. It such an awesome place that I proposed to my girlfriend there! The staff. Is amazing especially Leo whom help make the moment special. If you want to visit a classic ice cream place in Gainesville go to this restaurant you won't be disappointed!
(5)
Ling S.
This is one of my FAVORITE sandwich/dessert places in Gainesville! Perfect for lunch or a quick dinner. It's a very small restaurant containing probably only 5 tables inside. On a nice day, eat outside on the patio tables. The staff is always very friendly. If you order a sandwich or panini for their special, it comes with a free small gelato. Which is more than enough, because their gelato is very rich! Delicious, but very rich. My favorite hot and fresh panini is the Pollo. Try their chicken salad! It's excellent with perfectly sweet red grapes. My boyfriend is in LOVE with their philly cheese steak sandwich. You really can't go wrong with anything that you order there. Downtown parking sucks for the restaurant. Be prepared to hunt and stalk down a parking spot on a busy night. One thing I really like about the Gelato Co. is that they do group fundraising. If your club or organizations needs to raise funds for a charity, host an event here! A portion of all the sales of the night will go towards your charity.
(4)
Richard C.
This is one of the best places I've been to in Gainesville. The food is excellent, the atmosphere is nice and the employees are very welcoming. There was also live pianist playing!!!!!!!!
(5)
Kelly S.
I really love this place! I've eaten here for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert. All amazing! Sometimes their food can be a little too salty, but the gelato is always spot on. I really like that the employees are nice and helpful and they let you try as many flavors as you like! I think this place is reasonably priced, has a decent interior, and I am always glad when I come here.
(5)
Kaitlin H.
As I rolled up to Gelato Co tonight around 8, the live piano playing in the background, the sweet smell of gelato and promise of a hot panini in my future, the phrase that came to my mind was "classy as hell." The turkey panini was nice, the sides were decent. But the gelato. Oh, the gelato. One cannot comprehend the deliciousness of the gelato at this fine establishment. Smooth, rich, perfectly balanced in flavor... Holy crap it was good. I recommend getting two flavors (bittersweet chocolate is fantastic, especially combined with red velvet). Also, a note on the sizes of the gelato cups: they have empty small, medium, and large cups on display so you can decide which size you want to get. Don't be alarmed by how small they are. They really pile the gelato on! I was perfectly fine with a small. I'd much rather go here than Karma, and it's probably tied with Sweet Dreams in my book, and that's saying a lot. So please. Please please please. Go try the gelato.
(4)
Amy S.
Mmmmmmmm. It seems that their small size cup is far bigger than any other small I've ever had before! You definitely get your money's worth and can easily share one with another person.
(5)
Richard W.
Great place to go for lunch in Gville. Both the gelato and sandwiches are really good. I'd recommend the turkey and apple sandwich. It's very good. Downside to the place is that it's kinda small and only has a row of seating along the wall so it can be a bit cramped. But it's still good!
(4)
Sara G.
I have a few things to say about this place. I've been here several times for the gelato and a few times for food. Generally speaking, its not worth it...but it's really the only ice cream option downtown except for Mochi (which really isn't my style) so it will remain regardless of how good it actually is. I'll start with the food...its pretty meh. The cheese steak is the best option IMO. Its NJ style and pretty tasty. However, it clearly made with pre-packaged mushrooms and onions. I asked for it with just peppers and mushrooms and was told that they can't do that b/c they come in a mix together. That kind of BS short cut irks me in restaurants - its not that hard to saute fresh mushrooms and onions, etc. A lot of the other sandwiches come on what looks like grocery store white bread pressed in a panini press...it tastes that way too. Their sides are also disgusting...ask for chips instead. As for the gelato, I think calling it gelato is a bit of a stretch. Its more like Coldstone than real gelato. The flavor options are mediocre at best. Sometimes there is a good one or two but more often than not the flavors are uncreative and forgettable. Also, the daily "deal" where you get a free gelato with the purchase of a sandwich and a drink is a ripoff. The sandwich alone is usually around $7...it's ~$10 for the deal but the drink is small (yes you get free refills) and soda only costs them about 10 cents but they charge 3$ for it...and the free gelato is served in a plastic sauce cup that you'd put ketchup in at a normal restaurant...its not even served in the small size gelato cup. To suggest that a soda and a scoop of gelato is worth $3 is absurd. Even so, I usually don't finish the gelato b/c its not that good. I went for 2 stars b/c of the absence of viable ice cream alternatives in the downtown area so I go here sometimes but you're better off to drive across town to Sweet Dreams as I more often do.
(2)
Adam W.
We have ate here several times with our family. We think the meal deal is pretty good (sandwich, salad, chips, drink, sm gelato for under $10). The pressed sandwiches are very good with odd but good choices such as turkey and sour apple and ham and raspberry. The salads are good too. I'm a big eater and I am reasonably full after this meal. I'm not into gelato. It's not as good as my home town Ruggle's brand but I have found nothing wrong with it. No, there is no parking which is planned by the city, not any of the businesses downtown.
(4)
Lauren O.
I enjoy the panini that are served here and the abundance of things that the lunch combo comes with makes me happy (I'm a grazer at heart). I got the vegetarian panini for lunch today and it's hard to say what I enjoyed more...the sandwich, the cup of tomato bisque, the little scoop of chicken salad (a dollop of protein?) or the small dish of 1/2 coconut and 1/2 pineapple gelato I got for free b/c I bought a drink with my meal. Not to mention the side salad which has the most delicious seasoned croutons and the best house dressing ever that I scarfed off my daughter's plate. The only reason I left off a star is because I've been turned off of some very inventive turkey sandwich creations due to their use of subpar slimy turkey cold cuts. I would gladly pay a little extra if they used a better turkey meat for their sandwiches.
(4)
Stephanie R.
Never had a bad meal at the Gelato Company! It is definitely one of my favorite places in Gainesville. Their special is pretty much unbeatable; a sandwich, side salad, small scoop of chicken or tuna salad, a drink, and a small gelato for just under $10. Awesome deal. It's extra awesome because EVERYTHING is delicious. I usually get the raspberry turkey sandwich (can't remember the exact name), it comes hot and dripping with cheese. One time I made a "mistake" and ordered it with the Jalapeno cheddar bread...it ended up being AWESOME. The sweet and the spice went perfectly together and now I order it every time. The side salad is fresh and has a creamy italian dressing on it, very tasty. Their chicken salad texture may weird some people out, but it is quite tasty. The gelato is made fresh in house everyday, so they always have new flavors. Don't be shy about asking to try a sample! It is, of course, also delicious (Oreo cheesecake ftw). Definitely a hidden gem. If you blink, you just might miss it :)
(5)
Jocelyn R.
Love the Gelato company! I work in the downtown area, so its an excellent option for lunch. They have a great lunch special for about 7 dollars that includes a salad, sandwich, and drink. You have a couple of different options for your sandwich, but my favorite is the turkey and apple sandwich with a delish cream cheese spread on sourdough. I kind of hate salad, so I usually don't end up eating the salad, but I'm sure its acceptable. The cafe itself is really cute, but the seating is limited, so I don't usually go there with groups (unless theres only 2 of us). They have a really nice outdoor area if its a pretty day though! The wait staff is really really nice and polite here. Their gelato is also very good, I'm just not a huge fan of sweets so I don't usually get it. But when I do, I try everything, and they're really nice about it. I can always find one that is delish. I would def recommend!!!
(5)
Coleen T.
Tried the cheese steak late one night... still haven't tried the gelato, but the cheese steak was awesome! I loved the bell peppers in it, but I asked for no mushrooms... I'm only a fan of the 'special' kinds :) The atmosphere of the restaurant was really cute, and the fact that Sublime was playing over the speakers made the whole experience great.
(4)
Lanise A.
Thumbs up for the gelato. It may be a small serving and pricey, but it is worth it if you're not in the mood for regular ice cream. However, I did not expect this place to be so small, and I'm cluster-phobic.
(4)
Hana B.
The first time I stumbled upon Gelato Company was at midnight while roaming around the streets of downtown Gainesville. The location is very nice and I have since returned on days where it was the perfect amount of sunny and breezy to enjoy my meal outside. While this is a nice place to share a meal with friends because of the intimate atmosphere, the food is really nothing special. The sandwiches and paninis are reliable but there's nothing I've ordered here that has really stood out. That being said, the gelato that comes with the combo is a great way to end the meal. Despite being served in a small, plastic container, the scoops are generous and I have never been able to finish a small gelato by myself. Though I wouldn't go here specifically for the food, I'll probably end up back in here some midnight in the future craving some gelato.
(3)
Kelly A.
Stopped in here for a light dinner the other night, and their sign didn't lie - it was indeed a good value! I had a vegetarian sandwich with avocados, tomatoes, and fresh mozz (came with jalapeno chips) and an iced tea, while the boy had a different type of vegetarian sandwich with salad and an iced tea; both came with free gelato at the end, and we still got out of there for under $20! The sandwiches were good, and the options for gelato were plentiful. I went for the cookie dough; he went for the amaretto. Both were good (though a little colder than I prefer). The service was really friendly. I don't know if that's a Florida thing or what, but it's hard to find such friendly service here in Boston. The girl at the counter even made conversation about the band on the shirt I was wearing. The hipster snobbery in Boston tends to prevent those types of conversations from occurring. So that was refreshing.
(4)
Sasha P.
The Gelato Company is a very cute and cozy restaurant If the weather is nice, the outside seating area is a very good place to eat your meal, people watch, or chat with a friend. The inside is narrow and long. Enough for seating on the left side of the wall and the gelato-holding units to the right. They have different food combinations that are a mix of classic Tuna Sandwiches to your not-so-usual Avocado Sandwiches. I've had the Tuna Sandwich and it was actually pretty good. Not fishy like one usually thinks canned tuna tastes. It came alongside a mixed greens salad and potato soup. The potato soup was realllly good! Lastly, I will say that I enjoy gelato but the kind they make here is too rich for my taste. I can only have a sample of the hazelnut gelato before I feel overloaded on sugar and hazelnut flavor. Also, they don't offer coffee gelato which is my favorite but they do have several other assorted flavors. It's not crazy expensive in here but do plan on spending more than $8 for a meal. The Gelato Company is a nice place to eat but it doesn't stand out in my book. Nothing bad about it, don't get me wrong but it's just another place to eat for me.
(3)
Nolan R.
I stopped in here to have some Gelato at the Gainesville Art Fest. I'm was impressed with how many flavors they offered. Some Gelato places tend to play it safe and make 10 flavors. These guys went all out. I bet there were close to 20. I got a medium with two flavors in it. Lemon & Fruit of the Forest....they were both terrific. I will definitely be back, I just haven't got around to G'ville's downtown lately.
(5)
Justine B.
Their red velvet gelato is a little bit of heaven on earth! I only wish they had it available more often. Oh and go try their cheesesteaks on the weekend. I promise you will not regret it.
(4)
Matt H.
I want to love this place because apparently so many other people do but I just can't because every time I go something else goes wrong....maybe I'm just cursed. I've had a panini several times and it never has been served hot like a panini should be. Even after asking for them to heat it extra long it still comes out luke warm at best. Not to mention that I get the ole eye roll when I ask for them to leave it on a little long. The flavors of the gelato are awesome but every time I've been it's more a less resembled soft serve ice cream and didn't look nice and thick like the picture Coty S. posted. Maybe I just happen to visit when there freezer thingy isn't working at full blast. Lastly and the cherry on top is the ole hair in the salad. The strawberry rainforest salad would have been great had I been able to get the mental image of the curly blonde hair out of my head. For the record I do not have blonde curly hair. Knowing that the staff rolls their eyes at me when I request a hot sandwich I didn't even bother letting them know. See you never.
(2)
Mike W.
I've only had the gelato as dessert here, never tried anything for lunch so I cannot comment on that aspect of The Gelato Company at all. However, the gelato itself is very, very, good and the service was cheerful and prompt. One night I was there they had a young lady playing the house piano and she was churning out some pretty good Mozart and Bach which only added to the charm of the place. Their piano could benefit from tuning and also, as a grand it's a slight bit loud for the space. All and all, the mere thought of having a live pianist added much to the atmosphere. Gainesville would profit from more places for quality dessert: The Top is about the only place I can think of for pies and cakes and such that is worthwhile as a dessert destination alone if you've had dinner elsewhere. The Gelato Company is a nice addition to what we have going on downtown and I expect it to thrive.
(4)
David M.
A business trip brought me to Gainesville and I arrived a couple of hours early. That gave me the time to wander a bit and to enjoy a relaxed lunch. After passing by several chain restaurants, I was pleased to discover The Gelato Company which, according to the server behind the counter, was started by a couple of UF grads a few years ago. Always happy to support a local business, I took that as my cue to stay at The Gelato Company for lunch. Others have commented on the great value offered by The Gelato Company, and I echo that. I ordered a vegetarian panini (avocado, tomato, mozzarella and a homemade pesto). The sandwich was very good, although the flavors did not blend perfectly, primarily because the sauce was a bit too overpowering. It was still quite tasty nevertheless. The panini was served with a side salad which was ENORMOUS and dressed with a wonderfully flavorful dressing that I loved but cannot begin to describe (except to suggest that it was as if I were enjoying all of the good things in nature turned into a salad dressing!). The coffee chip gelato with which I capped my meal was both delicious and richly decadent. I can only hope that business brings me to Gainesville again soon!
(4)
Gigi A.
Amazing gelato, absolute delight. Food is mind blowing, and well the atmosphere. The atmosphere is french bistro meets new york. The people around are amazing as well. I love love love this place :) A lot. GO.
(5)
Christina L.
I used to come here for their special - a sandwich, drink, and gelato for under $10! Decent sandwiches. I'm oddly drawn to the chicken salad every time. Yummy gelato. It's pretty laid-back and chill, with a piano in the front. I've only seen a person play on it once, though. A good spot to grab lunch and catch up with friends.
(3)
Vicki M.
Yummy! I have ALWAYS got the Very Berry Turkey, with salad (there homemade dressing) and chicken salad. It's always the same and is so good. They change the flavor of gelato, so I have never been able to get the same kind twice, which is good and bad. I found a favorite, but probably won't have it again, but I always find something I like at least, so all is good....I have even turned my husband onto the very berry turkey when he has been coming here before me and always got something different.
(5)
Brooke B.
I eat here regularly, not anymore. I always get the same sandwich and ask for panini bread instead of regular. The sandwiches and paninis are the same price and in the past they have always obliged. Today I went in and asked and was told they were running low on paninis, I told the lady it's the only thing I eat there and I would pay extra for the bread. Still no. My friend offered to get a panini and just give me here bread and she would take regular. The lady still said no! She then proceeded to tell us we were being very difficult and she's the store manager and she said no. I probably would've picked another option had the manager not given us such attitude. As we walked out after deciding to not be treated with disrespect the manager continued to mumble things under her breath. I used to go there weekly, however sadly I will be picking panera.
(1)
Brent C.
Great late night philly cheese steaks. The restaurant is small but they have a nice patio to enjoy your treats.
(4)
Molly M.
I love this place. They have really good sandwiches (I get the sweet and smokey) and if you buy a drink with your food, a small gelato is free. How can you beat that. Service at lunch is fairly quick so I have plenty of time to sit and eat my meal while reading or just relaxing during lunch.
(5)
Spooky T.
Their croissants are GREAT, and they always have a gelato flavor to suit any palate.
(4)
Brea G.
Been here a couple of times. The paninnis are really pretty good (try the salmon). The little ball of tuna salad is ... odd .. but tasty. The real reason to go here is the gelato. Lots of yummy flavors. I've been here a few times and it seems they've turned down the cooler as the gelato was a bit hard last time I went there.
(3)
Gramley A.
One of our favorite places to go in town. Great selection and different every day. Worth a try if you are in the area
(5)
Syama K.
Such good gelato.. they change their flavors often and so far I haven't had anything there I didn't like! Definitely worth it!
(5)
April O.
This place is GOOD. How good? Good enough to make you eat very cold gelato when it's only 40 degrees outside. And as native Floridians know, 40 degrees is bordering on arctic misery. Of course, the gelato is the star of the show (and it should be), but don't overlook their insanely good paninis or their very tasty salads. I don't know how they manage to make such light and delicious mayonnaise-based tuna and chicken salads ... think they'd tell me if I begged for a recipe? The shop itself exudes "tiny loft" charm. I'm a sucker for exposed brickwork and baby grand pianos carefully wedged in tiny spaces. Come here when you just want to people-watch while slowly eating lunch. Very pretty staff, very pretty clientele. Guys in and around this store are abnormally hawt.
(5)
Danny D.
I saw this girl I sorta know working there. It was awkward because I wasn't sure if I should acknowledge her or not. Their paninis are good.
(3)
Paul D.
Amazing gelato, good sandwiches. If in Gainesville and craving ice cream I rank it better than Hagan-Dazs, Ben and Jerry and Cold-Stone Creamery.
(4)
Diana N.
Their crepes are soooooo yummy!! But it's a little pricey, but I am willing to pay since its the only place that I know of in Gainesville to get crepes. The guy at the register was a little rude to us, other than that, I'd definitely come back!
(4)
James B.
A great local downtown spot to kick back and enjoy lunch. I love the exposed brick wall with the mildly artsy decor giving it a great downtown-vibe. The gelato is great here. I can be happy to recommend anyone to eat their gelato. Fresh, bursting in flavor, affordable, and delicious! They also have sorbettos and other desserts. You can never come here bored because new flavors roll out almost daily. Feel free to mix 2 flavors in one cup! The paninis are delicious with their crunchy focaccia bread. Perfectly crunchy on the outside, soft inside and tasty all over. I love their salmone panini. Their salad is light and delicious; their dressing is not overwhelming. As gross as it may sound, their chicken or tuna salad is great too. All, with a small drink equals around $8-10 dollars...plus free gelato. Can't beat that! Highly recommended for those looking for a quick, relatively healthy, and light meal.
(4)
Belle C.
4 stars because it's called The Gelato Company and the gelato is very good. It's a charming little place and the staff is friendly. I was less than impressed with my mozzarella/tomato/avocado panini. The bread was stale-ish, the mozzarella was not fresh, and I could barely taste the avocado. It came with a clump of "tuna salad" (looked like canned tuna and mayo) which seems like a really random side. I know, it's cheap, but I don't care how cheap the food is if it isn't good. I'll be back only for the gelato.
(4)
Amanda D.
Was toddling around Gainesville with my BFFs the other day and had to stop in here. Parking was okay, but what took off stars right from the beginning is the way they have their order line set up. Its right next to peoples tables that theyre trying to eat at, and people have to walk back down the opposite way to get out of the line at the end. Being claustrophobic, that really did not set the mood. Onto the food. I got the Americano panini with "chicken salad" and creamy potato soup. The panini was good, very cheesy, but didnt really have any texture. There was no crunch or bite to it. The chicken salad is just too weird. Its a uniform texture and color, more like the appearance of a scoop of shredded cat food. The potato soup was pretty decent. A bit gritty in texture, but not too bad. Thought it was odd and rather wasteful for them to use Styrofoam cuts and plastic wear to serve the food. The only saving grace is the gelato. The peanutbutter was to die for, and the chocolate pudding was in the awesome area. Other sandwich and crepe options look promising, and Im willing to try something twice so Id probably come back again but probably only for dessert.
(3)
Maggie P.
Great place! Amazing gelato! Open late. The cookies and sandwiches are also delicious!
(5)
Laura M.
This place is awesome. They're open late, they have a totally relaxed atmosphere, the snacks and drinks are good, and oh yeah, GELATO. My best friend spent a semester in Rome and says this stuff is as good as what you get in Italy. She brought me here and we indulged. The staff will let you mix multiple flavors in one serving, and they pile on the gelato as high as it'll go in your little dish. Plus, you get a hazelnut cookie to dip in it. We went around 11:30 on a weeknight in December and they were out of almost every flavor, though. I mean, yes, it was the end of the day, but if you're going to stay open late (which rules), then make sure you can cater to the customers who come in at that time. I'm sure we could've gotten coffee or wine and been all set, but they're not called the Coffee or Wine Company. So, down one star.
(4)
Y Y.
I actually went to this place based on some of the great reviews some fo the other yelp users left. What a great decision that was! I tried the gelato and absolutely loved it. When I was in Italy I ate gelato every single day and it really reminded me of gelato in Italy.
(5)
Heather S.
Oh! My! Gawd! It's a beautiful thing when a pregnant lady meets gorgeous waves of delicious gelato on a hot summer day. I spent a month in Italy and have had my fair share of gelato - this place makes it fresh and authentically. I even learned something - gelato is never made with eggs - who knew? All of the desserts, cakes and pastries looked wonderful, but I only had eyes for stracciatella. They do have a pretty extensive sandwich and salad menu, and the tiny interior is cozy and tastefully decorated - I'll definitely be back! Isn't this where Wolfgang's used to be?
(5)
Mrs. H.
Ay, I'm ashamed to admit that I've been here quite a few times since it's opened, but after having gelato every night on our trip to Europe I've had a fever and the only cure is more gelato. Is it the exposed brick walls and cozy atmosphere that draw me in? Or is it the bad ass gelato? My favorite so far is pistachio, with every other flavor I've tried coming in second. I had the 3 in a medium tonight, a generous three flavors in one cup: Irish Cream, Pecan Shortbread and Death by Chocolate. The Stracciatella and Amaretto also good. The super friendly staff make it a plus. There's also cookies and cakes that look pretty darn good. And like everyone else, I'll have to remember to try the sandwiches and salads next time. This place is located between Harry's and Emiliano's, where Wolfgang's used to be. Wherever you have dinner, go downtown for a stroll and end your evening here. **UPDATE: I've had their paninis and they're the best darn paninis I've ever had. Seriously. They must have a really good panini iron because the bread was crunchy inside and out and everything was nice and melted on the inside. My friend and I shared two sandwiches, one was the Focoso which was stuffed with salami, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and oregano on focacio bread, and the other was the Americano which had turkey, roasted red peppers, portabella mushrooms, dijon mustard and homemade horseradish sauce on focacio bread. Both came with chips, a side of chicken salad, a drink and a small gelato for under $10. It's a real, real good deal. They really took sandwich art in Gainesville to the next level. ***UPDATE: My people hear me: I've had the salads and they are good. I pity the fool that don't come here.
(5)
Heather S.
The Gelato Company is where "dinner" used to be before they moved west. They have very fresh gelato, comparable to what you'd enjoy in Italy. I enjoyed the special, which included a sandwich, a tuna salad, a small gelato and drink. Cozy atmosphere. I hope they make it.
(4)
Logan f.
Great gelato. I got the gelato/sandwich/drink deal combo thingy and it was amazing. Sandwiches are great and it ends with great gelato. Everytime I have gone their staff has been friendly and cute. There was some guy playing the piano that was amazing. The only downside.......get a location with more parking.
(5)
Joshua N.
I can't believe that Gainesville now has two ice cream places that aren't corporate and damn tasty. Now if you're close to downtown and don't want to make the trip across town to sweet dreams you can sample some of the delicious gelato here. I had the chocolate and hazlenut gelatos and both of them hit the spot on a hot day. One warning, this place is kinda expensive. $3.45 for a small gelato seems kinda high to me. They also had some tasty sounding sandwiches and salads which I will try on my next trip.
(4)
Brooke B.
I eat here regularly, not anymore. I always get the same sandwich and ask for panini bread instead of regular. The sandwiches and paninis are the same price and in the past they have always obliged. Today I went in and asked and was told they were running low on paninis, I told the lady it's the only thing I eat there and I would pay extra for the bread. Still no. My friend offered to get a panini and just give me here bread and she would take regular. The lady still said no! She then proceeded to tell us we were being very difficult and she's the store manager and she said no. I probably would've picked another option had the manager not given us such attitude. As we walked out after deciding to not be treated with disrespect the manager continued to mumble things under her breath. I used to go there weekly, however sadly I will be picking panera.
(1)
Brent C.
Great late night philly cheese steaks. The restaurant is small but they have a nice patio to enjoy your treats.
(4)
Molly M.
I love this place. They have really good sandwiches (I get the sweet and smokey) and if you buy a drink with your food, a small gelato is free. How can you beat that. Service at lunch is fairly quick so I have plenty of time to sit and eat my meal while reading or just relaxing during lunch.
(5)
Spooky T.
Their croissants are GREAT, and they always have a gelato flavor to suit any palate.
(4)
Brea G.
Been here a couple of times. The paninnis are really pretty good (try the salmon). The little ball of tuna salad is ... odd .. but tasty. The real reason to go here is the gelato. Lots of yummy flavors. I've been here a few times and it seems they've turned down the cooler as the gelato was a bit hard last time I went there.
(3)
Gramley A.
One of our favorite places to go in town. Great selection and different every day. Worth a try if you are in the area
(5)
Syama K.
Such good gelato.. they change their flavors often and so far I haven't had anything there I didn't like! Definitely worth it!
(5)
April O.
This place is GOOD. How good? Good enough to make you eat very cold gelato when it's only 40 degrees outside. And as native Floridians know, 40 degrees is bordering on arctic misery. Of course, the gelato is the star of the show (and it should be), but don't overlook their insanely good paninis or their very tasty salads. I don't know how they manage to make such light and delicious mayonnaise-based tuna and chicken salads ... think they'd tell me if I begged for a recipe? The shop itself exudes "tiny loft" charm. I'm a sucker for exposed brickwork and baby grand pianos carefully wedged in tiny spaces. Come here when you just want to people-watch while slowly eating lunch. Very pretty staff, very pretty clientele. Guys in and around this store are abnormally hawt.
(5)
Danny D.
I saw this girl I sorta know working there. It was awkward because I wasn't sure if I should acknowledge her or not. Their paninis are good.
(3)
Paul D.
Amazing gelato, good sandwiches. If in Gainesville and craving ice cream I rank it better than Hagan-Dazs, Ben and Jerry and Cold-Stone Creamery.
(4)
Diana N.
Their crepes are soooooo yummy!! But it's a little pricey, but I am willing to pay since its the only place that I know of in Gainesville to get crepes. The guy at the register was a little rude to us, other than that, I'd definitely come back!
(4)
James B.
A great local downtown spot to kick back and enjoy lunch. I love the exposed brick wall with the mildly artsy decor giving it a great downtown-vibe. The gelato is great here. I can be happy to recommend anyone to eat their gelato. Fresh, bursting in flavor, affordable, and delicious! They also have sorbettos and other desserts. You can never come here bored because new flavors roll out almost daily. Feel free to mix 2 flavors in one cup! The paninis are delicious with their crunchy focaccia bread. Perfectly crunchy on the outside, soft inside and tasty all over. I love their salmone panini. Their salad is light and delicious; their dressing is not overwhelming. As gross as it may sound, their chicken or tuna salad is great too. All, with a small drink equals around $8-10 dollars...plus free gelato. Can't beat that! Highly recommended for those looking for a quick, relatively healthy, and light meal.
(4)
Belle C.
4 stars because it's called The Gelato Company and the gelato is very good. It's a charming little place and the staff is friendly. I was less than impressed with my mozzarella/tomato/avocado panini. The bread was stale-ish, the mozzarella was not fresh, and I could barely taste the avocado. It came with a clump of "tuna salad" (looked like canned tuna and mayo) which seems like a really random side. I know, it's cheap, but I don't care how cheap the food is if it isn't good. I'll be back only for the gelato.
(4)
Amanda D.
Was toddling around Gainesville with my BFFs the other day and had to stop in here. Parking was okay, but what took off stars right from the beginning is the way they have their order line set up. Its right next to peoples tables that theyre trying to eat at, and people have to walk back down the opposite way to get out of the line at the end. Being claustrophobic, that really did not set the mood. Onto the food. I got the Americano panini with "chicken salad" and creamy potato soup. The panini was good, very cheesy, but didnt really have any texture. There was no crunch or bite to it. The chicken salad is just too weird. Its a uniform texture and color, more like the appearance of a scoop of shredded cat food. The potato soup was pretty decent. A bit gritty in texture, but not too bad. Thought it was odd and rather wasteful for them to use Styrofoam cuts and plastic wear to serve the food. The only saving grace is the gelato. The peanutbutter was to die for, and the chocolate pudding was in the awesome area. Other sandwich and crepe options look promising, and Im willing to try something twice so Id probably come back again but probably only for dessert.
(3)
Maggie P.
Great place! Amazing gelato! Open late. The cookies and sandwiches are also delicious!
(5)
Laura M.
This place is awesome. They're open late, they have a totally relaxed atmosphere, the snacks and drinks are good, and oh yeah, GELATO. My best friend spent a semester in Rome and says this stuff is as good as what you get in Italy. She brought me here and we indulged. The staff will let you mix multiple flavors in one serving, and they pile on the gelato as high as it'll go in your little dish. Plus, you get a hazelnut cookie to dip in it. We went around 11:30 on a weeknight in December and they were out of almost every flavor, though. I mean, yes, it was the end of the day, but if you're going to stay open late (which rules), then make sure you can cater to the customers who come in at that time. I'm sure we could've gotten coffee or wine and been all set, but they're not called the Coffee or Wine Company. So, down one star.
(4)
Y Y.
I actually went to this place based on some of the great reviews some fo the other yelp users left. What a great decision that was! I tried the gelato and absolutely loved it. When I was in Italy I ate gelato every single day and it really reminded me of gelato in Italy.
(5)
Heather S.
Oh! My! Gawd! It's a beautiful thing when a pregnant lady meets gorgeous waves of delicious gelato on a hot summer day. I spent a month in Italy and have had my fair share of gelato - this place makes it fresh and authentically. I even learned something - gelato is never made with eggs - who knew? All of the desserts, cakes and pastries looked wonderful, but I only had eyes for stracciatella. They do have a pretty extensive sandwich and salad menu, and the tiny interior is cozy and tastefully decorated - I'll definitely be back! Isn't this where Wolfgang's used to be?
(5)
Mrs. H.
Ay, I'm ashamed to admit that I've been here quite a few times since it's opened, but after having gelato every night on our trip to Europe I've had a fever and the only cure is more gelato. Is it the exposed brick walls and cozy atmosphere that draw me in? Or is it the bad ass gelato? My favorite so far is pistachio, with every other flavor I've tried coming in second. I had the 3 in a medium tonight, a generous three flavors in one cup: Irish Cream, Pecan Shortbread and Death by Chocolate. The Stracciatella and Amaretto also good. The super friendly staff make it a plus. There's also cookies and cakes that look pretty darn good. And like everyone else, I'll have to remember to try the sandwiches and salads next time. This place is located between Harry's and Emiliano's, where Wolfgang's used to be. Wherever you have dinner, go downtown for a stroll and end your evening here. **UPDATE: I've had their paninis and they're the best darn paninis I've ever had. Seriously. They must have a really good panini iron because the bread was crunchy inside and out and everything was nice and melted on the inside. My friend and I shared two sandwiches, one was the Focoso which was stuffed with salami, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and oregano on focacio bread, and the other was the Americano which had turkey, roasted red peppers, portabella mushrooms, dijon mustard and homemade horseradish sauce on focacio bread. Both came with chips, a side of chicken salad, a drink and a small gelato for under $10. It's a real, real good deal. They really took sandwich art in Gainesville to the next level. ***UPDATE: My people hear me: I've had the salads and they are good. I pity the fool that don't come here.
(5)
Heather S.
The Gelato Company is where "dinner" used to be before they moved west. They have very fresh gelato, comparable to what you'd enjoy in Italy. I enjoyed the special, which included a sandwich, a tuna salad, a small gelato and drink. Cozy atmosphere. I hope they make it.
(4)
Logan f.
Great gelato. I got the gelato/sandwich/drink deal combo thingy and it was amazing. Sandwiches are great and it ends with great gelato. Everytime I have gone their staff has been friendly and cute. There was some guy playing the piano that was amazing. The only downside.......get a location with more parking.
(5)
Joshua N.
I can't believe that Gainesville now has two ice cream places that aren't corporate and damn tasty. Now if you're close to downtown and don't want to make the trip across town to sweet dreams you can sample some of the delicious gelato here. I had the chocolate and hazlenut gelatos and both of them hit the spot on a hot day. One warning, this place is kinda expensive. $3.45 for a small gelato seems kinda high to me. They also had some tasty sounding sandwiches and salads which I will try on my next trip.
(4)
Julie A.
So college chick took me to Cold Stone Creamery, being the chain dame she is. But I wanted to introduce her to the mother of all ice cream -- gelato! (Cue the Lizzie McGuire movie... wait.. nobody here knows what I'm talkin bout? Hahaha Nevermind youtube.com/watch?v=4KCn… at 8:45.) I can't remember the exact flavor now, but it was rich with flavor. I'm sure my son would enjoy it, too. =D
(4)
Alan W.
Chicken salad sandwich is bae!!!! Mandarin orange salad with honey vinaigrette is pretty decent. You must must must try the house dressing, HOLY SMOKES!!!!!! Seriously, I could see coming back to this place again and again and again. The workers were fun and super quirky. The hipster customers make me feel like I've entered a new dimension. What a fascinating culture at The Gelato Co! Dinner and a show, what could be better!?!?!?
(5)
Gaurav G.
Took my now girlfriend on our first date 6 years ago to this restaurant. We loved the gelato there and always the service. Cool place to visit when downtown. The food and the gelato are amazing. It such an awesome place that I proposed to my girlfriend there! The staff. Is amazing especially Leo whom help make the moment special. If you want to visit a classic ice cream place in Gainesville go to this restaurant you won't be disappointed!
(5)
Alayna D.
Atmosphere Quaint and cute local Gainesville gelato and lunch spot for great sandwiches and salads. Seriously, don't go just for the gelato - albeit well worth the trip alone just for the sweet treat - the food is just as good! Rustic little hidden gem in downtown Gainesville. Save room after dining downtown and stop in for dessert here. A few tables inside and outside. Sometimes there's live music on the piano to add to the quaintness feel which I love. Service I don't frequent the place, but when I go I'm usually greeted with happy staff who offer as many samplings of gelato until my taste buds find the right one which I'm thankful for. Friendly people and always with smiles the times I've gone. Food/Gelato As I said, the sandwiches and salads are just as good as the gelato. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because I do wish there was a way to know ahead of time which gelatos they had featured each day somehow online so I knew when to stop in for my favorites, but I tend to find at least a few I like each time I go so no complaints. Like I said, you can sample the gelatos to your hearts content, too! The salads and sandwiches are plentiful and FRESH - love them! TIP: You can get more than one gelato flavor in your cup; don't be shy! Be daring and mix it up with multiple flavors guys and gals. :) Why I'd go back...whether a big salad or great sandwich on yummy toasted bread or after dinner cup of creamy gelato, my reasons to return are abundant! Stay dreamy, Gelato Company!
(4)
Damien S.
Gimme that Jersey fat cheesesteak. Gimme a fountain drank. Gimme that gelato. Oh, it comes with a free small gelato? Hey girl hey. A glorious gamut of gourmet sandwiches, but when the owner says "You've got to try the Fat Cheesesteak," well sir, I listen. Not quite the whiz wit, and regional in its own right, this sloppy mess packs onions, peppers and mushrooms, is a caloric indulgence that's bound to end up (in part) on your withered dewlap. The half ($7.50) is fine for lunch, especially when you consider each sandwich comes with two sides. I was a little confused, however, as the Fatty allegedly came standard with Funyuns as a side (NJ Law), yet none were to be found, and the staffer at the register relayed the cheesesteak only comes with a single side. Methinks a mistake in communication? Add a self-serve soda or iced tea to the mix, and you'll get a small (and it's small) gelato on the house. Which you owe it to yourself to try - the salted caramel and pretzel in dark chocolate had a killer consistency and wasn't overly sweet. It's a solid $10 lunch with a sweet nightcap, and I'd assume hot messes like the Fat Cheesesteak bring in the after-hours crowds. *reads other reviews* Yep. Will definitely stop by again to dabble in something a bit healthier. But I won't be happy about it.
(4)
James O.
I love sandwiches. I also love Gelato, not nearly as much as sandwiches..but you get the point. The Gelato Co. does both well. I had the raspberry turkey. Plenty of sauce, my only complaint was that they turkey was a little dry. But for the price and quality its hard to beat!
(4)
Mel V.
Better coffee than Starbucks. Awesome atmosphere and flavorful breakfast sandwiches. The gelato flavors are creative and taste so good.
(5)
Ling S.
This is one of my FAVORITE sandwich/dessert places in Gainesville! Perfect for lunch or a quick dinner. It's a very small restaurant containing probably only 5 tables inside. On a nice day, eat outside on the patio tables. The staff is always very friendly. If you order a sandwich or panini for their special, it comes with a free small gelato. Which is more than enough, because their gelato is very rich! Delicious, but very rich. My favorite hot and fresh panini is the Pollo. Try their chicken salad! It's excellent with perfectly sweet red grapes. My boyfriend is in LOVE with their philly cheese steak sandwich. You really can't go wrong with anything that you order there. Downtown parking sucks for the restaurant. Be prepared to hunt and stalk down a parking spot on a busy night. One thing I really like about the Gelato Co. is that they do group fundraising. If your club or organizations needs to raise funds for a charity, host an event here! A portion of all the sales of the night will go towards your charity.
(4)
Richard C.
This is one of the best places I've been to in Gainesville. The food is excellent, the atmosphere is nice and the employees are very welcoming. There was also live pianist playing!!!!!!!!
(5)
Kelly S.
I really love this place! I've eaten here for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert. All amazing! Sometimes their food can be a little too salty, but the gelato is always spot on. I really like that the employees are nice and helpful and they let you try as many flavors as you like! I think this place is reasonably priced, has a decent interior, and I am always glad when I come here.
(5)
Kaitlin H.
As I rolled up to Gelato Co tonight around 8, the live piano playing in the background, the sweet smell of gelato and promise of a hot panini in my future, the phrase that came to my mind was "classy as hell." The turkey panini was nice, the sides were decent. But the gelato. Oh, the gelato. One cannot comprehend the deliciousness of the gelato at this fine establishment. Smooth, rich, perfectly balanced in flavor... Holy crap it was good. I recommend getting two flavors (bittersweet chocolate is fantastic, especially combined with red velvet). Also, a note on the sizes of the gelato cups: they have empty small, medium, and large cups on display so you can decide which size you want to get. Don't be alarmed by how small they are. They really pile the gelato on! I was perfectly fine with a small. I'd much rather go here than Karma, and it's probably tied with Sweet Dreams in my book, and that's saying a lot. So please. Please please please. Go try the gelato.
(4)
Amy S.
Mmmmmmmm. It seems that their small size cup is far bigger than any other small I've ever had before! You definitely get your money's worth and can easily share one with another person.
(5)
Honest R.
This review is based solely on their gelato. Yes, the servings are small and the prices are high per oz BUT the gelato has a unique texture and flavor to justify it. I recommend the lime or raspberry flavors. The place is small and has a new-age European feel to it; it has character. Perfect place to stop by dessert with your significant other and eat it outside on the tables out front.
(5)
Coty S.
Great location, but no parking. I hope they get tons of dessert businesses from all of the restaurants in the area. They could get more of a late night crowd if they were open until after the clubs let out on the weekends, but they might want to avoid the hassle. The people that work here are extremely nice. They do not have that many interesting flavors to choose from. I came hoping for some of the stranger flavors listed on their website- honeydew, watermelon, cantaloupe, amaretto, or chai tea, . They don't have a problem with letting you taste a ton of flavors before making a decision. And, they are willing to pack more than 5 flavors in a small serving. I really liked the Bittersweet Chocolate flavor, it is nice to have chocolate that is not super sweet. It is great to see so many local ice cream shops opening in the area.
(3)
Chelsea B.
Although I've been to the Gelato Co. several times before, I've always resisted writing a review. I'm not a huge fan of Gelato (I go when I'm with friends--everyone else seems to love gelato, except me!), so I always thought it would be a little unfair. But I recently tried the food and need to share my disappointing meal. The sandwich I ordered sounded promising (Very Berry Turkey: Turkey with dried cranberries, Swiss cheese, and tomato with honey mustard mayonnaise) but when it arrived I could tell something was way off.... -The turkey looked and tasted like Oscar Mayer sandwich meat (or rubber). -The swiss cheese looked and tasted like white movie theater nacho cheese (how do you ruin swiss cheese?!) -The sourdough bread looked and tasted like toasted Wonder Bread (that stuff is nasty....one aspect of my childhood I wish I could forget) Really, though, it was the soupy cheese that ruined what could have been a salvageable sandwich. I'm sure I will return, but it will be against my will. But come to think of it....now that I know how terrible the food is, the gelato doesn't seem so bad anymore.
(2)
Stan R.
Went downhill. Used to have a diverse selection and now they dont. Also the last 2 times I was in there the gelato serving area looked really messy and I didnt even order anything.
(2)
Michelle H.
A solid array of flavors that include some sorbettos that don't suck--hello banana. Their small cup is way bigger than most smalls I've ever seen, and you'll get that sweet cookie on top. I was super surprised to see that they a) were open super late [like 3:30am], b) had a huge food menu for being a "gelato company," and c) supposedly sold a killer cheese steak. Cheese steak and gelato don't seem as apparent as peas and carrots to me, but I think I could make it work.
(5)
Richard W.
Great place to go for lunch in Gville. Both the gelato and sandwiches are really good. I'd recommend the turkey and apple sandwich. It's very good. Downside to the place is that it's kinda small and only has a row of seating along the wall so it can be a bit cramped. But it's still good!
(4)
Sara G.
I have a few things to say about this place. I've been here several times for the gelato and a few times for food. Generally speaking, its not worth it...but it's really the only ice cream option downtown except for Mochi (which really isn't my style) so it will remain regardless of how good it actually is. I'll start with the food...its pretty meh. The cheese steak is the best option IMO. Its NJ style and pretty tasty. However, it clearly made with pre-packaged mushrooms and onions. I asked for it with just peppers and mushrooms and was told that they can't do that b/c they come in a mix together. That kind of BS short cut irks me in restaurants - its not that hard to saute fresh mushrooms and onions, etc. A lot of the other sandwiches come on what looks like grocery store white bread pressed in a panini press...it tastes that way too. Their sides are also disgusting...ask for chips instead. As for the gelato, I think calling it gelato is a bit of a stretch. Its more like Coldstone than real gelato. The flavor options are mediocre at best. Sometimes there is a good one or two but more often than not the flavors are uncreative and forgettable. Also, the daily "deal" where you get a free gelato with the purchase of a sandwich and a drink is a ripoff. The sandwich alone is usually around $7...it's ~$10 for the deal but the drink is small (yes you get free refills) and soda only costs them about 10 cents but they charge 3$ for it...and the free gelato is served in a plastic sauce cup that you'd put ketchup in at a normal restaurant...its not even served in the small size gelato cup. To suggest that a soda and a scoop of gelato is worth $3 is absurd. Even so, I usually don't finish the gelato b/c its not that good. I went for 2 stars b/c of the absence of viable ice cream alternatives in the downtown area so I go here sometimes but you're better off to drive across town to Sweet Dreams as I more often do.
(2)
Adam W.
We have ate here several times with our family. We think the meal deal is pretty good (sandwich, salad, chips, drink, sm gelato for under $10). The pressed sandwiches are very good with odd but good choices such as turkey and sour apple and ham and raspberry. The salads are good too. I'm a big eater and I am reasonably full after this meal. I'm not into gelato. It's not as good as my home town Ruggle's brand but I have found nothing wrong with it. No, there is no parking which is planned by the city, not any of the businesses downtown.
(4)
Lauren O.
I enjoy the panini that are served here and the abundance of things that the lunch combo comes with makes me happy (I'm a grazer at heart). I got the vegetarian panini for lunch today and it's hard to say what I enjoyed more...the sandwich, the cup of tomato bisque, the little scoop of chicken salad (a dollop of protein?) or the small dish of 1/2 coconut and 1/2 pineapple gelato I got for free b/c I bought a drink with my meal. Not to mention the side salad which has the most delicious seasoned croutons and the best house dressing ever that I scarfed off my daughter's plate. The only reason I left off a star is because I've been turned off of some very inventive turkey sandwich creations due to their use of subpar slimy turkey cold cuts. I would gladly pay a little extra if they used a better turkey meat for their sandwiches.
(4)
Jessica K.
Sweet lunch deal. Sandwiches come with two sides and if you add a drink you get gelato for free or a dollar or something. My vegetarian sammie had avo, cashews, dill havarti and other stuff on it and was totally good. Tomato soup was fine. Service was fine. Pretty varied menu including crepes, paninis and sandwiches. Choices for a pretty wide group and totally fair prices. Will be back. Interior is pretty sparse and basic. There's also a small patio with a few tables. Owner seemed down to earth and like the kind of small business owner you want to keep in business.
(3)
Moni M.
So I've been a HUGE lover of Gelato Co for a while. Ever since I moved to Gainesville 3 years ago, I always looked forward to the delicious and carefully prepared sandwiches that they have. Every time I go there I get the same thing: Pollo Pesto panini with double sides of potato salad. And everytime when I take a bite out of that delicious buttery pressed bakery bread I smile and I am in heaven. You think by the above that I would be giving them a 5+ star rating, right? Gelato Co's food used to take me to a heavenly euphoria. I emphasize "used to." But the sad truth of it all is The Gelato Co is not the same. I went a few weeks ago and ordered my usual, and I literally could not bite into the sandwich. Someone had not known how to make a panini and forgotten butter or something because I could have knocked someone out with that sandwich. But to give them credit, the potato salad is always delicious and has this nice sweet taste that just melts in your mouth. Thankfully one of the owners were there and they personally made me another sandwich which was just like it used to be, Panini euphoria! I was ecstatic and went on my merry way. Now today I order The Gelato Co to go. Again same order. But to my dismay when I get home with my delicious lunch and come to find out that the panini is again dry, hard and not tasty. I added some of my own tomato since they had forgotten to put it on, but still it was not enjoyable. I ate for the sheer fact that I was already home and I was very hungry. But I know at least my double potato salad would be good and give me the happy vibes I was searching for. I took a bite and to my surprise it was SO SALTY and mustardy and none of the sweet delicious taste that I had come to love for 3 years. I was so disheartened and so this is why I am making a review. I wish I would have done a review when I first tried Gelato Co. But the sad truth is that I never felt the need since it was always so good. *sigh* So please owners of The Gelato Co. teach your new staff the care and perfection that you used when creating your artisan masterpieces. I hate to say it, but I don't know if I will ever go back to eat here since i have been burned twice and their food is not cheap. It's just sad how the quality of some things start to disintegrate with time.
(2)
Kelly A.
My favorite lunch place in Gainesville! The most unique and tasty sandwiches. And of course the gelato is to die for. They always have a great variety of flavors. They let you sample before you pick your flavor out which is great. The staff is always very friendly. If it's a nice day, I recommend sitting outside. I highly recommend this place for lunch or a light dinner.
(5)
Natalie B.
This place is my FAVORITE sandwich place in Gainesville. All of their sandwiches are delicious and come with delicious sides. And if you buy a drink with a meal, you get a free small gelato. Always good customer service, a small spot but never fails to be a delicious meal. Can't go wrong with a panini.
(5)
Stephanie R.
Never had a bad meal at the Gelato Company! It is definitely one of my favorite places in Gainesville. Their special is pretty much unbeatable; a sandwich, side salad, small scoop of chicken or tuna salad, a drink, and a small gelato for just under $10. Awesome deal. It's extra awesome because EVERYTHING is delicious. I usually get the raspberry turkey sandwich (can't remember the exact name), it comes hot and dripping with cheese. One time I made a "mistake" and ordered it with the Jalapeno cheddar bread...it ended up being AWESOME. The sweet and the spice went perfectly together and now I order it every time. The side salad is fresh and has a creamy italian dressing on it, very tasty. Their chicken salad texture may weird some people out, but it is quite tasty. The gelato is made fresh in house everyday, so they always have new flavors. Don't be shy about asking to try a sample! It is, of course, also delicious (Oreo cheesecake ftw). Definitely a hidden gem. If you blink, you just might miss it :)
(5)
Jocelyn R.
Love the Gelato company! I work in the downtown area, so its an excellent option for lunch. They have a great lunch special for about 7 dollars that includes a salad, sandwich, and drink. You have a couple of different options for your sandwich, but my favorite is the turkey and apple sandwich with a delish cream cheese spread on sourdough. I kind of hate salad, so I usually don't end up eating the salad, but I'm sure its acceptable. The cafe itself is really cute, but the seating is limited, so I don't usually go there with groups (unless theres only 2 of us). They have a really nice outdoor area if its a pretty day though! The wait staff is really really nice and polite here. Their gelato is also very good, I'm just not a huge fan of sweets so I don't usually get it. But when I do, I try everything, and they're really nice about it. I can always find one that is delish. I would def recommend!!!
(5)
Coleen T.
Tried the cheese steak late one night... still haven't tried the gelato, but the cheese steak was awesome! I loved the bell peppers in it, but I asked for no mushrooms... I'm only a fan of the 'special' kinds :) The atmosphere of the restaurant was really cute, and the fact that Sublime was playing over the speakers made the whole experience great.
(4)
Lanise A.
Thumbs up for the gelato. It may be a small serving and pricey, but it is worth it if you're not in the mood for regular ice cream. However, I did not expect this place to be so small, and I'm cluster-phobic.
(4)
Megan G.
Best lunch in Gainesville if you like a gourmet sandwich and great gelato. I'd go for a panini or the turkey and apple sandwich. Sooooo good!
(5)
Robert P.
They have good sandwiches and great gelato. There are so many flavors of gelato and they change over time - so it keeps you coming back to see what they have available now. As of this writing their regular special is buy an entree & drink and get a free gelato. Usually around $10.
(4)
Hana B.
The first time I stumbled upon Gelato Company was at midnight while roaming around the streets of downtown Gainesville. The location is very nice and I have since returned on days where it was the perfect amount of sunny and breezy to enjoy my meal outside. While this is a nice place to share a meal with friends because of the intimate atmosphere, the food is really nothing special. The sandwiches and paninis are reliable but there's nothing I've ordered here that has really stood out. That being said, the gelato that comes with the combo is a great way to end the meal. Despite being served in a small, plastic container, the scoops are generous and I have never been able to finish a small gelato by myself. Though I wouldn't go here specifically for the food, I'll probably end up back in here some midnight in the future craving some gelato.
(3)
Kelly A.
Stopped in here for a light dinner the other night, and their sign didn't lie - it was indeed a good value! I had a vegetarian sandwich with avocados, tomatoes, and fresh mozz (came with jalapeno chips) and an iced tea, while the boy had a different type of vegetarian sandwich with salad and an iced tea; both came with free gelato at the end, and we still got out of there for under $20! The sandwiches were good, and the options for gelato were plentiful. I went for the cookie dough; he went for the amaretto. Both were good (though a little colder than I prefer). The service was really friendly. I don't know if that's a Florida thing or what, but it's hard to find such friendly service here in Boston. The girl at the counter even made conversation about the band on the shirt I was wearing. The hipster snobbery in Boston tends to prevent those types of conversations from occurring. So that was refreshing.
(4)
Sasha P.
The Gelato Company is a very cute and cozy restaurant If the weather is nice, the outside seating area is a very good place to eat your meal, people watch, or chat with a friend. The inside is narrow and long. Enough for seating on the left side of the wall and the gelato-holding units to the right. They have different food combinations that are a mix of classic Tuna Sandwiches to your not-so-usual Avocado Sandwiches. I've had the Tuna Sandwich and it was actually pretty good. Not fishy like one usually thinks canned tuna tastes. It came alongside a mixed greens salad and potato soup. The potato soup was realllly good! Lastly, I will say that I enjoy gelato but the kind they make here is too rich for my taste. I can only have a sample of the hazelnut gelato before I feel overloaded on sugar and hazelnut flavor. Also, they don't offer coffee gelato which is my favorite but they do have several other assorted flavors. It's not crazy expensive in here but do plan on spending more than $8 for a meal. The Gelato Company is a nice place to eat but it doesn't stand out in my book. Nothing bad about it, don't get me wrong but it's just another place to eat for me.
(3)
Nolan R.
I stopped in here to have some Gelato at the Gainesville Art Fest. I'm was impressed with how many flavors they offered. Some Gelato places tend to play it safe and make 10 flavors. These guys went all out. I bet there were close to 20. I got a medium with two flavors in it. Lemon & Fruit of the Forest....they were both terrific. I will definitely be back, I just haven't got around to G'ville's downtown lately.
(5)
Sniks L.
Gelato Company provides excellent service and remains one of my favorite breakfast/lunch restaurants; I recommend either the new egg breakfast sandwich or the Sweet and Smokey turkey sandwich. Their homemade gelato flavors also present a wonderful surprise to the end of a good meal. I hear they are opening one in the midtown area as well!
(4)
Justine B.
Their red velvet gelato is a little bit of heaven on earth! I only wish they had it available more often. Oh and go try their cheesesteaks on the weekend. I promise you will not regret it.
(4)
Matt H.
I want to love this place because apparently so many other people do but I just can't because every time I go something else goes wrong....maybe I'm just cursed. I've had a panini several times and it never has been served hot like a panini should be. Even after asking for them to heat it extra long it still comes out luke warm at best. Not to mention that I get the ole eye roll when I ask for them to leave it on a little long. The flavors of the gelato are awesome but every time I've been it's more a less resembled soft serve ice cream and didn't look nice and thick like the picture Coty S. posted. Maybe I just happen to visit when there freezer thingy isn't working at full blast. Lastly and the cherry on top is the ole hair in the salad. The strawberry rainforest salad would have been great had I been able to get the mental image of the curly blonde hair out of my head. For the record I do not have blonde curly hair. Knowing that the staff rolls their eyes at me when I request a hot sandwich I didn't even bother letting them know. See you never.
(2)
Mike W.
I've only had the gelato as dessert here, never tried anything for lunch so I cannot comment on that aspect of The Gelato Company at all. However, the gelato itself is very, very, good and the service was cheerful and prompt. One night I was there they had a young lady playing the house piano and she was churning out some pretty good Mozart and Bach which only added to the charm of the place. Their piano could benefit from tuning and also, as a grand it's a slight bit loud for the space. All and all, the mere thought of having a live pianist added much to the atmosphere. Gainesville would profit from more places for quality dessert: The Top is about the only place I can think of for pies and cakes and such that is worthwhile as a dessert destination alone if you've had dinner elsewhere. The Gelato Company is a nice addition to what we have going on downtown and I expect it to thrive.
(4)
David M.
A business trip brought me to Gainesville and I arrived a couple of hours early. That gave me the time to wander a bit and to enjoy a relaxed lunch. After passing by several chain restaurants, I was pleased to discover The Gelato Company which, according to the server behind the counter, was started by a couple of UF grads a few years ago. Always happy to support a local business, I took that as my cue to stay at The Gelato Company for lunch. Others have commented on the great value offered by The Gelato Company, and I echo that. I ordered a vegetarian panini (avocado, tomato, mozzarella and a homemade pesto). The sandwich was very good, although the flavors did not blend perfectly, primarily because the sauce was a bit too overpowering. It was still quite tasty nevertheless. The panini was served with a side salad which was ENORMOUS and dressed with a wonderfully flavorful dressing that I loved but cannot begin to describe (except to suggest that it was as if I were enjoying all of the good things in nature turned into a salad dressing!). The coffee chip gelato with which I capped my meal was both delicious and richly decadent. I can only hope that business brings me to Gainesville again soon!
(4)
Vicki M.
Yummy! I have ALWAYS got the Very Berry Turkey, with salad (there homemade dressing) and chicken salad. It's always the same and is so good. They change the flavor of gelato, so I have never been able to get the same kind twice, which is good and bad. I found a favorite, but probably won't have it again, but I always find something I like at least, so all is good....I have even turned my husband onto the very berry turkey when he has been coming here before me and always got something different.
(5)
Adam N.
Fresh, fresh, fresh! Great salads that are fresh and healthy. Incredible gelato options with many unique choices and all of them delicious. Plus they let you test out each type (which I studiously avoid doing out of principle. Be bold! Go for it! Your order isn't your last meal or last time there ya know). The staff are always friendly and gregarious. I love the brick wall lined sitting area or the chance to sit outside and enjoy the downtown atmosphere (brick paved roads). This place is the tops. Oh, they also do specials regularly via FB or email list.
(4)
Gigi A.
Amazing gelato, absolute delight. Food is mind blowing, and well the atmosphere. The atmosphere is french bistro meets new york. The people around are amazing as well. I love love love this place :) A lot. GO.
(5)
Christina L.
I used to come here for their special - a sandwich, drink, and gelato for under $10! Decent sandwiches. I'm oddly drawn to the chicken salad every time. Yummy gelato. It's pretty laid-back and chill, with a piano in the front. I've only seen a person play on it once, though. A good spot to grab lunch and catch up with friends.
(3)
Alan W.
Chicken salad sandwich is bae!!!! Mandarin orange salad with honey vinaigrette is pretty decent. You must must must try the house dressing, HOLY SMOKES!!!!!! Seriously, I could see coming back to this place again and again and again. The workers were fun and super quirky. The hipster customers make me feel like I've entered a new dimension. What a fascinating culture at The Gelato Co! Dinner and a show, what could be better!?!?!?
(5)
Alayna D.
Atmosphere Quaint and cute local Gainesville gelato and lunch spot for great sandwiches and salads. Seriously, don't go just for the gelato - albeit well worth the trip alone just for the sweet treat - the food is just as good! Rustic little hidden gem in downtown Gainesville. Save room after dining downtown and stop in for dessert here. A few tables inside and outside. Sometimes there's live music on the piano to add to the quaintness feel which I love. Service I don't frequent the place, but when I go I'm usually greeted with happy staff who offer as many samplings of gelato until my taste buds find the right one which I'm thankful for. Friendly people and always with smiles the times I've gone. Food/Gelato As I said, the sandwiches and salads are just as good as the gelato. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because I do wish there was a way to know ahead of time which gelatos they had featured each day somehow online so I knew when to stop in for my favorites, but I tend to find at least a few I like each time I go so no complaints. Like I said, you can sample the gelatos to your hearts content, too! The salads and sandwiches are plentiful and FRESH - love them! TIP: You can get more than one gelato flavor in your cup; don't be shy! Be daring and mix it up with multiple flavors guys and gals. :) Why I'd go back...whether a big salad or great sandwich on yummy toasted bread or after dinner cup of creamy gelato, my reasons to return are abundant! Stay dreamy, Gelato Company!
(4)
Moni M.
So I've been a HUGE lover of Gelato Co for a while. Ever since I moved to Gainesville 3 years ago, I always looked forward to the delicious and carefully prepared sandwiches that they have. Every time I go there I get the same thing: Pollo Pesto panini with double sides of potato salad. And everytime when I take a bite out of that delicious buttery pressed bakery bread I smile and I am in heaven. You think by the above that I would be giving them a 5+ star rating, right? Gelato Co's food used to take me to a heavenly euphoria. I emphasize "used to." But the sad truth of it all is The Gelato Co is not the same. I went a few weeks ago and ordered my usual, and I literally could not bite into the sandwich. Someone had not known how to make a panini and forgotten butter or something because I could have knocked someone out with that sandwich. But to give them credit, the potato salad is always delicious and has this nice sweet taste that just melts in your mouth. Thankfully one of the owners were there and they personally made me another sandwich which was just like it used to be, Panini euphoria! I was ecstatic and went on my merry way. Now today I order The Gelato Co to go. Again same order. But to my dismay when I get home with my delicious lunch and come to find out that the panini is again dry, hard and not tasty. I added some of my own tomato since they had forgotten to put it on, but still it was not enjoyable. I ate for the sheer fact that I was already home and I was very hungry. But I know at least my double potato salad would be good and give me the happy vibes I was searching for. I took a bite and to my surprise it was SO SALTY and mustardy and none of the sweet delicious taste that I had come to love for 3 years. I was so disheartened and so this is why I am making a review. I wish I would have done a review when I first tried Gelato Co. But the sad truth is that I never felt the need since it was always so good. *sigh* So please owners of The Gelato Co. teach your new staff the care and perfection that you used when creating your artisan masterpieces. I hate to say it, but I don't know if I will ever go back to eat here since i have been burned twice and their food is not cheap. It's just sad how the quality of some things start to disintegrate with time.
(2)
Kelly A.
My favorite lunch place in Gainesville! The most unique and tasty sandwiches. And of course the gelato is to die for. They always have a great variety of flavors. They let you sample before you pick your flavor out which is great. The staff is always very friendly. If it's a nice day, I recommend sitting outside. I highly recommend this place for lunch or a light dinner.
(5)
Natalie B.
This place is my FAVORITE sandwich place in Gainesville. All of their sandwiches are delicious and come with delicious sides. And if you buy a drink with a meal, you get a free small gelato. Always good customer service, a small spot but never fails to be a delicious meal. Can't go wrong with a panini.
(5)
Damien S.
Gimme that Jersey fat cheesesteak. Gimme a fountain drank. Gimme that gelato. Oh, it comes with a free small gelato? Hey girl hey. A glorious gamut of gourmet sandwiches, but when the owner says "You've got to try the Fat Cheesesteak," well sir, I listen. Not quite the whiz wit, and regional in its own right, this sloppy mess packs onions, peppers and mushrooms, is a caloric indulgence that's bound to end up (in part) on your withered dewlap. The half ($7.50) is fine for lunch, especially when you consider each sandwich comes with two sides. I was a little confused, however, as the Fatty allegedly came standard with Funyuns as a side (NJ Law), yet none were to be found, and the staffer at the register relayed the cheesesteak only comes with a single side. Methinks a mistake in communication? Add a self-serve soda or iced tea to the mix, and you'll get a small (and it's small) gelato on the house. Which you owe it to yourself to try - the salted caramel and pretzel in dark chocolate had a killer consistency and wasn't overly sweet. It's a solid $10 lunch with a sweet nightcap, and I'd assume hot messes like the Fat Cheesesteak bring in the after-hours crowds. *reads other reviews* Yep. Will definitely stop by again to dabble in something a bit healthier. But I won't be happy about it.
(4)
James O.
I love sandwiches. I also love Gelato, not nearly as much as sandwiches..but you get the point. The Gelato Co. does both well. I had the raspberry turkey. Plenty of sauce, my only complaint was that they turkey was a little dry. But for the price and quality its hard to beat!
(4)
Mel V.
Better coffee than Starbucks. Awesome atmosphere and flavorful breakfast sandwiches. The gelato flavors are creative and taste so good.
(5)
Jessica K.
Sweet lunch deal. Sandwiches come with two sides and if you add a drink you get gelato for free or a dollar or something. My vegetarian sammie had avo, cashews, dill havarti and other stuff on it and was totally good. Tomato soup was fine. Service was fine. Pretty varied menu including crepes, paninis and sandwiches. Choices for a pretty wide group and totally fair prices. Will be back. Interior is pretty sparse and basic. There's also a small patio with a few tables. Owner seemed down to earth and like the kind of small business owner you want to keep in business.
(3)
Gaurav G.
Took my now girlfriend on our first date 6 years ago to this restaurant. We loved the gelato there and always the service. Cool place to visit when downtown. The food and the gelato are amazing. It such an awesome place that I proposed to my girlfriend there! The staff. Is amazing especially Leo whom help make the moment special. If you want to visit a classic ice cream place in Gainesville go to this restaurant you won't be disappointed!
(5)
Amanda D.
Was toddling around Gainesville with my BFFs the other day and had to stop in here. Parking was okay, but what took off stars right from the beginning is the way they have their order line set up. Its right next to peoples tables that theyre trying to eat at, and people have to walk back down the opposite way to get out of the line at the end. Being claustrophobic, that really did not set the mood. Onto the food. I got the Americano panini with "chicken salad" and creamy potato soup. The panini was good, very cheesy, but didnt really have any texture. There was no crunch or bite to it. The chicken salad is just too weird. Its a uniform texture and color, more like the appearance of a scoop of shredded cat food. The potato soup was pretty decent. A bit gritty in texture, but not too bad. Thought it was odd and rather wasteful for them to use Styrofoam cuts and plastic wear to serve the food. The only saving grace is the gelato. The peanutbutter was to die for, and the chocolate pudding was in the awesome area. Other sandwich and crepe options look promising, and Im willing to try something twice so Id probably come back again but probably only for dessert.
(3)
Maggie P.
Great place! Amazing gelato! Open late. The cookies and sandwiches are also delicious!
(5)
Laura M.
This place is awesome. They're open late, they have a totally relaxed atmosphere, the snacks and drinks are good, and oh yeah, GELATO. My best friend spent a semester in Rome and says this stuff is as good as what you get in Italy. She brought me here and we indulged. The staff will let you mix multiple flavors in one serving, and they pile on the gelato as high as it'll go in your little dish. Plus, you get a hazelnut cookie to dip in it. We went around 11:30 on a weeknight in December and they were out of almost every flavor, though. I mean, yes, it was the end of the day, but if you're going to stay open late (which rules), then make sure you can cater to the customers who come in at that time. I'm sure we could've gotten coffee or wine and been all set, but they're not called the Coffee or Wine Company. So, down one star.
(4)
Y Y.
I actually went to this place based on some of the great reviews some fo the other yelp users left. What a great decision that was! I tried the gelato and absolutely loved it. When I was in Italy I ate gelato every single day and it really reminded me of gelato in Italy.
(5)
Heather S.
Oh! My! Gawd! It's a beautiful thing when a pregnant lady meets gorgeous waves of delicious gelato on a hot summer day. I spent a month in Italy and have had my fair share of gelato - this place makes it fresh and authentically. I even learned something - gelato is never made with eggs - who knew? All of the desserts, cakes and pastries looked wonderful, but I only had eyes for stracciatella. They do have a pretty extensive sandwich and salad menu, and the tiny interior is cozy and tastefully decorated - I'll definitely be back! Isn't this where Wolfgang's used to be?
(5)
Mrs. H.
Ay, I'm ashamed to admit that I've been here quite a few times since it's opened, but after having gelato every night on our trip to Europe I've had a fever and the only cure is more gelato. Is it the exposed brick walls and cozy atmosphere that draw me in? Or is it the bad ass gelato? My favorite so far is pistachio, with every other flavor I've tried coming in second. I had the 3 in a medium tonight, a generous three flavors in one cup: Irish Cream, Pecan Shortbread and Death by Chocolate. The Stracciatella and Amaretto also good. The super friendly staff make it a plus. There's also cookies and cakes that look pretty darn good. And like everyone else, I'll have to remember to try the sandwiches and salads next time. This place is located between Harry's and Emiliano's, where Wolfgang's used to be. Wherever you have dinner, go downtown for a stroll and end your evening here. **UPDATE: I've had their paninis and they're the best darn paninis I've ever had. Seriously. They must have a really good panini iron because the bread was crunchy inside and out and everything was nice and melted on the inside. My friend and I shared two sandwiches, one was the Focoso which was stuffed with salami, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and oregano on focacio bread, and the other was the Americano which had turkey, roasted red peppers, portabella mushrooms, dijon mustard and homemade horseradish sauce on focacio bread. Both came with chips, a side of chicken salad, a drink and a small gelato for under $10. It's a real, real good deal. They really took sandwich art in Gainesville to the next level. ***UPDATE: My people hear me: I've had the salads and they are good. I pity the fool that don't come here.
(5)
Heather S.
The Gelato Company is where "dinner" used to be before they moved west. They have very fresh gelato, comparable to what you'd enjoy in Italy. I enjoyed the special, which included a sandwich, a tuna salad, a small gelato and drink. Cozy atmosphere. I hope they make it.
(4)
Logan f.
Great gelato. I got the gelato/sandwich/drink deal combo thingy and it was amazing. Sandwiches are great and it ends with great gelato. Everytime I have gone their staff has been friendly and cute. There was some guy playing the piano that was amazing. The only downside.......get a location with more parking.
(5)
Joshua N.
I can't believe that Gainesville now has two ice cream places that aren't corporate and damn tasty. Now if you're close to downtown and don't want to make the trip across town to sweet dreams you can sample some of the delicious gelato here. I had the chocolate and hazlenut gelatos and both of them hit the spot on a hot day. One warning, this place is kinda expensive. $3.45 for a small gelato seems kinda high to me. They also had some tasty sounding sandwiches and salads which I will try on my next trip.
(4)
April O.
This place is GOOD. How good? Good enough to make you eat very cold gelato when it's only 40 degrees outside. And as native Floridians know, 40 degrees is bordering on arctic misery. Of course, the gelato is the star of the show (and it should be), but don't overlook their insanely good paninis or their very tasty salads. I don't know how they manage to make such light and delicious mayonnaise-based tuna and chicken salads ... think they'd tell me if I begged for a recipe? The shop itself exudes "tiny loft" charm. I'm a sucker for exposed brickwork and baby grand pianos carefully wedged in tiny spaces. Come here when you just want to people-watch while slowly eating lunch. Very pretty staff, very pretty clientele. Guys in and around this store are abnormally hawt.
(5)
Danny D.
I saw this girl I sorta know working there. It was awkward because I wasn't sure if I should acknowledge her or not. Their paninis are good.
(3)
Paul D.
Amazing gelato, good sandwiches. If in Gainesville and craving ice cream I rank it better than Hagan-Dazs, Ben and Jerry and Cold-Stone Creamery.
(4)
Diana N.
Their crepes are soooooo yummy!! But it's a little pricey, but I am willing to pay since its the only place that I know of in Gainesville to get crepes. The guy at the register was a little rude to us, other than that, I'd definitely come back!
(4)
James B.
A great local downtown spot to kick back and enjoy lunch. I love the exposed brick wall with the mildly artsy decor giving it a great downtown-vibe. The gelato is great here. I can be happy to recommend anyone to eat their gelato. Fresh, bursting in flavor, affordable, and delicious! They also have sorbettos and other desserts. You can never come here bored because new flavors roll out almost daily. Feel free to mix 2 flavors in one cup! The paninis are delicious with their crunchy focaccia bread. Perfectly crunchy on the outside, soft inside and tasty all over. I love their salmone panini. Their salad is light and delicious; their dressing is not overwhelming. As gross as it may sound, their chicken or tuna salad is great too. All, with a small drink equals around $8-10 dollars...plus free gelato. Can't beat that! Highly recommended for those looking for a quick, relatively healthy, and light meal.
(4)
Belle C.
4 stars because it's called The Gelato Company and the gelato is very good. It's a charming little place and the staff is friendly. I was less than impressed with my mozzarella/tomato/avocado panini. The bread was stale-ish, the mozzarella was not fresh, and I could barely taste the avocado. It came with a clump of "tuna salad" (looked like canned tuna and mayo) which seems like a really random side. I know, it's cheap, but I don't care how cheap the food is if it isn't good. I'll be back only for the gelato.
(4)
Megan G.
Best lunch in Gainesville if you like a gourmet sandwich and great gelato. I'd go for a panini or the turkey and apple sandwich. Sooooo good!
(5)
Ling S.
This is one of my FAVORITE sandwich/dessert places in Gainesville! Perfect for lunch or a quick dinner. It's a very small restaurant containing probably only 5 tables inside. On a nice day, eat outside on the patio tables. The staff is always very friendly. If you order a sandwich or panini for their special, it comes with a free small gelato. Which is more than enough, because their gelato is very rich! Delicious, but very rich. My favorite hot and fresh panini is the Pollo. Try their chicken salad! It's excellent with perfectly sweet red grapes. My boyfriend is in LOVE with their philly cheese steak sandwich. You really can't go wrong with anything that you order there. Downtown parking sucks for the restaurant. Be prepared to hunt and stalk down a parking spot on a busy night. One thing I really like about the Gelato Co. is that they do group fundraising. If your club or organizations needs to raise funds for a charity, host an event here! A portion of all the sales of the night will go towards your charity.
(4)
Richard C.
This is one of the best places I've been to in Gainesville. The food is excellent, the atmosphere is nice and the employees are very welcoming. There was also live pianist playing!!!!!!!!
(5)
Kelly S.
I really love this place! I've eaten here for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert. All amazing! Sometimes their food can be a little too salty, but the gelato is always spot on. I really like that the employees are nice and helpful and they let you try as many flavors as you like! I think this place is reasonably priced, has a decent interior, and I am always glad when I come here.
(5)
Kaitlin H.
As I rolled up to Gelato Co tonight around 8, the live piano playing in the background, the sweet smell of gelato and promise of a hot panini in my future, the phrase that came to my mind was "classy as hell." The turkey panini was nice, the sides were decent. But the gelato. Oh, the gelato. One cannot comprehend the deliciousness of the gelato at this fine establishment. Smooth, rich, perfectly balanced in flavor... Holy crap it was good. I recommend getting two flavors (bittersweet chocolate is fantastic, especially combined with red velvet). Also, a note on the sizes of the gelato cups: they have empty small, medium, and large cups on display so you can decide which size you want to get. Don't be alarmed by how small they are. They really pile the gelato on! I was perfectly fine with a small. I'd much rather go here than Karma, and it's probably tied with Sweet Dreams in my book, and that's saying a lot. So please. Please please please. Go try the gelato.
(4)
Amy S.
Mmmmmmmm. It seems that their small size cup is far bigger than any other small I've ever had before! You definitely get your money's worth and can easily share one with another person.
(5)
Honest R.
This review is based solely on their gelato. Yes, the servings are small and the prices are high per oz BUT the gelato has a unique texture and flavor to justify it. I recommend the lime or raspberry flavors. The place is small and has a new-age European feel to it; it has character. Perfect place to stop by dessert with your significant other and eat it outside on the tables out front.
(5)
Coty S.
Great location, but no parking. I hope they get tons of dessert businesses from all of the restaurants in the area. They could get more of a late night crowd if they were open until after the clubs let out on the weekends, but they might want to avoid the hassle. The people that work here are extremely nice. They do not have that many interesting flavors to choose from. I came hoping for some of the stranger flavors listed on their website- honeydew, watermelon, cantaloupe, amaretto, or chai tea, . They don't have a problem with letting you taste a ton of flavors before making a decision. And, they are willing to pack more than 5 flavors in a small serving. I really liked the Bittersweet Chocolate flavor, it is nice to have chocolate that is not super sweet. It is great to see so many local ice cream shops opening in the area.
(3)
Robert P.
They have good sandwiches and great gelato. There are so many flavors of gelato and they change over time - so it keeps you coming back to see what they have available now. As of this writing their regular special is buy an entree & drink and get a free gelato. Usually around $10.
(4)
Chelsea B.
Although I've been to the Gelato Co. several times before, I've always resisted writing a review. I'm not a huge fan of Gelato (I go when I'm with friends--everyone else seems to love gelato, except me!), so I always thought it would be a little unfair. But I recently tried the food and need to share my disappointing meal. The sandwich I ordered sounded promising (Very Berry Turkey: Turkey with dried cranberries, Swiss cheese, and tomato with honey mustard mayonnaise) but when it arrived I could tell something was way off.... -The turkey looked and tasted like Oscar Mayer sandwich meat (or rubber). -The swiss cheese looked and tasted like white movie theater nacho cheese (how do you ruin swiss cheese?!) -The sourdough bread looked and tasted like toasted Wonder Bread (that stuff is nasty....one aspect of my childhood I wish I could forget) Really, though, it was the soupy cheese that ruined what could have been a salvageable sandwich. I'm sure I will return, but it will be against my will. But come to think of it....now that I know how terrible the food is, the gelato doesn't seem so bad anymore.
(2)
Stan R.
Went downhill. Used to have a diverse selection and now they dont. Also the last 2 times I was in there the gelato serving area looked really messy and I didnt even order anything.
(2)
Michelle H.
A solid array of flavors that include some sorbettos that don't suck--hello banana. Their small cup is way bigger than most smalls I've ever seen, and you'll get that sweet cookie on top. I was super surprised to see that they a) were open super late [like 3:30am], b) had a huge food menu for being a "gelato company," and c) supposedly sold a killer cheese steak. Cheese steak and gelato don't seem as apparent as peas and carrots to me, but I think I could make it work.
(5)
Richard W.
Great place to go for lunch in Gville. Both the gelato and sandwiches are really good. I'd recommend the turkey and apple sandwich. It's very good. Downside to the place is that it's kinda small and only has a row of seating along the wall so it can be a bit cramped. But it's still good!
(4)
Sara G.
I have a few things to say about this place. I've been here several times for the gelato and a few times for food. Generally speaking, its not worth it...but it's really the only ice cream option downtown except for Mochi (which really isn't my style) so it will remain regardless of how good it actually is. I'll start with the food...its pretty meh. The cheese steak is the best option IMO. Its NJ style and pretty tasty. However, it clearly made with pre-packaged mushrooms and onions. I asked for it with just peppers and mushrooms and was told that they can't do that b/c they come in a mix together. That kind of BS short cut irks me in restaurants - its not that hard to saute fresh mushrooms and onions, etc. A lot of the other sandwiches come on what looks like grocery store white bread pressed in a panini press...it tastes that way too. Their sides are also disgusting...ask for chips instead. As for the gelato, I think calling it gelato is a bit of a stretch. Its more like Coldstone than real gelato. The flavor options are mediocre at best. Sometimes there is a good one or two but more often than not the flavors are uncreative and forgettable. Also, the daily "deal" where you get a free gelato with the purchase of a sandwich and a drink is a ripoff. The sandwich alone is usually around $7...it's ~$10 for the deal but the drink is small (yes you get free refills) and soda only costs them about 10 cents but they charge 3$ for it...and the free gelato is served in a plastic sauce cup that you'd put ketchup in at a normal restaurant...its not even served in the small size gelato cup. To suggest that a soda and a scoop of gelato is worth $3 is absurd. Even so, I usually don't finish the gelato b/c its not that good. I went for 2 stars b/c of the absence of viable ice cream alternatives in the downtown area so I go here sometimes but you're better off to drive across town to Sweet Dreams as I more often do.
(2)
Adam W.
We have ate here several times with our family. We think the meal deal is pretty good (sandwich, salad, chips, drink, sm gelato for under $10). The pressed sandwiches are very good with odd but good choices such as turkey and sour apple and ham and raspberry. The salads are good too. I'm a big eater and I am reasonably full after this meal. I'm not into gelato. It's not as good as my home town Ruggle's brand but I have found nothing wrong with it. No, there is no parking which is planned by the city, not any of the businesses downtown.
(4)
Lauren O.
I enjoy the panini that are served here and the abundance of things that the lunch combo comes with makes me happy (I'm a grazer at heart). I got the vegetarian panini for lunch today and it's hard to say what I enjoyed more...the sandwich, the cup of tomato bisque, the little scoop of chicken salad (a dollop of protein?) or the small dish of 1/2 coconut and 1/2 pineapple gelato I got for free b/c I bought a drink with my meal. Not to mention the side salad which has the most delicious seasoned croutons and the best house dressing ever that I scarfed off my daughter's plate. The only reason I left off a star is because I've been turned off of some very inventive turkey sandwich creations due to their use of subpar slimy turkey cold cuts. I would gladly pay a little extra if they used a better turkey meat for their sandwiches.
(4)
Stephanie R.
Never had a bad meal at the Gelato Company! It is definitely one of my favorite places in Gainesville. Their special is pretty much unbeatable; a sandwich, side salad, small scoop of chicken or tuna salad, a drink, and a small gelato for just under $10. Awesome deal. It's extra awesome because EVERYTHING is delicious. I usually get the raspberry turkey sandwich (can't remember the exact name), it comes hot and dripping with cheese. One time I made a "mistake" and ordered it with the Jalapeno cheddar bread...it ended up being AWESOME. The sweet and the spice went perfectly together and now I order it every time. The side salad is fresh and has a creamy italian dressing on it, very tasty. Their chicken salad texture may weird some people out, but it is quite tasty. The gelato is made fresh in house everyday, so they always have new flavors. Don't be shy about asking to try a sample! It is, of course, also delicious (Oreo cheesecake ftw). Definitely a hidden gem. If you blink, you just might miss it :)
(5)
Jocelyn R.
Love the Gelato company! I work in the downtown area, so its an excellent option for lunch. They have a great lunch special for about 7 dollars that includes a salad, sandwich, and drink. You have a couple of different options for your sandwich, but my favorite is the turkey and apple sandwich with a delish cream cheese spread on sourdough. I kind of hate salad, so I usually don't end up eating the salad, but I'm sure its acceptable. The cafe itself is really cute, but the seating is limited, so I don't usually go there with groups (unless theres only 2 of us). They have a really nice outdoor area if its a pretty day though! The wait staff is really really nice and polite here. Their gelato is also very good, I'm just not a huge fan of sweets so I don't usually get it. But when I do, I try everything, and they're really nice about it. I can always find one that is delish. I would def recommend!!!
(5)
Coleen T.
Tried the cheese steak late one night... still haven't tried the gelato, but the cheese steak was awesome! I loved the bell peppers in it, but I asked for no mushrooms... I'm only a fan of the 'special' kinds :) The atmosphere of the restaurant was really cute, and the fact that Sublime was playing over the speakers made the whole experience great.
(4)
Lanise A.
Thumbs up for the gelato. It may be a small serving and pricey, but it is worth it if you're not in the mood for regular ice cream. However, I did not expect this place to be so small, and I'm cluster-phobic.
(4)
Julie A.
So college chick took me to Cold Stone Creamery, being the chain dame she is. But I wanted to introduce her to the mother of all ice cream -- gelato! (Cue the Lizzie McGuire movie... wait.. nobody here knows what I'm talkin bout? Hahaha Nevermind youtube.com/watch?v=4KCn… at 8:45.) I can't remember the exact flavor now, but it was rich with flavor. I'm sure my son would enjoy it, too. =D
(4)
Hana B.
The first time I stumbled upon Gelato Company was at midnight while roaming around the streets of downtown Gainesville. The location is very nice and I have since returned on days where it was the perfect amount of sunny and breezy to enjoy my meal outside. While this is a nice place to share a meal with friends because of the intimate atmosphere, the food is really nothing special. The sandwiches and paninis are reliable but there's nothing I've ordered here that has really stood out. That being said, the gelato that comes with the combo is a great way to end the meal. Despite being served in a small, plastic container, the scoops are generous and I have never been able to finish a small gelato by myself. Though I wouldn't go here specifically for the food, I'll probably end up back in here some midnight in the future craving some gelato.
(3)
Kelly A.
Stopped in here for a light dinner the other night, and their sign didn't lie - it was indeed a good value! I had a vegetarian sandwich with avocados, tomatoes, and fresh mozz (came with jalapeno chips) and an iced tea, while the boy had a different type of vegetarian sandwich with salad and an iced tea; both came with free gelato at the end, and we still got out of there for under $20! The sandwiches were good, and the options for gelato were plentiful. I went for the cookie dough; he went for the amaretto. Both were good (though a little colder than I prefer). The service was really friendly. I don't know if that's a Florida thing or what, but it's hard to find such friendly service here in Boston. The girl at the counter even made conversation about the band on the shirt I was wearing. The hipster snobbery in Boston tends to prevent those types of conversations from occurring. So that was refreshing.
(4)
Sasha P.
The Gelato Company is a very cute and cozy restaurant If the weather is nice, the outside seating area is a very good place to eat your meal, people watch, or chat with a friend. The inside is narrow and long. Enough for seating on the left side of the wall and the gelato-holding units to the right. They have different food combinations that are a mix of classic Tuna Sandwiches to your not-so-usual Avocado Sandwiches. I've had the Tuna Sandwich and it was actually pretty good. Not fishy like one usually thinks canned tuna tastes. It came alongside a mixed greens salad and potato soup. The potato soup was realllly good! Lastly, I will say that I enjoy gelato but the kind they make here is too rich for my taste. I can only have a sample of the hazelnut gelato before I feel overloaded on sugar and hazelnut flavor. Also, they don't offer coffee gelato which is my favorite but they do have several other assorted flavors. It's not crazy expensive in here but do plan on spending more than $8 for a meal. The Gelato Company is a nice place to eat but it doesn't stand out in my book. Nothing bad about it, don't get me wrong but it's just another place to eat for me.
(3)
Nolan R.
I stopped in here to have some Gelato at the Gainesville Art Fest. I'm was impressed with how many flavors they offered. Some Gelato places tend to play it safe and make 10 flavors. These guys went all out. I bet there were close to 20. I got a medium with two flavors in it. Lemon & Fruit of the Forest....they were both terrific. I will definitely be back, I just haven't got around to G'ville's downtown lately.
(5)
Matt H.
I want to love this place because apparently so many other people do but I just can't because every time I go something else goes wrong....maybe I'm just cursed. I've had a panini several times and it never has been served hot like a panini should be. Even after asking for them to heat it extra long it still comes out luke warm at best. Not to mention that I get the ole eye roll when I ask for them to leave it on a little long. The flavors of the gelato are awesome but every time I've been it's more a less resembled soft serve ice cream and didn't look nice and thick like the picture Coty S. posted. Maybe I just happen to visit when there freezer thingy isn't working at full blast. Lastly and the cherry on top is the ole hair in the salad. The strawberry rainforest salad would have been great had I been able to get the mental image of the curly blonde hair out of my head. For the record I do not have blonde curly hair. Knowing that the staff rolls their eyes at me when I request a hot sandwich I didn't even bother letting them know. See you never.
(2)
Sniks L.
Gelato Company provides excellent service and remains one of my favorite breakfast/lunch restaurants; I recommend either the new egg breakfast sandwich or the Sweet and Smokey turkey sandwich. Their homemade gelato flavors also present a wonderful surprise to the end of a good meal. I hear they are opening one in the midtown area as well!
(4)
Justine B.
Their red velvet gelato is a little bit of heaven on earth! I only wish they had it available more often. Oh and go try their cheesesteaks on the weekend. I promise you will not regret it.
(4)
Mike W.
I've only had the gelato as dessert here, never tried anything for lunch so I cannot comment on that aspect of The Gelato Company at all. However, the gelato itself is very, very, good and the service was cheerful and prompt. One night I was there they had a young lady playing the house piano and she was churning out some pretty good Mozart and Bach which only added to the charm of the place. Their piano could benefit from tuning and also, as a grand it's a slight bit loud for the space. All and all, the mere thought of having a live pianist added much to the atmosphere. Gainesville would profit from more places for quality dessert: The Top is about the only place I can think of for pies and cakes and such that is worthwhile as a dessert destination alone if you've had dinner elsewhere. The Gelato Company is a nice addition to what we have going on downtown and I expect it to thrive.
(4)
David M.
A business trip brought me to Gainesville and I arrived a couple of hours early. That gave me the time to wander a bit and to enjoy a relaxed lunch. After passing by several chain restaurants, I was pleased to discover The Gelato Company which, according to the server behind the counter, was started by a couple of UF grads a few years ago. Always happy to support a local business, I took that as my cue to stay at The Gelato Company for lunch. Others have commented on the great value offered by The Gelato Company, and I echo that. I ordered a vegetarian panini (avocado, tomato, mozzarella and a homemade pesto). The sandwich was very good, although the flavors did not blend perfectly, primarily because the sauce was a bit too overpowering. It was still quite tasty nevertheless. The panini was served with a side salad which was ENORMOUS and dressed with a wonderfully flavorful dressing that I loved but cannot begin to describe (except to suggest that it was as if I were enjoying all of the good things in nature turned into a salad dressing!). The coffee chip gelato with which I capped my meal was both delicious and richly decadent. I can only hope that business brings me to Gainesville again soon!
(4)
Adam N.
Fresh, fresh, fresh! Great salads that are fresh and healthy. Incredible gelato options with many unique choices and all of them delicious. Plus they let you test out each type (which I studiously avoid doing out of principle. Be bold! Go for it! Your order isn't your last meal or last time there ya know). The staff are always friendly and gregarious. I love the brick wall lined sitting area or the chance to sit outside and enjoy the downtown atmosphere (brick paved roads). This place is the tops. Oh, they also do specials regularly via FB or email list.
(4)
Syama K.
Such good gelato.. they change their flavors often and so far I haven't had anything there I didn't like! Definitely worth it!
(5)
Vicki M.
Yummy! I have ALWAYS got the Very Berry Turkey, with salad (there homemade dressing) and chicken salad. It's always the same and is so good. They change the flavor of gelato, so I have never been able to get the same kind twice, which is good and bad. I found a favorite, but probably won't have it again, but I always find something I like at least, so all is good....I have even turned my husband onto the very berry turkey when he has been coming here before me and always got something different.
(5)
Gigi A.
Amazing gelato, absolute delight. Food is mind blowing, and well the atmosphere. The atmosphere is french bistro meets new york. The people around are amazing as well. I love love love this place :) A lot. GO.
(5)
Christina L.
I used to come here for their special - a sandwich, drink, and gelato for under $10! Decent sandwiches. I'm oddly drawn to the chicken salad every time. Yummy gelato. It's pretty laid-back and chill, with a piano in the front. I've only seen a person play on it once, though. A good spot to grab lunch and catch up with friends.
(3)
Brooke B.
I eat here regularly, not anymore. I always get the same sandwich and ask for panini bread instead of regular. The sandwiches and paninis are the same price and in the past they have always obliged. Today I went in and asked and was told they were running low on paninis, I told the lady it's the only thing I eat there and I would pay extra for the bread. Still no. My friend offered to get a panini and just give me here bread and she would take regular. The lady still said no! She then proceeded to tell us we were being very difficult and she's the store manager and she said no. I probably would've picked another option had the manager not given us such attitude. As we walked out after deciding to not be treated with disrespect the manager continued to mumble things under her breath. I used to go there weekly, however sadly I will be picking panera.
(1)
Brent C.
Great late night philly cheese steaks. The restaurant is small but they have a nice patio to enjoy your treats.
(4)
Molly M.
I love this place. They have really good sandwiches (I get the sweet and smokey) and if you buy a drink with your food, a small gelato is free. How can you beat that. Service at lunch is fairly quick so I have plenty of time to sit and eat my meal while reading or just relaxing during lunch.
(5)
Spooky T.
Their croissants are GREAT, and they always have a gelato flavor to suit any palate.
(4)
Brea G.
Been here a couple of times. The paninnis are really pretty good (try the salmon). The little ball of tuna salad is ... odd .. but tasty. The real reason to go here is the gelato. Lots of yummy flavors. I've been here a few times and it seems they've turned down the cooler as the gelato was a bit hard last time I went there.
(3)
Gramley A.
One of our favorite places to go in town. Great selection and different every day. Worth a try if you are in the area
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : Yes Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Lunch, Dessert Parking : Garage, Street Bike Parking : Yes Wheelchair Accessible : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : Yes Attire : Casual Ambience : Casual Noise Level : Average Alcohol : No Outdoor Seating : Yes Wi-Fi : Free Has TV : No Dogs Allowed : Yes Waiter Service : No Caters : Yes
The immense popularity of Italian cuisine globally isn't unknown. You can find an Italian Pizzeria around every corner of almost every city in the United States. Not to forget that in every house, people enjoy mac and cheese as comfort food. But it would be wrong to believe that Italian food starts with pizza and ends with good pasta as this Mediterranean country has much more to offer other than these two dishes. In Italian Cuisine, there is a high use of fresh tomatoes, all kinds of herbs, great quality of cheese, all types of meat, seafood and fresh handmade pasta. Many find it hard to believe that Italians have been making noodles long back.
Italian and Greek cuisines are always mistaken to be same, but they are poles apart. The primary difference between the two cuisines is the use of cheese in most of the Italian dishes. Italians love to cultivate their own cheese and process them as per their food requirement. It is believed that some cheese is so expensive that cheese producers secure them in lockers.
If you are bored eating the same old pasta or pizza, you can try some of the authentic Italian dishes like Risotto, Polenta, Ribollita, Lasagna, Fiorentina Steak, Bottarga, Ossobuco, Carbonara, Focaccia, Arancini and Supplì. Another item which Italians love to relish every morning is a good cup of Italian Coffee. Once you taste a freshly brewed cup of Italian Coffee, you might not visit Starbucks ever again. Authentic Italian food is made with heart and soul, so go find a restaurant where you can relish Italian cuisine in your city.
Alan W.
Chicken salad sandwich is bae!!!! Mandarin orange salad with honey vinaigrette is pretty decent. You must must must try the house dressing, HOLY SMOKES!!!!!! Seriously, I could see coming back to this place again and again and again. The workers were fun and super quirky. The hipster customers make me feel like I've entered a new dimension. What a fascinating culture at The Gelato Co! Dinner and a show, what could be better!?!?!?
(5)Alayna D.
Atmosphere Quaint and cute local Gainesville gelato and lunch spot for great sandwiches and salads. Seriously, don't go just for the gelato - albeit well worth the trip alone just for the sweet treat - the food is just as good! Rustic little hidden gem in downtown Gainesville. Save room after dining downtown and stop in for dessert here. A few tables inside and outside. Sometimes there's live music on the piano to add to the quaintness feel which I love. Service I don't frequent the place, but when I go I'm usually greeted with happy staff who offer as many samplings of gelato until my taste buds find the right one which I'm thankful for. Friendly people and always with smiles the times I've gone. Food/Gelato As I said, the sandwiches and salads are just as good as the gelato. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because I do wish there was a way to know ahead of time which gelatos they had featured each day somehow online so I knew when to stop in for my favorites, but I tend to find at least a few I like each time I go so no complaints. Like I said, you can sample the gelatos to your hearts content, too! The salads and sandwiches are plentiful and FRESH - love them! TIP: You can get more than one gelato flavor in your cup; don't be shy! Be daring and mix it up with multiple flavors guys and gals. :) Why I'd go back...whether a big salad or great sandwich on yummy toasted bread or after dinner cup of creamy gelato, my reasons to return are abundant! Stay dreamy, Gelato Company!
(4)Honest R.
This review is based solely on their gelato. Yes, the servings are small and the prices are high per oz BUT the gelato has a unique texture and flavor to justify it. I recommend the lime or raspberry flavors. The place is small and has a new-age European feel to it; it has character. Perfect place to stop by dessert with your significant other and eat it outside on the tables out front.
(5)Coty S.
Great location, but no parking. I hope they get tons of dessert businesses from all of the restaurants in the area. They could get more of a late night crowd if they were open until after the clubs let out on the weekends, but they might want to avoid the hassle. The people that work here are extremely nice. They do not have that many interesting flavors to choose from. I came hoping for some of the stranger flavors listed on their website- honeydew, watermelon, cantaloupe, amaretto, or chai tea, . They don't have a problem with letting you taste a ton of flavors before making a decision. And, they are willing to pack more than 5 flavors in a small serving. I really liked the Bittersweet Chocolate flavor, it is nice to have chocolate that is not super sweet. It is great to see so many local ice cream shops opening in the area.
(3)Chelsea B.
Although I've been to the Gelato Co. several times before, I've always resisted writing a review. I'm not a huge fan of Gelato (I go when I'm with friends--everyone else seems to love gelato, except me!), so I always thought it would be a little unfair. But I recently tried the food and need to share my disappointing meal. The sandwich I ordered sounded promising (Very Berry Turkey: Turkey with dried cranberries, Swiss cheese, and tomato with honey mustard mayonnaise) but when it arrived I could tell something was way off.... -The turkey looked and tasted like Oscar Mayer sandwich meat (or rubber). -The swiss cheese looked and tasted like white movie theater nacho cheese (how do you ruin swiss cheese?!) -The sourdough bread looked and tasted like toasted Wonder Bread (that stuff is nasty....one aspect of my childhood I wish I could forget) Really, though, it was the soupy cheese that ruined what could have been a salvageable sandwich. I'm sure I will return, but it will be against my will. But come to think of it....now that I know how terrible the food is, the gelato doesn't seem so bad anymore.
(2)Stan R.
Went downhill. Used to have a diverse selection and now they dont. Also the last 2 times I was in there the gelato serving area looked really messy and I didnt even order anything.
(2)Michelle H.
A solid array of flavors that include some sorbettos that don't suck--hello banana. Their small cup is way bigger than most smalls I've ever seen, and you'll get that sweet cookie on top. I was super surprised to see that they a) were open super late [like 3:30am], b) had a huge food menu for being a "gelato company," and c) supposedly sold a killer cheese steak. Cheese steak and gelato don't seem as apparent as peas and carrots to me, but I think I could make it work.
(5)Adam N.
Fresh, fresh, fresh! Great salads that are fresh and healthy. Incredible gelato options with many unique choices and all of them delicious. Plus they let you test out each type (which I studiously avoid doing out of principle. Be bold! Go for it! Your order isn't your last meal or last time there ya know). The staff are always friendly and gregarious. I love the brick wall lined sitting area or the chance to sit outside and enjoy the downtown atmosphere (brick paved roads). This place is the tops. Oh, they also do specials regularly via FB or email list.
(4)Julie A.
So college chick took me to Cold Stone Creamery, being the chain dame she is. But I wanted to introduce her to the mother of all ice cream -- gelato! (Cue the Lizzie McGuire movie... wait.. nobody here knows what I'm talkin bout? Hahaha Nevermind youtube.com/watch?v=4KCn… at 8:45.) I can't remember the exact flavor now, but it was rich with flavor. I'm sure my son would enjoy it, too. =D
(4)Megan G.
Best lunch in Gainesville if you like a gourmet sandwich and great gelato. I'd go for a panini or the turkey and apple sandwich. Sooooo good!
(5)Robert P.
They have good sandwiches and great gelato. There are so many flavors of gelato and they change over time - so it keeps you coming back to see what they have available now. As of this writing their regular special is buy an entree & drink and get a free gelato. Usually around $10.
(4)Sniks L.
Gelato Company provides excellent service and remains one of my favorite breakfast/lunch restaurants; I recommend either the new egg breakfast sandwich or the Sweet and Smokey turkey sandwich. Their homemade gelato flavors also present a wonderful surprise to the end of a good meal. I hear they are opening one in the midtown area as well!
(4)Damien S.
Gimme that Jersey fat cheesesteak. Gimme a fountain drank. Gimme that gelato. Oh, it comes with a free small gelato? Hey girl hey. A glorious gamut of gourmet sandwiches, but when the owner says "You've got to try the Fat Cheesesteak," well sir, I listen. Not quite the whiz wit, and regional in its own right, this sloppy mess packs onions, peppers and mushrooms, is a caloric indulgence that's bound to end up (in part) on your withered dewlap. The half ($7.50) is fine for lunch, especially when you consider each sandwich comes with two sides. I was a little confused, however, as the Fatty allegedly came standard with Funyuns as a side (NJ Law), yet none were to be found, and the staffer at the register relayed the cheesesteak only comes with a single side. Methinks a mistake in communication? Add a self-serve soda or iced tea to the mix, and you'll get a small (and it's small) gelato on the house. Which you owe it to yourself to try - the salted caramel and pretzel in dark chocolate had a killer consistency and wasn't overly sweet. It's a solid $10 lunch with a sweet nightcap, and I'd assume hot messes like the Fat Cheesesteak bring in the after-hours crowds. *reads other reviews* Yep. Will definitely stop by again to dabble in something a bit healthier. But I won't be happy about it.
(4)James O.
I love sandwiches. I also love Gelato, not nearly as much as sandwiches..but you get the point. The Gelato Co. does both well. I had the raspberry turkey. Plenty of sauce, my only complaint was that they turkey was a little dry. But for the price and quality its hard to beat!
(4)Mel V.
Better coffee than Starbucks. Awesome atmosphere and flavorful breakfast sandwiches. The gelato flavors are creative and taste so good.
(5)Jessica K.
Sweet lunch deal. Sandwiches come with two sides and if you add a drink you get gelato for free or a dollar or something. My vegetarian sammie had avo, cashews, dill havarti and other stuff on it and was totally good. Tomato soup was fine. Service was fine. Pretty varied menu including crepes, paninis and sandwiches. Choices for a pretty wide group and totally fair prices. Will be back. Interior is pretty sparse and basic. There's also a small patio with a few tables. Owner seemed down to earth and like the kind of small business owner you want to keep in business.
(3)Moni M.
So I've been a HUGE lover of Gelato Co for a while. Ever since I moved to Gainesville 3 years ago, I always looked forward to the delicious and carefully prepared sandwiches that they have. Every time I go there I get the same thing: Pollo Pesto panini with double sides of potato salad. And everytime when I take a bite out of that delicious buttery pressed bakery bread I smile and I am in heaven. You think by the above that I would be giving them a 5+ star rating, right? Gelato Co's food used to take me to a heavenly euphoria. I emphasize "used to." But the sad truth of it all is The Gelato Co is not the same. I went a few weeks ago and ordered my usual, and I literally could not bite into the sandwich. Someone had not known how to make a panini and forgotten butter or something because I could have knocked someone out with that sandwich. But to give them credit, the potato salad is always delicious and has this nice sweet taste that just melts in your mouth. Thankfully one of the owners were there and they personally made me another sandwich which was just like it used to be, Panini euphoria! I was ecstatic and went on my merry way. Now today I order The Gelato Co to go. Again same order. But to my dismay when I get home with my delicious lunch and come to find out that the panini is again dry, hard and not tasty. I added some of my own tomato since they had forgotten to put it on, but still it was not enjoyable. I ate for the sheer fact that I was already home and I was very hungry. But I know at least my double potato salad would be good and give me the happy vibes I was searching for. I took a bite and to my surprise it was SO SALTY and mustardy and none of the sweet delicious taste that I had come to love for 3 years. I was so disheartened and so this is why I am making a review. I wish I would have done a review when I first tried Gelato Co. But the sad truth is that I never felt the need since it was always so good. *sigh* So please owners of The Gelato Co. teach your new staff the care and perfection that you used when creating your artisan masterpieces. I hate to say it, but I don't know if I will ever go back to eat here since i have been burned twice and their food is not cheap. It's just sad how the quality of some things start to disintegrate with time.
(2)Kelly A.
My favorite lunch place in Gainesville! The most unique and tasty sandwiches. And of course the gelato is to die for. They always have a great variety of flavors. They let you sample before you pick your flavor out which is great. The staff is always very friendly. If it's a nice day, I recommend sitting outside. I highly recommend this place for lunch or a light dinner.
(5)Natalie B.
This place is my FAVORITE sandwich place in Gainesville. All of their sandwiches are delicious and come with delicious sides. And if you buy a drink with a meal, you get a free small gelato. Always good customer service, a small spot but never fails to be a delicious meal. Can't go wrong with a panini.
(5)Gaurav G.
Took my now girlfriend on our first date 6 years ago to this restaurant. We loved the gelato there and always the service. Cool place to visit when downtown. The food and the gelato are amazing. It such an awesome place that I proposed to my girlfriend there! The staff. Is amazing especially Leo whom help make the moment special. If you want to visit a classic ice cream place in Gainesville go to this restaurant you won't be disappointed!
(5)Ling S.
This is one of my FAVORITE sandwich/dessert places in Gainesville! Perfect for lunch or a quick dinner. It's a very small restaurant containing probably only 5 tables inside. On a nice day, eat outside on the patio tables. The staff is always very friendly. If you order a sandwich or panini for their special, it comes with a free small gelato. Which is more than enough, because their gelato is very rich! Delicious, but very rich. My favorite hot and fresh panini is the Pollo. Try their chicken salad! It's excellent with perfectly sweet red grapes. My boyfriend is in LOVE with their philly cheese steak sandwich. You really can't go wrong with anything that you order there. Downtown parking sucks for the restaurant. Be prepared to hunt and stalk down a parking spot on a busy night. One thing I really like about the Gelato Co. is that they do group fundraising. If your club or organizations needs to raise funds for a charity, host an event here! A portion of all the sales of the night will go towards your charity.
(4)Richard C.
This is one of the best places I've been to in Gainesville. The food is excellent, the atmosphere is nice and the employees are very welcoming. There was also live pianist playing!!!!!!!!
(5)Kelly S.
I really love this place! I've eaten here for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert. All amazing! Sometimes their food can be a little too salty, but the gelato is always spot on. I really like that the employees are nice and helpful and they let you try as many flavors as you like! I think this place is reasonably priced, has a decent interior, and I am always glad when I come here.
(5)Kaitlin H.
As I rolled up to Gelato Co tonight around 8, the live piano playing in the background, the sweet smell of gelato and promise of a hot panini in my future, the phrase that came to my mind was "classy as hell." The turkey panini was nice, the sides were decent. But the gelato. Oh, the gelato. One cannot comprehend the deliciousness of the gelato at this fine establishment. Smooth, rich, perfectly balanced in flavor... Holy crap it was good. I recommend getting two flavors (bittersweet chocolate is fantastic, especially combined with red velvet). Also, a note on the sizes of the gelato cups: they have empty small, medium, and large cups on display so you can decide which size you want to get. Don't be alarmed by how small they are. They really pile the gelato on! I was perfectly fine with a small. I'd much rather go here than Karma, and it's probably tied with Sweet Dreams in my book, and that's saying a lot. So please. Please please please. Go try the gelato.
(4)Amy S.
Mmmmmmmm. It seems that their small size cup is far bigger than any other small I've ever had before! You definitely get your money's worth and can easily share one with another person.
(5)Richard W.
Great place to go for lunch in Gville. Both the gelato and sandwiches are really good. I'd recommend the turkey and apple sandwich. It's very good. Downside to the place is that it's kinda small and only has a row of seating along the wall so it can be a bit cramped. But it's still good!
(4)Sara G.
I have a few things to say about this place. I've been here several times for the gelato and a few times for food. Generally speaking, its not worth it...but it's really the only ice cream option downtown except for Mochi (which really isn't my style) so it will remain regardless of how good it actually is. I'll start with the food...its pretty meh. The cheese steak is the best option IMO. Its NJ style and pretty tasty. However, it clearly made with pre-packaged mushrooms and onions. I asked for it with just peppers and mushrooms and was told that they can't do that b/c they come in a mix together. That kind of BS short cut irks me in restaurants - its not that hard to saute fresh mushrooms and onions, etc. A lot of the other sandwiches come on what looks like grocery store white bread pressed in a panini press...it tastes that way too. Their sides are also disgusting...ask for chips instead. As for the gelato, I think calling it gelato is a bit of a stretch. Its more like Coldstone than real gelato. The flavor options are mediocre at best. Sometimes there is a good one or two but more often than not the flavors are uncreative and forgettable. Also, the daily "deal" where you get a free gelato with the purchase of a sandwich and a drink is a ripoff. The sandwich alone is usually around $7...it's ~$10 for the deal but the drink is small (yes you get free refills) and soda only costs them about 10 cents but they charge 3$ for it...and the free gelato is served in a plastic sauce cup that you'd put ketchup in at a normal restaurant...its not even served in the small size gelato cup. To suggest that a soda and a scoop of gelato is worth $3 is absurd. Even so, I usually don't finish the gelato b/c its not that good. I went for 2 stars b/c of the absence of viable ice cream alternatives in the downtown area so I go here sometimes but you're better off to drive across town to Sweet Dreams as I more often do.
(2)Adam W.
We have ate here several times with our family. We think the meal deal is pretty good (sandwich, salad, chips, drink, sm gelato for under $10). The pressed sandwiches are very good with odd but good choices such as turkey and sour apple and ham and raspberry. The salads are good too. I'm a big eater and I am reasonably full after this meal. I'm not into gelato. It's not as good as my home town Ruggle's brand but I have found nothing wrong with it. No, there is no parking which is planned by the city, not any of the businesses downtown.
(4)Lauren O.
I enjoy the panini that are served here and the abundance of things that the lunch combo comes with makes me happy (I'm a grazer at heart). I got the vegetarian panini for lunch today and it's hard to say what I enjoyed more...the sandwich, the cup of tomato bisque, the little scoop of chicken salad (a dollop of protein?) or the small dish of 1/2 coconut and 1/2 pineapple gelato I got for free b/c I bought a drink with my meal. Not to mention the side salad which has the most delicious seasoned croutons and the best house dressing ever that I scarfed off my daughter's plate. The only reason I left off a star is because I've been turned off of some very inventive turkey sandwich creations due to their use of subpar slimy turkey cold cuts. I would gladly pay a little extra if they used a better turkey meat for their sandwiches.
(4)Stephanie R.
Never had a bad meal at the Gelato Company! It is definitely one of my favorite places in Gainesville. Their special is pretty much unbeatable; a sandwich, side salad, small scoop of chicken or tuna salad, a drink, and a small gelato for just under $10. Awesome deal. It's extra awesome because EVERYTHING is delicious. I usually get the raspberry turkey sandwich (can't remember the exact name), it comes hot and dripping with cheese. One time I made a "mistake" and ordered it with the Jalapeno cheddar bread...it ended up being AWESOME. The sweet and the spice went perfectly together and now I order it every time. The side salad is fresh and has a creamy italian dressing on it, very tasty. Their chicken salad texture may weird some people out, but it is quite tasty. The gelato is made fresh in house everyday, so they always have new flavors. Don't be shy about asking to try a sample! It is, of course, also delicious (Oreo cheesecake ftw). Definitely a hidden gem. If you blink, you just might miss it :)
(5)Jocelyn R.
Love the Gelato company! I work in the downtown area, so its an excellent option for lunch. They have a great lunch special for about 7 dollars that includes a salad, sandwich, and drink. You have a couple of different options for your sandwich, but my favorite is the turkey and apple sandwich with a delish cream cheese spread on sourdough. I kind of hate salad, so I usually don't end up eating the salad, but I'm sure its acceptable. The cafe itself is really cute, but the seating is limited, so I don't usually go there with groups (unless theres only 2 of us). They have a really nice outdoor area if its a pretty day though! The wait staff is really really nice and polite here. Their gelato is also very good, I'm just not a huge fan of sweets so I don't usually get it. But when I do, I try everything, and they're really nice about it. I can always find one that is delish. I would def recommend!!!
(5)Coleen T.
Tried the cheese steak late one night... still haven't tried the gelato, but the cheese steak was awesome! I loved the bell peppers in it, but I asked for no mushrooms... I'm only a fan of the 'special' kinds :) The atmosphere of the restaurant was really cute, and the fact that Sublime was playing over the speakers made the whole experience great.
(4)Lanise A.
Thumbs up for the gelato. It may be a small serving and pricey, but it is worth it if you're not in the mood for regular ice cream. However, I did not expect this place to be so small, and I'm cluster-phobic.
(4)Hana B.
The first time I stumbled upon Gelato Company was at midnight while roaming around the streets of downtown Gainesville. The location is very nice and I have since returned on days where it was the perfect amount of sunny and breezy to enjoy my meal outside. While this is a nice place to share a meal with friends because of the intimate atmosphere, the food is really nothing special. The sandwiches and paninis are reliable but there's nothing I've ordered here that has really stood out. That being said, the gelato that comes with the combo is a great way to end the meal. Despite being served in a small, plastic container, the scoops are generous and I have never been able to finish a small gelato by myself. Though I wouldn't go here specifically for the food, I'll probably end up back in here some midnight in the future craving some gelato.
(3)Kelly A.
Stopped in here for a light dinner the other night, and their sign didn't lie - it was indeed a good value! I had a vegetarian sandwich with avocados, tomatoes, and fresh mozz (came with jalapeno chips) and an iced tea, while the boy had a different type of vegetarian sandwich with salad and an iced tea; both came with free gelato at the end, and we still got out of there for under $20! The sandwiches were good, and the options for gelato were plentiful. I went for the cookie dough; he went for the amaretto. Both were good (though a little colder than I prefer). The service was really friendly. I don't know if that's a Florida thing or what, but it's hard to find such friendly service here in Boston. The girl at the counter even made conversation about the band on the shirt I was wearing. The hipster snobbery in Boston tends to prevent those types of conversations from occurring. So that was refreshing.
(4)Sasha P.
The Gelato Company is a very cute and cozy restaurant If the weather is nice, the outside seating area is a very good place to eat your meal, people watch, or chat with a friend. The inside is narrow and long. Enough for seating on the left side of the wall and the gelato-holding units to the right. They have different food combinations that are a mix of classic Tuna Sandwiches to your not-so-usual Avocado Sandwiches. I've had the Tuna Sandwich and it was actually pretty good. Not fishy like one usually thinks canned tuna tastes. It came alongside a mixed greens salad and potato soup. The potato soup was realllly good! Lastly, I will say that I enjoy gelato but the kind they make here is too rich for my taste. I can only have a sample of the hazelnut gelato before I feel overloaded on sugar and hazelnut flavor. Also, they don't offer coffee gelato which is my favorite but they do have several other assorted flavors. It's not crazy expensive in here but do plan on spending more than $8 for a meal. The Gelato Company is a nice place to eat but it doesn't stand out in my book. Nothing bad about it, don't get me wrong but it's just another place to eat for me.
(3)Nolan R.
I stopped in here to have some Gelato at the Gainesville Art Fest. I'm was impressed with how many flavors they offered. Some Gelato places tend to play it safe and make 10 flavors. These guys went all out. I bet there were close to 20. I got a medium with two flavors in it. Lemon & Fruit of the Forest....they were both terrific. I will definitely be back, I just haven't got around to G'ville's downtown lately.
(5)Justine B.
Their red velvet gelato is a little bit of heaven on earth! I only wish they had it available more often. Oh and go try their cheesesteaks on the weekend. I promise you will not regret it.
(4)Matt H.
I want to love this place because apparently so many other people do but I just can't because every time I go something else goes wrong....maybe I'm just cursed. I've had a panini several times and it never has been served hot like a panini should be. Even after asking for them to heat it extra long it still comes out luke warm at best. Not to mention that I get the ole eye roll when I ask for them to leave it on a little long. The flavors of the gelato are awesome but every time I've been it's more a less resembled soft serve ice cream and didn't look nice and thick like the picture Coty S. posted. Maybe I just happen to visit when there freezer thingy isn't working at full blast. Lastly and the cherry on top is the ole hair in the salad. The strawberry rainforest salad would have been great had I been able to get the mental image of the curly blonde hair out of my head. For the record I do not have blonde curly hair. Knowing that the staff rolls their eyes at me when I request a hot sandwich I didn't even bother letting them know. See you never.
(2)Mike W.
I've only had the gelato as dessert here, never tried anything for lunch so I cannot comment on that aspect of The Gelato Company at all. However, the gelato itself is very, very, good and the service was cheerful and prompt. One night I was there they had a young lady playing the house piano and she was churning out some pretty good Mozart and Bach which only added to the charm of the place. Their piano could benefit from tuning and also, as a grand it's a slight bit loud for the space. All and all, the mere thought of having a live pianist added much to the atmosphere. Gainesville would profit from more places for quality dessert: The Top is about the only place I can think of for pies and cakes and such that is worthwhile as a dessert destination alone if you've had dinner elsewhere. The Gelato Company is a nice addition to what we have going on downtown and I expect it to thrive.
(4)David M.
A business trip brought me to Gainesville and I arrived a couple of hours early. That gave me the time to wander a bit and to enjoy a relaxed lunch. After passing by several chain restaurants, I was pleased to discover The Gelato Company which, according to the server behind the counter, was started by a couple of UF grads a few years ago. Always happy to support a local business, I took that as my cue to stay at The Gelato Company for lunch. Others have commented on the great value offered by The Gelato Company, and I echo that. I ordered a vegetarian panini (avocado, tomato, mozzarella and a homemade pesto). The sandwich was very good, although the flavors did not blend perfectly, primarily because the sauce was a bit too overpowering. It was still quite tasty nevertheless. The panini was served with a side salad which was ENORMOUS and dressed with a wonderfully flavorful dressing that I loved but cannot begin to describe (except to suggest that it was as if I were enjoying all of the good things in nature turned into a salad dressing!). The coffee chip gelato with which I capped my meal was both delicious and richly decadent. I can only hope that business brings me to Gainesville again soon!
(4)Gigi A.
Amazing gelato, absolute delight. Food is mind blowing, and well the atmosphere. The atmosphere is french bistro meets new york. The people around are amazing as well. I love love love this place :) A lot. GO.
(5)Christina L.
I used to come here for their special - a sandwich, drink, and gelato for under $10! Decent sandwiches. I'm oddly drawn to the chicken salad every time. Yummy gelato. It's pretty laid-back and chill, with a piano in the front. I've only seen a person play on it once, though. A good spot to grab lunch and catch up with friends.
(3)Vicki M.
Yummy! I have ALWAYS got the Very Berry Turkey, with salad (there homemade dressing) and chicken salad. It's always the same and is so good. They change the flavor of gelato, so I have never been able to get the same kind twice, which is good and bad. I found a favorite, but probably won't have it again, but I always find something I like at least, so all is good....I have even turned my husband onto the very berry turkey when he has been coming here before me and always got something different.
(5)Brooke B.
I eat here regularly, not anymore. I always get the same sandwich and ask for panini bread instead of regular. The sandwiches and paninis are the same price and in the past they have always obliged. Today I went in and asked and was told they were running low on paninis, I told the lady it's the only thing I eat there and I would pay extra for the bread. Still no. My friend offered to get a panini and just give me here bread and she would take regular. The lady still said no! She then proceeded to tell us we were being very difficult and she's the store manager and she said no. I probably would've picked another option had the manager not given us such attitude. As we walked out after deciding to not be treated with disrespect the manager continued to mumble things under her breath. I used to go there weekly, however sadly I will be picking panera.
(1)Brent C.
Great late night philly cheese steaks. The restaurant is small but they have a nice patio to enjoy your treats.
(4)Molly M.
I love this place. They have really good sandwiches (I get the sweet and smokey) and if you buy a drink with your food, a small gelato is free. How can you beat that. Service at lunch is fairly quick so I have plenty of time to sit and eat my meal while reading or just relaxing during lunch.
(5)Spooky T.
Their croissants are GREAT, and they always have a gelato flavor to suit any palate.
(4)Brea G.
Been here a couple of times. The paninnis are really pretty good (try the salmon). The little ball of tuna salad is ... odd .. but tasty. The real reason to go here is the gelato. Lots of yummy flavors. I've been here a few times and it seems they've turned down the cooler as the gelato was a bit hard last time I went there.
(3)Gramley A.
One of our favorite places to go in town. Great selection and different every day. Worth a try if you are in the area
(5)Syama K.
Such good gelato.. they change their flavors often and so far I haven't had anything there I didn't like! Definitely worth it!
(5)April O.
This place is GOOD. How good? Good enough to make you eat very cold gelato when it's only 40 degrees outside. And as native Floridians know, 40 degrees is bordering on arctic misery. Of course, the gelato is the star of the show (and it should be), but don't overlook their insanely good paninis or their very tasty salads. I don't know how they manage to make such light and delicious mayonnaise-based tuna and chicken salads ... think they'd tell me if I begged for a recipe? The shop itself exudes "tiny loft" charm. I'm a sucker for exposed brickwork and baby grand pianos carefully wedged in tiny spaces. Come here when you just want to people-watch while slowly eating lunch. Very pretty staff, very pretty clientele. Guys in and around this store are abnormally hawt.
(5)Danny D.
I saw this girl I sorta know working there. It was awkward because I wasn't sure if I should acknowledge her or not. Their paninis are good.
(3)Paul D.
Amazing gelato, good sandwiches. If in Gainesville and craving ice cream I rank it better than Hagan-Dazs, Ben and Jerry and Cold-Stone Creamery.
(4)Diana N.
Their crepes are soooooo yummy!! But it's a little pricey, but I am willing to pay since its the only place that I know of in Gainesville to get crepes. The guy at the register was a little rude to us, other than that, I'd definitely come back!
(4)James B.
A great local downtown spot to kick back and enjoy lunch. I love the exposed brick wall with the mildly artsy decor giving it a great downtown-vibe. The gelato is great here. I can be happy to recommend anyone to eat their gelato. Fresh, bursting in flavor, affordable, and delicious! They also have sorbettos and other desserts. You can never come here bored because new flavors roll out almost daily. Feel free to mix 2 flavors in one cup! The paninis are delicious with their crunchy focaccia bread. Perfectly crunchy on the outside, soft inside and tasty all over. I love their salmone panini. Their salad is light and delicious; their dressing is not overwhelming. As gross as it may sound, their chicken or tuna salad is great too. All, with a small drink equals around $8-10 dollars...plus free gelato. Can't beat that! Highly recommended for those looking for a quick, relatively healthy, and light meal.
(4)Belle C.
4 stars because it's called The Gelato Company and the gelato is very good. It's a charming little place and the staff is friendly. I was less than impressed with my mozzarella/tomato/avocado panini. The bread was stale-ish, the mozzarella was not fresh, and I could barely taste the avocado. It came with a clump of "tuna salad" (looked like canned tuna and mayo) which seems like a really random side. I know, it's cheap, but I don't care how cheap the food is if it isn't good. I'll be back only for the gelato.
(4)Amanda D.
Was toddling around Gainesville with my BFFs the other day and had to stop in here. Parking was okay, but what took off stars right from the beginning is the way they have their order line set up. Its right next to peoples tables that theyre trying to eat at, and people have to walk back down the opposite way to get out of the line at the end. Being claustrophobic, that really did not set the mood. Onto the food. I got the Americano panini with "chicken salad" and creamy potato soup. The panini was good, very cheesy, but didnt really have any texture. There was no crunch or bite to it. The chicken salad is just too weird. Its a uniform texture and color, more like the appearance of a scoop of shredded cat food. The potato soup was pretty decent. A bit gritty in texture, but not too bad. Thought it was odd and rather wasteful for them to use Styrofoam cuts and plastic wear to serve the food. The only saving grace is the gelato. The peanutbutter was to die for, and the chocolate pudding was in the awesome area. Other sandwich and crepe options look promising, and Im willing to try something twice so Id probably come back again but probably only for dessert.
(3)Maggie P.
Great place! Amazing gelato! Open late. The cookies and sandwiches are also delicious!
(5)Laura M.
This place is awesome. They're open late, they have a totally relaxed atmosphere, the snacks and drinks are good, and oh yeah, GELATO. My best friend spent a semester in Rome and says this stuff is as good as what you get in Italy. She brought me here and we indulged. The staff will let you mix multiple flavors in one serving, and they pile on the gelato as high as it'll go in your little dish. Plus, you get a hazelnut cookie to dip in it. We went around 11:30 on a weeknight in December and they were out of almost every flavor, though. I mean, yes, it was the end of the day, but if you're going to stay open late (which rules), then make sure you can cater to the customers who come in at that time. I'm sure we could've gotten coffee or wine and been all set, but they're not called the Coffee or Wine Company. So, down one star.
(4)Y Y.
I actually went to this place based on some of the great reviews some fo the other yelp users left. What a great decision that was! I tried the gelato and absolutely loved it. When I was in Italy I ate gelato every single day and it really reminded me of gelato in Italy.
(5)Heather S.
Oh! My! Gawd! It's a beautiful thing when a pregnant lady meets gorgeous waves of delicious gelato on a hot summer day. I spent a month in Italy and have had my fair share of gelato - this place makes it fresh and authentically. I even learned something - gelato is never made with eggs - who knew? All of the desserts, cakes and pastries looked wonderful, but I only had eyes for stracciatella. They do have a pretty extensive sandwich and salad menu, and the tiny interior is cozy and tastefully decorated - I'll definitely be back! Isn't this where Wolfgang's used to be?
(5)Mrs. H.
Ay, I'm ashamed to admit that I've been here quite a few times since it's opened, but after having gelato every night on our trip to Europe I've had a fever and the only cure is more gelato. Is it the exposed brick walls and cozy atmosphere that draw me in? Or is it the bad ass gelato? My favorite so far is pistachio, with every other flavor I've tried coming in second. I had the 3 in a medium tonight, a generous three flavors in one cup: Irish Cream, Pecan Shortbread and Death by Chocolate. The Stracciatella and Amaretto also good. The super friendly staff make it a plus. There's also cookies and cakes that look pretty darn good. And like everyone else, I'll have to remember to try the sandwiches and salads next time. This place is located between Harry's and Emiliano's, where Wolfgang's used to be. Wherever you have dinner, go downtown for a stroll and end your evening here. **UPDATE: I've had their paninis and they're the best darn paninis I've ever had. Seriously. They must have a really good panini iron because the bread was crunchy inside and out and everything was nice and melted on the inside. My friend and I shared two sandwiches, one was the Focoso which was stuffed with salami, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and oregano on focacio bread, and the other was the Americano which had turkey, roasted red peppers, portabella mushrooms, dijon mustard and homemade horseradish sauce on focacio bread. Both came with chips, a side of chicken salad, a drink and a small gelato for under $10. It's a real, real good deal. They really took sandwich art in Gainesville to the next level. ***UPDATE: My people hear me: I've had the salads and they are good. I pity the fool that don't come here.
(5)Heather S.
The Gelato Company is where "dinner" used to be before they moved west. They have very fresh gelato, comparable to what you'd enjoy in Italy. I enjoyed the special, which included a sandwich, a tuna salad, a small gelato and drink. Cozy atmosphere. I hope they make it.
(4)Logan f.
Great gelato. I got the gelato/sandwich/drink deal combo thingy and it was amazing. Sandwiches are great and it ends with great gelato. Everytime I have gone their staff has been friendly and cute. There was some guy playing the piano that was amazing. The only downside.......get a location with more parking.
(5)Joshua N.
I can't believe that Gainesville now has two ice cream places that aren't corporate and damn tasty. Now if you're close to downtown and don't want to make the trip across town to sweet dreams you can sample some of the delicious gelato here. I had the chocolate and hazlenut gelatos and both of them hit the spot on a hot day. One warning, this place is kinda expensive. $3.45 for a small gelato seems kinda high to me. They also had some tasty sounding sandwiches and salads which I will try on my next trip.
(4)Brooke B.
I eat here regularly, not anymore. I always get the same sandwich and ask for panini bread instead of regular. The sandwiches and paninis are the same price and in the past they have always obliged. Today I went in and asked and was told they were running low on paninis, I told the lady it's the only thing I eat there and I would pay extra for the bread. Still no. My friend offered to get a panini and just give me here bread and she would take regular. The lady still said no! She then proceeded to tell us we were being very difficult and she's the store manager and she said no. I probably would've picked another option had the manager not given us such attitude. As we walked out after deciding to not be treated with disrespect the manager continued to mumble things under her breath. I used to go there weekly, however sadly I will be picking panera.
(1)Brent C.
Great late night philly cheese steaks. The restaurant is small but they have a nice patio to enjoy your treats.
(4)Molly M.
I love this place. They have really good sandwiches (I get the sweet and smokey) and if you buy a drink with your food, a small gelato is free. How can you beat that. Service at lunch is fairly quick so I have plenty of time to sit and eat my meal while reading or just relaxing during lunch.
(5)Spooky T.
Their croissants are GREAT, and they always have a gelato flavor to suit any palate.
(4)Brea G.
Been here a couple of times. The paninnis are really pretty good (try the salmon). The little ball of tuna salad is ... odd .. but tasty. The real reason to go here is the gelato. Lots of yummy flavors. I've been here a few times and it seems they've turned down the cooler as the gelato was a bit hard last time I went there.
(3)Gramley A.
One of our favorite places to go in town. Great selection and different every day. Worth a try if you are in the area
(5)Syama K.
Such good gelato.. they change their flavors often and so far I haven't had anything there I didn't like! Definitely worth it!
(5)April O.
This place is GOOD. How good? Good enough to make you eat very cold gelato when it's only 40 degrees outside. And as native Floridians know, 40 degrees is bordering on arctic misery. Of course, the gelato is the star of the show (and it should be), but don't overlook their insanely good paninis or their very tasty salads. I don't know how they manage to make such light and delicious mayonnaise-based tuna and chicken salads ... think they'd tell me if I begged for a recipe? The shop itself exudes "tiny loft" charm. I'm a sucker for exposed brickwork and baby grand pianos carefully wedged in tiny spaces. Come here when you just want to people-watch while slowly eating lunch. Very pretty staff, very pretty clientele. Guys in and around this store are abnormally hawt.
(5)Danny D.
I saw this girl I sorta know working there. It was awkward because I wasn't sure if I should acknowledge her or not. Their paninis are good.
(3)Paul D.
Amazing gelato, good sandwiches. If in Gainesville and craving ice cream I rank it better than Hagan-Dazs, Ben and Jerry and Cold-Stone Creamery.
(4)Diana N.
Their crepes are soooooo yummy!! But it's a little pricey, but I am willing to pay since its the only place that I know of in Gainesville to get crepes. The guy at the register was a little rude to us, other than that, I'd definitely come back!
(4)James B.
A great local downtown spot to kick back and enjoy lunch. I love the exposed brick wall with the mildly artsy decor giving it a great downtown-vibe. The gelato is great here. I can be happy to recommend anyone to eat their gelato. Fresh, bursting in flavor, affordable, and delicious! They also have sorbettos and other desserts. You can never come here bored because new flavors roll out almost daily. Feel free to mix 2 flavors in one cup! The paninis are delicious with their crunchy focaccia bread. Perfectly crunchy on the outside, soft inside and tasty all over. I love their salmone panini. Their salad is light and delicious; their dressing is not overwhelming. As gross as it may sound, their chicken or tuna salad is great too. All, with a small drink equals around $8-10 dollars...plus free gelato. Can't beat that! Highly recommended for those looking for a quick, relatively healthy, and light meal.
(4)Belle C.
4 stars because it's called The Gelato Company and the gelato is very good. It's a charming little place and the staff is friendly. I was less than impressed with my mozzarella/tomato/avocado panini. The bread was stale-ish, the mozzarella was not fresh, and I could barely taste the avocado. It came with a clump of "tuna salad" (looked like canned tuna and mayo) which seems like a really random side. I know, it's cheap, but I don't care how cheap the food is if it isn't good. I'll be back only for the gelato.
(4)Amanda D.
Was toddling around Gainesville with my BFFs the other day and had to stop in here. Parking was okay, but what took off stars right from the beginning is the way they have their order line set up. Its right next to peoples tables that theyre trying to eat at, and people have to walk back down the opposite way to get out of the line at the end. Being claustrophobic, that really did not set the mood. Onto the food. I got the Americano panini with "chicken salad" and creamy potato soup. The panini was good, very cheesy, but didnt really have any texture. There was no crunch or bite to it. The chicken salad is just too weird. Its a uniform texture and color, more like the appearance of a scoop of shredded cat food. The potato soup was pretty decent. A bit gritty in texture, but not too bad. Thought it was odd and rather wasteful for them to use Styrofoam cuts and plastic wear to serve the food. The only saving grace is the gelato. The peanutbutter was to die for, and the chocolate pudding was in the awesome area. Other sandwich and crepe options look promising, and Im willing to try something twice so Id probably come back again but probably only for dessert.
(3)Maggie P.
Great place! Amazing gelato! Open late. The cookies and sandwiches are also delicious!
(5)Laura M.
This place is awesome. They're open late, they have a totally relaxed atmosphere, the snacks and drinks are good, and oh yeah, GELATO. My best friend spent a semester in Rome and says this stuff is as good as what you get in Italy. She brought me here and we indulged. The staff will let you mix multiple flavors in one serving, and they pile on the gelato as high as it'll go in your little dish. Plus, you get a hazelnut cookie to dip in it. We went around 11:30 on a weeknight in December and they were out of almost every flavor, though. I mean, yes, it was the end of the day, but if you're going to stay open late (which rules), then make sure you can cater to the customers who come in at that time. I'm sure we could've gotten coffee or wine and been all set, but they're not called the Coffee or Wine Company. So, down one star.
(4)Y Y.
I actually went to this place based on some of the great reviews some fo the other yelp users left. What a great decision that was! I tried the gelato and absolutely loved it. When I was in Italy I ate gelato every single day and it really reminded me of gelato in Italy.
(5)Heather S.
Oh! My! Gawd! It's a beautiful thing when a pregnant lady meets gorgeous waves of delicious gelato on a hot summer day. I spent a month in Italy and have had my fair share of gelato - this place makes it fresh and authentically. I even learned something - gelato is never made with eggs - who knew? All of the desserts, cakes and pastries looked wonderful, but I only had eyes for stracciatella. They do have a pretty extensive sandwich and salad menu, and the tiny interior is cozy and tastefully decorated - I'll definitely be back! Isn't this where Wolfgang's used to be?
(5)Mrs. H.
Ay, I'm ashamed to admit that I've been here quite a few times since it's opened, but after having gelato every night on our trip to Europe I've had a fever and the only cure is more gelato. Is it the exposed brick walls and cozy atmosphere that draw me in? Or is it the bad ass gelato? My favorite so far is pistachio, with every other flavor I've tried coming in second. I had the 3 in a medium tonight, a generous three flavors in one cup: Irish Cream, Pecan Shortbread and Death by Chocolate. The Stracciatella and Amaretto also good. The super friendly staff make it a plus. There's also cookies and cakes that look pretty darn good. And like everyone else, I'll have to remember to try the sandwiches and salads next time. This place is located between Harry's and Emiliano's, where Wolfgang's used to be. Wherever you have dinner, go downtown for a stroll and end your evening here. **UPDATE: I've had their paninis and they're the best darn paninis I've ever had. Seriously. They must have a really good panini iron because the bread was crunchy inside and out and everything was nice and melted on the inside. My friend and I shared two sandwiches, one was the Focoso which was stuffed with salami, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and oregano on focacio bread, and the other was the Americano which had turkey, roasted red peppers, portabella mushrooms, dijon mustard and homemade horseradish sauce on focacio bread. Both came with chips, a side of chicken salad, a drink and a small gelato for under $10. It's a real, real good deal. They really took sandwich art in Gainesville to the next level. ***UPDATE: My people hear me: I've had the salads and they are good. I pity the fool that don't come here.
(5)Heather S.
The Gelato Company is where "dinner" used to be before they moved west. They have very fresh gelato, comparable to what you'd enjoy in Italy. I enjoyed the special, which included a sandwich, a tuna salad, a small gelato and drink. Cozy atmosphere. I hope they make it.
(4)Logan f.
Great gelato. I got the gelato/sandwich/drink deal combo thingy and it was amazing. Sandwiches are great and it ends with great gelato. Everytime I have gone their staff has been friendly and cute. There was some guy playing the piano that was amazing. The only downside.......get a location with more parking.
(5)Joshua N.
I can't believe that Gainesville now has two ice cream places that aren't corporate and damn tasty. Now if you're close to downtown and don't want to make the trip across town to sweet dreams you can sample some of the delicious gelato here. I had the chocolate and hazlenut gelatos and both of them hit the spot on a hot day. One warning, this place is kinda expensive. $3.45 for a small gelato seems kinda high to me. They also had some tasty sounding sandwiches and salads which I will try on my next trip.
(4)Julie A.
So college chick took me to Cold Stone Creamery, being the chain dame she is. But I wanted to introduce her to the mother of all ice cream -- gelato! (Cue the Lizzie McGuire movie... wait.. nobody here knows what I'm talkin bout? Hahaha Nevermind youtube.com/watch?v=4KCn… at 8:45.) I can't remember the exact flavor now, but it was rich with flavor. I'm sure my son would enjoy it, too. =D
(4)Alan W.
Chicken salad sandwich is bae!!!! Mandarin orange salad with honey vinaigrette is pretty decent. You must must must try the house dressing, HOLY SMOKES!!!!!! Seriously, I could see coming back to this place again and again and again. The workers were fun and super quirky. The hipster customers make me feel like I've entered a new dimension. What a fascinating culture at The Gelato Co! Dinner and a show, what could be better!?!?!?
(5)Gaurav G.
Took my now girlfriend on our first date 6 years ago to this restaurant. We loved the gelato there and always the service. Cool place to visit when downtown. The food and the gelato are amazing. It such an awesome place that I proposed to my girlfriend there! The staff. Is amazing especially Leo whom help make the moment special. If you want to visit a classic ice cream place in Gainesville go to this restaurant you won't be disappointed!
(5)Alayna D.
Atmosphere Quaint and cute local Gainesville gelato and lunch spot for great sandwiches and salads. Seriously, don't go just for the gelato - albeit well worth the trip alone just for the sweet treat - the food is just as good! Rustic little hidden gem in downtown Gainesville. Save room after dining downtown and stop in for dessert here. A few tables inside and outside. Sometimes there's live music on the piano to add to the quaintness feel which I love. Service I don't frequent the place, but when I go I'm usually greeted with happy staff who offer as many samplings of gelato until my taste buds find the right one which I'm thankful for. Friendly people and always with smiles the times I've gone. Food/Gelato As I said, the sandwiches and salads are just as good as the gelato. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because I do wish there was a way to know ahead of time which gelatos they had featured each day somehow online so I knew when to stop in for my favorites, but I tend to find at least a few I like each time I go so no complaints. Like I said, you can sample the gelatos to your hearts content, too! The salads and sandwiches are plentiful and FRESH - love them! TIP: You can get more than one gelato flavor in your cup; don't be shy! Be daring and mix it up with multiple flavors guys and gals. :) Why I'd go back...whether a big salad or great sandwich on yummy toasted bread or after dinner cup of creamy gelato, my reasons to return are abundant! Stay dreamy, Gelato Company!
(4)Damien S.
Gimme that Jersey fat cheesesteak. Gimme a fountain drank. Gimme that gelato. Oh, it comes with a free small gelato? Hey girl hey. A glorious gamut of gourmet sandwiches, but when the owner says "You've got to try the Fat Cheesesteak," well sir, I listen. Not quite the whiz wit, and regional in its own right, this sloppy mess packs onions, peppers and mushrooms, is a caloric indulgence that's bound to end up (in part) on your withered dewlap. The half ($7.50) is fine for lunch, especially when you consider each sandwich comes with two sides. I was a little confused, however, as the Fatty allegedly came standard with Funyuns as a side (NJ Law), yet none were to be found, and the staffer at the register relayed the cheesesteak only comes with a single side. Methinks a mistake in communication? Add a self-serve soda or iced tea to the mix, and you'll get a small (and it's small) gelato on the house. Which you owe it to yourself to try - the salted caramel and pretzel in dark chocolate had a killer consistency and wasn't overly sweet. It's a solid $10 lunch with a sweet nightcap, and I'd assume hot messes like the Fat Cheesesteak bring in the after-hours crowds. *reads other reviews* Yep. Will definitely stop by again to dabble in something a bit healthier. But I won't be happy about it.
(4)James O.
I love sandwiches. I also love Gelato, not nearly as much as sandwiches..but you get the point. The Gelato Co. does both well. I had the raspberry turkey. Plenty of sauce, my only complaint was that they turkey was a little dry. But for the price and quality its hard to beat!
(4)Mel V.
Better coffee than Starbucks. Awesome atmosphere and flavorful breakfast sandwiches. The gelato flavors are creative and taste so good.
(5)Ling S.
This is one of my FAVORITE sandwich/dessert places in Gainesville! Perfect for lunch or a quick dinner. It's a very small restaurant containing probably only 5 tables inside. On a nice day, eat outside on the patio tables. The staff is always very friendly. If you order a sandwich or panini for their special, it comes with a free small gelato. Which is more than enough, because their gelato is very rich! Delicious, but very rich. My favorite hot and fresh panini is the Pollo. Try their chicken salad! It's excellent with perfectly sweet red grapes. My boyfriend is in LOVE with their philly cheese steak sandwich. You really can't go wrong with anything that you order there. Downtown parking sucks for the restaurant. Be prepared to hunt and stalk down a parking spot on a busy night. One thing I really like about the Gelato Co. is that they do group fundraising. If your club or organizations needs to raise funds for a charity, host an event here! A portion of all the sales of the night will go towards your charity.
(4)Richard C.
This is one of the best places I've been to in Gainesville. The food is excellent, the atmosphere is nice and the employees are very welcoming. There was also live pianist playing!!!!!!!!
(5)Kelly S.
I really love this place! I've eaten here for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert. All amazing! Sometimes their food can be a little too salty, but the gelato is always spot on. I really like that the employees are nice and helpful and they let you try as many flavors as you like! I think this place is reasonably priced, has a decent interior, and I am always glad when I come here.
(5)Kaitlin H.
As I rolled up to Gelato Co tonight around 8, the live piano playing in the background, the sweet smell of gelato and promise of a hot panini in my future, the phrase that came to my mind was "classy as hell." The turkey panini was nice, the sides were decent. But the gelato. Oh, the gelato. One cannot comprehend the deliciousness of the gelato at this fine establishment. Smooth, rich, perfectly balanced in flavor... Holy crap it was good. I recommend getting two flavors (bittersweet chocolate is fantastic, especially combined with red velvet). Also, a note on the sizes of the gelato cups: they have empty small, medium, and large cups on display so you can decide which size you want to get. Don't be alarmed by how small they are. They really pile the gelato on! I was perfectly fine with a small. I'd much rather go here than Karma, and it's probably tied with Sweet Dreams in my book, and that's saying a lot. So please. Please please please. Go try the gelato.
(4)Amy S.
Mmmmmmmm. It seems that their small size cup is far bigger than any other small I've ever had before! You definitely get your money's worth and can easily share one with another person.
(5)Honest R.
This review is based solely on their gelato. Yes, the servings are small and the prices are high per oz BUT the gelato has a unique texture and flavor to justify it. I recommend the lime or raspberry flavors. The place is small and has a new-age European feel to it; it has character. Perfect place to stop by dessert with your significant other and eat it outside on the tables out front.
(5)Coty S.
Great location, but no parking. I hope they get tons of dessert businesses from all of the restaurants in the area. They could get more of a late night crowd if they were open until after the clubs let out on the weekends, but they might want to avoid the hassle. The people that work here are extremely nice. They do not have that many interesting flavors to choose from. I came hoping for some of the stranger flavors listed on their website- honeydew, watermelon, cantaloupe, amaretto, or chai tea, . They don't have a problem with letting you taste a ton of flavors before making a decision. And, they are willing to pack more than 5 flavors in a small serving. I really liked the Bittersweet Chocolate flavor, it is nice to have chocolate that is not super sweet. It is great to see so many local ice cream shops opening in the area.
(3)Chelsea B.
Although I've been to the Gelato Co. several times before, I've always resisted writing a review. I'm not a huge fan of Gelato (I go when I'm with friends--everyone else seems to love gelato, except me!), so I always thought it would be a little unfair. But I recently tried the food and need to share my disappointing meal. The sandwich I ordered sounded promising (Very Berry Turkey: Turkey with dried cranberries, Swiss cheese, and tomato with honey mustard mayonnaise) but when it arrived I could tell something was way off.... -The turkey looked and tasted like Oscar Mayer sandwich meat (or rubber). -The swiss cheese looked and tasted like white movie theater nacho cheese (how do you ruin swiss cheese?!) -The sourdough bread looked and tasted like toasted Wonder Bread (that stuff is nasty....one aspect of my childhood I wish I could forget) Really, though, it was the soupy cheese that ruined what could have been a salvageable sandwich. I'm sure I will return, but it will be against my will. But come to think of it....now that I know how terrible the food is, the gelato doesn't seem so bad anymore.
(2)Stan R.
Went downhill. Used to have a diverse selection and now they dont. Also the last 2 times I was in there the gelato serving area looked really messy and I didnt even order anything.
(2)Michelle H.
A solid array of flavors that include some sorbettos that don't suck--hello banana. Their small cup is way bigger than most smalls I've ever seen, and you'll get that sweet cookie on top. I was super surprised to see that they a) were open super late [like 3:30am], b) had a huge food menu for being a "gelato company," and c) supposedly sold a killer cheese steak. Cheese steak and gelato don't seem as apparent as peas and carrots to me, but I think I could make it work.
(5)Richard W.
Great place to go for lunch in Gville. Both the gelato and sandwiches are really good. I'd recommend the turkey and apple sandwich. It's very good. Downside to the place is that it's kinda small and only has a row of seating along the wall so it can be a bit cramped. But it's still good!
(4)Sara G.
I have a few things to say about this place. I've been here several times for the gelato and a few times for food. Generally speaking, its not worth it...but it's really the only ice cream option downtown except for Mochi (which really isn't my style) so it will remain regardless of how good it actually is. I'll start with the food...its pretty meh. The cheese steak is the best option IMO. Its NJ style and pretty tasty. However, it clearly made with pre-packaged mushrooms and onions. I asked for it with just peppers and mushrooms and was told that they can't do that b/c they come in a mix together. That kind of BS short cut irks me in restaurants - its not that hard to saute fresh mushrooms and onions, etc. A lot of the other sandwiches come on what looks like grocery store white bread pressed in a panini press...it tastes that way too. Their sides are also disgusting...ask for chips instead. As for the gelato, I think calling it gelato is a bit of a stretch. Its more like Coldstone than real gelato. The flavor options are mediocre at best. Sometimes there is a good one or two but more often than not the flavors are uncreative and forgettable. Also, the daily "deal" where you get a free gelato with the purchase of a sandwich and a drink is a ripoff. The sandwich alone is usually around $7...it's ~$10 for the deal but the drink is small (yes you get free refills) and soda only costs them about 10 cents but they charge 3$ for it...and the free gelato is served in a plastic sauce cup that you'd put ketchup in at a normal restaurant...its not even served in the small size gelato cup. To suggest that a soda and a scoop of gelato is worth $3 is absurd. Even so, I usually don't finish the gelato b/c its not that good. I went for 2 stars b/c of the absence of viable ice cream alternatives in the downtown area so I go here sometimes but you're better off to drive across town to Sweet Dreams as I more often do.
(2)Adam W.
We have ate here several times with our family. We think the meal deal is pretty good (sandwich, salad, chips, drink, sm gelato for under $10). The pressed sandwiches are very good with odd but good choices such as turkey and sour apple and ham and raspberry. The salads are good too. I'm a big eater and I am reasonably full after this meal. I'm not into gelato. It's not as good as my home town Ruggle's brand but I have found nothing wrong with it. No, there is no parking which is planned by the city, not any of the businesses downtown.
(4)Lauren O.
I enjoy the panini that are served here and the abundance of things that the lunch combo comes with makes me happy (I'm a grazer at heart). I got the vegetarian panini for lunch today and it's hard to say what I enjoyed more...the sandwich, the cup of tomato bisque, the little scoop of chicken salad (a dollop of protein?) or the small dish of 1/2 coconut and 1/2 pineapple gelato I got for free b/c I bought a drink with my meal. Not to mention the side salad which has the most delicious seasoned croutons and the best house dressing ever that I scarfed off my daughter's plate. The only reason I left off a star is because I've been turned off of some very inventive turkey sandwich creations due to their use of subpar slimy turkey cold cuts. I would gladly pay a little extra if they used a better turkey meat for their sandwiches.
(4)Jessica K.
Sweet lunch deal. Sandwiches come with two sides and if you add a drink you get gelato for free or a dollar or something. My vegetarian sammie had avo, cashews, dill havarti and other stuff on it and was totally good. Tomato soup was fine. Service was fine. Pretty varied menu including crepes, paninis and sandwiches. Choices for a pretty wide group and totally fair prices. Will be back. Interior is pretty sparse and basic. There's also a small patio with a few tables. Owner seemed down to earth and like the kind of small business owner you want to keep in business.
(3)Moni M.
So I've been a HUGE lover of Gelato Co for a while. Ever since I moved to Gainesville 3 years ago, I always looked forward to the delicious and carefully prepared sandwiches that they have. Every time I go there I get the same thing: Pollo Pesto panini with double sides of potato salad. And everytime when I take a bite out of that delicious buttery pressed bakery bread I smile and I am in heaven. You think by the above that I would be giving them a 5+ star rating, right? Gelato Co's food used to take me to a heavenly euphoria. I emphasize "used to." But the sad truth of it all is The Gelato Co is not the same. I went a few weeks ago and ordered my usual, and I literally could not bite into the sandwich. Someone had not known how to make a panini and forgotten butter or something because I could have knocked someone out with that sandwich. But to give them credit, the potato salad is always delicious and has this nice sweet taste that just melts in your mouth. Thankfully one of the owners were there and they personally made me another sandwich which was just like it used to be, Panini euphoria! I was ecstatic and went on my merry way. Now today I order The Gelato Co to go. Again same order. But to my dismay when I get home with my delicious lunch and come to find out that the panini is again dry, hard and not tasty. I added some of my own tomato since they had forgotten to put it on, but still it was not enjoyable. I ate for the sheer fact that I was already home and I was very hungry. But I know at least my double potato salad would be good and give me the happy vibes I was searching for. I took a bite and to my surprise it was SO SALTY and mustardy and none of the sweet delicious taste that I had come to love for 3 years. I was so disheartened and so this is why I am making a review. I wish I would have done a review when I first tried Gelato Co. But the sad truth is that I never felt the need since it was always so good. *sigh* So please owners of The Gelato Co. teach your new staff the care and perfection that you used when creating your artisan masterpieces. I hate to say it, but I don't know if I will ever go back to eat here since i have been burned twice and their food is not cheap. It's just sad how the quality of some things start to disintegrate with time.
(2)Kelly A.
My favorite lunch place in Gainesville! The most unique and tasty sandwiches. And of course the gelato is to die for. They always have a great variety of flavors. They let you sample before you pick your flavor out which is great. The staff is always very friendly. If it's a nice day, I recommend sitting outside. I highly recommend this place for lunch or a light dinner.
(5)Natalie B.
This place is my FAVORITE sandwich place in Gainesville. All of their sandwiches are delicious and come with delicious sides. And if you buy a drink with a meal, you get a free small gelato. Always good customer service, a small spot but never fails to be a delicious meal. Can't go wrong with a panini.
(5)Stephanie R.
Never had a bad meal at the Gelato Company! It is definitely one of my favorite places in Gainesville. Their special is pretty much unbeatable; a sandwich, side salad, small scoop of chicken or tuna salad, a drink, and a small gelato for just under $10. Awesome deal. It's extra awesome because EVERYTHING is delicious. I usually get the raspberry turkey sandwich (can't remember the exact name), it comes hot and dripping with cheese. One time I made a "mistake" and ordered it with the Jalapeno cheddar bread...it ended up being AWESOME. The sweet and the spice went perfectly together and now I order it every time. The side salad is fresh and has a creamy italian dressing on it, very tasty. Their chicken salad texture may weird some people out, but it is quite tasty. The gelato is made fresh in house everyday, so they always have new flavors. Don't be shy about asking to try a sample! It is, of course, also delicious (Oreo cheesecake ftw). Definitely a hidden gem. If you blink, you just might miss it :)
(5)Jocelyn R.
Love the Gelato company! I work in the downtown area, so its an excellent option for lunch. They have a great lunch special for about 7 dollars that includes a salad, sandwich, and drink. You have a couple of different options for your sandwich, but my favorite is the turkey and apple sandwich with a delish cream cheese spread on sourdough. I kind of hate salad, so I usually don't end up eating the salad, but I'm sure its acceptable. The cafe itself is really cute, but the seating is limited, so I don't usually go there with groups (unless theres only 2 of us). They have a really nice outdoor area if its a pretty day though! The wait staff is really really nice and polite here. Their gelato is also very good, I'm just not a huge fan of sweets so I don't usually get it. But when I do, I try everything, and they're really nice about it. I can always find one that is delish. I would def recommend!!!
(5)Coleen T.
Tried the cheese steak late one night... still haven't tried the gelato, but the cheese steak was awesome! I loved the bell peppers in it, but I asked for no mushrooms... I'm only a fan of the 'special' kinds :) The atmosphere of the restaurant was really cute, and the fact that Sublime was playing over the speakers made the whole experience great.
(4)Lanise A.
Thumbs up for the gelato. It may be a small serving and pricey, but it is worth it if you're not in the mood for regular ice cream. However, I did not expect this place to be so small, and I'm cluster-phobic.
(4)Megan G.
Best lunch in Gainesville if you like a gourmet sandwich and great gelato. I'd go for a panini or the turkey and apple sandwich. Sooooo good!
(5)Robert P.
They have good sandwiches and great gelato. There are so many flavors of gelato and they change over time - so it keeps you coming back to see what they have available now. As of this writing their regular special is buy an entree & drink and get a free gelato. Usually around $10.
(4)Hana B.
The first time I stumbled upon Gelato Company was at midnight while roaming around the streets of downtown Gainesville. The location is very nice and I have since returned on days where it was the perfect amount of sunny and breezy to enjoy my meal outside. While this is a nice place to share a meal with friends because of the intimate atmosphere, the food is really nothing special. The sandwiches and paninis are reliable but there's nothing I've ordered here that has really stood out. That being said, the gelato that comes with the combo is a great way to end the meal. Despite being served in a small, plastic container, the scoops are generous and I have never been able to finish a small gelato by myself. Though I wouldn't go here specifically for the food, I'll probably end up back in here some midnight in the future craving some gelato.
(3)Kelly A.
Stopped in here for a light dinner the other night, and their sign didn't lie - it was indeed a good value! I had a vegetarian sandwich with avocados, tomatoes, and fresh mozz (came with jalapeno chips) and an iced tea, while the boy had a different type of vegetarian sandwich with salad and an iced tea; both came with free gelato at the end, and we still got out of there for under $20! The sandwiches were good, and the options for gelato were plentiful. I went for the cookie dough; he went for the amaretto. Both were good (though a little colder than I prefer). The service was really friendly. I don't know if that's a Florida thing or what, but it's hard to find such friendly service here in Boston. The girl at the counter even made conversation about the band on the shirt I was wearing. The hipster snobbery in Boston tends to prevent those types of conversations from occurring. So that was refreshing.
(4)Sasha P.
The Gelato Company is a very cute and cozy restaurant If the weather is nice, the outside seating area is a very good place to eat your meal, people watch, or chat with a friend. The inside is narrow and long. Enough for seating on the left side of the wall and the gelato-holding units to the right. They have different food combinations that are a mix of classic Tuna Sandwiches to your not-so-usual Avocado Sandwiches. I've had the Tuna Sandwich and it was actually pretty good. Not fishy like one usually thinks canned tuna tastes. It came alongside a mixed greens salad and potato soup. The potato soup was realllly good! Lastly, I will say that I enjoy gelato but the kind they make here is too rich for my taste. I can only have a sample of the hazelnut gelato before I feel overloaded on sugar and hazelnut flavor. Also, they don't offer coffee gelato which is my favorite but they do have several other assorted flavors. It's not crazy expensive in here but do plan on spending more than $8 for a meal. The Gelato Company is a nice place to eat but it doesn't stand out in my book. Nothing bad about it, don't get me wrong but it's just another place to eat for me.
(3)Nolan R.
I stopped in here to have some Gelato at the Gainesville Art Fest. I'm was impressed with how many flavors they offered. Some Gelato places tend to play it safe and make 10 flavors. These guys went all out. I bet there were close to 20. I got a medium with two flavors in it. Lemon & Fruit of the Forest....they were both terrific. I will definitely be back, I just haven't got around to G'ville's downtown lately.
(5)Sniks L.
Gelato Company provides excellent service and remains one of my favorite breakfast/lunch restaurants; I recommend either the new egg breakfast sandwich or the Sweet and Smokey turkey sandwich. Their homemade gelato flavors also present a wonderful surprise to the end of a good meal. I hear they are opening one in the midtown area as well!
(4)Justine B.
Their red velvet gelato is a little bit of heaven on earth! I only wish they had it available more often. Oh and go try their cheesesteaks on the weekend. I promise you will not regret it.
(4)Matt H.
I want to love this place because apparently so many other people do but I just can't because every time I go something else goes wrong....maybe I'm just cursed. I've had a panini several times and it never has been served hot like a panini should be. Even after asking for them to heat it extra long it still comes out luke warm at best. Not to mention that I get the ole eye roll when I ask for them to leave it on a little long. The flavors of the gelato are awesome but every time I've been it's more a less resembled soft serve ice cream and didn't look nice and thick like the picture Coty S. posted. Maybe I just happen to visit when there freezer thingy isn't working at full blast. Lastly and the cherry on top is the ole hair in the salad. The strawberry rainforest salad would have been great had I been able to get the mental image of the curly blonde hair out of my head. For the record I do not have blonde curly hair. Knowing that the staff rolls their eyes at me when I request a hot sandwich I didn't even bother letting them know. See you never.
(2)Mike W.
I've only had the gelato as dessert here, never tried anything for lunch so I cannot comment on that aspect of The Gelato Company at all. However, the gelato itself is very, very, good and the service was cheerful and prompt. One night I was there they had a young lady playing the house piano and she was churning out some pretty good Mozart and Bach which only added to the charm of the place. Their piano could benefit from tuning and also, as a grand it's a slight bit loud for the space. All and all, the mere thought of having a live pianist added much to the atmosphere. Gainesville would profit from more places for quality dessert: The Top is about the only place I can think of for pies and cakes and such that is worthwhile as a dessert destination alone if you've had dinner elsewhere. The Gelato Company is a nice addition to what we have going on downtown and I expect it to thrive.
(4)David M.
A business trip brought me to Gainesville and I arrived a couple of hours early. That gave me the time to wander a bit and to enjoy a relaxed lunch. After passing by several chain restaurants, I was pleased to discover The Gelato Company which, according to the server behind the counter, was started by a couple of UF grads a few years ago. Always happy to support a local business, I took that as my cue to stay at The Gelato Company for lunch. Others have commented on the great value offered by The Gelato Company, and I echo that. I ordered a vegetarian panini (avocado, tomato, mozzarella and a homemade pesto). The sandwich was very good, although the flavors did not blend perfectly, primarily because the sauce was a bit too overpowering. It was still quite tasty nevertheless. The panini was served with a side salad which was ENORMOUS and dressed with a wonderfully flavorful dressing that I loved but cannot begin to describe (except to suggest that it was as if I were enjoying all of the good things in nature turned into a salad dressing!). The coffee chip gelato with which I capped my meal was both delicious and richly decadent. I can only hope that business brings me to Gainesville again soon!
(4)Vicki M.
Yummy! I have ALWAYS got the Very Berry Turkey, with salad (there homemade dressing) and chicken salad. It's always the same and is so good. They change the flavor of gelato, so I have never been able to get the same kind twice, which is good and bad. I found a favorite, but probably won't have it again, but I always find something I like at least, so all is good....I have even turned my husband onto the very berry turkey when he has been coming here before me and always got something different.
(5)Adam N.
Fresh, fresh, fresh! Great salads that are fresh and healthy. Incredible gelato options with many unique choices and all of them delicious. Plus they let you test out each type (which I studiously avoid doing out of principle. Be bold! Go for it! Your order isn't your last meal or last time there ya know). The staff are always friendly and gregarious. I love the brick wall lined sitting area or the chance to sit outside and enjoy the downtown atmosphere (brick paved roads). This place is the tops. Oh, they also do specials regularly via FB or email list.
(4)Gigi A.
Amazing gelato, absolute delight. Food is mind blowing, and well the atmosphere. The atmosphere is french bistro meets new york. The people around are amazing as well. I love love love this place :) A lot. GO.
(5)Christina L.
I used to come here for their special - a sandwich, drink, and gelato for under $10! Decent sandwiches. I'm oddly drawn to the chicken salad every time. Yummy gelato. It's pretty laid-back and chill, with a piano in the front. I've only seen a person play on it once, though. A good spot to grab lunch and catch up with friends.
(3)Alan W.
Chicken salad sandwich is bae!!!! Mandarin orange salad with honey vinaigrette is pretty decent. You must must must try the house dressing, HOLY SMOKES!!!!!! Seriously, I could see coming back to this place again and again and again. The workers were fun and super quirky. The hipster customers make me feel like I've entered a new dimension. What a fascinating culture at The Gelato Co! Dinner and a show, what could be better!?!?!?
(5)Alayna D.
Atmosphere Quaint and cute local Gainesville gelato and lunch spot for great sandwiches and salads. Seriously, don't go just for the gelato - albeit well worth the trip alone just for the sweet treat - the food is just as good! Rustic little hidden gem in downtown Gainesville. Save room after dining downtown and stop in for dessert here. A few tables inside and outside. Sometimes there's live music on the piano to add to the quaintness feel which I love. Service I don't frequent the place, but when I go I'm usually greeted with happy staff who offer as many samplings of gelato until my taste buds find the right one which I'm thankful for. Friendly people and always with smiles the times I've gone. Food/Gelato As I said, the sandwiches and salads are just as good as the gelato. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because I do wish there was a way to know ahead of time which gelatos they had featured each day somehow online so I knew when to stop in for my favorites, but I tend to find at least a few I like each time I go so no complaints. Like I said, you can sample the gelatos to your hearts content, too! The salads and sandwiches are plentiful and FRESH - love them! TIP: You can get more than one gelato flavor in your cup; don't be shy! Be daring and mix it up with multiple flavors guys and gals. :) Why I'd go back...whether a big salad or great sandwich on yummy toasted bread or after dinner cup of creamy gelato, my reasons to return are abundant! Stay dreamy, Gelato Company!
(4)Moni M.
So I've been a HUGE lover of Gelato Co for a while. Ever since I moved to Gainesville 3 years ago, I always looked forward to the delicious and carefully prepared sandwiches that they have. Every time I go there I get the same thing: Pollo Pesto panini with double sides of potato salad. And everytime when I take a bite out of that delicious buttery pressed bakery bread I smile and I am in heaven. You think by the above that I would be giving them a 5+ star rating, right? Gelato Co's food used to take me to a heavenly euphoria. I emphasize "used to." But the sad truth of it all is The Gelato Co is not the same. I went a few weeks ago and ordered my usual, and I literally could not bite into the sandwich. Someone had not known how to make a panini and forgotten butter or something because I could have knocked someone out with that sandwich. But to give them credit, the potato salad is always delicious and has this nice sweet taste that just melts in your mouth. Thankfully one of the owners were there and they personally made me another sandwich which was just like it used to be, Panini euphoria! I was ecstatic and went on my merry way. Now today I order The Gelato Co to go. Again same order. But to my dismay when I get home with my delicious lunch and come to find out that the panini is again dry, hard and not tasty. I added some of my own tomato since they had forgotten to put it on, but still it was not enjoyable. I ate for the sheer fact that I was already home and I was very hungry. But I know at least my double potato salad would be good and give me the happy vibes I was searching for. I took a bite and to my surprise it was SO SALTY and mustardy and none of the sweet delicious taste that I had come to love for 3 years. I was so disheartened and so this is why I am making a review. I wish I would have done a review when I first tried Gelato Co. But the sad truth is that I never felt the need since it was always so good. *sigh* So please owners of The Gelato Co. teach your new staff the care and perfection that you used when creating your artisan masterpieces. I hate to say it, but I don't know if I will ever go back to eat here since i have been burned twice and their food is not cheap. It's just sad how the quality of some things start to disintegrate with time.
(2)Kelly A.
My favorite lunch place in Gainesville! The most unique and tasty sandwiches. And of course the gelato is to die for. They always have a great variety of flavors. They let you sample before you pick your flavor out which is great. The staff is always very friendly. If it's a nice day, I recommend sitting outside. I highly recommend this place for lunch or a light dinner.
(5)Natalie B.
This place is my FAVORITE sandwich place in Gainesville. All of their sandwiches are delicious and come with delicious sides. And if you buy a drink with a meal, you get a free small gelato. Always good customer service, a small spot but never fails to be a delicious meal. Can't go wrong with a panini.
(5)Damien S.
Gimme that Jersey fat cheesesteak. Gimme a fountain drank. Gimme that gelato. Oh, it comes with a free small gelato? Hey girl hey. A glorious gamut of gourmet sandwiches, but when the owner says "You've got to try the Fat Cheesesteak," well sir, I listen. Not quite the whiz wit, and regional in its own right, this sloppy mess packs onions, peppers and mushrooms, is a caloric indulgence that's bound to end up (in part) on your withered dewlap. The half ($7.50) is fine for lunch, especially when you consider each sandwich comes with two sides. I was a little confused, however, as the Fatty allegedly came standard with Funyuns as a side (NJ Law), yet none were to be found, and the staffer at the register relayed the cheesesteak only comes with a single side. Methinks a mistake in communication? Add a self-serve soda or iced tea to the mix, and you'll get a small (and it's small) gelato on the house. Which you owe it to yourself to try - the salted caramel and pretzel in dark chocolate had a killer consistency and wasn't overly sweet. It's a solid $10 lunch with a sweet nightcap, and I'd assume hot messes like the Fat Cheesesteak bring in the after-hours crowds. *reads other reviews* Yep. Will definitely stop by again to dabble in something a bit healthier. But I won't be happy about it.
(4)James O.
I love sandwiches. I also love Gelato, not nearly as much as sandwiches..but you get the point. The Gelato Co. does both well. I had the raspberry turkey. Plenty of sauce, my only complaint was that they turkey was a little dry. But for the price and quality its hard to beat!
(4)Mel V.
Better coffee than Starbucks. Awesome atmosphere and flavorful breakfast sandwiches. The gelato flavors are creative and taste so good.
(5)Jessica K.
Sweet lunch deal. Sandwiches come with two sides and if you add a drink you get gelato for free or a dollar or something. My vegetarian sammie had avo, cashews, dill havarti and other stuff on it and was totally good. Tomato soup was fine. Service was fine. Pretty varied menu including crepes, paninis and sandwiches. Choices for a pretty wide group and totally fair prices. Will be back. Interior is pretty sparse and basic. There's also a small patio with a few tables. Owner seemed down to earth and like the kind of small business owner you want to keep in business.
(3)Gaurav G.
Took my now girlfriend on our first date 6 years ago to this restaurant. We loved the gelato there and always the service. Cool place to visit when downtown. The food and the gelato are amazing. It such an awesome place that I proposed to my girlfriend there! The staff. Is amazing especially Leo whom help make the moment special. If you want to visit a classic ice cream place in Gainesville go to this restaurant you won't be disappointed!
(5)Amanda D.
Was toddling around Gainesville with my BFFs the other day and had to stop in here. Parking was okay, but what took off stars right from the beginning is the way they have their order line set up. Its right next to peoples tables that theyre trying to eat at, and people have to walk back down the opposite way to get out of the line at the end. Being claustrophobic, that really did not set the mood. Onto the food. I got the Americano panini with "chicken salad" and creamy potato soup. The panini was good, very cheesy, but didnt really have any texture. There was no crunch or bite to it. The chicken salad is just too weird. Its a uniform texture and color, more like the appearance of a scoop of shredded cat food. The potato soup was pretty decent. A bit gritty in texture, but not too bad. Thought it was odd and rather wasteful for them to use Styrofoam cuts and plastic wear to serve the food. The only saving grace is the gelato. The peanutbutter was to die for, and the chocolate pudding was in the awesome area. Other sandwich and crepe options look promising, and Im willing to try something twice so Id probably come back again but probably only for dessert.
(3)Maggie P.
Great place! Amazing gelato! Open late. The cookies and sandwiches are also delicious!
(5)Laura M.
This place is awesome. They're open late, they have a totally relaxed atmosphere, the snacks and drinks are good, and oh yeah, GELATO. My best friend spent a semester in Rome and says this stuff is as good as what you get in Italy. She brought me here and we indulged. The staff will let you mix multiple flavors in one serving, and they pile on the gelato as high as it'll go in your little dish. Plus, you get a hazelnut cookie to dip in it. We went around 11:30 on a weeknight in December and they were out of almost every flavor, though. I mean, yes, it was the end of the day, but if you're going to stay open late (which rules), then make sure you can cater to the customers who come in at that time. I'm sure we could've gotten coffee or wine and been all set, but they're not called the Coffee or Wine Company. So, down one star.
(4)Y Y.
I actually went to this place based on some of the great reviews some fo the other yelp users left. What a great decision that was! I tried the gelato and absolutely loved it. When I was in Italy I ate gelato every single day and it really reminded me of gelato in Italy.
(5)Heather S.
Oh! My! Gawd! It's a beautiful thing when a pregnant lady meets gorgeous waves of delicious gelato on a hot summer day. I spent a month in Italy and have had my fair share of gelato - this place makes it fresh and authentically. I even learned something - gelato is never made with eggs - who knew? All of the desserts, cakes and pastries looked wonderful, but I only had eyes for stracciatella. They do have a pretty extensive sandwich and salad menu, and the tiny interior is cozy and tastefully decorated - I'll definitely be back! Isn't this where Wolfgang's used to be?
(5)Mrs. H.
Ay, I'm ashamed to admit that I've been here quite a few times since it's opened, but after having gelato every night on our trip to Europe I've had a fever and the only cure is more gelato. Is it the exposed brick walls and cozy atmosphere that draw me in? Or is it the bad ass gelato? My favorite so far is pistachio, with every other flavor I've tried coming in second. I had the 3 in a medium tonight, a generous three flavors in one cup: Irish Cream, Pecan Shortbread and Death by Chocolate. The Stracciatella and Amaretto also good. The super friendly staff make it a plus. There's also cookies and cakes that look pretty darn good. And like everyone else, I'll have to remember to try the sandwiches and salads next time. This place is located between Harry's and Emiliano's, where Wolfgang's used to be. Wherever you have dinner, go downtown for a stroll and end your evening here. **UPDATE: I've had their paninis and they're the best darn paninis I've ever had. Seriously. They must have a really good panini iron because the bread was crunchy inside and out and everything was nice and melted on the inside. My friend and I shared two sandwiches, one was the Focoso which was stuffed with salami, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and oregano on focacio bread, and the other was the Americano which had turkey, roasted red peppers, portabella mushrooms, dijon mustard and homemade horseradish sauce on focacio bread. Both came with chips, a side of chicken salad, a drink and a small gelato for under $10. It's a real, real good deal. They really took sandwich art in Gainesville to the next level. ***UPDATE: My people hear me: I've had the salads and they are good. I pity the fool that don't come here.
(5)Heather S.
The Gelato Company is where "dinner" used to be before they moved west. They have very fresh gelato, comparable to what you'd enjoy in Italy. I enjoyed the special, which included a sandwich, a tuna salad, a small gelato and drink. Cozy atmosphere. I hope they make it.
(4)Logan f.
Great gelato. I got the gelato/sandwich/drink deal combo thingy and it was amazing. Sandwiches are great and it ends with great gelato. Everytime I have gone their staff has been friendly and cute. There was some guy playing the piano that was amazing. The only downside.......get a location with more parking.
(5)Joshua N.
I can't believe that Gainesville now has two ice cream places that aren't corporate and damn tasty. Now if you're close to downtown and don't want to make the trip across town to sweet dreams you can sample some of the delicious gelato here. I had the chocolate and hazlenut gelatos and both of them hit the spot on a hot day. One warning, this place is kinda expensive. $3.45 for a small gelato seems kinda high to me. They also had some tasty sounding sandwiches and salads which I will try on my next trip.
(4)April O.
This place is GOOD. How good? Good enough to make you eat very cold gelato when it's only 40 degrees outside. And as native Floridians know, 40 degrees is bordering on arctic misery. Of course, the gelato is the star of the show (and it should be), but don't overlook their insanely good paninis or their very tasty salads. I don't know how they manage to make such light and delicious mayonnaise-based tuna and chicken salads ... think they'd tell me if I begged for a recipe? The shop itself exudes "tiny loft" charm. I'm a sucker for exposed brickwork and baby grand pianos carefully wedged in tiny spaces. Come here when you just want to people-watch while slowly eating lunch. Very pretty staff, very pretty clientele. Guys in and around this store are abnormally hawt.
(5)Danny D.
I saw this girl I sorta know working there. It was awkward because I wasn't sure if I should acknowledge her or not. Their paninis are good.
(3)Paul D.
Amazing gelato, good sandwiches. If in Gainesville and craving ice cream I rank it better than Hagan-Dazs, Ben and Jerry and Cold-Stone Creamery.
(4)Diana N.
Their crepes are soooooo yummy!! But it's a little pricey, but I am willing to pay since its the only place that I know of in Gainesville to get crepes. The guy at the register was a little rude to us, other than that, I'd definitely come back!
(4)James B.
A great local downtown spot to kick back and enjoy lunch. I love the exposed brick wall with the mildly artsy decor giving it a great downtown-vibe. The gelato is great here. I can be happy to recommend anyone to eat their gelato. Fresh, bursting in flavor, affordable, and delicious! They also have sorbettos and other desserts. You can never come here bored because new flavors roll out almost daily. Feel free to mix 2 flavors in one cup! The paninis are delicious with their crunchy focaccia bread. Perfectly crunchy on the outside, soft inside and tasty all over. I love their salmone panini. Their salad is light and delicious; their dressing is not overwhelming. As gross as it may sound, their chicken or tuna salad is great too. All, with a small drink equals around $8-10 dollars...plus free gelato. Can't beat that! Highly recommended for those looking for a quick, relatively healthy, and light meal.
(4)Belle C.
4 stars because it's called The Gelato Company and the gelato is very good. It's a charming little place and the staff is friendly. I was less than impressed with my mozzarella/tomato/avocado panini. The bread was stale-ish, the mozzarella was not fresh, and I could barely taste the avocado. It came with a clump of "tuna salad" (looked like canned tuna and mayo) which seems like a really random side. I know, it's cheap, but I don't care how cheap the food is if it isn't good. I'll be back only for the gelato.
(4)Megan G.
Best lunch in Gainesville if you like a gourmet sandwich and great gelato. I'd go for a panini or the turkey and apple sandwich. Sooooo good!
(5)Ling S.
This is one of my FAVORITE sandwich/dessert places in Gainesville! Perfect for lunch or a quick dinner. It's a very small restaurant containing probably only 5 tables inside. On a nice day, eat outside on the patio tables. The staff is always very friendly. If you order a sandwich or panini for their special, it comes with a free small gelato. Which is more than enough, because their gelato is very rich! Delicious, but very rich. My favorite hot and fresh panini is the Pollo. Try their chicken salad! It's excellent with perfectly sweet red grapes. My boyfriend is in LOVE with their philly cheese steak sandwich. You really can't go wrong with anything that you order there. Downtown parking sucks for the restaurant. Be prepared to hunt and stalk down a parking spot on a busy night. One thing I really like about the Gelato Co. is that they do group fundraising. If your club or organizations needs to raise funds for a charity, host an event here! A portion of all the sales of the night will go towards your charity.
(4)Richard C.
This is one of the best places I've been to in Gainesville. The food is excellent, the atmosphere is nice and the employees are very welcoming. There was also live pianist playing!!!!!!!!
(5)Kelly S.
I really love this place! I've eaten here for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert. All amazing! Sometimes their food can be a little too salty, but the gelato is always spot on. I really like that the employees are nice and helpful and they let you try as many flavors as you like! I think this place is reasonably priced, has a decent interior, and I am always glad when I come here.
(5)Kaitlin H.
As I rolled up to Gelato Co tonight around 8, the live piano playing in the background, the sweet smell of gelato and promise of a hot panini in my future, the phrase that came to my mind was "classy as hell." The turkey panini was nice, the sides were decent. But the gelato. Oh, the gelato. One cannot comprehend the deliciousness of the gelato at this fine establishment. Smooth, rich, perfectly balanced in flavor... Holy crap it was good. I recommend getting two flavors (bittersweet chocolate is fantastic, especially combined with red velvet). Also, a note on the sizes of the gelato cups: they have empty small, medium, and large cups on display so you can decide which size you want to get. Don't be alarmed by how small they are. They really pile the gelato on! I was perfectly fine with a small. I'd much rather go here than Karma, and it's probably tied with Sweet Dreams in my book, and that's saying a lot. So please. Please please please. Go try the gelato.
(4)Amy S.
Mmmmmmmm. It seems that their small size cup is far bigger than any other small I've ever had before! You definitely get your money's worth and can easily share one with another person.
(5)Honest R.
This review is based solely on their gelato. Yes, the servings are small and the prices are high per oz BUT the gelato has a unique texture and flavor to justify it. I recommend the lime or raspberry flavors. The place is small and has a new-age European feel to it; it has character. Perfect place to stop by dessert with your significant other and eat it outside on the tables out front.
(5)Coty S.
Great location, but no parking. I hope they get tons of dessert businesses from all of the restaurants in the area. They could get more of a late night crowd if they were open until after the clubs let out on the weekends, but they might want to avoid the hassle. The people that work here are extremely nice. They do not have that many interesting flavors to choose from. I came hoping for some of the stranger flavors listed on their website- honeydew, watermelon, cantaloupe, amaretto, or chai tea, . They don't have a problem with letting you taste a ton of flavors before making a decision. And, they are willing to pack more than 5 flavors in a small serving. I really liked the Bittersweet Chocolate flavor, it is nice to have chocolate that is not super sweet. It is great to see so many local ice cream shops opening in the area.
(3)Robert P.
They have good sandwiches and great gelato. There are so many flavors of gelato and they change over time - so it keeps you coming back to see what they have available now. As of this writing their regular special is buy an entree & drink and get a free gelato. Usually around $10.
(4)Chelsea B.
Although I've been to the Gelato Co. several times before, I've always resisted writing a review. I'm not a huge fan of Gelato (I go when I'm with friends--everyone else seems to love gelato, except me!), so I always thought it would be a little unfair. But I recently tried the food and need to share my disappointing meal. The sandwich I ordered sounded promising (Very Berry Turkey: Turkey with dried cranberries, Swiss cheese, and tomato with honey mustard mayonnaise) but when it arrived I could tell something was way off.... -The turkey looked and tasted like Oscar Mayer sandwich meat (or rubber). -The swiss cheese looked and tasted like white movie theater nacho cheese (how do you ruin swiss cheese?!) -The sourdough bread looked and tasted like toasted Wonder Bread (that stuff is nasty....one aspect of my childhood I wish I could forget) Really, though, it was the soupy cheese that ruined what could have been a salvageable sandwich. I'm sure I will return, but it will be against my will. But come to think of it....now that I know how terrible the food is, the gelato doesn't seem so bad anymore.
(2)Stan R.
Went downhill. Used to have a diverse selection and now they dont. Also the last 2 times I was in there the gelato serving area looked really messy and I didnt even order anything.
(2)Michelle H.
A solid array of flavors that include some sorbettos that don't suck--hello banana. Their small cup is way bigger than most smalls I've ever seen, and you'll get that sweet cookie on top. I was super surprised to see that they a) were open super late [like 3:30am], b) had a huge food menu for being a "gelato company," and c) supposedly sold a killer cheese steak. Cheese steak and gelato don't seem as apparent as peas and carrots to me, but I think I could make it work.
(5)Richard W.
Great place to go for lunch in Gville. Both the gelato and sandwiches are really good. I'd recommend the turkey and apple sandwich. It's very good. Downside to the place is that it's kinda small and only has a row of seating along the wall so it can be a bit cramped. But it's still good!
(4)Sara G.
I have a few things to say about this place. I've been here several times for the gelato and a few times for food. Generally speaking, its not worth it...but it's really the only ice cream option downtown except for Mochi (which really isn't my style) so it will remain regardless of how good it actually is. I'll start with the food...its pretty meh. The cheese steak is the best option IMO. Its NJ style and pretty tasty. However, it clearly made with pre-packaged mushrooms and onions. I asked for it with just peppers and mushrooms and was told that they can't do that b/c they come in a mix together. That kind of BS short cut irks me in restaurants - its not that hard to saute fresh mushrooms and onions, etc. A lot of the other sandwiches come on what looks like grocery store white bread pressed in a panini press...it tastes that way too. Their sides are also disgusting...ask for chips instead. As for the gelato, I think calling it gelato is a bit of a stretch. Its more like Coldstone than real gelato. The flavor options are mediocre at best. Sometimes there is a good one or two but more often than not the flavors are uncreative and forgettable. Also, the daily "deal" where you get a free gelato with the purchase of a sandwich and a drink is a ripoff. The sandwich alone is usually around $7...it's ~$10 for the deal but the drink is small (yes you get free refills) and soda only costs them about 10 cents but they charge 3$ for it...and the free gelato is served in a plastic sauce cup that you'd put ketchup in at a normal restaurant...its not even served in the small size gelato cup. To suggest that a soda and a scoop of gelato is worth $3 is absurd. Even so, I usually don't finish the gelato b/c its not that good. I went for 2 stars b/c of the absence of viable ice cream alternatives in the downtown area so I go here sometimes but you're better off to drive across town to Sweet Dreams as I more often do.
(2)Adam W.
We have ate here several times with our family. We think the meal deal is pretty good (sandwich, salad, chips, drink, sm gelato for under $10). The pressed sandwiches are very good with odd but good choices such as turkey and sour apple and ham and raspberry. The salads are good too. I'm a big eater and I am reasonably full after this meal. I'm not into gelato. It's not as good as my home town Ruggle's brand but I have found nothing wrong with it. No, there is no parking which is planned by the city, not any of the businesses downtown.
(4)Lauren O.
I enjoy the panini that are served here and the abundance of things that the lunch combo comes with makes me happy (I'm a grazer at heart). I got the vegetarian panini for lunch today and it's hard to say what I enjoyed more...the sandwich, the cup of tomato bisque, the little scoop of chicken salad (a dollop of protein?) or the small dish of 1/2 coconut and 1/2 pineapple gelato I got for free b/c I bought a drink with my meal. Not to mention the side salad which has the most delicious seasoned croutons and the best house dressing ever that I scarfed off my daughter's plate. The only reason I left off a star is because I've been turned off of some very inventive turkey sandwich creations due to their use of subpar slimy turkey cold cuts. I would gladly pay a little extra if they used a better turkey meat for their sandwiches.
(4)Stephanie R.
Never had a bad meal at the Gelato Company! It is definitely one of my favorite places in Gainesville. Their special is pretty much unbeatable; a sandwich, side salad, small scoop of chicken or tuna salad, a drink, and a small gelato for just under $10. Awesome deal. It's extra awesome because EVERYTHING is delicious. I usually get the raspberry turkey sandwich (can't remember the exact name), it comes hot and dripping with cheese. One time I made a "mistake" and ordered it with the Jalapeno cheddar bread...it ended up being AWESOME. The sweet and the spice went perfectly together and now I order it every time. The side salad is fresh and has a creamy italian dressing on it, very tasty. Their chicken salad texture may weird some people out, but it is quite tasty. The gelato is made fresh in house everyday, so they always have new flavors. Don't be shy about asking to try a sample! It is, of course, also delicious (Oreo cheesecake ftw). Definitely a hidden gem. If you blink, you just might miss it :)
(5)Jocelyn R.
Love the Gelato company! I work in the downtown area, so its an excellent option for lunch. They have a great lunch special for about 7 dollars that includes a salad, sandwich, and drink. You have a couple of different options for your sandwich, but my favorite is the turkey and apple sandwich with a delish cream cheese spread on sourdough. I kind of hate salad, so I usually don't end up eating the salad, but I'm sure its acceptable. The cafe itself is really cute, but the seating is limited, so I don't usually go there with groups (unless theres only 2 of us). They have a really nice outdoor area if its a pretty day though! The wait staff is really really nice and polite here. Their gelato is also very good, I'm just not a huge fan of sweets so I don't usually get it. But when I do, I try everything, and they're really nice about it. I can always find one that is delish. I would def recommend!!!
(5)Coleen T.
Tried the cheese steak late one night... still haven't tried the gelato, but the cheese steak was awesome! I loved the bell peppers in it, but I asked for no mushrooms... I'm only a fan of the 'special' kinds :) The atmosphere of the restaurant was really cute, and the fact that Sublime was playing over the speakers made the whole experience great.
(4)Lanise A.
Thumbs up for the gelato. It may be a small serving and pricey, but it is worth it if you're not in the mood for regular ice cream. However, I did not expect this place to be so small, and I'm cluster-phobic.
(4)Julie A.
So college chick took me to Cold Stone Creamery, being the chain dame she is. But I wanted to introduce her to the mother of all ice cream -- gelato! (Cue the Lizzie McGuire movie... wait.. nobody here knows what I'm talkin bout? Hahaha Nevermind youtube.com/watch?v=4KCn… at 8:45.) I can't remember the exact flavor now, but it was rich with flavor. I'm sure my son would enjoy it, too. =D
(4)Hana B.
The first time I stumbled upon Gelato Company was at midnight while roaming around the streets of downtown Gainesville. The location is very nice and I have since returned on days where it was the perfect amount of sunny and breezy to enjoy my meal outside. While this is a nice place to share a meal with friends because of the intimate atmosphere, the food is really nothing special. The sandwiches and paninis are reliable but there's nothing I've ordered here that has really stood out. That being said, the gelato that comes with the combo is a great way to end the meal. Despite being served in a small, plastic container, the scoops are generous and I have never been able to finish a small gelato by myself. Though I wouldn't go here specifically for the food, I'll probably end up back in here some midnight in the future craving some gelato.
(3)Kelly A.
Stopped in here for a light dinner the other night, and their sign didn't lie - it was indeed a good value! I had a vegetarian sandwich with avocados, tomatoes, and fresh mozz (came with jalapeno chips) and an iced tea, while the boy had a different type of vegetarian sandwich with salad and an iced tea; both came with free gelato at the end, and we still got out of there for under $20! The sandwiches were good, and the options for gelato were plentiful. I went for the cookie dough; he went for the amaretto. Both were good (though a little colder than I prefer). The service was really friendly. I don't know if that's a Florida thing or what, but it's hard to find such friendly service here in Boston. The girl at the counter even made conversation about the band on the shirt I was wearing. The hipster snobbery in Boston tends to prevent those types of conversations from occurring. So that was refreshing.
(4)Sasha P.
The Gelato Company is a very cute and cozy restaurant If the weather is nice, the outside seating area is a very good place to eat your meal, people watch, or chat with a friend. The inside is narrow and long. Enough for seating on the left side of the wall and the gelato-holding units to the right. They have different food combinations that are a mix of classic Tuna Sandwiches to your not-so-usual Avocado Sandwiches. I've had the Tuna Sandwich and it was actually pretty good. Not fishy like one usually thinks canned tuna tastes. It came alongside a mixed greens salad and potato soup. The potato soup was realllly good! Lastly, I will say that I enjoy gelato but the kind they make here is too rich for my taste. I can only have a sample of the hazelnut gelato before I feel overloaded on sugar and hazelnut flavor. Also, they don't offer coffee gelato which is my favorite but they do have several other assorted flavors. It's not crazy expensive in here but do plan on spending more than $8 for a meal. The Gelato Company is a nice place to eat but it doesn't stand out in my book. Nothing bad about it, don't get me wrong but it's just another place to eat for me.
(3)Nolan R.
I stopped in here to have some Gelato at the Gainesville Art Fest. I'm was impressed with how many flavors they offered. Some Gelato places tend to play it safe and make 10 flavors. These guys went all out. I bet there were close to 20. I got a medium with two flavors in it. Lemon & Fruit of the Forest....they were both terrific. I will definitely be back, I just haven't got around to G'ville's downtown lately.
(5)Matt H.
I want to love this place because apparently so many other people do but I just can't because every time I go something else goes wrong....maybe I'm just cursed. I've had a panini several times and it never has been served hot like a panini should be. Even after asking for them to heat it extra long it still comes out luke warm at best. Not to mention that I get the ole eye roll when I ask for them to leave it on a little long. The flavors of the gelato are awesome but every time I've been it's more a less resembled soft serve ice cream and didn't look nice and thick like the picture Coty S. posted. Maybe I just happen to visit when there freezer thingy isn't working at full blast. Lastly and the cherry on top is the ole hair in the salad. The strawberry rainforest salad would have been great had I been able to get the mental image of the curly blonde hair out of my head. For the record I do not have blonde curly hair. Knowing that the staff rolls their eyes at me when I request a hot sandwich I didn't even bother letting them know. See you never.
(2)Sniks L.
Gelato Company provides excellent service and remains one of my favorite breakfast/lunch restaurants; I recommend either the new egg breakfast sandwich or the Sweet and Smokey turkey sandwich. Their homemade gelato flavors also present a wonderful surprise to the end of a good meal. I hear they are opening one in the midtown area as well!
(4)Justine B.
Their red velvet gelato is a little bit of heaven on earth! I only wish they had it available more often. Oh and go try their cheesesteaks on the weekend. I promise you will not regret it.
(4)Mike W.
I've only had the gelato as dessert here, never tried anything for lunch so I cannot comment on that aspect of The Gelato Company at all. However, the gelato itself is very, very, good and the service was cheerful and prompt. One night I was there they had a young lady playing the house piano and she was churning out some pretty good Mozart and Bach which only added to the charm of the place. Their piano could benefit from tuning and also, as a grand it's a slight bit loud for the space. All and all, the mere thought of having a live pianist added much to the atmosphere. Gainesville would profit from more places for quality dessert: The Top is about the only place I can think of for pies and cakes and such that is worthwhile as a dessert destination alone if you've had dinner elsewhere. The Gelato Company is a nice addition to what we have going on downtown and I expect it to thrive.
(4)David M.
A business trip brought me to Gainesville and I arrived a couple of hours early. That gave me the time to wander a bit and to enjoy a relaxed lunch. After passing by several chain restaurants, I was pleased to discover The Gelato Company which, according to the server behind the counter, was started by a couple of UF grads a few years ago. Always happy to support a local business, I took that as my cue to stay at The Gelato Company for lunch. Others have commented on the great value offered by The Gelato Company, and I echo that. I ordered a vegetarian panini (avocado, tomato, mozzarella and a homemade pesto). The sandwich was very good, although the flavors did not blend perfectly, primarily because the sauce was a bit too overpowering. It was still quite tasty nevertheless. The panini was served with a side salad which was ENORMOUS and dressed with a wonderfully flavorful dressing that I loved but cannot begin to describe (except to suggest that it was as if I were enjoying all of the good things in nature turned into a salad dressing!). The coffee chip gelato with which I capped my meal was both delicious and richly decadent. I can only hope that business brings me to Gainesville again soon!
(4)Adam N.
Fresh, fresh, fresh! Great salads that are fresh and healthy. Incredible gelato options with many unique choices and all of them delicious. Plus they let you test out each type (which I studiously avoid doing out of principle. Be bold! Go for it! Your order isn't your last meal or last time there ya know). The staff are always friendly and gregarious. I love the brick wall lined sitting area or the chance to sit outside and enjoy the downtown atmosphere (brick paved roads). This place is the tops. Oh, they also do specials regularly via FB or email list.
(4)Syama K.
Such good gelato.. they change their flavors often and so far I haven't had anything there I didn't like! Definitely worth it!
(5)Vicki M.
Yummy! I have ALWAYS got the Very Berry Turkey, with salad (there homemade dressing) and chicken salad. It's always the same and is so good. They change the flavor of gelato, so I have never been able to get the same kind twice, which is good and bad. I found a favorite, but probably won't have it again, but I always find something I like at least, so all is good....I have even turned my husband onto the very berry turkey when he has been coming here before me and always got something different.
(5)Gigi A.
Amazing gelato, absolute delight. Food is mind blowing, and well the atmosphere. The atmosphere is french bistro meets new york. The people around are amazing as well. I love love love this place :) A lot. GO.
(5)Christina L.
I used to come here for their special - a sandwich, drink, and gelato for under $10! Decent sandwiches. I'm oddly drawn to the chicken salad every time. Yummy gelato. It's pretty laid-back and chill, with a piano in the front. I've only seen a person play on it once, though. A good spot to grab lunch and catch up with friends.
(3)Brooke B.
I eat here regularly, not anymore. I always get the same sandwich and ask for panini bread instead of regular. The sandwiches and paninis are the same price and in the past they have always obliged. Today I went in and asked and was told they were running low on paninis, I told the lady it's the only thing I eat there and I would pay extra for the bread. Still no. My friend offered to get a panini and just give me here bread and she would take regular. The lady still said no! She then proceeded to tell us we were being very difficult and she's the store manager and she said no. I probably would've picked another option had the manager not given us such attitude. As we walked out after deciding to not be treated with disrespect the manager continued to mumble things under her breath. I used to go there weekly, however sadly I will be picking panera.
(1)Brent C.
Great late night philly cheese steaks. The restaurant is small but they have a nice patio to enjoy your treats.
(4)Molly M.
I love this place. They have really good sandwiches (I get the sweet and smokey) and if you buy a drink with your food, a small gelato is free. How can you beat that. Service at lunch is fairly quick so I have plenty of time to sit and eat my meal while reading or just relaxing during lunch.
(5)Spooky T.
Their croissants are GREAT, and they always have a gelato flavor to suit any palate.
(4)Brea G.
Been here a couple of times. The paninnis are really pretty good (try the salmon). The little ball of tuna salad is ... odd .. but tasty. The real reason to go here is the gelato. Lots of yummy flavors. I've been here a few times and it seems they've turned down the cooler as the gelato was a bit hard last time I went there.
(3)Gramley A.
One of our favorite places to go in town. Great selection and different every day. Worth a try if you are in the area
(5)