Nice Guys Pizza
1334 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral, FL, 33904
Nice Guys Pizza Menu
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.
Visit below restaurant in Cape Coral for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Cape Coral for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Cape Coral for healthy meals suggestion.
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
-
Address :
1334 Cape Coral Pkwy E
Cape Coral, FL, 33904 - Phone (239) 549-7542
- Website https://www.niceguyspizza.com/
- Click To Get Directions
Opening Hours
- Tue
Specialities
- Takes Reservations : No
Delivery : No
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Good For : Dessert
Parking : Street
Bike Parking : Yes
Good for Kids : No
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Hipster
Noise Level : Average
Good For Dancing : No
Alcohol : Beer & Wine Only
Happy Hour : Yes
Best Nights : Fri, Sat
Coat Check : No
Smoking : Outdoor Area/ Patio Only
Outdoor Seating : Yes
Wi-Fi : Free
Has TV : No
Waiter Service : Yes
Caters : No
Categories
Pizza
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES
Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online
Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.
John S.
The food was excellent. I had a margherita pizza, my girlfriend had a truffle shuffle and got hers with vegan cheese. Both were very, very good. We also had an order of french fries, which were awesome. Batter-dipped, and very tasty. We weren't drinking, but their beer list looks good, and was priced very fairly. It's a small joint, only 5 or 6 tables plus a bar. It's not a tourist-back-from-the-beach type place, and it's not a rent-a-clown-for-a-birthday-party place. Young people running the place, indie-rock on the stereo, posters and flyers on the walls. It's an atmosphere you don't find a lot of in SWFL and I'll definitely be back.
(5)Jeffrey C.
We ordered a Margarita Pizza for take out. Crust was incredible, cheese was loaded, skimpy amount of tomatoes very little basil (actually, I could not see any, it may have been dry) It was basically a fantastic "cheese pizza". My partner ordered the deep fried Oreo's and said they were "to die for"!
(3)Kristen V.
Amazing food and service, I've never left once disappointed. Only when there's no seats at the bar because there's so many people. But it's a good sign to see a small place doing fantastic!
(5)Mike P.
Just great pizza! Reminds me of all the local great pizza joints of my youth in New York & New England. Forget about all the chain junk. This is the real deal at affordable prices. Only word of caution is that this is a very small local bar and seating is limited. Nice folks but I'm not sure I would take grandkids for dine in. REAL HAPPY we found this place.
(5)Mike G.
Great pizza, great beer selection (drafts and bottles), good wings and salads, friendly young owner / operators, funky beat-up homemade atmosphere, no TVs, good indie music not too loud - I love this little place. I'm 60 but most of the clientele are younger. It is small, maybe 8 or 10 seats at the bar, half a dozen tables, mostly 2-tops, and a couple tables outside essentially in the parking lot.
(5)Andres A.
Excellent place!!!! The pizza was sooooo delicious!!!! I highly recommend it!!! If you are visiting (I live in Miami) you should definitely check this place. Friendly staff, cool looking place and great pizza!!!
(5)Chelsea C.
This place is awesome! The staff really loves beer and will recommend a beer for your taste, and the food!! Soooo delicious.. The garlic knots are to die for and the wings too!! Every time were go there is always a different or new beer to try. Glad there is finally a place like this in the cape. The ONLY reason i give this place a 4 is it is soooo small :/ doesn't stop me from coming but they should def expand! Especially with their growing business! Congrats guys!
(4)Terra A.
This was a radical change from other bar/restaurants I've visited in the area. The bar top has been modge-podged with beautiful almost nude women (they've been censored with flowers!) I loved it! There were good tunes, and friendly service. The space itself is that of a typical sized bar with approximately ten 2-4 top tables, as well as a couple outdoor tables. There was actual beer here! I was so surprised to find something other than your typical domestic brews that I forgot what i enjoy drinking! No worries, there was plenty to choose from and I decided on an abita wheat beer. as for food, I went with a hummus plate and pepperoni pizza. the hummus plate definitely serves more than one person! the hummus, topped with a red and green pepper jam, was a nice twist. It was sweet, but not overly so. the pizza: the crust was really the best part of the pizza. the other ingredients weren't particularly one thing or another. on a second trip, i'd get a white pizza, or an EVOO based pizza for sure. pizza is such a subjective food. i will not dock any stars, i'll just try a different pizza. In an area with little to no worthwhile restaurants, this is a MUST eat at, drink at establishment!.
(5)Darbi L.
Really yummy pizza and the male server/greeter/bartender was suuuuuuuper friendly and just nice to be served by! The female waitress who brought us our food was not as nice but could have been having a bad day. Fun atmosphere (cool to have a "hipster-y" place in the cape) and good food. I will definitely go back!
(4)John S.
Great pizza, decent wings and service, fantastic craft beer selection. Garlic knots were cheap, generous, & garlicy af. Truffle shuffle pizza is where it's at. 'Balls' hot wings could be hotter.. I wanna cry man! Judging by the atmosphere and theme, I was hoping the service be rude & arrogant (just for fun), but they were polite and kind.. (maybe cause I was with my mom.) Neat decor and idea. No TV, kinda family friendly, cute bartenders. Lots of little board games and food to try, I can see myself spending an afternoon here next time I'm home.
(5)Kyle S.
Great Beer. Great Food. Great service. Do yourself a favor and get the chicken parm. Pizzas are amazing too.
(5)Laura M.
The food was good but the only guy working here the night we went was not very nice to us at all
(2)Alexis P.
This place is cool! We pulled up and were very on edge about entering but I'm so glad we did. It is a real laid back hippie joint. Check out the bathroom when you go! Pizza was delish and very reasonably priced. Great beer selection.
(4)Jessica S.
Let's just say I will definitely hit this place up again. It might be my new hot spot. They are open until 1:30am during the week which is great. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, french fries, fried oreos and it came up to $30. Besides the price being so cheap, the food was hands down the best I've had in a while. I recommend it 100%.
(5)Aric B.
I can't say enough good this about this place. The pizza was fantastic, the wings as good and terrific craft beer selection. As well, the owner was very friendly and even help hook my sons and I up with things to do while on vacation. Try it out!
(5)Thelonious F.
In the sense that it serves a really good pizza and has the name Nice Guy's Pizza, this is a pizza joint. But it isn't. Not really. It's a bar that serves great food. Great food. All kinds of food. Exciting food. The people are friendly, the beer is cold and the atmosphere relaxed. There is a tinge of a punk ethos in the air. You should go. It reminds me of Yabo back when it was just a hole in the wall secret. GO.
(5)Maureen M.
Saw alot of great reviews so ordered takeout. Soggy crust-- mediocre quality. You know its not good when a group of guys throw out a whole left over pizza rather than save for breakfast. Very disappointing.
(2)K N.
Really wanted to love this place. Loved the atmosphere. Called in a pickup order, which I was quoted 15 minutes, and was ready right on time. Wasn't greeted for a little while after walking in. Got it home and man, it is the herbiest pizza ever. So. Many. Herbs. Could barely taste the cheese or crust. Holy herbs, Batman!
(3)Terin B.
I went for the first time today and I am so glad I did. Tried the American pizza, garlic knots, and deep fried Oreos. It was all delicious. Great service, food, and atmosphere. Can't wait to try out the rest of the menu. :-)
(5)Wendell B.
We hadn't had pizza for a couple of weeks, so my wife found this one on Yelp! First impression was that we should not go in--it's a tacky storefront and really small. But because of all the 5-star reviews, we decided to brave it now that we were there. There are 27 seats in the place--including the 12 or so seats at the bar. Moderate draft beer selection on the blackboard, and just about everything you can imagine in a bottle or a can. As we walked in, the heavily tattooed and long braided pigtailed bartender Jamie greeted us, and said to sit anywhere except the first table because she hadn't wiped that one down yet. Turned out that Jamie was almost a one-woman show all night. We didn't get there until 9:00, and it seemed that the dinner crowd help was leaving about the time we arrived, and she shared bartender duties with a bearded partner but took care of the serving all herself. Jamie is a good example of not judging a book by its cover: she was very friendly, warm, attentive and we enjoyed chatting with her when she had a moment, which she made time for in spite of being a solo most of the night. She took very good care of us and everyone in the small place. We ordered draft Hoegaartens, a familiar favorite white wheat brew. The pizza lived up to its reputation: we ordered the medium American, which included pepperoni, sausage, ham, black olives, onion, creminis (mushrooms--I had to look it up too ;-) and green peppers, and it was delicious and filling--we brought two slices home for lunch the next day. We also saw a Stiegl grapefruit beer on the menu--in fact, it just said "grapefruit beer" and Jamie did not know the brand name, but it turned out to be refreshing and delicious, and both of us ordered one, although my wife went back to our original Hoegaartens to wash down her last piece of pizza. Altogether a really fun night--the crowd was sitting around eating pizza, drinking beer and playing board games from Mancala to Connect Four, and there were lots of quirky things on the walls to look at and read. My wife visited the rest room and said the walls wer covered in sticky notes! Very much an individual kind of place that you probably would not frequent otherwise, but that everyone should experience at least once in their lives. Good choice for pizza and beer. Kitchen open until 1:30 a.m.!
(4)Jennifer M.
This pizza place is so fantastic that my husband and I would drive from Tampa to Ft. Myers just to have it. You must get their garlic knots!!!
(5)Mike U.
Phenomenal service selection and quality...not to mention atmosphere. Strongly recommend you visit when in town!
(5)Wolfgang D.
Wow what a great pizza place. Pizza is great, and a good beer selection. Staff is friendly, with music that would make anyone in their early 30s that had a fairly good knowledge of indie music would really cause them to have fond memories of their 20s. Glad this place opened in Cape Coral. Great good, great price, and great atmosphere.
(5)Joe N.
Ok so, full disclosure, I'm a regular here. I love this place. It's easily the best pizza in the area. Jovi and Greg who own the place are behind the bar every night, and they treat everyone that comes in like a friend. I used to have this place rated four stars because they didn't have beer and wine. That has changed. Craft beer, craft beer everywhere. The only mainstream brew they carry is bud light cans. It's a perfect restaurant if you want to have a good time in a laid back atmosphere with great music. Try it and you'll want to come back.
(5)Kim D.
Awesome staff, great atmosphere, incredible deserts. Everything is made by hand, down to the ketchup! The appetizers are awesome. Wonderfully comfortable atmosphere. Give this place a try!
(5)Vicky N.
I have to admit I was not expecting much. I hear over and over how each pizza place is as good as New York Pizza and I am always disappointed. While we have yet to dine in here, we get takeout about once a week from this place now as we LOVE the pizza! Margherita is my favorite but we love the cheese, meatball and other flavors we have tried. Salads are awesome as well with homemade dressings, and save room for dessert! This place is always trying new things and so far we have enjoyed every single bite! For the first time in 20 years I happily head SOUTH for pizza!
(5)Roger H.
You will not meet any restaurant owners who care more about their customers and the food they serve. Best pizza in town. Great selection of craft beer. Awesome place just to hang out and relax.
(5)Dan D.
best pizza place in the area hands down.
(5)Nick D.
A colleague and I visit the Ft. Myers area for business on a regular basis and we often stay with friends in Cape Coral. Nice Guys has become our go-to hang-out and dinner spot. They have wonderful food-try the garlic knots and roast beef with the zesty sauce, in particular. We've had the truffle pizza, cheese sticks, and chicken fingers, too--all amazing. Made to order, flavorful, and unique--what more could you ask for? Greg and Jovenah have always been incredibly accommodating and helpful, not to mention they're a lot of fun to hang out with. Prices are reasonable, and the draft beer and cider choices are incredible, especially for a place of its size. Oh, and their dessert is great, too! Try the fried oreos. Anyway, stop reading this and go eat there!
(5)Beth M.
Called in for a pick up. American was what was recommended. Great pie. Will be back.
(5)Angela S.
Never been disappointed with the quirky pizza choices. Washington Carver is a combo of apple smoked bacon with cheese, raspberry jam in peanut sauce. Deceptively delicious! The Hot Honey is not to be missed either. Salami and prosciutto with a hot honey sauce. Yummy! Great craft beer selection too. It's pretty small inside so get there early. People bring their kids but only early in the evening. It's not a place for them after dark. Very hipster but cool enough for us older folks. Good music but it's loud.
(5)Claudia V.
Beyond excellent food. Good beer and decent wine. (Ask a manager for wine paring recommendation.). Beyond hipster crowd. Bottom line- if ur not cool like me, either get take out or acquire a getup to fit in. Service is also nice too. Music was good, but I'm not hip, so the regulars probably dislike the tunes. (?). Zagat rating: 25 Food, 20 Atmosphere, 22 Service. Yelp rating: 5 * food, 3 * atmosphere, 4 * service. PS for the hipsters- bring QUARTERS for the video games in second room. (Uncool people have these quarter things in our cars for parking.). ;) Atari pacman
(5)Ab To The G.
The best pizza in Cape! Havent had a bad meal here yet. The garlic knots are soooo good. Every pizza we have tried (cuban, hot honey, wash carver, mushroom) were so good! They fill you up too because they are so loaded with yumminess. Great craft beer list. Service is super friendly. They really are nice here. I left my $400 sunglasses on the table after dinner and the manager held onto them for me to pick up the next day. We will take all of our visitors here its just that good! They also are always playing good music.
(5)Rob O.
Picked up a pie and garlic knots the other night. NICE SURPRISE!!! Got the Truffle Shuffle ....DELISH...I'm not a Garlic Knot expert but these were the best I ever had!! Suggestions? Get your pie and get out of there!! It's a BAR serving great Pie...I had to hold my Pie over my head to get out of there..lots of CC 20-30something's ... Staff was friendly and fixed me up Will be back
(5)Diana G.
Fantastic atmosphere and over the top service. I come here at least 2 times a month. D fried orris are delicious!!! Do not miss out on checking thus unique place out.
(5)Billy H.
I really wanted to love Nice Guys. We arrived into town after a 12 hour drive up from Nashville to stay at my parents place down here. We didn't want to mess with cooking or eating out somewhere so we decided on pizza. Pizza is probably one of my favorite food groups, if not favorite. We usually get pizza from Paradise Pizza, but we were looking to try something new, so we deciding on Nice Guys. We skimmed the menu & picked the 'carnivore' pizza, a medium for $15 & ordered a side of the cheese sticks. The girl on the phone was very short while taking our order on the phone, almost like it was a nuisance for taking a phone order. She told us it would be ready in about 30 minutes. We set off for Nice Guys about 25 minutes after ordering & arrived when it should be ready. It was a Friday night & the place was busy. The bartender said it would be a few minutes for the order & if we wanted a drink. A few minutes turned into about 25 minutes, nearly an hour after calling in the order. I'm not sure if they forgot about it or if they were just really busy. We got home & were so excited. We opened the cheese sticks & tried them. They were okay, tasted a little overdone. There were 5 sticks in the order for $7. Onto the pizza. It was nice sized for a medium, a nice amount of toppings, but nothing had any flavor. The crust tasted like bread & flour, the meat didn't have any seasoning. It as was very basic. Was it bad pizza, no. Was it great pizza, no. It was a just very mediocre. Like I said, I wanted to love this place, but after my first experience, I'll stick with my usual place.
(2)Tom S.
If you blink, you'd miss this place. We're big micro brew fans and this is the place to be. Food is great, people are great, beer is FANTASTIC- what else can you ask for? Only con is it's on the small side, so hard to take a large group.
(5)Dani P.
They now have 'stinky buns' which have pork, kimchi, cucumber, in a bun. I ordered some to go, and when I went back home to eat it, it was so delicious I contemplated texting my brother in the room next door to exclaim how good they were. It comes in a set of two. I could've eaten two more.
(5)Belinda S.
Wow. Garlic knots are a MUST. Food was fantastic and service was down right homey! This will become a regular haunt.
(5)Benny F.
Very good local hangout. If you blink you will miss it! The food was home cooked and fresh. The garlic knots is great appetizer and one the best garlic rolls I have had. We had the veggie pizza which was filled with fresh veggies and it the sauce and dough was perfect. However to finish the night, you must have the deep fried Oreos ! I promise you that you won't regret it!
(5)Linda M.
Been here once and am sold! Love the atmosphere and the food is above the other 5 stars I've given at other places! Touché!
(5)Janie T.
OH. MY. GOODNESS! This teeny, tiny little hole in the wall is FABULOUS! We visited this little gem on Sunday and absolutely could not get enough. We sat at a high top and were promptly greeted by a sweet and crazy little chick. She gave us opinions on the beers and shared her favorites. We ordered based off of her recommendations and were super glad that we did. There wasn't a beer we didn't like (my favorite was the Peach In Cider). Her partner in crime, a very chill and laid back fella, came over to take our order. He made some pizza suggestion but we already had it nailed down as to what we wanted to try...first was the Hot Honey Pizza, which is to die for!!! Second was the truffle shuffle (not even close to the Hot Honey). We gorged ourselves on pizza, beer and of course the Mexican Coke and left our new found treasure with full bellies and a hankering to come back as soon as we could. If you are looking for something different...THIS IS IT. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. Make sure to go in with an open mind, remember I said it is teeny tiny. Takeout may be the way to go if you don't like tight spots. We will be back!!!
(5)Scott H.
My wife and I are from the San Francisco Bay Area where you can go out to dinner at midnight on a Sunday night and still find a place to eat. Not so in Cape Coral / Ft. Myers, except for Nice Guys Pizza. And that they were, Nice Guys! The pizza was outstanding, beer selection was even better and we had a great bottle of red wine to compliment our meal. Men, I would highly recommend eating at the bar. The entire bar is designed with cutouts of old Playboy models and centerfolds, but tastefully designed to not offend the woman. My wife and I had a blast eating there last night and wholeheartedly endorse this little slice of heaven for a great meal, great service and a great time.
(5)gail s.
Nice Guys is a great little bar/restaurant here in the Cape. Great selection of craft beers, decent wine and really good food. I love the roast beef and chicken parm sandwiches and the fried oreos are evil. Greg is a great host and appreciates the valu of food service and treating his customers right!
(4)Emily A.
The owner, Greg, was a super nice guy and my BF and I felt like we'd known him forever when we left. The pizza was really good and fried Oreos were heavenly. They also have great craft beer choices. We probably could have shared a small pizza, but went home with lunch for the next day. I hope they do well, I don't want to see them go. My BF has a condo in Cape Coral and we plan to visit Nice Guys Pizza every time we come down.
(5)Alison P.
This place is AMAZING!!! We absolutely LOVE the personal service we get when we go there. They're constantly changing out their selection of craft beer; Greg is a like a beer encyclopedia, there is nothing the guy doesn't know. The food? Ah-mazing!! Do yourself a favor and try the new Hot Honey Ham pie...you can thank me later. Oh, and the garlic knots? For sure keeping the vampires away...they are so perfectly garlicy. Don't even get me started on their deep fried oreo's...yep, I said deep fried oreos. Yes, it's a small place, but WHO FREAKING CARES!?!? It's a top notch bar with amazing food, and a stellar staff...it's totally worth the wait!
(5)Jessica R.
Loved the hhot n honey not the hawaiian pizza. Garlic knors ok too. Better for take out. Ugly location
(4)Nacho G.
Awesome! I had their garlic knots and green eggs and ham pizza...both were delicious! Good selection of craft beers as well.
(5)Lewis H.
We like to visit family every couple months down in the Cape, and pizza and garlic knots from Nice Guys is automatic. The location seems like a fun hole in the wall dive bar, but we always get it to go. I'm an Italian from NY, and this is proper pizza. The knots are perfect, and powerful with spicy garlic. The hot honey pizza is one of my favorite slices in the world, and unlike anything I've found. Keep it up guys.
(5)Elisa A.
We keep on going... Love the food, the staff and the games ..;) the honey pizza is delicious...
(5)Deena S.
The Hot and Honey pizza has become a staple every time we are in town. Get the crust well done, and a side of knots. Cannot go wrong with that combo!
(5)Adam N.
Excellent pizza to go along with an always changing craft beer selection. Greg and his staff are doing great things. If you're in the area, make sure you stop in for a pint and some pizza.
(5)Clint T.
I love the atmosphere. It was dimly lit with good music playing. If I had a bar, it would closely resemble this one. Awesome beer and wine selection. A good selection of craft beers. The pizza was very good and tasted like it was made from fresh ingredients. The garlic knots were awesome an addictive.
(5)Kendahl V.
If you want to actually experience a good night out with great food and great beer, I sincerely would start here. This is truly a unique place. I love the wings. Owners are great people with some wicked pizza making skills.
(5)Kyle N.
The best pizza in lee county. Greg is always getting new and awesome beers. The rest of the food is top notch not one single complaint. They also have new special appetizers and desserts on the weekends also. My only gripe is kinda wish it was bigger so more people could share this amazing place. Oh and don't bring your kids and complain that it's not kid friendly it's not supposed to be its a bar. Use your brain.
(5)Jenna A.
I had the margherita pizza here, which was actually very good but the quality of the food was completely overshadowed by the poor attitude by the bartender (who I was told is one of the owners?!), lack of service we received and the dirty dining room and restroom. The few tables inside were either taken or dirty when I walked in, so I asked the busboy if I could grab a table outside since no one else greeted me. He said yes, came out and cleaned the table and said my server would be right out. I sat outside for a solid 10 minutes, completely unacknowledged, while able to see through the windows and watch the bartender/owner schmoozing with the 5 people sitting at the bar. Ended up going inside and sitting at the bar after 10 minutes of being ignored, and received no apology for not being greeted. I'm hungry and mad and ready to get out of there at this point, but my friend and I decided to stay and split a pizza anyway. We shared the small margherita and it was the perfect size for two. After ordering we didn't get much further interaction from the bartender/owner, who continued to schmooze with what I gathered to be the regulars sitting at the bar. Had to call for her attention to get refills and the check. I would get takeout from here in the future but will never return as a dine in guest. P.S. Just because you have a sign on the door that says "if you are impatient or cranky go to McDonald's across the street!" doesn't give you the right to be an asshole to new customers.
(2)Adam B.
This place is great. The garlic knots are the best I've ever had. The fried Oreos are the only desert ill eat, like ever, dessert sucks! but these things are awesome. The whole style of the place is real interesting as well.
(5)Rj D.
Truffle shuffle... The two words you need to know going in here. Wings are awesome.. Never frozen. They are amazing. Music is great and they are starting to have live shows.. In Cape Coral??really? This might be a game changer...
(5)Melissa G.
One of the better spots in the Cape. Good pizza, good beer selection, and usually good music. Try the 48 Hour Garlic Knots. That's not the official name, but it should be, because that's how long you'll be tasting them for.
(4)Brian H.
One of my favorite spots on the cape. I've been here several times, and each time has been great. From the food, to the mix of customers, it's just a fun place. The owners are awesome people. I've been remembered each time I've eaten here. They go out of their way to interact with you, and you can tell they really care about their place. They're not afraid to play around with the menu, which means you can always try something new! If you're a beer person, they've got a great mix. A rolling selection on draft, and some nice options in bottles. The place is small, and that's just fine with me. It's cozy and friendly, and there is always a good mix of people here. Somehow, everyone just seems to feel welcome. Worth a stop.
(5)Nathan C.
Great place, great atmosphere, great beer and even better food! I go here pretty regularly, they're isn't anything on the menu that isn't fantastic. They are always adding new menu items and new beer. just go if you're thinking about it! You won't regret it!
(5)Laura R.
Wanted to check it out after hearing about their amazing outdoor signage and finally did. SOOOOO worth it. Holy crap, we went for the beer and are still going back for the fantastic food and great people. They have trivia on Wednesday nights which is stellar, get there early if you want a seat! It's a small place, but the staff is fantastic. Greg is super knowledgeable about his beer and is always on hand to make a great suggestion. The french fries are game changing and their chicken parm sandwich is one of the best I've ever had...and keep having...I want it all the time. They are always there until late and the kitchen is open until at least 1a - so a great late night option!
(5)Ian R.
The owners' ability to think outside the box and prepare fresh ingredients in creative ways is the thing I love most about this place. A close second to that is their customer service. I love going there and feeling like part of the family. Being in the business myself I appreciate the hard work and dedication that goes into creating a great dining experience and this place accomplishes just that.
(5)Erin C.
Love it! Great pizza, wings and beer! Owner Greg was ver friendly. Atmosphere is Eclectic. Love the burlesque photos inlaid in the bar. You can even leave your own post it note in the bathroom!!
(4)Andrea C.
My husband and I just moved to Cape Coral from the Detroit area and have found very, very few places to eat that are even kind of good. The food here is AMAZING. The first time we went I had a pulled pork sammy which was delicious. The second time I had the white truffle pizza which was very good as well. They serve a wide variety of craft beers and wine. Only downside is that it is FREEZING in there. My husband (who is never cold) even thinks it is extremely cold inside.
(5)John H.
Tried last week for the first time after reading all of the reviews. Actually did a to go order and was early and the owner greeted me and asked if I wanted a beer until food was ready. First impression was this place is like Seattle/Athens Ga mix. Awesome, unique atmosphere here in CC. He gave me a great reco on a beer I have never heard of, had two of them as a matter of fact while soaking up the place! When I got home, everyone agreed the pizza was outstanding, not sure where they get the sausage but it is great. Went tonight, a week later and we sat inside, got there early just to get a sit. Again just a great place, service is great. Oh yeah try the garlic knots, prefer these over the wings..
(5)John H.
The place looks kind of divey, but don't let that fool you. The food is amazing!! They are very friendly. They also have a great beer selection and reasonable prices. Will most definitely be back! !
(5)Uuu B.
OMG this place is soooo good!! The pizzas, the beer selection, and the deep-fried pickles all made my mouth so happy. And the vibe is on point too...the music, the decor, the post-it notes in the bathroom...and our waiter Kristen was a sweetheart. Love this place!
(5)Elizabeth R.
We were looking for somewhere different tonight and , score we found it. Nice Guys is a small, quaint, eclectic, and yes friendly place. There is seating at the bar with its varieties of beer taps and a good assortment of canned and bottled beers. 3 or 4 two top tables and two 4 tops inside. a server with card games and board games for your entertainment. . I am guessing the nice guy and our girl were the owners . Quick to greet us and seemed happy to have us. They were full at that moment ,but a couple at the two top waves and said they were leaving in a few, really a friendly place. people were relaxed and enjoying their spaces. Oh yeah we went to eat! I ordered the meatball sub. Homemade meat balls nice toasty bun and not overwhelmed with sauce, I actually tasted the meat ! French fries very good . My partner had the Chicken Parm. Sub again nice crispy toasty roll and real chicken and again not a lot of sauce. That impressed me they weren't hiding fake processed food. The beers were good. A very nice pleasant evening ,a definite place to visit again. Oh and the EuroTrash Donuts were a powdery fun dessert. 6 large balls of fried dough with sweet powdery covering them .. mmmmmm very good!!
(4)Dan B.
Great atmosphere, great food, and great service!!! This place is a must try! We had the green eggs and ham pizza and loved it. I have never had anything like it before. Our waitress took care of us immediately and was very helpful and pleasant. One of the owners even came by to make sure we had been taken care of. Atmosphere is awesome! Try it you will love it!
(5)Kristann M.
It seems Cape Coral has more pizza places than any other place we've ever visited (practically one in every strip mall, and in Cape Coral there are A LOT of strip malls!), and we've had good luck with several of them. We decided to try Nice Guys based on the good Yelp reviews -- my husband loves to try local craft beers when he visits new places -- and are glad we went. We had a tasty pepperoni & bacon pizza, which had a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, toppings and crust. The place definitely has a dive vibe and there's hardly any seating available. However we were lucky to get a seat. Very good service, good music playing, huge beer selection, including some great local craft beers. People at the bar were friendly and relaxed. We plan to return. We wish the place was larger as seating was very limited -- hopefully they'll expand into the vacant space next door, or open another location.
(4)T A.
Best pizza spot here! Best fried pickles and garlic knots. Beer is great! Love this place!
(5)Madison M.
Didn't really know what to expect, but from the moment we got there to when we l left it was great! Truffle Shuffle pizza was amazing, cheese sticks were unexpected and delicious, and bartender Kristen was super helpful and nice. Beer was a little pricy. We will definitely be back!
(4)Janette G.
Awesome, awesome place! Great beer, great pizza, wonderful atmosphere. I guess everyone else thinks so because the place is always packed! I can't wait for season to be over so that we can find a place to sit again.
(4)Brad T.
The only thing that outdid the food was the incredible service. This place is a diamond in the rough - the sort of shopping strip gem you hope to find in a bustling place like Cape Coral. Most notably, everything is homemade. Really, EVERYTHING. And your tastebuds can tell. The Truffle Shuffle pizza and fries were our choices from the menu and they didn't disappoint. From the rich, complex truffle flavor in the pizza to the hand-battered fries, we definitely left full. After having dined at Nice Guys, we came back for a nighttime event last week - a prom thrown by the tattoo parlour across the street. The transformation was flawless! From eclectic-but-likable pizza parlor to full-on venue with the ease. We don't drink, but the beer list boasted an impressive array of selections, from the standard American pilsners to microbrews and craft beers. All-in-all, if you're in the market for a great meal, friendly service, and a totally unique environment, you've found your spot!
(5)Brad T.
The only thing that outdid the food was the incredible service. This place is a diamond in the rough - the sort of shopping strip gem you hope to find in a bustling place like Cape Coral. Most notably, everything is homemade. Really, EVERYTHING. And your tastebuds can tell. The Truffle Shuffle pizza and fries were our choices from the menu and they didn't disappoint. From the rich, complex truffle flavor in the pizza to the hand-battered fries, we definitely left full. After having dined at Nice Guys, we came back for a nighttime event last week - a prom thrown by the tattoo parlour across the street. The transformation was flawless! From eclectic-but-likable pizza parlor to full-on venue with the ease. We don't drink, but the beer list boasted an impressive array of selections, from the standard American pilsners to microbrews and craft beers. All-in-all, if you're in the market for a great meal, friendly service, and a totally unique environment, you've found your spot!
(5)Billy H.
I really wanted to love Nice Guys. We arrived into town after a 12 hour drive up from Nashville to stay at my parents place down here. We didn't want to mess with cooking or eating out somewhere so we decided on pizza. Pizza is probably one of my favorite food groups, if not favorite. We usually get pizza from Paradise Pizza, but we were looking to try something new, so we deciding on Nice Guys. We skimmed the menu & picked the 'carnivore' pizza, a medium for $15 & ordered a side of the cheese sticks. The girl on the phone was very short while taking our order on the phone, almost like it was a nuisance for taking a phone order. She told us it would be ready in about 30 minutes. We set off for Nice Guys about 25 minutes after ordering & arrived when it should be ready. It was a Friday night & the place was busy. The bartender said it would be a few minutes for the order & if we wanted a drink. A few minutes turned into about 25 minutes, nearly an hour after calling in the order. I'm not sure if they forgot about it or if they were just really busy. We got home & were so excited. We opened the cheese sticks & tried them. They were okay, tasted a little overdone. There were 5 sticks in the order for $7. Onto the pizza. It was nice sized for a medium, a nice amount of toppings, but nothing had any flavor. The crust tasted like bread & flour, the meat didn't have any seasoning. It as was very basic. Was it bad pizza, no. Was it great pizza, no. It was a just very mediocre. Like I said, I wanted to love this place, but after my first experience, I'll stick with my usual place.
(2)Tom S.
If you blink, you'd miss this place. We're big micro brew fans and this is the place to be. Food is great, people are great, beer is FANTASTIC- what else can you ask for? Only con is it's on the small side, so hard to take a large group.
(5)Claudia V.
Beyond excellent food. Good beer and decent wine. (Ask a manager for wine paring recommendation.). Beyond hipster crowd. Bottom line- if ur not cool like me, either get take out or acquire a getup to fit in. Service is also nice too. Music was good, but I'm not hip, so the regulars probably dislike the tunes. (?). Zagat rating: 25 Food, 20 Atmosphere, 22 Service. Yelp rating: 5 * food, 3 * atmosphere, 4 * service. PS for the hipsters- bring QUARTERS for the video games in second room. (Uncool people have these quarter things in our cars for parking.). ;) Atari pacman
(5)Ab To The G.
The best pizza in Cape! Havent had a bad meal here yet. The garlic knots are soooo good. Every pizza we have tried (cuban, hot honey, wash carver, mushroom) were so good! They fill you up too because they are so loaded with yumminess. Great craft beer list. Service is super friendly. They really are nice here. I left my $400 sunglasses on the table after dinner and the manager held onto them for me to pick up the next day. We will take all of our visitors here its just that good! They also are always playing good music.
(5)Angela S.
Never been disappointed with the quirky pizza choices. Washington Carver is a combo of apple smoked bacon with cheese, raspberry jam in peanut sauce. Deceptively delicious! The Hot Honey is not to be missed either. Salami and prosciutto with a hot honey sauce. Yummy! Great craft beer selection too. It's pretty small inside so get there early. People bring their kids but only early in the evening. It's not a place for them after dark. Very hipster but cool enough for us older folks. Good music but it's loud.
(5)Janie T.
OH. MY. GOODNESS! This teeny, tiny little hole in the wall is FABULOUS! We visited this little gem on Sunday and absolutely could not get enough. We sat at a high top and were promptly greeted by a sweet and crazy little chick. She gave us opinions on the beers and shared her favorites. We ordered based off of her recommendations and were super glad that we did. There wasn't a beer we didn't like (my favorite was the Peach In Cider). Her partner in crime, a very chill and laid back fella, came over to take our order. He made some pizza suggestion but we already had it nailed down as to what we wanted to try...first was the Hot Honey Pizza, which is to die for!!! Second was the truffle shuffle (not even close to the Hot Honey). We gorged ourselves on pizza, beer and of course the Mexican Coke and left our new found treasure with full bellies and a hankering to come back as soon as we could. If you are looking for something different...THIS IS IT. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. Make sure to go in with an open mind, remember I said it is teeny tiny. Takeout may be the way to go if you don't like tight spots. We will be back!!!
(5)Alison P.
This place is AMAZING!!! We absolutely LOVE the personal service we get when we go there. They're constantly changing out their selection of craft beer; Greg is a like a beer encyclopedia, there is nothing the guy doesn't know. The food? Ah-mazing!! Do yourself a favor and try the new Hot Honey Ham pie...you can thank me later. Oh, and the garlic knots? For sure keeping the vampires away...they are so perfectly garlicy. Don't even get me started on their deep fried oreo's...yep, I said deep fried oreos. Yes, it's a small place, but WHO FREAKING CARES!?!? It's a top notch bar with amazing food, and a stellar staff...it's totally worth the wait!
(5)Jessica R.
Loved the hhot n honey not the hawaiian pizza. Garlic knors ok too. Better for take out. Ugly location
(4)Nacho G.
Awesome! I had their garlic knots and green eggs and ham pizza...both were delicious! Good selection of craft beers as well.
(5)Lewis H.
We like to visit family every couple months down in the Cape, and pizza and garlic knots from Nice Guys is automatic. The location seems like a fun hole in the wall dive bar, but we always get it to go. I'm an Italian from NY, and this is proper pizza. The knots are perfect, and powerful with spicy garlic. The hot honey pizza is one of my favorite slices in the world, and unlike anything I've found. Keep it up guys.
(5)Elisa A.
We keep on going... Love the food, the staff and the games ..;) the honey pizza is delicious...
(5)Adam N.
Excellent pizza to go along with an always changing craft beer selection. Greg and his staff are doing great things. If you're in the area, make sure you stop in for a pint and some pizza.
(5)Clint T.
I love the atmosphere. It was dimly lit with good music playing. If I had a bar, it would closely resemble this one. Awesome beer and wine selection. A good selection of craft beers. The pizza was very good and tasted like it was made from fresh ingredients. The garlic knots were awesome an addictive.
(5)Kendahl V.
If you want to actually experience a good night out with great food and great beer, I sincerely would start here. This is truly a unique place. I love the wings. Owners are great people with some wicked pizza making skills.
(5)Kyle N.
The best pizza in lee county. Greg is always getting new and awesome beers. The rest of the food is top notch not one single complaint. They also have new special appetizers and desserts on the weekends also. My only gripe is kinda wish it was bigger so more people could share this amazing place. Oh and don't bring your kids and complain that it's not kid friendly it's not supposed to be its a bar. Use your brain.
(5)Jenna A.
I had the margherita pizza here, which was actually very good but the quality of the food was completely overshadowed by the poor attitude by the bartender (who I was told is one of the owners?!), lack of service we received and the dirty dining room and restroom. The few tables inside were either taken or dirty when I walked in, so I asked the busboy if I could grab a table outside since no one else greeted me. He said yes, came out and cleaned the table and said my server would be right out. I sat outside for a solid 10 minutes, completely unacknowledged, while able to see through the windows and watch the bartender/owner schmoozing with the 5 people sitting at the bar. Ended up going inside and sitting at the bar after 10 minutes of being ignored, and received no apology for not being greeted. I'm hungry and mad and ready to get out of there at this point, but my friend and I decided to stay and split a pizza anyway. We shared the small margherita and it was the perfect size for two. After ordering we didn't get much further interaction from the bartender/owner, who continued to schmooze with what I gathered to be the regulars sitting at the bar. Had to call for her attention to get refills and the check. I would get takeout from here in the future but will never return as a dine in guest. P.S. Just because you have a sign on the door that says "if you are impatient or cranky go to McDonald's across the street!" doesn't give you the right to be an asshole to new customers.
(2)Adam B.
This place is great. The garlic knots are the best I've ever had. The fried Oreos are the only desert ill eat, like ever, dessert sucks! but these things are awesome. The whole style of the place is real interesting as well.
(5)Rj D.
Truffle shuffle... The two words you need to know going in here. Wings are awesome.. Never frozen. They are amazing. Music is great and they are starting to have live shows.. In Cape Coral??really? This might be a game changer...
(5)Beth M.
Called in for a pick up. American was what was recommended. Great pie. Will be back.
(5)Terra A.
This was a radical change from other bar/restaurants I've visited in the area. The bar top has been modge-podged with beautiful almost nude women (they've been censored with flowers!) I loved it! There were good tunes, and friendly service. The space itself is that of a typical sized bar with approximately ten 2-4 top tables, as well as a couple outdoor tables. There was actual beer here! I was so surprised to find something other than your typical domestic brews that I forgot what i enjoy drinking! No worries, there was plenty to choose from and I decided on an abita wheat beer. as for food, I went with a hummus plate and pepperoni pizza. the hummus plate definitely serves more than one person! the hummus, topped with a red and green pepper jam, was a nice twist. It was sweet, but not overly so. the pizza: the crust was really the best part of the pizza. the other ingredients weren't particularly one thing or another. on a second trip, i'd get a white pizza, or an EVOO based pizza for sure. pizza is such a subjective food. i will not dock any stars, i'll just try a different pizza. In an area with little to no worthwhile restaurants, this is a MUST eat at, drink at establishment!.
(5)Darbi L.
Really yummy pizza and the male server/greeter/bartender was suuuuuuuper friendly and just nice to be served by! The female waitress who brought us our food was not as nice but could have been having a bad day. Fun atmosphere (cool to have a "hipster-y" place in the cape) and good food. I will definitely go back!
(4)John S.
Great pizza, decent wings and service, fantastic craft beer selection. Garlic knots were cheap, generous, & garlicy af. Truffle shuffle pizza is where it's at. 'Balls' hot wings could be hotter.. I wanna cry man! Judging by the atmosphere and theme, I was hoping the service be rude & arrogant (just for fun), but they were polite and kind.. (maybe cause I was with my mom.) Neat decor and idea. No TV, kinda family friendly, cute bartenders. Lots of little board games and food to try, I can see myself spending an afternoon here next time I'm home.
(5)Kyle S.
Great Beer. Great Food. Great service. Do yourself a favor and get the chicken parm. Pizzas are amazing too.
(5)Laura M.
The food was good but the only guy working here the night we went was not very nice to us at all
(2)Alexis P.
This place is cool! We pulled up and were very on edge about entering but I'm so glad we did. It is a real laid back hippie joint. Check out the bathroom when you go! Pizza was delish and very reasonably priced. Great beer selection.
(4)Jessica S.
Let's just say I will definitely hit this place up again. It might be my new hot spot. They are open until 1:30am during the week which is great. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, french fries, fried oreos and it came up to $30. Besides the price being so cheap, the food was hands down the best I've had in a while. I recommend it 100%.
(5)Nick D.
A colleague and I visit the Ft. Myers area for business on a regular basis and we often stay with friends in Cape Coral. Nice Guys has become our go-to hang-out and dinner spot. They have wonderful food-try the garlic knots and roast beef with the zesty sauce, in particular. We've had the truffle pizza, cheese sticks, and chicken fingers, too--all amazing. Made to order, flavorful, and unique--what more could you ask for? Greg and Jovenah have always been incredibly accommodating and helpful, not to mention they're a lot of fun to hang out with. Prices are reasonable, and the draft beer and cider choices are incredible, especially for a place of its size. Oh, and their dessert is great, too! Try the fried oreos. Anyway, stop reading this and go eat there!
(5)Rob O.
Picked up a pie and garlic knots the other night. NICE SURPRISE!!! Got the Truffle Shuffle ....DELISH...I'm not a Garlic Knot expert but these were the best I ever had!! Suggestions? Get your pie and get out of there!! It's a BAR serving great Pie...I had to hold my Pie over my head to get out of there..lots of CC 20-30something's ... Staff was friendly and fixed me up Will be back
(5)Diana G.
Fantastic atmosphere and over the top service. I come here at least 2 times a month. D fried orris are delicious!!! Do not miss out on checking thus unique place out.
(5)Linda M.
Been here once and am sold! Love the atmosphere and the food is above the other 5 stars I've given at other places! Touché!
(5)Dani P.
They now have 'stinky buns' which have pork, kimchi, cucumber, in a bun. I ordered some to go, and when I went back home to eat it, it was so delicious I contemplated texting my brother in the room next door to exclaim how good they were. It comes in a set of two. I could've eaten two more.
(5)Belinda S.
Wow. Garlic knots are a MUST. Food was fantastic and service was down right homey! This will become a regular haunt.
(5)Benny F.
Very good local hangout. If you blink you will miss it! The food was home cooked and fresh. The garlic knots is great appetizer and one the best garlic rolls I have had. We had the veggie pizza which was filled with fresh veggies and it the sauce and dough was perfect. However to finish the night, you must have the deep fried Oreos ! I promise you that you won't regret it!
(5)Deena S.
The Hot and Honey pizza has become a staple every time we are in town. Get the crust well done, and a side of knots. Cannot go wrong with that combo!
(5)Melissa G.
One of the better spots in the Cape. Good pizza, good beer selection, and usually good music. Try the 48 Hour Garlic Knots. That's not the official name, but it should be, because that's how long you'll be tasting them for.
(4)Brian H.
One of my favorite spots on the cape. I've been here several times, and each time has been great. From the food, to the mix of customers, it's just a fun place. The owners are awesome people. I've been remembered each time I've eaten here. They go out of their way to interact with you, and you can tell they really care about their place. They're not afraid to play around with the menu, which means you can always try something new! If you're a beer person, they've got a great mix. A rolling selection on draft, and some nice options in bottles. The place is small, and that's just fine with me. It's cozy and friendly, and there is always a good mix of people here. Somehow, everyone just seems to feel welcome. Worth a stop.
(5)Nathan C.
Great place, great atmosphere, great beer and even better food! I go here pretty regularly, they're isn't anything on the menu that isn't fantastic. They are always adding new menu items and new beer. just go if you're thinking about it! You won't regret it!
(5)Laura R.
Wanted to check it out after hearing about their amazing outdoor signage and finally did. SOOOOO worth it. Holy crap, we went for the beer and are still going back for the fantastic food and great people. They have trivia on Wednesday nights which is stellar, get there early if you want a seat! It's a small place, but the staff is fantastic. Greg is super knowledgeable about his beer and is always on hand to make a great suggestion. The french fries are game changing and their chicken parm sandwich is one of the best I've ever had...and keep having...I want it all the time. They are always there until late and the kitchen is open until at least 1a - so a great late night option!
(5)Ian R.
The owners' ability to think outside the box and prepare fresh ingredients in creative ways is the thing I love most about this place. A close second to that is their customer service. I love going there and feeling like part of the family. Being in the business myself I appreciate the hard work and dedication that goes into creating a great dining experience and this place accomplishes just that.
(5)Erin C.
Love it! Great pizza, wings and beer! Owner Greg was ver friendly. Atmosphere is Eclectic. Love the burlesque photos inlaid in the bar. You can even leave your own post it note in the bathroom!!
(4)Andrea C.
My husband and I just moved to Cape Coral from the Detroit area and have found very, very few places to eat that are even kind of good. The food here is AMAZING. The first time we went I had a pulled pork sammy which was delicious. The second time I had the white truffle pizza which was very good as well. They serve a wide variety of craft beers and wine. Only downside is that it is FREEZING in there. My husband (who is never cold) even thinks it is extremely cold inside.
(5)John H.
Tried last week for the first time after reading all of the reviews. Actually did a to go order and was early and the owner greeted me and asked if I wanted a beer until food was ready. First impression was this place is like Seattle/Athens Ga mix. Awesome, unique atmosphere here in CC. He gave me a great reco on a beer I have never heard of, had two of them as a matter of fact while soaking up the place! When I got home, everyone agreed the pizza was outstanding, not sure where they get the sausage but it is great. Went tonight, a week later and we sat inside, got there early just to get a sit. Again just a great place, service is great. Oh yeah try the garlic knots, prefer these over the wings..
(5)John H.
The place looks kind of divey, but don't let that fool you. The food is amazing!! They are very friendly. They also have a great beer selection and reasonable prices. Will most definitely be back! !
(5)Uuu B.
OMG this place is soooo good!! The pizzas, the beer selection, and the deep-fried pickles all made my mouth so happy. And the vibe is on point too...the music, the decor, the post-it notes in the bathroom...and our waiter Kristen was a sweetheart. Love this place!
(5)Elizabeth R.
We were looking for somewhere different tonight and , score we found it. Nice Guys is a small, quaint, eclectic, and yes friendly place. There is seating at the bar with its varieties of beer taps and a good assortment of canned and bottled beers. 3 or 4 two top tables and two 4 tops inside. a server with card games and board games for your entertainment. . I am guessing the nice guy and our girl were the owners . Quick to greet us and seemed happy to have us. They were full at that moment ,but a couple at the two top waves and said they were leaving in a few, really a friendly place. people were relaxed and enjoying their spaces. Oh yeah we went to eat! I ordered the meatball sub. Homemade meat balls nice toasty bun and not overwhelmed with sauce, I actually tasted the meat ! French fries very good . My partner had the Chicken Parm. Sub again nice crispy toasty roll and real chicken and again not a lot of sauce. That impressed me they weren't hiding fake processed food. The beers were good. A very nice pleasant evening ,a definite place to visit again. Oh and the EuroTrash Donuts were a powdery fun dessert. 6 large balls of fried dough with sweet powdery covering them .. mmmmmm very good!!
(4)Dan B.
Great atmosphere, great food, and great service!!! This place is a must try! We had the green eggs and ham pizza and loved it. I have never had anything like it before. Our waitress took care of us immediately and was very helpful and pleasant. One of the owners even came by to make sure we had been taken care of. Atmosphere is awesome! Try it you will love it!
(5)Kristann M.
It seems Cape Coral has more pizza places than any other place we've ever visited (practically one in every strip mall, and in Cape Coral there are A LOT of strip malls!), and we've had good luck with several of them. We decided to try Nice Guys based on the good Yelp reviews -- my husband loves to try local craft beers when he visits new places -- and are glad we went. We had a tasty pepperoni & bacon pizza, which had a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, toppings and crust. The place definitely has a dive vibe and there's hardly any seating available. However we were lucky to get a seat. Very good service, good music playing, huge beer selection, including some great local craft beers. People at the bar were friendly and relaxed. We plan to return. We wish the place was larger as seating was very limited -- hopefully they'll expand into the vacant space next door, or open another location.
(4)T A.
Best pizza spot here! Best fried pickles and garlic knots. Beer is great! Love this place!
(5)Madison M.
Didn't really know what to expect, but from the moment we got there to when we l left it was great! Truffle Shuffle pizza was amazing, cheese sticks were unexpected and delicious, and bartender Kristen was super helpful and nice. Beer was a little pricy. We will definitely be back!
(4)John S.
The food was excellent. I had a margherita pizza, my girlfriend had a truffle shuffle and got hers with vegan cheese. Both were very, very good. We also had an order of french fries, which were awesome. Batter-dipped, and very tasty. We weren't drinking, but their beer list looks good, and was priced very fairly. It's a small joint, only 5 or 6 tables plus a bar. It's not a tourist-back-from-the-beach type place, and it's not a rent-a-clown-for-a-birthday-party place. Young people running the place, indie-rock on the stereo, posters and flyers on the walls. It's an atmosphere you don't find a lot of in SWFL and I'll definitely be back.
(5)Jeffrey C.
We ordered a Margarita Pizza for take out. Crust was incredible, cheese was loaded, skimpy amount of tomatoes very little basil (actually, I could not see any, it may have been dry) It was basically a fantastic "cheese pizza". My partner ordered the deep fried Oreo's and said they were "to die for"!
(3)Kristen V.
Amazing food and service, I've never left once disappointed. Only when there's no seats at the bar because there's so many people. But it's a good sign to see a small place doing fantastic!
(5)Mike P.
Just great pizza! Reminds me of all the local great pizza joints of my youth in New York & New England. Forget about all the chain junk. This is the real deal at affordable prices. Only word of caution is that this is a very small local bar and seating is limited. Nice folks but I'm not sure I would take grandkids for dine in. REAL HAPPY we found this place.
(5)Janette G.
Awesome, awesome place! Great beer, great pizza, wonderful atmosphere. I guess everyone else thinks so because the place is always packed! I can't wait for season to be over so that we can find a place to sit again.
(4)Mike G.
Great pizza, great beer selection (drafts and bottles), good wings and salads, friendly young owner / operators, funky beat-up homemade atmosphere, no TVs, good indie music not too loud - I love this little place. I'm 60 but most of the clientele are younger. It is small, maybe 8 or 10 seats at the bar, half a dozen tables, mostly 2-tops, and a couple tables outside essentially in the parking lot.
(5)Andres A.
Excellent place!!!! The pizza was sooooo delicious!!!! I highly recommend it!!! If you are visiting (I live in Miami) you should definitely check this place. Friendly staff, cool looking place and great pizza!!!
(5)Scott H.
My wife and I are from the San Francisco Bay Area where you can go out to dinner at midnight on a Sunday night and still find a place to eat. Not so in Cape Coral / Ft. Myers, except for Nice Guys Pizza. And that they were, Nice Guys! The pizza was outstanding, beer selection was even better and we had a great bottle of red wine to compliment our meal. Men, I would highly recommend eating at the bar. The entire bar is designed with cutouts of old Playboy models and centerfolds, but tastefully designed to not offend the woman. My wife and I had a blast eating there last night and wholeheartedly endorse this little slice of heaven for a great meal, great service and a great time.
(5)gail s.
Nice Guys is a great little bar/restaurant here in the Cape. Great selection of craft beers, decent wine and really good food. I love the roast beef and chicken parm sandwiches and the fried oreos are evil. Greg is a great host and appreciates the valu of food service and treating his customers right!
(4)Emily A.
The owner, Greg, was a super nice guy and my BF and I felt like we'd known him forever when we left. The pizza was really good and fried Oreos were heavenly. They also have great craft beer choices. We probably could have shared a small pizza, but went home with lunch for the next day. I hope they do well, I don't want to see them go. My BF has a condo in Cape Coral and we plan to visit Nice Guys Pizza every time we come down.
(5)Chelsea C.
This place is awesome! The staff really loves beer and will recommend a beer for your taste, and the food!! Soooo delicious.. The garlic knots are to die for and the wings too!! Every time were go there is always a different or new beer to try. Glad there is finally a place like this in the cape. The ONLY reason i give this place a 4 is it is soooo small :/ doesn't stop me from coming but they should def expand! Especially with their growing business! Congrats guys!
(4)Aric B.
I can't say enough good this about this place. The pizza was fantastic, the wings as good and terrific craft beer selection. As well, the owner was very friendly and even help hook my sons and I up with things to do while on vacation. Try it out!
(5)Thelonious F.
In the sense that it serves a really good pizza and has the name Nice Guy's Pizza, this is a pizza joint. But it isn't. Not really. It's a bar that serves great food. Great food. All kinds of food. Exciting food. The people are friendly, the beer is cold and the atmosphere relaxed. There is a tinge of a punk ethos in the air. You should go. It reminds me of Yabo back when it was just a hole in the wall secret. GO.
(5)Maureen M.
Saw alot of great reviews so ordered takeout. Soggy crust-- mediocre quality. You know its not good when a group of guys throw out a whole left over pizza rather than save for breakfast. Very disappointing.
(2)K N.
Really wanted to love this place. Loved the atmosphere. Called in a pickup order, which I was quoted 15 minutes, and was ready right on time. Wasn't greeted for a little while after walking in. Got it home and man, it is the herbiest pizza ever. So. Many. Herbs. Could barely taste the cheese or crust. Holy herbs, Batman!
(3)Terin B.
I went for the first time today and I am so glad I did. Tried the American pizza, garlic knots, and deep fried Oreos. It was all delicious. Great service, food, and atmosphere. Can't wait to try out the rest of the menu. :-)
(5)Joe N.
Ok so, full disclosure, I'm a regular here. I love this place. It's easily the best pizza in the area. Jovi and Greg who own the place are behind the bar every night, and they treat everyone that comes in like a friend. I used to have this place rated four stars because they didn't have beer and wine. That has changed. Craft beer, craft beer everywhere. The only mainstream brew they carry is bud light cans. It's a perfect restaurant if you want to have a good time in a laid back atmosphere with great music. Try it and you'll want to come back.
(5)Wendell B.
We hadn't had pizza for a couple of weeks, so my wife found this one on Yelp! First impression was that we should not go in--it's a tacky storefront and really small. But because of all the 5-star reviews, we decided to brave it now that we were there. There are 27 seats in the place--including the 12 or so seats at the bar. Moderate draft beer selection on the blackboard, and just about everything you can imagine in a bottle or a can. As we walked in, the heavily tattooed and long braided pigtailed bartender Jamie greeted us, and said to sit anywhere except the first table because she hadn't wiped that one down yet. Turned out that Jamie was almost a one-woman show all night. We didn't get there until 9:00, and it seemed that the dinner crowd help was leaving about the time we arrived, and she shared bartender duties with a bearded partner but took care of the serving all herself. Jamie is a good example of not judging a book by its cover: she was very friendly, warm, attentive and we enjoyed chatting with her when she had a moment, which she made time for in spite of being a solo most of the night. She took very good care of us and everyone in the small place. We ordered draft Hoegaartens, a familiar favorite white wheat brew. The pizza lived up to its reputation: we ordered the medium American, which included pepperoni, sausage, ham, black olives, onion, creminis (mushrooms--I had to look it up too ;-) and green peppers, and it was delicious and filling--we brought two slices home for lunch the next day. We also saw a Stiegl grapefruit beer on the menu--in fact, it just said "grapefruit beer" and Jamie did not know the brand name, but it turned out to be refreshing and delicious, and both of us ordered one, although my wife went back to our original Hoegaartens to wash down her last piece of pizza. Altogether a really fun night--the crowd was sitting around eating pizza, drinking beer and playing board games from Mancala to Connect Four, and there were lots of quirky things on the walls to look at and read. My wife visited the rest room and said the walls wer covered in sticky notes! Very much an individual kind of place that you probably would not frequent otherwise, but that everyone should experience at least once in their lives. Good choice for pizza and beer. Kitchen open until 1:30 a.m.!
(4)Jennifer M.
This pizza place is so fantastic that my husband and I would drive from Tampa to Ft. Myers just to have it. You must get their garlic knots!!!
(5)Mike U.
Phenomenal service selection and quality...not to mention atmosphere. Strongly recommend you visit when in town!
(5)Wolfgang D.
Wow what a great pizza place. Pizza is great, and a good beer selection. Staff is friendly, with music that would make anyone in their early 30s that had a fairly good knowledge of indie music would really cause them to have fond memories of their 20s. Glad this place opened in Cape Coral. Great good, great price, and great atmosphere.
(5)Kim D.
Awesome staff, great atmosphere, incredible deserts. Everything is made by hand, down to the ketchup! The appetizers are awesome. Wonderfully comfortable atmosphere. Give this place a try!
(5)Vicky N.
I have to admit I was not expecting much. I hear over and over how each pizza place is as good as New York Pizza and I am always disappointed. While we have yet to dine in here, we get takeout about once a week from this place now as we LOVE the pizza! Margherita is my favorite but we love the cheese, meatball and other flavors we have tried. Salads are awesome as well with homemade dressings, and save room for dessert! This place is always trying new things and so far we have enjoyed every single bite! For the first time in 20 years I happily head SOUTH for pizza!
(5)Roger H.
You will not meet any restaurant owners who care more about their customers and the food they serve. Best pizza in town. Great selection of craft beer. Awesome place just to hang out and relax.
(5)Dan D.
best pizza place in the area hands down.
(5)