Old Chicago Menu

Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.

  • Andrea L.

    After just recently moving to the area I had asked around for pizza recommendations and someone mentioned Old Chicago. My husband and I ordered a medium-sized vegetarian pizza expecting a true Chicago-style pie. We were disappointed when we open the box and found a pizza that wasn't even deep dish, forget Chicago style. The crust had a decent taste but everything else was generic and bland.

    (2)
  • David W.

    been through the beer tour almost 2 times now. amazing variety of beer. the food is always good. if i had to recommend something i would say the nachos, the Stromboli, or the pizza all great food. sporting events are awesome especially if you are in to UFC. The staff is awesome again. they do tend to suck in the summer this past summer we had the battle axe of all that can be mean and cranky. hopefully next summer will be better. other than that the place is a great place to chill with friends drink beer and watch sports.

    (5)
  • Kirsten B.

    I came here on my 21st birthday and the waitstaff was amazing. Our server was excellent, I wish I could remember her name, but she really made the night special. The drinks were great too!

    (5)
  • Shae M.

    fantastic service! even when they're busy on a Saturday night.

    (5)
  • Sara R.

    Always great beer! Love the food. Service was fantastic as always. Unfortunately, this time the kitchen messed up the Alfredo sauce. But my boyfriend loved every bit of his buffalo chicken sandwich. The tvs in the bar had the game on and the beer is cold

    (4)
  • Mims G.

    What a horrific dump! The place smelled of old grease and mildew! The food was horrible and the wait was long!

    (1)
  • J.B. R.

    The best pizzas in town, hands down. Vast selection of craft brews. I just wish they would bring back their Lasagna... Great sports bar atmosphere with plenty of Tvs for the game...

    (4)
  • Nancy R.

    Service always prompt and courteous. ..the Italian Natchos are to die for...crispy and full of cheese pepperoni. .the sauce is delish. Hint. Have the banana peppers served on the side. Hone had one of the single pizzas...just right. We always love coming here. Honey loves the 16oz PBRs. ..

    (4)
  • June V.

    I came here for dinner with my bf and my sister on our visit from CA. I ordered the crispy chicken salad and it was a huge delicious salad! I recommend to order the half size...our waitress was quick to refill our drinks and very attentive. My bf ordered a calzone which was very good but also huge! He only ate half...all in all very good food, great staff, and cool atmosphere!

    (5)
  • mandy b.

    I ate here while visiting Greeley Colorado the pizza the beer and the appetizers were all top-of-the-line could not ask for a better pizza and the service was great the waiters let us try so many different flavors of beer. And we will be going back later this week to try their calzones!!!!

    (5)
  • William A.

    Only decent pizza I have found in Greeley. No wow factor in their pizza, other appetizers have nothing speical going for them as well.

    (3)
  • andrew g.

    i have many fond memories of late night runs to old chicago's. they've got great late night pizza specials and their fat tire tuesdays are amazing. something about colorado beer. it's not the greatest, but it's certainly better than most. their buffalo chicken and bbq chicken pizzas are pretty good.

    (4)
  • Michael A.

    i have never had worse service or been insulted so much.. the bartender was grabbing the girls boobs next to me, being completely rude making foul jokes and when i got up to leave he told me to go back to where i came from... well i was just here on vacation so believe me i am going back home, BUT i will never visit this establishment at ANY location..! PS the bar was filthy and practically empty but still not kept up... this place deserves no stars but it requires me to put at least one... but believe me, that is a negative one at best....

    (1)
  • Jason G.

    Poor service. Manager was rude. Employees off the clock sat in corner table in the bar, loud and obnoxious. Manager sat with that table most of the evening. Music was loud, sounded more like a nightclub.

    (1)
  • Joe H.

    Love the Italian nachos! Old Chicago is still - and always has been - a great place to hang out in a casual environment, drink good beer, and have yummy food, served quickly, hot and tasty, by friendly staff. I've eaten at their restaurants all over the Colorado Front Range, and never left disappointed. I wish I could join their beer tour, but I think by the time I'd earn a mug, I'd have lost my liver.

    (3)
  • Taylor A.

    I ate here a few times while I was working in Greeley and the service, food, and beer is all top-notch. Burgers and steak are big and juicy. Their beer selection is probably the best in town. I definitely wasn't expecting a Old Chicago in Greeley, but it's my most favorite restaurant to eat at while I'm here. Go here, you won't be disappointed!

    (4)
  • Anonymous A.

    Food is good, happy hour prices are great, but waitstaff is not. While I have had good service in the past, last night's was piss poor (hence the review). This seems to be the case about 9 times out of 10. I really like Old Chicago and would be bummed to stop going, but I just can't eat at a restaurant where I get the impression that my presence is a burden to my waiter/waitress.

    (2)
  • L H.

    We visited tonight, waited 15 min for a table which is normal and actually less than what we expected, we were seated and then waited 24 min before anyone came to our table to even take drink orders. Our waitress was new, she said it was her third day, bless her heart she was flustered, she was very kind and apologetic about our long wait tonight, we were here an hour and a half before we got any food. The waitress even though she was new, we could tell she was truly trying and my heart went out to her. My complaint is to the two managers who were standing around the whole time, doing nothing, including not offering to help out our waitress, she was clearly struggling, why aren't they stepping up to lend a hand? Hanging out at the hostess stand is more important??? Get with the program and help out the staff, that's your job, you get paid way more than our waitress, you could surely help her out! Shame on you BOTH, yeah with two of you here working the same shift, you'd think one of you could stop standing around and help out!!

    (1)
  • Hank C.

    You just can't get good pizza/Italian food in Texas. Old Chicago's is one place I miss when I am not in Colorado. I love the Italian nachos and the calzones are really good too. Great place for happy hour; a great place to meet up with friends and throw a few beers/shots back. just a good place to be to spend a few hours.

    (4)
  • Laurie W.

    Good Spaghetti and Meatballs! As simple and it sounds, its amazing.

    (4)
  • Will S.

    Pretty popular joint in Greeley. Pretty much everyone comes here for their 21st birthday, mostly because people of any age can come here. As far as price goes, their beer and pizza are fairly priced but liquor can get pretty expensive. The best part of Old C's is their Beer Tour. The restraunt has 110 different beers for you to sample and they encourage you to try each one. They issue you a card which keeps track of all the brews you've tried. At certain points through the tour (10, 20, 40 etc) you're given rewards like playing cards, a bottle opener, and shirts. Further, they have mini tours throughout the year which showcase 8 beers. If you finish all of them in the 2 week period you get a shirt. These beers also count toward your 110 beer tour as well. Examples of these are the St. Pattys tour with Irish Beers and the obligatory Guiness, the Craft Beer tour with local microbeers, and the Cinco de Mayo tour with tons of Mexican beers. They're open until 1 am, but from 4pm-6pm and from 10pm-12am they have happy hour where they have $3 personal pizzas. This specific Old C's has pretty decent service overall. The wait staff are, usually, fun and good at their jobs. They're also pretty good at giving recommendations for alcohol as well.

    (3)
  • Carol A.

    Being from out of town, our first time here, the mistake we made was to choose to sit in the dining room instead of the bar. The atmosphere in the dining room at 6:30 pm was akin to Chuck E Cheese. Rambunctious toddlers and fussy babies at almost every table. The drinks were very good, the pizza was fair, the service was average, but the "ambience" overwhelmed, so we really didn't enjoy ourselves.

    (3)
  • E C.

    We went for lunch... The food was ok. The place was so dirty, and I cannot believe how the manager was talking to his employees. I was embarrassed for those servers. Not sure I would go back.

    (2)
  • Trenton T.

    Last night I played the board game pandemic which is a very fun coop board game where you try to rid the world of 4 deadly diseases. It was getting late so I pasted my face with Vaseline to fix my horrendous sunburns from the night before. I hate Vaseline jt is so pasty and makes my skin feel like a glutinous goo but I've noticed my complexion tends to heal almost over night. I woke up the next morning and took a shower to scrape the thick layer of Vaseline off my face. As I arose from the bed I noticed an outline of my body in Vaseline on the bed. Ewwww really nasty stuff!!! I checked out of my hotel and went to work. It was a really long day and once again I was out in the sun all day (I see another Vaseline night coming ;) ) what a day!!!!!! This chick had a seizure which was really sad and frightening!!!! By the time work ended I had to break down alllllll of my equipment and repack my van for a long drive to greely. Immediately when I entered the town it started to smell like cow fecal matter. It was horrendous. I was starving before the fecal smell hit my nose but once it did my stomache turned off giving me a similar feeling to the terrible pasty feeling I recieved from spreading Vaseline over my burnt body. I quickly found a few loose napkins from my taco bell trip a few nights ago and shoved them into my nose. It worked for a while until the smell saturated the napkins and made the problem worst. I gaged. It was that bad. I continued down and reached my hotel exit. I pulled off and ate at old Chicago, it was delicious.

    (4)
  • Charles R.

    Are you kidding me, Greeley? Am I writing the first review for ANYWHERE in this town? I just spent a few minutes looking for a review of any place here, and nothing. Oh wait, I found one for a burger joint, and it opens with "Not from Greeley (thank god) but been there enough." And on that lovely note... So yeah, I'm from Los Angeles, and visiting some family here, but checked out Old Chicago last night with a friend from Ft. Collins. If you know of the restaurant chain BJ's, you have a good idea of what this place is about. The menu has a good variety of pizza, burgers, sandwiches, salads, even calzones, and more. I was a bit disappointed to not find any BBQ chicken pizza or sandwich thought - I thought that was a staple at most any pizza place. Anyway, the other big story here is the beer. They have a whole bunch to choose from, and many local favorites on draft. I went with good ol' Fat Tire, and had a nice helping with a tall glass. For the meal, I went with the personal-size Hawaiian pizza Chicago style. Yes, deep-dish. It was...alright. It had the greasy goodness I was expecting, so that left me satisfied. Yeah, I don't always have to eat healthy. But it was alright. I think if I were to go again I might try a calzone - my friend got one and it looked pretty good. I've been told this is one of THE places to go here in Greeley, and judging by the crowd late last night, that seems to be the case. The people there were very Colorado...some of you might know what I mean by that. Aye, this place was okay, but I'm not rushing for a return visit.

    (3)

Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.

Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.

Map

Opening Hours

  • Mon :11:00 am - 2:00pm

Specialities

  • Takes Reservations : Yes
    Delivery : No
    Take-out : Yes
    Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
    Good For : Dinner, Late Night
    Parking : Private Lot
    Bike Parking : Yes
    Wheelchair Accessible : Yes
    Good for Kids : Yes
    Good for Groups : Yes
    Attire : Casual
    Ambience : Casual
    Noise Level : Average
    Alcohol : Full Bar
    Outdoor Seating : No
    Wi-Fi : Free
    Has TV : Yes
    Waiter Service : Yes
    Caters : Yes

Categories

Pizza

Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.

Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.

Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.

Old Chicago

Share with your social network

Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online

Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.

© 2024 Restaurant Listings. All rights reserved.