FINALLY... a good bagel in Colorado. Nothing better than a bagel with cream cheese in the morning after a long night of boozing. My fave - poppy with cream cheese. toasted.
(4)
Olivia B.
My Favorite Muffin? More like My Favorite Cupcake, these things are loaded with calories and sugar. Yet I keep coming back for more... Maybe I've never been during a rush, but believe me when I say I've been in and out around 9 am on a weekday in less than three minutes. The service is fast. Almost too fast. It's also a nice place to just sit and eat your enormous muffin and sip your coffee while you read a Westword or a paper or something. I do wish they had a better selection of mini muffins every day, because the big ones are just too much. Yes, I can finish them, we've already established this, but it doesn't mean I necessarily WANT to.
(4)
Sugar L.
My go-to stop for giant cheesy bagels and muffins the size of my head. Oh and the minis are perfect for the kids. I always grab a cup of hazelnut joe too, it's my fave.
(4)
Mel H.
This is my favorite place to get muffins and bagels. They have muffins that you have probably never heard of... like cinnamon cream cheese and Boston cream pie. Many of them are very sweet (which is probably why I like them so much). The bagels are great as well, the cheddar cheese one is my favorite. Sometimes that staff is a little unfriendly but the quality of the food makes up for this.
(4)
Allie R.
I love my favorite muffin. I stop by frequently in the morning to get a muffin on my way to work or on the weekends stop by to have a sandwich before I run all my errands. They have the most amazing muffins. I love the cinnamon crumb in the morning but if I am looking for a dessert type muffin the boston creme pie is AMAZING...the is topped with imported chocolate and filled with a vanilla custard. The first time I ever tried it I was in heaven. I also like the chocolate chip muffins for just the right amount of chocolate without being overwhelming. The sandwiches are great too, I stick to the cafe chicken melt on a parmesan bagel...delicious. Soooo glad this place is close by!
(5)
Paul H.
I really want to like this place, but I just can't. The coffee is weak and unpalatable. I said this to the girl and she replied " yeah that's just how it is. Our coffee is really light in color but it tastes good". Actually it tastes bad because the coffee is not measured properly. The flavored coffees are worse. The blueberry coffee tastes like its flavored with smarties candy. The muffins are greasy and heavy, like they're made with vegetable oil in lieu of butter. I had cinnamon raisin bagel today, which looked like it contained cinnamon but didn't taste like it. In fact it tasted strongly of yeast. And did I mention the restaurant is hot and stuffy?
(2)
Lena M.
Service is good! Bagels are yummy ..Always fresh .. Try it you will not be disapointed.
(3)
Terry B.
I may have gotten into a "habit" of stopping here for breakfast these days, which consists of a toasted bagel with cream cheese. The bagels here are really good. The breakfast sandwhiches are made from well, eggs that can be nuked. They're OK. I've never had the muffins, so I can't really say if it was my favorite muffin or not. My bad. This is a small, dual-family-owned joint with only five or six tables. I wouldn't necessarily recommend eating in, especially if you go on a busy day. (Fridays?) There have also been multiple times when the coffee thermos has been next to empty, prompting me to have to make suicide coffee. I'm no coffee snob, but this isn't exactly my idea of what I want my day to start out with. Give them a try though. The bagels are delicious and they have a boatload of flavors available.
(3)
Barb B.
I know people who absolutely love this place. And I kind of get it but kind of don't. The muffins are tasty for sure, if you like cake without frosting (I prefer my cake with a big pile of frosting). They are all incredibly sweet and very moist and at two bucks for a huge muffin a decent value. I wouldn't go out of my way to go to My Favorite Muffin but I certainly wouldn't turn one down either. They should start selling them with frosting and they could charge twice what they charge now though!
(3)
ryan m.
Decent food. Went there Saturday morning with kiddo and wife hoping for a fun relaxing morning. The place could use a makeover. The floors were old and "sticky". And everything else was just run down. I don't expect new, but clean and an open feeling would be nice. Guess I'm going back to Einsteins...although I always try to give my business to local joints
(3)
Jim W.
I used to drop in here all the time for a Muffin (yes, it needs to be capitalized when it comes from this place) or breakfast sandwich. They always had a great variety of Muffins that were really moist and Delicious-things like a Peach Muffin that was bursting with slices of peach-you get the idea-Muffin to the extreme. They did a nice job on breakfast sandwich's as well-I especially like them on jalapeno bagels-good stuff!
(4)
Shelby E.
I love this place! It's very close to my house and the muffins are fabulous (maybe that's because I have a hardcore sugar tooth). The staff is friendly and very quick on getting you in and out ASAP. Not expensive and you get a huge muffin for the price. The breakfast sandwiches are good too but as mentioned, not absolutely amazing. I definitely recommend this place!
(4)
Cyn C.
If you like/love muffins (aka cake) for breakfast, you would want to come here. They have something for everyone. For people who like bagels and eggs for breakfast, they've got that too. I actually like coming for lunch too. Bagel sandwich, and a couple mini-muffins for dessert. PERFECT.
(5)
Lacey M.
So you may ask yourself, "Why give a little muffin and bagel shop 5 stars, Lacey?" Well, I'll tell you why: I had the best bagel and best muffin here that I have EVER had. So in comparison to all other similar cafes, this one deserves 5 stars. I stopped in for some breakfast to go, on my way to work this morning. I was craving a bagel with cream cheese, but wanted to try something new, and not a chain restaurant. I browsed my bookmarked places from my iphone, and found this place. Once inside, I thought it necessary to order one of each: a Jalapeno and Pepper Jack cheese Bagel, and a Boston Cream Pie Muffin. Wow....amazing. The bagel was HUGE and so yummy. I had it toasted with plain cream cheese...costing only $2.39. Completely worth it because of its size...I saved half to eat for lunch! About a million times better then those *other* chain bagel places...you know what I'm talking about. The muffin was so good too...drizzled with chocolate and filled with custard. It really was like dessert, but not has heavy as an actual piece of pie. The huge muffin was only $1.99...and again, saved half for lunch. I definitely will be back to try other yummy items on their menu, like bagel breakfast sandwiches and bagel pizzas. I vow to never go to another bagel place again when I'm wanting to grab breakfast before work. It's only My Favorite from now on!
(5)
Kent T.
3 stars is rather ordinary. Yet that's what I felt after coming out of this place. I had high hopes for My Favorite Muffin, but after sampling the menu I wasn't too thrilled. It was acceptable...but not delicious. Consider that I've had daydreams about hanging out with Otis Spunkmeyer and eating banana nut muffins, and you might understand my mild disappointment. Frankly, I find their muffins aren't that much more tasty than, say, the 4 packs you can find at the King Soopers or Safeway bakery. Okay, so they added a big glob of cream on top. They're good muffins, but after visiting a place that's dedicated to MUFFINS, I should walk out saying: "Damn! Now that was a good **$%^!@ muffin". But I walked out saying: "eh..it was allright". Their breakfast sandwiches were incredibly ordinary. I had something with cheese and a slice of ham. No real exotic flavor..it tasted like I had pulled the same ingredients out of my fridge and whipped it up. At times, I tasted too much bagel and not enough ham or cheese. I also tried their BLT breakfast sandwich. THAT was tasty, but I'm a big bacon fan. "Bacon is goooood. Sausage is gooood". The sandwiches reminded me of a downtown bakery/lunch joint I hit in Boston, once. Serviceable and they'll fill you up...but nothing truly "delicious". Places like that are all over Eastern cities, but the Denver suburbs don't have many. I'd also like to see this place stay open past 3pm. They have deli sandwiches that I've been aching to try. I'll drive by in the evening hours and think: "hey! Why not stop in and pick something up for lunch, tomorrow?!" But I'll pull into the lot and find them CLOSED. Then it's off to the nearby Tokyo Joe's or (ugh) Qdoba. So while I wouldn't go out of my way for this place, I wouldn't mind stopping in if I was passing by in the morning or looking for something beyond the typical "cop breakfast" (coffee/bagel/donut).
(3)
Daniel D.
Now this place has amazing muffins, the best. SO many great flavors whether you get mini or large. But the sandwiches are also amazing. I would go there without the muffins involved. I don't get to go here much because of there hours but I always will when I can
(5)
Jimmy J.
Grabbed fare for a business meeting. The venue is clean, the staff helpfull, and the muffins were a hit with my coworkers.
(3)
Cori U.
I thoroughly enjoyed eating all the mini muffins! They are delicious! I would like to try the Boston cream pie muffin. Maybe I will tomorrow! I am only giving them 4 stars because I wish they had more variety for the mini muffins but overall it was still a good selection. So far, my favorite is the chocolate cheesecake muffin!
(4)
Kevin S.
Good sandwiches for lunch time. Bagels are decent for Colorado. Muffins can be really good. Recent price increase has taken affect and for some reason they no longer give you the bagel chips they used to get when you purchased the mean deal.
(4)
Karli F.
This location is very near my office so I've wound up coming here on occasion with co-workers or to grab a quick bite for late breakfast. The muffins are, as the previous poster said, like cake. YUM!! They have so many interesting options to choose from. My personal favorite muffin is the Cinnamon Crumb Cake. It has a touch of icing on the top just to make it extra sweet. I've tried the chocolate cheesecake muffin too. For some reason it's sweetness makes me want it for dessert and not breakfast. Today my co-worker had the breakfast BLT bagel. YUM!! It had normal BLT fixings but they added their cheddar cream cheese to it. The bagel was soft enough to bite through as a sandwich--a key for me with bagel sandwiches. It was sinful. That's what I'm getting next time. I happen to really like their coffee too. All around good place for breakfast!
(5)
Nicole M.
I drive by this place every M-F on my way into work and have been wanting to try it. Today was the day as I finally had a few extra minutes to spare (10 to be exact) so I thought I'd give it a chance. The place is cute and small - I could see it getting really busy around lunch time - and the employees friendly. From what I saw they have the breakfast rush streamlined. As it was my first time there I took some time to go over the menu and the girls behind the counter were very pleasant in asking me if I had questions but still giving me time to decide. I was also pleased with how before they would help the next customer that walked in they would always check back with me to see if I was ready. They had about three girls behind the counter (and one on the register) so the line moved very quickly. I decided the cheddar cheese and egg on a sesame bagel. I was out the door with time to spare. Then of course I get to work and have several things on my desk I need to handle before I can even peek into my paper sack - a good 15 mins pass. I opened my sack, unwrapped my breakfast treasure and it was still relatively warm and the bagel was soft and crunchy in all the right places. I would DEF go back and try their muffins as they looked great too but my favorite (Low-fat Blueberry) was sold out today. Now just to run early again...and hopefully soon!
Maria B.
FINALLY... a good bagel in Colorado. Nothing better than a bagel with cream cheese in the morning after a long night of boozing. My fave - poppy with cream cheese. toasted.
(4)Olivia B.
My Favorite Muffin? More like My Favorite Cupcake, these things are loaded with calories and sugar. Yet I keep coming back for more... Maybe I've never been during a rush, but believe me when I say I've been in and out around 9 am on a weekday in less than three minutes. The service is fast. Almost too fast. It's also a nice place to just sit and eat your enormous muffin and sip your coffee while you read a Westword or a paper or something. I do wish they had a better selection of mini muffins every day, because the big ones are just too much. Yes, I can finish them, we've already established this, but it doesn't mean I necessarily WANT to.
(4)Sugar L.
My go-to stop for giant cheesy bagels and muffins the size of my head. Oh and the minis are perfect for the kids. I always grab a cup of hazelnut joe too, it's my fave.
(4)Mel H.
This is my favorite place to get muffins and bagels. They have muffins that you have probably never heard of... like cinnamon cream cheese and Boston cream pie. Many of them are very sweet (which is probably why I like them so much). The bagels are great as well, the cheddar cheese one is my favorite. Sometimes that staff is a little unfriendly but the quality of the food makes up for this.
(4)Allie R.
I love my favorite muffin. I stop by frequently in the morning to get a muffin on my way to work or on the weekends stop by to have a sandwich before I run all my errands. They have the most amazing muffins. I love the cinnamon crumb in the morning but if I am looking for a dessert type muffin the boston creme pie is AMAZING...the is topped with imported chocolate and filled with a vanilla custard. The first time I ever tried it I was in heaven. I also like the chocolate chip muffins for just the right amount of chocolate without being overwhelming. The sandwiches are great too, I stick to the cafe chicken melt on a parmesan bagel...delicious. Soooo glad this place is close by!
(5)Paul H.
I really want to like this place, but I just can't. The coffee is weak and unpalatable. I said this to the girl and she replied " yeah that's just how it is. Our coffee is really light in color but it tastes good". Actually it tastes bad because the coffee is not measured properly. The flavored coffees are worse. The blueberry coffee tastes like its flavored with smarties candy. The muffins are greasy and heavy, like they're made with vegetable oil in lieu of butter. I had cinnamon raisin bagel today, which looked like it contained cinnamon but didn't taste like it. In fact it tasted strongly of yeast. And did I mention the restaurant is hot and stuffy?
(2)Lena M.
Service is good! Bagels are yummy ..Always fresh .. Try it you will not be disapointed.
(3)Terry B.
I may have gotten into a "habit" of stopping here for breakfast these days, which consists of a toasted bagel with cream cheese. The bagels here are really good. The breakfast sandwhiches are made from well, eggs that can be nuked. They're OK. I've never had the muffins, so I can't really say if it was my favorite muffin or not. My bad. This is a small, dual-family-owned joint with only five or six tables. I wouldn't necessarily recommend eating in, especially if you go on a busy day. (Fridays?) There have also been multiple times when the coffee thermos has been next to empty, prompting me to have to make suicide coffee. I'm no coffee snob, but this isn't exactly my idea of what I want my day to start out with. Give them a try though. The bagels are delicious and they have a boatload of flavors available.
(3)Barb B.
I know people who absolutely love this place. And I kind of get it but kind of don't. The muffins are tasty for sure, if you like cake without frosting (I prefer my cake with a big pile of frosting). They are all incredibly sweet and very moist and at two bucks for a huge muffin a decent value. I wouldn't go out of my way to go to My Favorite Muffin but I certainly wouldn't turn one down either. They should start selling them with frosting and they could charge twice what they charge now though!
(3)ryan m.
Decent food. Went there Saturday morning with kiddo and wife hoping for a fun relaxing morning. The place could use a makeover. The floors were old and "sticky". And everything else was just run down. I don't expect new, but clean and an open feeling would be nice. Guess I'm going back to Einsteins...although I always try to give my business to local joints
(3)Jim W.
I used to drop in here all the time for a Muffin (yes, it needs to be capitalized when it comes from this place) or breakfast sandwich. They always had a great variety of Muffins that were really moist and Delicious-things like a Peach Muffin that was bursting with slices of peach-you get the idea-Muffin to the extreme. They did a nice job on breakfast sandwich's as well-I especially like them on jalapeno bagels-good stuff!
(4)Shelby E.
I love this place! It's very close to my house and the muffins are fabulous (maybe that's because I have a hardcore sugar tooth). The staff is friendly and very quick on getting you in and out ASAP. Not expensive and you get a huge muffin for the price. The breakfast sandwiches are good too but as mentioned, not absolutely amazing. I definitely recommend this place!
(4)Cyn C.
If you like/love muffins (aka cake) for breakfast, you would want to come here. They have something for everyone. For people who like bagels and eggs for breakfast, they've got that too. I actually like coming for lunch too. Bagel sandwich, and a couple mini-muffins for dessert. PERFECT.
(5)Lacey M.
So you may ask yourself, "Why give a little muffin and bagel shop 5 stars, Lacey?" Well, I'll tell you why: I had the best bagel and best muffin here that I have EVER had. So in comparison to all other similar cafes, this one deserves 5 stars. I stopped in for some breakfast to go, on my way to work this morning. I was craving a bagel with cream cheese, but wanted to try something new, and not a chain restaurant. I browsed my bookmarked places from my iphone, and found this place. Once inside, I thought it necessary to order one of each: a Jalapeno and Pepper Jack cheese Bagel, and a Boston Cream Pie Muffin. Wow....amazing. The bagel was HUGE and so yummy. I had it toasted with plain cream cheese...costing only $2.39. Completely worth it because of its size...I saved half to eat for lunch! About a million times better then those *other* chain bagel places...you know what I'm talking about. The muffin was so good too...drizzled with chocolate and filled with custard. It really was like dessert, but not has heavy as an actual piece of pie. The huge muffin was only $1.99...and again, saved half for lunch. I definitely will be back to try other yummy items on their menu, like bagel breakfast sandwiches and bagel pizzas. I vow to never go to another bagel place again when I'm wanting to grab breakfast before work. It's only My Favorite from now on!
(5)Kent T.
3 stars is rather ordinary. Yet that's what I felt after coming out of this place. I had high hopes for My Favorite Muffin, but after sampling the menu I wasn't too thrilled. It was acceptable...but not delicious. Consider that I've had daydreams about hanging out with Otis Spunkmeyer and eating banana nut muffins, and you might understand my mild disappointment. Frankly, I find their muffins aren't that much more tasty than, say, the 4 packs you can find at the King Soopers or Safeway bakery. Okay, so they added a big glob of cream on top. They're good muffins, but after visiting a place that's dedicated to MUFFINS, I should walk out saying: "Damn! Now that was a good **$%^!@ muffin". But I walked out saying: "eh..it was allright". Their breakfast sandwiches were incredibly ordinary. I had something with cheese and a slice of ham. No real exotic flavor..it tasted like I had pulled the same ingredients out of my fridge and whipped it up. At times, I tasted too much bagel and not enough ham or cheese. I also tried their BLT breakfast sandwich. THAT was tasty, but I'm a big bacon fan. "Bacon is goooood. Sausage is gooood". The sandwiches reminded me of a downtown bakery/lunch joint I hit in Boston, once. Serviceable and they'll fill you up...but nothing truly "delicious". Places like that are all over Eastern cities, but the Denver suburbs don't have many. I'd also like to see this place stay open past 3pm. They have deli sandwiches that I've been aching to try. I'll drive by in the evening hours and think: "hey! Why not stop in and pick something up for lunch, tomorrow?!" But I'll pull into the lot and find them CLOSED. Then it's off to the nearby Tokyo Joe's or (ugh) Qdoba. So while I wouldn't go out of my way for this place, I wouldn't mind stopping in if I was passing by in the morning or looking for something beyond the typical "cop breakfast" (coffee/bagel/donut).
(3)Daniel D.
Now this place has amazing muffins, the best. SO many great flavors whether you get mini or large. But the sandwiches are also amazing. I would go there without the muffins involved. I don't get to go here much because of there hours but I always will when I can
(5)Jimmy J.
Grabbed fare for a business meeting. The venue is clean, the staff helpfull, and the muffins were a hit with my coworkers.
(3)Cori U.
I thoroughly enjoyed eating all the mini muffins! They are delicious! I would like to try the Boston cream pie muffin. Maybe I will tomorrow! I am only giving them 4 stars because I wish they had more variety for the mini muffins but overall it was still a good selection. So far, my favorite is the chocolate cheesecake muffin!
(4)Kevin S.
Good sandwiches for lunch time. Bagels are decent for Colorado. Muffins can be really good. Recent price increase has taken affect and for some reason they no longer give you the bagel chips they used to get when you purchased the mean deal.
(4)Karli F.
This location is very near my office so I've wound up coming here on occasion with co-workers or to grab a quick bite for late breakfast. The muffins are, as the previous poster said, like cake. YUM!! They have so many interesting options to choose from. My personal favorite muffin is the Cinnamon Crumb Cake. It has a touch of icing on the top just to make it extra sweet. I've tried the chocolate cheesecake muffin too. For some reason it's sweetness makes me want it for dessert and not breakfast. Today my co-worker had the breakfast BLT bagel. YUM!! It had normal BLT fixings but they added their cheddar cream cheese to it. The bagel was soft enough to bite through as a sandwich--a key for me with bagel sandwiches. It was sinful. That's what I'm getting next time. I happen to really like their coffee too. All around good place for breakfast!
(5)Nicole M.
I drive by this place every M-F on my way into work and have been wanting to try it. Today was the day as I finally had a few extra minutes to spare (10 to be exact) so I thought I'd give it a chance. The place is cute and small - I could see it getting really busy around lunch time - and the employees friendly. From what I saw they have the breakfast rush streamlined. As it was my first time there I took some time to go over the menu and the girls behind the counter were very pleasant in asking me if I had questions but still giving me time to decide. I was also pleased with how before they would help the next customer that walked in they would always check back with me to see if I was ready. They had about three girls behind the counter (and one on the register) so the line moved very quickly. I decided the cheddar cheese and egg on a sesame bagel. I was out the door with time to spare. Then of course I get to work and have several things on my desk I need to handle before I can even peek into my paper sack - a good 15 mins pass. I opened my sack, unwrapped my breakfast treasure and it was still relatively warm and the bagel was soft and crunchy in all the right places. I would DEF go back and try their muffins as they looked great too but my favorite (Low-fat Blueberry) was sold out today. Now just to run early again...and hopefully soon!
(3)